Oh dear! Napping?

If I was to see what mrs physio says and not mention it to him, ( If he was to go back) I could say its because he rears and not a back problem.
But it likely is a back problem, so if that's the case you couldnt with a clear conscience send him back to the dealer who will most likely just sell him on again, leaving him in discomfort?
By getting the physio out in my eyes you are committing to treat any problem which she may find.

xxx
 
If she found a problem and it could be remeded then thats fine, but if she found something that makes him un-rideable he would have to go back. But if said horse did go back his price would to due to them wanting to school him themselfs and for what they would want no one would not get a vetting :)
 
I'm just going to stick my 2 penneths worth in again for the final time, I promise.

I had Gradys back checked, I bought a new saddle for him, I had his teeth done.

Everytime I had something done I was sure that this time I'd found the problem and now he was fixed. Never happened. I spent hundreds out and sold him on in 'tip top condition' to his new home having had every vaccination and 'job' done up to date but he never changed for me.

Even if you remove what once caused the problem if it has been going on for a while the behaviour is instilled into their minds and takes a bit to remove.

This is my humble experience, just thought I'd share. I'm a bitter old mare aren't I!
 
If she found a problem and it could be remeded then thats fine, but if she found something that makes him un-rideable he would have to go back. But if said horse did go back his price would to due to them wanting to school him themselfs and for what they would want no one would not get a vetting
I might be reading this wrong so lets just be sure :p. Are you saying that if the physio turned up something which was a big problem you would send him back, but tell the dealer you were sending him back because he was rearing and too much for you?
You have to tell the dealer everything that you find out, if the physio finds out that he is even only slightly damaged then you cant send him back and not mention it, it wouldnt be fair on the horse.
Unless Ive misread what you were saying?
And a vetting would be unlikely to turn up a back problem unless it was obvious - my horse was 5 stage vetted and passed with flying colours, only to be referred to by my physio 4 months later as 'a good rehab case' :(

xxx
 
Jo- I am bad at explaining:o What I meant was that if she found a problem and it could be fixed then brill. But if its something that makes him unable to be ridden he would go back. :) Also I would say what the physio said and if it wouldnt be brought up in a vetting all the better as then he couldnt throw the 'you never had a vetting its your fault one at me' ;) :D

Bobbin- please say all you need :) I see what your saying but, if I knew he was rearing through naughtyness and not pain I would feel better for sending him back. If its pain I would like to give him achance :)
 
If he's napping at one spot, then get off, and lead him there, so he knows it okay. ET does that in the corner where we store extra jumps, and one day, I lead him over there, let him examine the spot over and over again, and now he's fine with it.
 
Also, as regards to napping in school can now get him to walk in a headcollar in hand anywhere in there, thanks to the 8's!

I learnt if I lean on the headcollar he eventually goes forward and it got to the point where he stopped stoping! :D
 
Also, as regards to napping in school can now get him to walk in a headcollar in hand anywhere in there, thanks to the 8's!

I learnt if I lean on the headcollar he eventually goes forward and it got to the point where he stopped stoping!

Good to hear - I will use it myself when we get use of a school then!

I can see you really like him, I hope it all works out for you. I'd be optimistic that if he's nice on the ground and to handle generally, that's his real personality and the ridden problems are maybe due to pain or discomfort (or previous bad experiences). It's a difficult situation, but fingers crossed for you :)
 
Thank you.:) As I said earlier he has a lovely personality in hand (Except for the overfriendly nips and stopping :rolleyes: )

I have grown rather fond of him :o

If the physio picks nothing up, then I will ride him again and if I cant ride through it I will send him back. :( But if I can sit and he starts to work then he will stay :D
 
Bobbin- please say all you need :) I see what your saying but, if I knew he was rearing through naughtyness and not pain I would feel better for sending him back. If its pain I would like to give him achance :)

I feel bad for saying anything as every case is different. I think my main point is, what originally starts out as pain related behaviour soon becomes habitual when they learn what 'reaction' it gets. I have similar problems with habitual behaviour with Bry as I'm sure you are aware but you learn to live with it and try and remedy it. Obviously Brys habitual behaviour is no-where near as bad as Gradys was.

