Old fashioned vet advice?

Cortrasna

Grumpy old nag
Aug 5, 2009
9,950
3,481
113
Ireland
This thread is inspired by a few recent threads on here and a discussion with my new farrier, who coincidentally has the same wonderful vet as I have.

Farrier and I were proclaiming Tom's virtues and what a sound, old fashioned type of horse vet he is.

Examples: Horses is lame, usual investigations done (nothing too costly unless absolutely essential for horse's welfare REGARDLESS OF INSURANCE STATUS OF HORSE!!:devil:) So nothing can be found, turn horse away for 6 weeks, 90 per cent of the time horse comes sound, if he doesnt then do further more costly investigation.

Old horse's stiff with athrititis or whatever makes their getting around less than perfect, do NOT stable and bandage every available joint, turn out 24/7 - rug up if the weather is very bad and let them slowly amble about with their friends. When they can no longer live happily OUT - then decide on PTS.

The latter was how I kept Solomon for the last 4 years of his life - if for any reason he was kept in for more than 24 hours he came out of the stable far more crook and stiff than he went in!

Had a recent conversation with Tom where the (wealthy) owners of their childs jumping machine absolutely insisted it was sent away for every test known to man because of intermittent lameness, Tom suggested turn away but they wanted the full works from the equine horspital. Horspital failed to find any concrete reason for lameness despite running up a bill of well over E2,000!!!:frown: Despondent owners turned horse away from April until July - pony came back into work sound and has been competing every since?

Debate is : Are we really being led by the nose due to Vets and Hospitals wanting to further their diagnositc skills, huge money pit from insurers and owners over coddling their horses and just buying every wrap, gel etc available and totally unnatural care regime that is, in reality, detrimental to our horses well-being?
 
Yes, yes and yes!

I much prefer the good old fashioned type of vets who actually know what they are talking about rather than some young jumped up version who is only interested in whether the animal is insured or not:frown: They in my opinion can stay is cities and deal with small animals!

Strangly enough, a friend has just popped round to borrow some stable rugs for her poorly horse, first vet found nothing wrong with horse despite making various cuts to find an abcess that didnt exsist. This vet was followed by a "proper" horse vet who found the issue within 30 seconds - this vet then spent nearly five hours sorting it out!:poop:

Wouldnt be wanting her vet bill:wink:
 
umm in my horses situations over the years then with regards to Rosie - i think she would have come sound anyway with field rest rather than loads of injections - as the last time she went lame with similar tendon injury i just turned her away and she came sound within 6 months (same recovery time as the previous 3 re-occurances but they were under vets instruction and cost over £3000 in vets fees for injections etc).

Moets injury however i do not believe she would have come sound naturally as after a year she was no better and so required an operation - after a further 5-6 months she did come sound after being turned away. BUT potentially had i sent her to a specialist within the first 3 months then could she have come sound sooner? potentially i suppose!)

Ummmm tbh these days i would just field rest a horse with tendon injuries to allow it time to come sound.... oh but then if your paying for insurance you may aswell attempt to make the most of it?! oh it is hard!
 
Last edited:
oh but then if your paying for insurance you may aswell attempt to make the most of it?! oh it is hard!

You see this is part of my quandary - do we do a lot of totally unnecessary and very often inconclusive and unhelpful, and sometimes stressful and painful for the horse type of procedures and investigation? When in very many cases the unidentifiable lameness, slight cough, bit of colour etc. etc. would have been resolved by giving the horse a good old natural rest with a bit of of Dr. Green. But because we have the insurance money at our disposale we and our vets decide we might as well spend it anyway, regardless as to this being in the best interest of our horse?

Or in the case of an old timer who has, frankly, gone past his sell by date - just let the poor old thing have a long or short happy retirement (according to his degree of injury or illness) mooching around the fields as close to the way nature intended being kept pain free where possible? And then PTS when the time comes. Or do we put the old horse in a stable, bandage every bit of it to keep joints warm, rub in gels and ointments, turnout for a couple of hours and watch them stiffly waddle around? surely this cant be right?
 
IMO - we put the old horse out to enjoy what is left of his life - this is what I have done with Archie - yes, we could have gone the "lets try every test know to man" route but do you what? He's the happiest that I have ever seen him - he lives out with Rocky 24/7, can come in if he decides he wants to...

When his time comes and to be honest, it could be next week - who knows, he will be pts at home without any fuss.
 
I think my views are already well known. I am a great believer in time, living naturally and good nursing as the cure for lots of things. More contraversially I think a lot of horses suffering from the modern '1/10 lame' fad either have dynamic conformational issues or are not well ridden and don't need expensive tests but understanding and possibly new owners.

In the last two years I have known two happy hackers denerved, one horse that just needed a serious diet subjected to a year of box rest and tests and one horse with awful hind leg conformation the owner cannot see that spends more time at the vets or on box rest than working.
 
