Napping - Can anybody help?

mojo

New Member
Jan 8, 2003
91
0
0
Visit site
Hi everybody. can anyone give me and my friend some advice?
My friend aquired an 11yr old section d welsh cob mare approx 6 mnths ago. The lady she bought her from had owned her for 6 years. Previous to that, as far as we know, she was a riding school horse. Several weeks after owning her she was out hacking when 2 police bikes came around the corner, the horse spooked and bolted down the middle of a busy road. She was also becoming increasingly difficult to school in the field, throwing her head, rushing towards and napping by the gate. She was so strong in the bit that we could only ride her on a very short reign in order to gain any kind of control. We discovered it was the bit (french-link) that was causing the problem and that she had a very sore mouth which was making her run out of the corners towards the gate. My friend had also lost all confidence in taking her out on the road. After resting her up for 10 days or so in order to let her mouth heal she changed her over to a pelham. I must admit that her schooling improved overnight, despite the apprehension a lot of people have over using pelhams. She looked much more comfortable in it, you could ride her on a much longer reign and her mouth problems ceased. However she has developed a serious problem with napping, especially when hacking out alone. She improves somewhat if someone walks alongside her or if she is with another horse, although she is still prone even then, and she will never go lead file. She does have a defiant streak in her. For example I was riding her in the school and it was getting near to her feed time. Knowing this she began her tricks napping by the gate again which I managed to get on top of by raising my voice and giving her a tap with the whip. Something I am loathe to do to horses as I don't really believe in this, but with this mare it sometimes seems to be the only way to get her to respond. However my friend and I took her out today, on the road and around the tracks. She was fine on the road but when we got to the tracks kept napping. I was riding her and my friend walked alongside. I managed to ride her through most of the problems but we reached a certain point where there was a small tractor part lying in the grass. We are not even sure that it was the tractor part that was worrying her but she hit a brick wall, went rigid and started spinning around when I tried to get her going forward by kicking her on and finally following up with the whip. she started backing up and throwing her head about. The firmer I was with her the worse it got, which was very frightening. She ended up doing a small rear and then a buck. My friend tried leading her past but after 10 mins or so we had to give up and go another way.
She is basically a nice natured horse, generally has good manners even though she can be a little stubborn. My friend recently found out that the lady who had her before used to encounter similar problems. She never rode her alone(her husband used to ride alongside her on a bike) and often used to end up getting off and walking her back to the yard, sometimes only 10 mins or so after leaving. We are not sure if we are dealing with a case of deeply ingrained defiance from having had her own way for so long or whether there is some other underlying cause. Could it be a case of intense insecurity? She has had her back checked and has her teeth done regularly. The strange thing is that some days she is fine. We don't think it can be anything to do with the pelham as she seems much happier in this. Although my friend does use roundings instead of double reigns which I am unsure about.
Another thing she does is rush over to other horses she sees if you are out riding and you have to fight with her to prevent her from doing this. She has always been kept in a field on her own, and I am sure this has a lot to do with it. Although there is often cattle in the field next to her.

Neither of us are really experienced riders. I have been riding for 18 months and my friend about a yr longer. Is there anyone out there that can give us a better insight into this problem. My friend has become very attached to this mare but doesnt look forward to riding her out at all, understandably! Any advice would be much appreciated
 
some ideas

Definitely look through the archives on this board, for ideas on napping, I'm sure there are threads from before;

I've read that you should take the horse out alone only a short distance, and try and turn them for home BEFORE they think of it, then progressively go on longer and longer forays;

I myself had a gelding who had a time where he was twirling about and trying to go back, I would just keep him going 360 degrees and keep going! It looked really bizarre to cars going by, I'm sure.... He did have some back discomfort that was fixed by horse chiropractic and a new saddle pad. Have you checked her saddle fit?

This gelding was also terrified of cattle and on one occasion we re-tracked an entire trail ride instead of come back the short way along the road past cows! He begged me to go back, even knowing it was a long trip! (Kept looking back down the trail, trying to go back, and almost rearing when asked to go by the cows.) And I was afraid I'd come off, so I let him take me home his way. Safety first.

