Need bit advice! (long-sorry!)

HairyCob

Has anyone seen my mind?
Mar 18, 2002
4,494
0
0
Visit site
Hi!

I think i need some advice on bitting- my 6yo 15hh cob was started in a snaffle (by someone else), which he evaded in every way, so when I got him I put him in a happy mouth straight bar with full cheeks- as reccomended by the saddler. The theory was that this was a mild bit, but the cheeks would help with his 'lack of understanding' :o about steering!

I kept him in this bit for about 18months, and he was OK in it, steering improved to the point that I could steer with my bum! But then he started to be quite strong, would take the bit and bolt at times, and started to refuse to turn if I asked him to go the way he didn't want to! He also never seemed to be really working from behind, and wouldn't go on the bit so.....

As a Heather Moffett disciple, and having taken advice from various places, I changed to a happy mouth pelham, two reins, elastic curb.. took a while for me to get to grips with the two reins, but we got there and now he does seem to work a bit more forward and has excellent 'brakes' with barely a touch on the reins.
However, we are still having problems with him refusing to go in a certain direction, for example, although I vary his hacking as much as possible, he knows that if we go straight on at a particular point, it means he has to go up a fairly steep hill, so he always wants to turn left, which means he avoids the hill- no matter how forward I ride him, or what I try, we always end up having a pitch battle at this junction- he will not even turn his head to the right, and we end up circling several times to the left before he realises that I won't give in, and we end up going the way I wanted to! When I say pitch battle- please don't mis-understand, I don't haul on his mouth, I just calmly and consistently stop him from going the way he wants by turning him (to the left, as he will not turn to the right in this place!) until he responds to my asking him to go the other way.

I also don't feel that he is particularly relaxed in this bit- although he is working more from behind, I don't get that wonderful feeling of it all coming together and him working 'on the bit'... it's difficult to explain, and I know I'm not the best rider in the world, but I know what a relaxed horse who is working from behind and on the bit should feel like, and H.C. just isn't!!

So, what does anyone think? Schooling tips? Bitting advice? I have to admit I don't really like his pelham (sorry Heather!!) - I find that the two reins are a handful, and don't seem to be able to master getting independent action from the curb as Heather suggests one should.

Well, I'll stop babbling on now, I hope this makes sense, and that someone out there can offer me some advivce!

Cheers,
H.C.'s Mum
 
Hi HairyCob

I read your post with great interest, as I have had a similar issue with the pelham on my young green cob, although steering hasn't been a problem as he is very responsive to leg and weight aids. He was originally ridden in a Happy Mouth snaffle but I was advised to try him in a Pelham (Happy Mouth straight bar), as he had tension in his poll and jaw. I have used the pelham for the last 12 months but although he went well in it, I felt that he wasn't quite happy in it. He seemed to dislike the curb chain, so I tried a leather and an elastic but to no avail. I too found it a handful at times to juggle with 2 reins and a schooling whip, so, after confirmation that there was no problem with his teeth or my hands, I decided to try him in a different bit. I chose a Hanging Cheek, French Link Snaffle so I still had slight poll pressure but with no curb action and I could go back to a single rein. I tried him in it for the first time last week. I have schooled him in it 3 times so far and he is going so much better, is happier and relaxed, very responsive, and is working in a lovely outline. I have yet to hack him in it but so far I have been very pleased with the transformation.

I'll be very interested to hear other peoples comments on this thread.
 
Last edited:
Not much help, really but a subject I find very interesting how much it can vary from horse to horse! I was just wondering if you are riding him in the pelham all of the time?

I found that keeping a horse in the same bit all of the time, led to evasions and the horse eventually not listening. For example, I ride in the school in a snaffle most of the time, changing to a pelham purely for hacking, or if I need to - use it to reinforce my schooling every now and again. When I first got my pelham, which I got for extra brakes when hacking, I started to school in it and he went brilliantly, but found after a while, that no matter how much extra leg I gave, how much I rode from my seat and how light and quiet my hands were, my horse started to lean on it, and I just couldn't get him to stop. So I ended up going back into the snaffle and he went brilliantly in it for a while, then started doing the mad horse impression again, so changed the bit again. Now I have about three or four bits (the pelham is the strongest), which I've tried and all have worked, but obviously won't suit everyone, which I sort of swop around depending on the result at the time and what I am trying to teach.

