cvb said:
...if we spend time teaching our horses to yield to pressure, how do we then teach them to accept it instead (in the form of a contact) ? There has to be a difference in there between the pressure we "ask" with and the pressure that is just "there".
We
train the horse to "pick up a soft feel" (also known as "give to the bit" or "contact") by specifically training the horse to accept longer and longer periods of contact.
The way to train your horse for contact at a rate it can accept is to follow the advice of Lyons, Brannaman, Dorrance, Pate, et al, and train your horse to (eventually) hold constant contact by incrementally increasing the length of time before the release. That is: hold for 1 second, release, and get that consistent; 2 seconds, release, and get that consistent; 3 seconds, release, and get that consistent;……..1 minute, release, and get that consistent; etc. As the horse
consistently holds contact for a specific period of time, move up to the next increment of time and get that consistent. In other words, you are resetting the horse's expectations (of your give) one second at a time, building the length of time it accepts contact, until it expects to hold contact for some long period of time.
The natural horsemanship masters call this "picking up a soft feel", or "giving to the bit" (and other labels), but it is nothing more than taking up contact, and the horse needs to be trained to learn how to do it at a rate he can accept.
You do this first while standing still, then start over at a walk, then start over at a trot, then start over at a canter, etc, gradually extending the time the horse holds the contact in each gait only as long as he does not "...brace
on the bit and not give". If your horse "...brace on the bit and not give" then you pushed too far/fast, and need to go back to a point where he is not braced and re-start from there.
Basically, you are training your horse that you "promise to release if he'll hold contact for longer periods of time". If you keep your promises, your horse will accept you asking. (And keeping promises goes a long way toward building trust.)
Also, from kthorse's other thread:
kthorse said:
Maybe I am looking for a problem that is not there and my instructer just cant understand I have gotten so far on my own. ? Is that possible.?
But you didn't get there on your own. John Lyons and Clinton Anderson taught you how to get there; right? (Based on your other threads.)
Lyons is a proponent of training the horse at a rate that it can accept, and although he pushes the envelope (as do the others), he advises against pushing so hard that the horse develops undesirable behaviors (such as "...brace on the bit and not give").
Your horse performs as well as he does because you pushed him at a rate he could accept, and he improved at a rate he could handle. Push too hard or too fast, and you'll have a lot of remedial training to do to get him back to where he is now.
You need to find out from your instructor what she is trying to achieve by requiring "firmer contact" (or "more contact" from your other thread). What's the objective?
If your horse does all the things that you indicate, then why "more contact"? (In other words, what problem is being solved with more contact?)
If the instructor is looking for an "outline" or some such thing, then you should consider whether you want to force that, or want to build it (i.e., train the horse) at a rate it can accept. (The fact that your horse "...brace on the bit and not give" is the indicator that he is being pushed too far/fast.)
The other thing that you should be aware of is that in the conventional world of horse training folks often have neither the time nor inclination to train the horse at a rate that it can accept, and tend to view training as requiring the horse to fit their timetable; that is, a rate they expect the horse to achieve.
If this is your instructor's view of training, then you should evaluate whether you wish to go down that path with your horse.
Best regards,
Harry