Here are some facts from my lecture on organic
In 2005 in the UK 729 550ha, or 4.3% of UK ha are farmed organically, now down to around 600,000
Shelf space for organic food is usually less than cat and dog food
Organic market is increasing 1999, £390 million; 2000, £605 million, 2005, over £1.214 billion. In November 2007 1.6% of overall food market.
7% of UK households eat organic
Denmark eats more organic per capita than any other EU country, Holland the least, (Soil Association 2007)
Problems with some of the methods used in Organic farming
Fungicides and insecticides include chemicals that are ‘natural’ but potentially dangerous (e.g. nicotine, copper salts, boleto toxin*)
Frequent mechanical weeding may damage nesting birds, worms and other invertebrates
Mechanical weeding can provoke soil erosion, digging deeper kills more wildlife although organic rotation which includes ‘catch’ crops can significantly decrease erosion
Use of seaweed as organic manure requires for it to be collected, then processed using energy and chemicals then sprayed on fields. Is this more environmentally friendly than producing nitrogen?
Cotton BT - Boleto toxin gene in GM cotton so insects die if they eat the cotton. Organic farmers are allowed to spray the substance on fields - extremely toxic to humans and crops, but they can be sold after a withdrawal period.
Nitrogen in manure is more mobile than inorganic nitrogen hence it is more biologically active and can cause more pollution
producers suggest organic food is healthier as it is more natural, no evidence to support that it tastes better or is healthier than more conventionally produced food
Organic produce has more cases of salmonella in eggs, poultry and pork, cannibalism by laying hens and a higher death rate of poultry; higher level of bacteria than on conventional farms
Might also pose a higher risk of mycotoxins, including ergot, aflatoxin (Aspergillus flavus) as in peanuts, but not confirmed
Overall production / ha. is less if organic methods are used, not only because yields are less, but the ground has to lay fallow for longer, so each field produces less over a 10 year period than with conventional farming (on average produce 25% less food per hectare than conventional farms) benefits mainly from reduced intensity
Britain only produces 50 - 60% of food needs, if all land were organic that would be even less
I think my lecturer isnt a big fan of organic so may be a little bias
ETA - I have a few scientific papers on organic farming but cant seem to get them on here. If anyone actually wants to see them i can try harder to get them off my uni website.