Napping can be re-schooled, it's just a lot of work and going back to basics to the point where you are getting compliance, and building on that....try not to get into fights with her, it's non-productive.
 
This horse may never have been ridden out on her own. If she had been a riding school horse, she will have been so used to riding in a line, following other horses and possibly never at the front.

To ask a horse to leave its 'herd' and go out on its own is a big thing to ask. My horse is quite good on his own, but we occasionally have problems, especially coming home or if we see other horses - he tries desperately to catch them up or go with them - this is a natural instinct.

Do you HAVE to ride out alone??? It is far safer not to, no matter how good your horse is. My friend NEVER rides alone - her horse hates it.

just keep riding out with another horse which has seen it all, done it all, and with someone who will give you confidence.

It does seem to me that your problems only occur when she is away from her 'herd' and being asked to do something on her own. Try schooling with another horse (and rider ) in the school as an experiment - see if you have any problems then. I don't think this is purely napping - she could be genuinely worried.

Persevere in the school - have knowledgeable people around when you are schooling to help if need be.

She is still young enough to be reschooled and don't forget, you haven't had her very long, so you need to build up some trust between you!!
 
also sounds like it might be a confidence problem (the horse that is).

As Sue C has said elsewhere, there is normally a reason. Some of the behaviour sounds similar to my mare immediately after we had an accident. Luckily we have managed to gradually get some confidence back, with partner working alongside, hacking out with others, ground work etc.

I would recommend ground work to build your relationship and her confidence in you. Then lots of patience and calm and persistance to gradually build confidence bit by bit. (as recommended above, by gradually building up how far you can go and what she will trust you to do).
 
Thanks for the advice everyone! I will pass on all of your comments to my friend who unfortunately dosent have internet access.
My friend does ride out with another horse once a week/fortnight and says she is much better behaved, although she still has problems. However the horse she rides out with does tend to shy a lot, so i'm not sure this gives her horse the greatest confidence. The rest of the time she dosent have a choice and has to ride out on her own.
I think I agree that little and often is probably the best strategy. I took her out on a short hack around the fields at the back of where she is kept a few weeks back and I dragged my partner along to walk beside us. We didnt have any problems. I didnt have to raise my voice once or tap her with the whip. I kept talking to her almost the whole way round in a soft voice. If she did look worried my partner gave her a pat on the neck and she seemed reassured. She had been on that route a few times before though and it could just be that she is now very used to it. I tried comforting her in the same way yesterday,on a different route (which apparently she has also been on before), lots of pats, reassurance etc, and my friend walking alongside, and it just didnt have the same effect.
What was really scary though was we tried getting her to go another way,rather than back over the same route, as we have been told it is not good to let them simply turn around and go back the way they came. I now dont think this can be right at all?? She did go the other way and then we came across some sheep, she didnt nap but she didnt like them either and was acting a bit spooked. Then we noticed there was electric fencing on one side of the track and a ditch on the other. I was terrified!!! but doing my utmost to remain calm for both our sakes. Luckily my friend spotted an opening, thank god! and so we were able to get off the track, away from the fencing, but I shudder to think of the danger! and to be honest it has put me off hacking in the countryside. It seems there are too many hidden dangers.
I think we may have been given some very bad advice. As we have been told to not let her get away with so called 'playing up' but yesterday I could see that me trying to force the issue was just making her worse and worse.
Thanks for everyones comments. I think my friend should go back to the drawing board and take the slowly but surely approach. I for one won't be forcing the issue when I ride her from now on. Just lots of gentle persuasion + I really think I'd like to stay alive, thankyou very much!! I will also as suggested take the time to trail through previous threads for more info.

Cheers!
 
mojo,

we have some routes where there is no 'loop' so we have to return the same way. The trick is to vary the turn around point so they don't get the idea that there is something wrong with going past a particular point.

Can your friend do more ground work if there is no one to hack out with ? Getting the confidence of the horse to walk over a piece of tarpaulin or whatever in an arena or field does help build confidence for obstacles outside, but allows you to practise somewhere safer.
 
Parelli?

Mojo
I've just recently come around to the idea of doing Parelli. I know some people swear by it and its supposed to be good to teach your horse to trust you, respect you etc.

Not having done it myself, I cannot say for sure, but if there are any Parelli people in your area, they might be able to direct you?
M.
 
