new car - help me decide

eventerbabe

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2004
15,114
550
113
don't you just love dad's? we'd been talking about trading in my beloved golf for a while as it's now getting on in years. And because of the traumatic few days, dad decided to try and cheer me up by taking me round garages today to look at cars. I am a petrol head so it was a very welcome distraction. My wonderful dad is also loaning me the cash to purchase my car.

Well, i've narrowed it down to two and tomorrow i kind of have to decide which one, if any, we buy.

Car 1 - volvo c30 1.8L petrol, R-design model. Very nice to drive, quirky and unusual design, not too sure on the arm rest that dunted my elbow every time i changed gear. Offered me a years warranty and 2 years servicing/MOT but offered a really poor trade in price on my golf.

Car 2 - audi A3 2L TDi sportback edition. STUNNING car, i fell in love with it the moment i saw it. Has the advantage over the volvo being 5 door (good if you car share like me!). Loaded with extras and low mileage for age. Parking sensors, tinted windows, black with silver trim (the exact colour i wanted!). Also comes with years warranty and servicing/MOT. Yet to get a trade in price for my car as we didn't have it with us.

Purchase price and insurance are comparable as have already checked with insurer. Heart is screaming audi, head is shouting volvo. am not in the best frame of mind to make decisions but both cars are a good deal, especially the audi which is IMMACULATE inside and out. I kind of feel as i spend so much time in my car, and as i love my golf so much i would only part with current car for something i love. And that is the audi. help!
 
Personally I'd have the Audi every time.

From what I've heard, some of the Volvo's quirky features make it hard to live with long term. The shape of the tailgate makes the bootspace awkward to use, I believe.


Just to throw a real spanner in the works, I was close to buying an A3 last year until I drove a Mazda 3 which was very nice indeed for a lot less money & has a quirkiness to the look. I actually ended up buying a Mazda 6 because I'm tall & needed more rear legroom. We are very happy together :D
 
The audi is really tempting me... it's definately between these 2 cars, i don't think I can stand much more hanging around on windy, cold car forecourts! I did wonder about the volvo boot space. I'm used to a massive boot on my old golf, and the audi is a big car with lots of back seat passenger/boot space which would suit me better i think.... All hinges on if the car is still available! some bloke was looking at it yesterday (hence preventing me from doing a test drive) but when i went past later it was back on forecourt with the price back on!
 
We have exactly the same little Audi A3 Sportback Turbo diesel. We bought it with our hearts and it is not really practical for us (it has cream leather seats :hot:) but we both love it. It is fast, fun, willing, and reliable. And the parking sensors are FABULOUS!

Having it serviced at an Audi garage is mucho expensivo though.
 
I'd go with the Audi, it screams class, and does share some of it's looks with our current Toyota (I know, different makes, but haven't you noticed the similarity in shape of a lot of different makes these days?).. My Oh always said he wanted a Audi A3, but Tilly has changed his mind, as being she's sleeker at the front, and although not an Audi, she's a good choice, he now wouldn't swap for one..
That said, both cars compared, they're as good as each other, and I'm pretty sure if you got behind the wheel of our car, you'd probably feel the same as Oh, but it's seen as an older persons car, hence the low mileage in a lot of Toyota's for sale, you can guarantee that those cars have been very well looked after, and it's very likely that the Audi has been in the same sort of hands..
Volvo.. Oh has never had one, but I've always thought that they're a bit 'square' if you know what I mean?
So defo go with the Audi :biggrin:
 
well......... i went and bought another golf! the audi got sold last night :( so we headed out of town to a wee garage that had a nice range of golfs and a3s. test drove an a3 and really didn't like it. So it was between a 1.9 TDi golf match and a 2.0 GT sport TDi. So i bought the GT sport :D very happy with my purchase, it was a fabby car to drive and is silver, my granny and grandad's favourite car colour so i'd like to think they'd approve :)
 
^^ that's very good to know! i agonised for ages between the GT and a 1.9L match. Both lovely cars. But as my mum said in 5 years time i might be looking for a 'sensible' car and not get the chance to have a sporty little number (i think she's thinking grandchildren there!) so why not :) cannot wait to get it on saturday.
 
newrider.com