Last edited:
Hind sight is wonderful isnt it.
Or in the case of an old timer who has, frankly, gone past his sell by date - just let the poor old thing have a long or short happy retirement (according to his degree of injury or illness) mooching around the fields

My beloved very elderly share went repeatedly lame last winter, so off she went for a well deserved retirement to a field. I visited her twice and both times she was happy and I cried a little. And as far as anyone knew she had gone forever.
Yet just as you describe Cortrasna, she became sound again. So she has come home for the winter where there is shelter if the weather turns nasty. She is happy, soft to ride and we go gently. Yesterday we even had a wee canter. On borrowed time.

But there wasnt any cure for her age and her arthritis. No one expected her to get a new lease of life. No vet could ever prescribe it?
 
Id much prefer to turn away then send any of mine to horspital! The less stress the better!

Wish there were more old fashioned vets out there, its all money money money these days! :timebomb:

When Finn injured his eye our vet asked us if we wanted him to go and have all the different brain scans, eye scans, specalist eye treatment etc just because we had 'extra therapies' or somthing like that! included on our insurance. None of it was neccessary at all, time & some drops healed him just fine! :timebomb:
 
I just wish vets would listen more. I appreciate the whole turn them away to see if they come good and I do buy into it, but in my most recent lameness situation it wouldn't have worked as there was a problem with his hoof balance. I did repeatedly tell my vet that we thought he'd started walking differently in the last couple of months but she ignored me and decided it could be a DDFT tear, hence why we ended up referred to the horspital. I think it could have been resolved at home....but then she wasn't confident dealing with such large hooves. So I have a £1k vet bill for some x-rays and nerve blocks. I did feel like as soon as they heard I was insured, it was more tests, more investigation, more work. I almost felt like a bad owner by calling back and suggesting that I'd like to wait for a couple of weeks and see if things resolved themselves before we ended up at the horspital. I trusted my gut more than I trusted the vet - but I can only say that in hindsight! I am really starting to realise how much the owner knows about their own horse and how much the vet needs to take that into account. Its just unfortunate that some of us are still very much influenced by these professional opinions - lets face it, we assume they have more experience and knowledge, but we should trust our own opinions and feelings as well. After all, we are with our horses every day. They aren't alien life forms.

I guess its like anything else these days. We've got the technology so why shouldn't we use it...kids type essays now instead of handwriting them. Maybe its laziness. Maybe its this litiguous financially starved society we are currently living in?

As for box rest at the slightest niggle, I hate the idea of a horse being molly coddled. I think sometimes they can end up more stressed in these situations. You've got to weigh up the potential damage they will do to themselves being wrapped in cotton wool as opposed to being in their own field enjoying their life. I couldn't have stabled my horse when he was lame, he would have done himself more damage. Instead I penned him into a small section of field so he was still with his mate but not being herded around 24/7. When the pen wasn't big enough that got him all riled up and I had to make it bigger otherwise he was going to risk injurying himself cantering around. Its just gauging what is best for the horse. I'm not for one second denying that sometimes box rest is necessary, but it would be a last resort for me. If he needs to be isolated I'd be working damn hard at finding some way for him to be out and about.

Admittedly it took me a year of seeing my horse cope in all four seasons before I could accept that he wouldn't melt or freeze in varying temps. I think far too often we anthropomorphise our horses so much that we treat like them like children, expecting and imagining them to want the same sort of things that we would want for ourselves when we are ill and that just isn't always the case. As my dad always replies when I'm worrying for the fifty millionth time about something silly to do with Flipo.....'for godsake, he's a Hoooooorrrrrsssseee!' They aint babies.
Ok, returning to my box.....I've babbled enough crap.:unsure::redface:
 
Over here veterinary treatment is considerably cheaper than it is in the UK. Think 25 euros for a nighttime emergency callout, 50 euros for two X-rays, that sort of cheap. Vets really don't have much to gain by suggesting unnecessary / excessive treatment - it just means more work for them and such little extra money, mostly they just think it isn't worth it! Incidentally it is also fairly unusual for horses to be insured here.

Methods are different too, and the "old fashioned" veterinary advice being referred to on this thread is actually normal practise here. French veterinary care is very practical and commonsense, and vets tend to recommend long-standing, tried & tested solutions that they have known to work over and over and over again.

I am a great believer in time, living naturally and good nursing as the cure for lots of things. More contraversially I think a lot of horses suffering from the modern '1/10 lame' fad either have dynamic conformational issues or are not well ridden and don't need expensive tests but understanding and possibly new owners.

Amen to that. Harsh but true.
 
Yes, I think vets school is turning out a bunch of very clever,vets who are desperate to please no matter what.

Sometimes there is nothing to prescribe, apart from a green field and turnout and not being ridden. IME lameness that is not an abscess or a broken leg is curable this way.
 
I agree for the most part, and consider myself lucky to have a vet who strikes the right balance.
I don't.always agree with retirement meaning living out though -.Stevie.lives out in summer but is in over winter with the others. However he's.spent his entire life hunting and competing so is used to being "hot housed" over winter. He's not happy out for long periods so I am happy to pander to that if it keeps him happy and calm.
 
