On the bit question

kthorse

New Member
Sep 25, 2005
18
0
0
I have been training my horse with natural methods eg. John Lyons, Clinton anderson. My horse is so soft and has great self carriage. I just starte d dressage for fun. My instructer says I need to have more contact. This causes him to brace on the bit and not give. He normally gives so wonderfully that you get a little slack in the reins for a few moments. He will stay in self carriage on his own. Should I forget about getting him used to firmer contact. He gets confused as in dressage the give is not as pronounsed as the natural method way. Help. I am confused.
 
No, the goal of rein contact in dressage isn't to have firm contact, but to have a consistent, elastic contact. It should be just enough feel that if you do soften your hand, briefly squeeze your hand, or momentarily stop it from following, it clearly means something to the horse.

Perhaps that part doesn't sound much different from what you were already doing. More likely, where you and your horse may be having difficulties is in the idea of "leg and rein together." If you and the horse find this confusing, you'll be in good company (with just about everyone else first learning dressage on a horse that hasn't already learned how to go on the bit.)

If you can get the opportunity to have your teacher help you learn the idea of contact, half-halts, and coordinating your aids on a horse that already knows how to go on the bit, it will be a huge help. Without actually feeling it on a horse that knows how to respond and won't be confused when you give the correct aids, it's very hard to get an understanding of what you are trying to achieve on a horse that hasn't learned the concept yet himself.
 
kthorse

your post makes me wonder whether you are getting true acceptance and softness, or whether the horse us simply tucking behind the leg/hand/aids ?

You're the only one who can answer this, and you know the horse best ;)

I went through a phase recently of "over-releasing". So every time my horse gave, accepting, softened, I released big time. Well thats fine cos I'm teaching her to offer all that - but I was NOT teaching her to maintain and keep it.

Hence my "wondering" above - whether you may be doing the same thing I was. (And I haven't fully solved it yet, as it poses a whole load of new questions).

When you ask your horse a question, if they brace - well either they are resisting answering the question or maybe you are asking in a way that is hard for them to understand ?

As kedwards said, "contact" doesn't have to mean hard, heavy etc. But it is (for me) about softness and acceptance.

I rode for Mark Rashid last Feb. I think quite a few of the riders were surprised that as a "cowboy" (;) ) he was asking us to take more contact, but he was quite clear that the horse needs to be able to feel your cues, so you need enough contact to achieve that. Kind of like the tin can and strings "phone" you make as kids - if there isn't a connection, there is not communication....
 
Hi,
CVB, Maybe thats whats happenning. The reason I started over releasing was to teach him to give. He does and will stay collected. I use all aids together. He has a cleft palate and I use a KK bit. It worked the best. Now I am thinking maybe it is still uncomfortable and thats why he gives so much. I did try today a mullen mouth and for the first time ever he accepted nice contact. Too early to tell but maybe its the bit. Even working on side reins he does not accept contact. I have them pretty loose. I tried him with sliding side reins so he cannot avoid the bit (they were not tight at all) and he got all worked up because he could not evade it. He is ultra smart.
Thanks everyone for all the thoughts. It is giving me somewhere else to think.
Thank you and keep any suggestions coming.
 
kthorse

The reason I started over releasing was to teach him to give.

I so get that :D And for me it was to teach ME to give as well ;)

I may have to ask Kate F the next question - if we spend time teaching our horses to yield to pressure, how do we then teach them to accept it instead (in the form of a contact) ? There has to be a difference in there between the pressure we "ask" with and the pressure that is just "there".

After all, if they yielded to all pressure, they would lie down when we sat on them ;) (Have heard of a horse that did this ! but there were all sorts of other things going on as well).

He could get frustrated by side reins because he feels he can't do what you ask ? (yield to them). Or of course because of his cleft palate and the bit. But it sounds like you are a good listener for him :) so you will be aware of this.
 
I would like the answer to that also

CVB I would love to know the answer to your question also.
kedwards. I do have the leg aids down pretty good. My dressage instructer says I have perfect hands ,balance ,seat and great with my leg and hand aids. She uses me to teach other elastic contact and soft elbows. I have been riding my whole life and I am now 34. I grew up on an arabian stud.
The only thing is that he gives so well we lose contact, If I dont reward with a big release he gets annoyed and starts ignoring me. If I give him the release he wants he will keep his hind tucked under and his head in a loverly position. I am thinking maybe the bit is the problem on why he does not want to stay on contact. I would not worry so much except that I like to have more feel without him pulling when we are doing hunter paces etc. It also gets scary when you are going at a super speed and he tucks his nose in when you squeeze you hands, or he pulls because he is not used to the contact.
 
cvb said:
...if we spend time teaching our horses to yield to pressure, how do we then teach them to accept it instead (in the form of a contact) ? There has to be a difference in there between the pressure we "ask" with and the pressure that is just "there".
We train the horse to "pick up a soft feel" (also known as "give to the bit" or "contact") by specifically training the horse to accept longer and longer periods of contact.