Kxx
 
Its ok, I like to see things from different points of view. :)

If I got his back done and he was still rearing through habit and was dangerous he would go back, but if it got better and there was just a 'threat' I would keep him and work through it. Was Grady the same as mine (he has no name! he was called Clover but he is far too big and handsome to be called Clover! I was thinking Bailey :rolleyes: )
 
The 'I'll send him back' relies entirly on the dealer being reasonable about it. And sadly you have not a leg to stand on as he's in no way obliged to take the horse back.:(

I would contact the dealer BEFORE you get the phyio out (book the physio right now though) and say he's being dangerous and rearing. Like Jo said, I would phrase it along the line of 'X is rearing when asked to work - do you have an history of him doing it before? You said he doesn't rear but it's obviously an established habit(state it, don't suggest it) ..............' Then mention you're were going to have the physio out and have him looked at to see if it's pain related. Then say you WILL return him if isn't not fixable as you were specifically told he's not a rearer. The reaction you get will give you an idea of if he'll take the horse back or not.

And you should have had him insured by now (image if he'd hurt someone - he's not even covered for 3rd party:eek: ) but they usually have a 14day exclusion so you cna't clain within 14days. That's too long to wait from the dealers point of veiw.

Do bear in mind that rearing is a habit (and this sounds like an established one) and even if it was orginally pain related (and may still be) he will always be a rearer and will probably be his answer to something difficult.
 
Did you make contact with them last night. What was their response.

I asked a dealer friend what she would hope for from a client's horse giving problems. ( bare in mind she is one of the good guys out there!)

Honesty was her reply.

She would prefer to know as soon as the problems arose, so she could help and advise. She would definatly want to know before you called other people to check the horse.


What ever you decide, think through the implications for you and your horse. Good luck

Libbyo :)

PS no further forward on the diary. :(
 
I am stuck. If I call and find he has a problem then I will feel its my responsibility to sort through. But then it will be months of trying to get wright which is not what i want (That sounds selfish!) yesterday I couldnt get to the yard and he was really naughty for the person who did him including kicking and biting :eek: :(

ETA- didnt call as got home late from london and there not there after 5ish (I got in at 7
 
You need to call the dealer first before making any plans - he may not be willing to have you have the physio out THEN send him back. He may not be willing to have him back at all. Dealer does sound a bit dodgy....:eek:

You could suggest that you would be willing to try and fix the problem but you want to be entirely sure that the dealer will have the horse back if it's not fixable, although I doubt he'll go for it.

But I think I would say to the dealer you would like to keep him for the next two weeks to see if it's just him settling and get the physio out but not say anything. If she finds something seriously wrong, send him back and say you think there is 'xxx' wrong with him - your 'physio friend' had a quick look and says he needs to have 'xxx' done with him. Not maybe the most honest thing to do but two can play at that game.

You didn't set out to buy a damaged horse and wouldn't have even considered him if you'd known about his problems before hand. Now is no different.
 
send him back and say you think there is 'xxx' wrong with him - your 'physio friend' had a quick look and says he needs to have 'xxx' done with him.
My problem with that is that it's about pretty likely the dealer wouldnt sort it out, and if there was something seriously wrong could you really send him back? I know you didnt set out to buy a damaged horse, no-one does, but by buying him you made a commitment to the horse that you would care for him. I wouldnt be able to give him back to the dealer without fixing him first. Ignorance is a slight excuse - if you send him back not knowing what's wrong then it's the dealer's responsibility to look into it (although I wouldnt even be happy about that). By investigating the problem you are committing to sort it out to the best of your ability.
Rubbish isnt it :p

xxx
 
Right..................

I am waiting for an instructer/sports massager/physio to get back to me who will hopefully come down tommorow and look him over and me on him and assess us.

Depending on what that person says is whether I keep him or not.

If she finds him in pain I will try and sort it.............. BUT if it is plain naughtyness he will be going back. (If dealer admits they said they would take him :eek: )
 
newrider.com