Organic Hay....!

seriously what is the point?
Oh and its not organic as its not soil association certified no matter what they say.
basically theyve spent less time and money growing and what you to pay extra for it!
We could say ours is organic weve never sprayed it or applied artificial fert on that basis, we check for ragwort aswell, infact thats how most hay is grown as its not worth spraying it or applying nitrates!!
 
Last edited:
We buy organic wherever we can. Choosing not to eat products that have been genetically modified or artificially grown wherever possible. Not only for our own health and well being but because we care about the environment and the future of our planet, and no im not a tree hugging hippy but the eco message will be pushed more and more by the government it will need to be. For this reason i am very supportive of the development and introduction of organic, natural and ethically sourced products. Unfortunately they tend to only be avaliable at a premium due to many reasons which i find highly frustrating for many reasons and is something i work toward addressing in my current job. Anyway the gist of my ramblings is yes i would pay a reasonable premium for good quality organic hay wherever finances allow. (should have just said that to start with shouldnt i :p)
 
Last edited:
I still buy organic veg. I like to think it is a good choice. But not so much with organic meat. I learned in class that organic means not giving your animal antibiotics or anti-inflammatories etc so the animal may suffer. Also with crops they are allowed to use substances like nicotine to spray on their crops as a substitute for chemicals. Not so human friendly.
Saying all that i still dont know enough about organic farming to decide what to choose :o
 
Our and ours is made using vintage tractors which use less diesel and more manpower so that makes it more environmentally friendly :P

Sorry keep crossposting :P
Dont get me wrong im very supportive of all efforts to be more eco friendly not just 'going organic', its just as a whole i'd like to see more organic options out there than there currently is in order to give people informad choices, promote organic farming overall and in the long term help to make prices more realistic by making it a more competitive market.
 
Because they just say that they havent sprayed it for 16 years, it could never have been sprayed but if they havent gone through the process of organic certification they shouldnt be calling it organic ;)
CP again lol so adding to this,
The thing is raggy doll and as i'm sure you know, because of pressure on yields and prices etc, it will only ever be economically viable for a farmer to produce organic if they are obtaining a premium for it. like you say about wating things that are grown in a natural way, the yields of cereals etc that we see have been obtained 'unaturally' and to continue making farming viable we have to continue exploring crop research which means creating varieties etc.
Farmers basically have a choice grow as much as possible using the traditional methods or go for a niche markets and sell at a premium.
I'm very supportive with the tenants I work with in entering schemes such as ELS but when they turn around and say to me all the birds im going to be introducing by cutting my hedgerows once in 3 years are going to eat away and my profits by eating my grain, I don't really have an answer!!
 
Last edited:
But how do you know they havent gone through the process?? Just because they don't specify it?? Jus thought there was something i didnt know about hay that meant it couldnt be organic, but think i may have got crossed wires :o
 
Right i am not going to take part in any sort of debate about what kind of meat i buy. If i buy any i buy free range. That is all i am going to say on that matter. I didnt start this thread to talk about meat!

Oh and ETA - even free range isnt great. Free range chicken farms arnt as good as they look. They dont consider the behavour of chickens. There is pecking order where the boss chickens dont let the other ones out of the barns. So free range chickens arnt so free ranged.
 
Last edited:
No, and for the record i dont want to come across as preaching on the organic subject i think people should be able to make informed choices on what they want to buy, its just that its something i personally support. I just want to make it easier for people to be greener!
 
i would like to see my hay having more variety of grasses...but im happy enough with it, plus the horses seem to like it (caught them eating some we have under cover instead of enjoying the grass in the field ive been saving up for them for winter...typical :)
 
Well basically anything that is truely organic will have soil association plastered all over it! They have to go through so much to get it they will ensure that you know that they have it!
I know some unscrupulous people who will lie and say that their stuff is organic when it is and twist words it makes me very wary of people jumping on the band waggon when other honest farmers work for years and years to get these certifications.
Always look out for the label of the soil association and certifications etc. check out
www.soilassociation.org
 
We buy ours from a local farmer who produces nothing but haylage and vegetable crops. He farms organically but is not certified. This year he's planted ryegrass and the haylage we've bought is just fantastic, sweet stuff. Doesn't cost us any extra (I'm sure it would if he was certified though!). To be honest, I would pay more for certified organic hay; we just don't need to here.
 
Just to be clear my job isnt based around farming its around environmental sustainable development. I mostly work in housing, its just the green bug has gotten under my skin :p interesting point about the grain/bird issue Jowles. I really think that if the government is as committed to addressing climate change as the claim to be (!) then there really needs to be more encouragement for farmers as well as other businesses to take that route. At the moment as you point out it is generally not in their favour to go down that route. Not only that, none of this info is made clear to joe public, as highlighted above with meat, do we really know what we are buying when something is labelled 'organic' or when it isnt for that matter! I have only been working in this field for 18 months although its something i have always been interested in but its a minefield, there is so much conflicting information out there and so many people falsely cashing in on it as you say.
 
Here are some facts from my lecture on organic

In 2005 in the UK 729 550ha, or 4.3% of UK ha are farmed organically, now down to around 600,000

Shelf space for organic food is usually less than cat and dog food

Organic market is increasing 1999, £390 million; 2000, £605 million, 2005, over £1.214 billion. In November 2007 1.6% of overall food market.

7% of UK households eat organic

Denmark eats more organic per capita than any other EU country, Holland the least, (Soil Association 2007)

Problems with some of the methods used in Organic farming

Fungicides and insecticides include chemicals that are ‘natural’ but potentially dangerous (e.g. nicotine, copper salts, boleto toxin*)

Frequent mechanical weeding may damage nesting birds, worms and other invertebrates

Mechanical weeding can provoke soil erosion, digging deeper kills more wildlife although organic rotation which includes ‘catch’ crops can significantly decrease erosion

Use of seaweed as organic manure requires for it to be collected, then processed using energy and chemicals then sprayed on fields. Is this more environmentally friendly than producing nitrogen?


Cotton BT - Boleto toxin gene in GM cotton so insects die if they eat the cotton. Organic farmers are allowed to spray the substance on fields - extremely toxic to humans and crops, but they can be sold after a withdrawal period.

Nitrogen in manure is more mobile than inorganic nitrogen hence it is more biologically active and can cause more pollution

producers suggest organic food is healthier as it is more natural, no evidence to support that it tastes better or is healthier than more conventionally produced food

Organic produce has more cases of salmonella in eggs, poultry and pork, cannibalism by laying hens and a higher death rate of poultry; higher level of bacteria than on conventional farms

Might also pose a higher risk of mycotoxins, including ergot, aflatoxin (Aspergillus flavus) as in peanuts, but not confirmed

Overall production / ha. is less if organic methods are used, not only because yields are less, but the ground has to lay fallow for longer, so each field produces less over a 10 year period than with conventional farming (on average produce 25% less food per hectare than conventional farms) benefits mainly from reduced intensity

Britain only produces 50 - 60% of food needs, if all land were organic that would be even less



I think my lecturer isnt a big fan of organic so may be a little bias :D

ETA - I have a few scientific papers on organic farming but cant seem to get them on here. If anyone actually wants to see them i can try harder to get them off my uni website.
 
Nope, I work as a land agent, and am studying rural enterprise and land management, and I have covered agriculture, countryside management etc as parts of my course and CPD and yes I am familiar with most of the above points being valid, its the same with anything tho theres fors and againsts. Its a brilliant subject!
 
newrider.com