Nosebands, do you really need one?

Zani

New Member
Jan 15, 2008
1,706
0
0
North Yorkshire
Was reading up on types of nosebands as still struggling to find a bit set up that my boy is totally happy in. He is not keen on being bridled at all and I am wondering if his noseband is causing some discomfort too.

I have ready that they can cause their teeth to rub on their cheeks and cause pain and I can possibly see this as an issue with my horse, he does have quite a large muzzle circumference and is very fleshy around his mouth and tounge.

On reading about the nosebands it seems that most of them don't actually "do" anything - so that being the case why do we need one?

Has anybody else had this problem and dispensed with noseband completely?

My friend was adamant she wouldn't ride without one, but I can't see why, though maybe I am being a bit thick and missing something! :o
 
Even a plain cavesson has an effect on the horse's ability to open its mouth and evade the bit if it's so inclined, but it shouldn't cause any pain if it's done up correctly (ie not too tight) and the horse has regular dental care.

Riding without a noseband is often a real test of the obedience of the horse and the ability of the rider, especially if you're schooling. It would be really interesting to see what would happen if nosebands were banned from competitive dressage :D
 
Even a plain cavesson has an effect on the horse's ability to open its mouth and evade the bit if it's so inclined, but it shouldn't cause any pain if it's done up correctly (ie not too tight) and the horse has regular dental care.

Riding without a noseband is often a real test of the obedience of the horse and the ability of the rider, especially if you're schooling. It would be really interesting to see what would happen if nosebands were banned from competitive dressage :D

With your mention of "obedience" and "ability" all in one sentence I think I will stick with one for the time being then and perhaps just look at slackening it off a little and see if that helps! :)

It's often niggled me as when I first got him he arrived with a bridle with no noseband, so I just wonder if it has been an issue with him for a while.

I also have a bitless that we use but only on home ground, not ventued out on a hack in it yet. Ultimately that might be the way we end up going though (if I can be brave enough!!!) as he seems much happier in that than any other set up.
 
Is it just a cavesson? I wouldn't have thought you'd be risking anything by trying him without it, it won't make that much difference unless you normally have it cranked tight rather than the traditional 2 fingers under.
 
Yes it is just a cavesson, though as he seems to have grown so much, I think it is a tad tighter than I would normally like.

He is a cob size in terms of length of head, but I would say full size around his muzzle, but then the full size nosebands don't fit as they come down way too far with oodles of excess leather up his cheeks!

Kis Vihar has sent me details of the bridles they make so I think I might have to go down that route to get one that truly fits properly.

It's a nice sunny day, I might risk it for a biscuit and try without this afternoon and see what happens! :)
 
I took Mrs P's noseband off last week so she could wear her Dually under her bridle. I've not bothered putting it back on, so we've schooled, hacked out on the road, been for a hoon on the gallop & popped a small jump and had a flatwork lesson, all just in a headstall and bit. She's been lovely! Whether a cavesson has any effect is dependent on how tight you have it, I normally have P's cavesson extremely loose & I really don't think it has any effect. I haven't noticed any difference without it anyway!

In your shoes I'd just whip his noseband off :) He might look funny without it but from what you say I suspect it will have very little effect on how he goes.
 
Wouldn't do any harm to take it off in a school and try?

However when you mention ridden in a bitless on home turf - is he better then than if in cavesson and bit? If okay in bitless I doubt noseband is the problem as the noseband on most bitless's is slightly snugger in fit than an inactive cavesson should be, and a bitless noseband usually has an 'action' to play in the transference of your aids to the horse. If it were nosebands in general he disliked, I would *EXPECT* he wouldn't get on with *most* bitless's. However there are of course always exceptions :D
 
I never school my horse in a noseband any more because I find that he goes better without one on. Just that slight restriction around his head and mouth means that he feels that he cant soften his jaw and accept the bit.
Some horses need them or they'll tank off with you but I can even ride my horse out and go cantering and galloping on wide open grass fields and we've still got breaks!!
I have also read about them being too tight causing the teeth to rub on the inside of the mouth.
Its a shame that I cant ride him in a dressage test without it on but when I do put it on now, its really loose.
In your case, just take it off and have a go, you might be pleasantly surprised :)
 
newrider.com