The way I understand Heather's book and from her posts on here, the pelham is only meant to be a training aid, not a substitute completely for other types of bit.

Just a thought. I'm not really the most experienced when it comes to bitting, and I know the idea of swopping bits around is alien to most people, but I've found it works. After all, dressage horses aren't always ridden in double-bridles, and showjumpers usually have an array of tack to help them.
 
My favourite bits are all ones mentioned already- happy mouth full cheek, french link hanging cheek and pelham. I often ride in the pelham with the curb rein 'bagging' and then just gather it up at need and lengthen it again as soon as I can. If HC has a tendency to lean on the bit (?) then a straight bar can make that worse. Play around with what works for you but obviously the bit is only a small piece of the jigsaw.

From what you are saying I am imagining that HC is working on the forehand. So in terms of schooling advice: anything to lighten the forehand- lots of transitions, turns and circles- all very simple but they have to be good quality or they won't get you anywhere. And of course lateral work will help engage the hind-end.

In your hacking problem I would try not to let HC go the other way. Personally in most circumstances I would just close every other option and keep asking the horse to go where I wanted. Use your legs and seat as well as your reins. As you know where it will happen I would set-up in shoulder-in right before the problem area as it will be much harder for HC to turn her head away if her body is flexed right.

A bit different but with some similarity- a while ago I was working with a pony that was refusing to go into its corners- to the extent that it was cutting off most of the schooling area. I got on and refused to let it cut its corners so the pony refused to move! Every time it started forwards it would try to go anywhere other than where I was asking it to go and when I wouldn't let it then it would stop again... we repeated this for a quite a while. And the pony was so used to getting her own way she was getting fairly cross! (but obviously this was a safe environment). Every time she tried to evade, she got no-where and I just quietly re-presented the problem. Finally the pony just stopped fighting and went beautifully- it was a real light-bulb moment!

Assuming that the situation was safe that would be my preferred approach.

Anyway I'd better stop myself now before its a full blown essay!
Good luck!
 
Last edited:
Hi Guys!

Thanks for all your advice!
Bit (pardon the pun!) of an update...
I got the chance to borrow a full cheek french link snaffle today, and with some trepidation, tried the boy in it- knowing how much he disliked a traditional snaffle, I expected some fireworks!

On our way out, I took him past the point that he usually wants to turn left, and with use of seat, leg and a bit of rein, he went straight on, which is what I wanted.

As a reward for not napping to the left, I didn't take him up the steep hill (softy!) but took a different route. Further along the route I took there are two places he would usually try to 'choose' the direction, and again, at both points, he listened to me and did as I asked. Great! I thought, cracked it!

But.... further on in our ride, at the point where on that particular route we could turn left for home, I decided we would go straight on- H.C. had different ideas, and once again the battle commenced. Instead of just kind of grabbing the bit and going, which I assume he couldn't do in this one, he stuck his head up in the air, opened his mouth wide, and went the way he wanted...looking like a giraffe...grrr!

I didn't let him get away with it (never do!) and spent the next ten minutes turning him round and round in circles, asking him to go the appropriate way at the appropriate point on the circle each time, until he finally did go that way. I rode him on for a few minutes, then did some figures of eight in the (very quiet, wide and safe!) lane, in an attempt to get him to listen to my aids and turn the way I wanted! This seemed to work quite well, and I eventually looped back towards home.

So, has anyone got any further advice in light of this? I really thought this bit was going to work (and it did on the way out!), but now it seems he has sussed that by opening his mouth and doing a girraffe impression, he can evade this one too!

Specific questions......

Does the full cheek french link sound like a good choice? It was a bit of a compromise as I wanted to try the hanging cheek as recommended by Jake's Mum, but couldn't lay hands on one today!