Why does being in a field for months work a cure? Is it that they arent carrying the weight of a rider?
 
Yes, I think vets school is turning out a bunch of very clever,vets who are desperate to please no matter what.

Sometimes there is nothing to prescribe, apart from a green field and turnout and not being ridden. IME lameness that is not an abscess or a broken leg is curable this way.

^^^ This .....


Coby is insured, but for the sake of anything big happening (colic etc). But the odd fashioned turn them away is for me the best method (if they can be)


The problem i had with Quinn, was that he couldn`t have turnout, he could not tolerate grass, he was only just managing to tolerate hay. So he had to be yarded, and he hated it, he was so depressed by it that he stopped eating altogether, and would just stand with his head in the corner of the stable :( But when he did have grass, he got the most horrific diarrhea. He was already painfully thin ... so it was hard knowing what to do for the best.

I agree with hating them being molly coddled .... Quinn rugged up, and stabled, was the most miserable unhappy horse you could find ... we persevered for nearly 4 months ... with tiny gradual attempts at grass, and it just didn`t work, and that was through the worst months of winter grass, i dread to think what spring grass would have done to him.


But for any horse where this isn`t an issue, i wouldn`t think twice about turning away to grass and just letting them rest :smile:


I can`t fault my vet, she is very no-nonsence and straight talking, and i applaud her for that. On the 3rd time he went rapidly downhill, my OH was working away, so she sent her husband, with their own horse trailer, to pick him up (he`d needed plasma/drip etc) ... It was not long after this, that the decision was made.


Sorry ... this has turned into a waffle hasn`t it :redcarded: ... But yes 'C' ... the good old fashioned approach is the best way by far.
 
hmm, i would love an old fasioned vet as opposed to a new vet.

When june did her knee i was told box rest box rest box rest.

She is living out again atm.

The weather took a nasty turn the other day and she came in overnight (sound) and went back out in the morning lame as a dog. 2 days later she was back sound just being out in the field working the muscles.

a horse at our yard has just been put on a months box rest for a mystery lameness, with the possibility that if she doesnt come sound after this she will be PTS.

I would rather field rest for 1 year than box rest for one month, only time i would BR is with lami! which we have done for 4 months this year with june :(
 
Why does being in a field for months work a cure? Is it that they arent carrying the weight of a rider?

Thats a good one, and I think the answer is probably many and varied. And of course field rest doesn't cure everyone of them does it.

I suppose the feed value in decent grass, gentle ambulation 24/7, in most cases (thinking Midnight Ashe's boy is the exception to the rule here) they are mentally more relaxed and happy when work/stabling and all the yard goings on are taken out of the equation. And if injury is the problem, then rest will just let nature have the time to do the healing?

I think sometimes horses, no matter how much we love them, are still looked on by some as a working machine. And people expect that working machine to recover as rapidly as possible to enable its ridden work to continue. But that is easy for me to say as mine are at home and it costs me no more to turn a horse away than it does to keep working it. I suppose if you are having to pay large livery bills every week, then some might want their horse back in work pronto, regardless of benefits of turn away.:unsure:

But thats another discussion altogether and one that would really get me up on my podium ranting and raving!:biggrin:
 
My vet who i trust a lot doeS not go for the expensive options right away unless there is an obvious welfare issue. He is a check out all the obvious then rest for a couple of weeks and see how she/he goes only get him back if there is no obvious improvement. We tend to pack our horses with all kinds of supplements which in most cases just goes in one end and out the other when good forage is all they require unless they are really hard worked which i think the vast majority are not. My horses would kick the stable to bits if locked in over night i would come back to a pile of rubble. My old retired mare has bad arthritis in her stifle but is far better out 24/7 even in all this rain and wind she might get a rug if it turns out to be a bad winter the vet agreed and said give some bute if really stiff and if she becomes a welfare issue then it would be PTS.
 
I don't think it's just the vets - I think as owners we push for answers - I think partly as we have a culture of results on paper in education, but also because we know that we have acces to technology.

I know certainly when silver was sick I wanted an answer - rather than treating her, as a whole - I wanted answers on paper.

The sidficulties I've had treating each bit has made me review and take a whole view of her
 
I don't think it's just the vets - I think as owners we push for answers - I think partly as we have a culture of results on paper in education, but also because we know that we have acces to technology.

I know certainly when silver was sick I wanted an answer - rather than treating her, as a whole - I wanted answers on paper.

The sidficulties I've had treating each bit has made me review and take a whole view of her

PF I think in such a complex case like Silvers it is a different matter altogether - and had she been mine I would also have pushed for answers and wanted every bit of up to date knowledge and technology thrown at her as well.

With Silvers type of health issues I would imagine without some of those answers it would have been very difficult to find some way of managing and treating her?
 
newrider.com