The way to train your horse for contact at a rate it can accept is to follow the advice of Lyons, Brannaman, Dorrance, Pate, et al, and train your horse to (eventually) hold constant contact by incrementally increasing the length of time before the release. That is: hold for 1 second, release, and get that consistent; 2 seconds, release, and get that consistent; 3 seconds, release, and get that consistent;……..1 minute, release, and get that consistent; etc. As the horse consistently holds contact for a specific period of time, move up to the next increment of time and get that consistent. In other words, you are resetting the horse's expectations (of your give) one second at a time, building the length of time it accepts contact, until it expects to hold contact for some long period of time.

The natural horsemanship masters call this "picking up a soft feel", or "giving to the bit" (and other labels), but it is nothing more than taking up contact, and the horse needs to be trained to learn how to do it at a rate he can accept.

You do this first while standing still, then start over at a walk, then start over at a trot, then start over at a canter, etc, gradually extending the time the horse holds the contact in each gait only as long as he does not "...brace on the bit and not give". If your horse "...brace on the bit and not give" then you pushed too far/fast, and need to go back to a point where he is not braced and re-start from there.

Basically, you are training your horse that you "promise to release if he'll hold contact for longer periods of time". If you keep your promises, your horse will accept you asking. (And keeping promises goes a long way toward building trust.)

Also, from kthorse's other thread:
kthorse said:
Maybe I am looking for a problem that is not there and my instructer just cant understand I have gotten so far on my own. ? Is that possible.?
But you didn't get there on your own. John Lyons and Clinton Anderson taught you how to get there; right? (Based on your other threads.)

Lyons is a proponent of training the horse at a rate that it can accept, and although he pushes the envelope (as do the others), he advises against pushing so hard that the horse develops undesirable behaviors (such as "...brace on the bit and not give").

Your horse performs as well as he does because you pushed him at a rate he could accept, and he improved at a rate he could handle. Push too hard or too fast, and you'll have a lot of remedial training to do to get him back to where he is now.

You need to find out from your instructor what she is trying to achieve by requiring "firmer contact" (or "more contact" from your other thread). What's the objective?

If your horse does all the things that you indicate, then why "more contact"? (In other words, what problem is being solved with more contact?)

If the instructor is looking for an "outline" or some such thing, then you should consider whether you want to force that, or want to build it (i.e., train the horse) at a rate it can accept. (The fact that your horse "...brace on the bit and not give" is the indicator that he is being pushed too far/fast.)

The other thing that you should be aware of is that in the conventional world of horse training folks often have neither the time nor inclination to train the horse at a rate that it can accept, and tend to view training as requiring the horse to fit their timetable; that is, a rate they expect the horse to achieve.

If this is your instructor's view of training, then you should evaluate whether you wish to go down that path with your horse.

Best regards,
Harry
 
Last edited:
Hi Harry

Bang on the spot again :D

Mark Rashid was effectively doing this at the last clinic, but relating it to "softness" rather than contact. I just hadn't made the connection about training "acceptance" more generally til your post. Thank you :D

I also relate strongly to your comment on rate of training. I came back from my first Rashid clinic, got on my mum's pony (as Fi had a sore back) and basically said "right, soft, now". And bless his cotton socks he DID.. but when I went to watch another Rashid clinic this summer I realised what I had done :( so am now having to go backwards somewhat and give him a better chance to offer his best, rather than me TAKING what I assume is his best :rolleyes: Could have kicked myself twenty times round the arena :mad: but at least I listened and realised my mistake (says she in mitigation....)
 
oooo just had what might be a lightbulb moment

its actually about a reply I put on the other thread
http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=63912

in that your "contact" issue may actually be nothing to do with what is happening with your hands, the reins, his mouth - but actually is about everything else (seat, legs, weight etc)

you said
I would not worry so much except that I like to have more feel without him pulling when we are doing hunter paces etc. It also gets scary when you are going at a super speed and he tucks his nose in when you squeeze you hands, or he pulls because he is not used to the contact.

this could be about his balance, and/or about how you support him with leg, seat, your position.

As I said in the other thread, the "feel" I got with my mare was very different - but the difference was not about hand but about what was "behind" it ;)
 
Harry what a fabulous definition. Thank you so much. I didn't feel qualified to answer this question, but you a smack on the money from what I know.
 