Would a hanging cheek help more with getting him off the forehand? It seems that he was fairly happy with the action of the french link, and if he is going to stick his head up to evade that, I think maybe I'd be better working on the turning problem with schooling, and having the benefit of the bit of poll pressure to get him working more correctly...any comments?!

Someone suggested a martingale...... I don't like them much, would prefer to 'school the problem out', but would using one for a short time make it easier for him to learn?

Sorry it's another long post guys...!

H.C.'s mum!
 
If it were my problem, I think I'd stick with the Pelham for a bit longer. If you find it difficult to handle two reins and a stick, practice at home on a chair or with a friend - anything!

Bar bits are comfy to lean on, but don't allow it. I assume HC is just ploppong along, head down? You need to get him up in front, and as Nic says lots of transitions will help - doesn't matter where you are - in the school or on a hack. If he goes to drop his head, just lift your hands (as if to say "No, not down there, up here") and back it up with your leg. Not a jerk, not backwards - just a positive "Up you come". Don't try to hold his head up once he lifts it; make it his responsibility to keep it where it should be.

I really don't think a martingale will help at all. It may even compound the leaning problem.

As for the turning issue, yes, you need to be quite positive; make sure you use your weight aids as well as your reins/legs. And something that often works very well is a nice sturdy switch with a clump of leaves on the end of it - just pull one off a tree before you set off. Keep it in your outside hand and if he goes to veer away, rattle it against his shoulder. You often find the noise offers an element of surprise :D
 
I am sure you probably have but might it be worth checking that everything fits as a sensitive soul will use the slightest discomfort as a justification to protest.
As regards bits I am a great believer in rubber pelhams. However the important thing is that the horse is comfy. Different bits suit different mouth conformations. Also a 5.5 french link snaffle may not be the same size as a 5.5 bar bit. Conn's bits vary between 5, 5.25, and 5,5 inch depending on style. Moss ia fairly standard 5.5 but his KK is a small 5.5 and fits fine.
 
Hello HC

I use a hanging cheek for schooling but have to use a pelham on a hack as Kaz gets far too strong and "runs away". If he's throwing his mouth open now - could you try a flash initally until he gets the idea that it's not an option. Ebs started in a flash but i found i didn't need it after a while. It also sounds to me that he's just being a bit of a bugger and seeing what he can get away with and trying to dominate you - what's he like when you do ground work and in the school? I think it's good that you changed your route slightly on the last hack and i think that's wehat i'd probably do so he never knows what you are going to do and where. he's probably also sensing from you that you know "right here comes the point that he's gonna play up" so he reacts to a change in your body (even though you might not notice it). What's he like if you hack out with another horse that can take the lead and direct him past these points?
 
Wow! Lots of food for thought here! Thanks guys!

Unfortunatley we don't have access to a schooling area- other than in a 10 acre field that can't be fenced off, he sometimes grazes on and is right next to his friends...

I do however school on hacks... sometimes it feels like constantly!
We do lots of transitions, half halts, halts, backing up, leg yields etc- anything really to get him listening to me.. and most of the time, although not working properly from behind yet, he is very well mannered and responsive- it's just these particular points on particular rides that are a problem!

I took him out in the french link full cheek again yesterday, this time with another horse, and he was much better- my friend said she thought he was coming onto the bit and looked more 'collected' than usual, and he felt better- he also didn't try to evade the bit at any point.

I did double check the fit, and suspect I may have had it a little bit low in his mouth last time- he seemed to respond much better to it with it 'up one'!;)

I think I will persevere with the french link for a little while, if that doesn't work then I think it will be back to the pelham and putting you guy's advice about riding in it into practice- though how I'll cope with two reins, a crop one side and a switch the other! Practice at home will be essential for that!!!
Maybe I will try alternating between the two if necessary at times so that he gets the benefits of both!;)

Thanks again everyone!:D :D ;)
 
have you tried a happymouth dutch gag as this has the same poll action as a pelham with out the curb and with out the need for two reins our arab used to bolt in a pelham but he seams fine in the dutch gag
 
Kanuma
Personally I am not overkeen on the multiring snaffles but if they suit the horse that is the important thing. However I thought they should be used with two reins. One on the main ring for general use and one on the secondary ring. Please do not call them gags. They are not. Gag bits have the cheek pieces through the bit rings and should ALWAYS be used with two reins.
 
alternatively?