Perfect perfect perfect

Harry oh my gosh, That is it. Thats the answer. In all the training tapes I have they did not mention holding for a few seconds longer. I always thought that they ment as soon as they give you release. Which is what he does. And when my instructer asks for longer she is making me push him beyond what he is ready to take. I know exactly what to do now. Oh I am so happy. :p You made my day. CVB I am sorry but I just had to reply on this post to Harry. :( He only pulls if my release is too long as in paces, that is because he is so excited it takes him longer to listen and I dont want to release until he has softened, :) :rolleyes:
Thank you, thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
glad to see you solved the mystery :)

I am a little simluar - I am always told to 'shorten my reins' and 'make his head go down' etc ... so lots of circle work!! Prob is, when I was at a riding school about a yr and a bit ago now, I was told to 'loosen your reins' - so now I ride with very lose reins - hehe oops. So when Cheek does go down onto the bit, I feel like he is pulling me out, but we now have that sorted ;)

Well done :)
 
...In all the training tapes I have they did not mention holding for a few seconds longer. I always thought that they ment as soon as they give you release.
They do; but those are basic training tapes. They are teaching you "how to crawl" rather than assuming that you can just run. This is proper training methodology: crawl, walk, then run.

But keep in mind that two parties are learning a new skill: How to crawl ---> The horse is learning to give, and you are learning to give back (release). It is exceedingly important that you both learn that skill as an unconscious reaction before you go on to advanced work (i.e., to run). Most novice riders (and some advanced riders) never learn how to give back to their horse; they just keep pushing, hence the myriad of problems.

Now you and your horse are ready to learn more advanced work ("how to walk") ---> so now both you and he need to learn how to hold for longer and longer periods of time, in all gaits.

Best regards,
Harry
 
I agree

CVB. I agree,
The answer was so simple. I can believe it. He has been giving wonderfully for 2 years now. I only have to pick up the rein and he is ready for me. I always felt stuck now what. Constantly asking for little gives has gotten him to the point of self carriage at the walk and trot, however I need to feel a little more contact especially at fast paces. I really am estatic.
Harry I have the rest of my life with this most perfect horse. I am in no rush. I am going to stop the lessons for now. My instructer was giving me a lesson in leg yeilding. My horse actully does the most perfect side step, I tried to tell her my horse did all that years ago. He is a pro at it. But it was her way or no way. We are going back to the basics untill he accepts contact. Yippee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D
 
Lms

To LMS who replyed on my other post. I am trying to keep it to this one.
My next thought was to try the mullen mouth. Similar to what you were saying. ITs a curved un broken mouth peice. I have tried him snaffles rubber mouths(way to big for his little mouth) regular snaffles are a definat no no . He opens his mouth, throws his head up. It hurts him. The kk he did not open his mouth or throw his head up, so I dont think it hurts. I dont think the mullen is as gentle as some people say however if it avoid palate pressure and hopefully allows a little room for his tongue (curved part) it might be ok. I still have that option if he still doesnt seem to accept a little more contact. But I do think we will be fine now . PS you can still post what your mentors said. I learn by hearing tons of opinions and putting togeteher what makes sense to me.
Thank you
Katrina
 
kthorse

yep - we're on the same song sheet ! Since I rode at a Mark Rashid clinic last feb I am on a quest for softness. But it has to be in everything we do. So it makes sense to start with the simple stuff - walk halt - as I can practice anything I want there.

Just the same way if I do an Alexander technique session, the AT person gets me to get in and out of a chair. Seems simple but you can practice the things for every other movement in that one simple process :D
 
I read your training log CVB

It made me smile. I think its wonderful that you do all disipilines. As a kid in australia. Pony club ment you did everything from dressage to eventing to barral racing. I love it all. I have done endurance for many years also as my mum breeds arabian endurance champions. The only thing left after my current goal is accompished is to try working with cows. That might be 5 years down the road but I love it all.
Katrina
 
the log is a bit out of date - I'm thinking of starting a blog up so I can keep it going.

One of my "ambitions" was to ride in "serious" snow (not the slush we tend to get in UK) and I did that while in Sweden :D (and it was fantastic)

I'd also like to work cattle, and we live on a farm (sister's inlaws) with cattle. But I think we also have a way to go with it - Fi still thinks they eat horses :rolleyes:
 
CVB I now live in NJ in the US. I live in the mountains and we have serious snow. It really is fun. The ice is the pits though. We have to put on special shoes so the horses dont fall while out playing. We ride all winter long.
Good luck with everything
 
newrider.com