I know its somewhat of a leap of faith but.....I've been schooling Mary Lou to go bitless. So far in the arena I can get her doing figure 8s, circles, yielding hind & forequarters. On the occasions I've taken her out, I've put the bitless halter on with the traditional snaffle over it. However, I only use the bitless and keep the snaffle as a "just in case" safety feature. So far i've not had to pick up the snaffle reins.

Granted it took a long time to get to this point (Nik J was witness to my first attempt....oh boy!! :D ) but she's gotten a lot better. The only issues we have now is when she sees a gelding and her mind is stuck on eye-balling him instead of doing what I ask (but then again, she's only 5....)

Now having said all that, I've only taken her out on quiet roads so we havent had a major test of my theories, but I know Showjumper works Dolly in a similar manner, so maybe she can add more....

If HC has such an aversion to bits, is it possible to start introducing a halter? You'd need to start training him from the ground in a contained area before you could risk getting on board with only the halter.
 
Hi all!

Surprised to see this thread resurrected, but thankyou for your replies!

Currently we are still doing well in the full cheek french link- despite my reservations about it, he seems to like it!
Would love to try bitless, but I think that may be a challenge for next year!
 
Originally posted by Mossy
Kanuma
Personally I am not overkeen on the multiring snaffles but if they suit the horse that is the important thing. However I thought they should be used with two reins. One on the main ring for general use and one on the secondary ring. Please do not call them gags. They are not. Gag bits have the cheek pieces through the bit rings and should ALWAYS be used with two reins.
i know its not a gag bit but that is what most ppl know it as. round here its called a three ring snaffle but down the raod they call it a different name so i was going for the common name in the hope that ppl would understand which bit i was talking about!!
you do not need two reins on a three ringed snaffle cos it is a snaffle and has no curb chain. it looks better if you do use 2 reins but it isnt strictly nessacery (sp).
 
A multi-ring snaffle with a single rein on one of the lower rings is not a snaffle - it is a curb. The lack of curb chain does alter the action but there is still a lot more leverage than in a conventional snaffle. If you are riding with a single rein you need to handle it with respect as it is effectively a curb bit. Everyone round here calls them gags as well, although they are not strictly a gag.
 
as ive said i know its not a gag!!!!! it is tecnicaly not a curb cos it doesnt exert pressure on their chins!!! yes they can be harsh because of the leaverage but some horses respect that and when they get to know you mean buisness you hardly haveto even touch it for them to obey my arab stopped bolting because of one and is now working in the perfect outline and seams to be very happy in it and i feel alot safer riding in it
 
Thanks Esther I know they are commonly known as gags but they are not. Just a personal irritation. Anything with the snaffle name seems to be seen as a "mild bit" whereas that bit of something round the back turns it into a "curb" which is then a "harsh bit" A baucher has poll pressure so the pressure from a multiring with the rein on the bottom ring must be quite appreciable.
PS I have seen multirings used with roundings on top and bottom ring and a single rein. Why?
 
Thanks Esther I know they are commonly known as gags but they are not

Have I managed to make you both (on opposite sides of the discussion) think that I was contradicting you. My English obviously needs polishing up.....what I meant was that

1. I agree with Mossy - they are not truly gags
2. I agree with Kanuma - lots of people call them gags

But I should have explained it better

grovel ;)

Oh and Mossy I agree with you about the severity - they worry me a little when they are used indiscriminately as 'snaffles', especially when you see children hauling around their ponies on the harshest 'curb' setting.
 
strange!!! a multi ring with roundings?????? i hate roundings i think they are a crime against horsemanship!! if you cant handle 2 reins then you shouldnt be rideing in a pelham. i flew off the wall a couple of days ago when i saw someone riding in a double with roundings
 
newrider.com