I can so sympathise with this!!!! A few months ago I posted a long thread about how a horse I was schooling was getting me a bit depressed because they were napping so much. There was quite a debate about it and how I should proceed, but I won't into many details about it as my problems were based during schooling sessions rather than hacking out (hacking out I had to hold the horse back most of the time). However, there were a few tricks I learnt which you could try on top of the great suggestions which you have already had (the effectiveness of how these work will depend on why the horse is napping).....


1) when a horse starts to nap it's almost a sub-concious decison on the part of the rider that the hand and rein aids change so that they don't necessarily get stronger, but stiffer. If you do this, your giving the opposite instruction with your hands to the ones you are asking with your legs in which you are asking the horse to move on. Sometimes, it's the hardest thing to do, especially if you're worried it might buck, but try softening your hands and give with the rein - then ask to move forward gently and unhurried, a little bit at a time. This way if the horse is napping due to panic it feels as if it has some freedom to move away from the scarey object if there is any danger.

2) The other thing you could try, is turning the horse so that it is facing away from the scarey object/direction. Sit very quietly allow it to calm down, but not move forward and away from the scarey object. Then ask in a totally calm manner for a few steps in rein back (it doesn't need to be more than two or three) using primarily your seat and legs rather than by blocking with your hands. Often the horse will find that facing the object head on is more preferable to reversing into it. However, I wouldn't recommend this method unless you are absolutely confident in the fact that you won't ask for too much with the hands.

The main thing to remember is that if a horse is napping then you don't want to play around with it's mouth more than you have to as this just increases the problem. As if often said on the board, less is often more and if the horse is wound up then playing around with the reins will just antagonise this further. Just imagine if you had a piece of metal/rubber in your mouth and wanted to flee/object to something and someone kept tugging even gently at your mouth how much worse that would make you feel! :D

I also wouldn't persist in the whole kicking crop thing. It will just work against you if in any way you are holding any tension in the reins. When I first got my horse he spooked at everything and I soon discovered that the best way to keep him calm was to hack out in walk on a longish rein to start off with, no trot or canter until he got used to the idea of being on his own used to the hacking routes, learnt to trust me and listened to me even in the most "frightening" situations. It does take a while but it does pay off.

Every horse is different so some methods will work and some won't. If you don't feel confident on a longer rein just yet, just try loosening the tension to start off with then when you approach an area you know is going to be a problem you can always begin to take more contact if it makes you feel more in control - but don't tug!

Good luck!
 
my youngster started to do this and still does it now when she is in season. I always make sure she has always hacked out alone and in company to prevent the hacking out alone problem, but sometimes she is just plain difficult. It got so bad in the sumer that I stopped hacking out. We went back to schooling. SHe had also had a wolf tooth and her saddle was far too narrow. Get the saddle checked, also, is it a dentist or the vet that does the teeth, if its a vet get a specialist dentist out.

my youngster has been perfect the last few months until she wasin season a few weeks back, she didn't want to leave the yard. she stops, tries to spin round and if you try and force her, ie use the whip or anything she does this little rear buck thing.

I found 2 ways to cure this: circle her really tightly with lots of inside leg and sternly say walk on. if she doesn't then I keep doing the same thing. the other thing I do is either tie a piece of rope to the end of the rein, or just use the reins themselves and tap them either side of her neck, just lightly, which also helps. on occassion I will attempt to do both these things at once.

she does it when in season because she gets excited and worked up, but the above gets us round the hack. if she is genuinely scared and stops dead I let her stand and look at what ever it is, but if she tries to spin round or turn for home she gets circled 5/6 times if necessary, spoken to sternly and made to move forward.

also, make sure you keep calm, if i shout at her or get worked up she gets 10 times worse, i have to stay relaxed. if you want to discuss further PM me and I;ll be happy to help.
 
I do agree, anuvb.

Horses hacking out alone can sometimes be a bit naughty, but I'd say it's mostly a nerves thing, and not always but very often one that starts with or is exacerbated by the rider.

I've done it myself on young horses - they see something and freeze; you think "uh oh!" and hold them a bit tighter so you can react if they decide to turn tail and run, and it goes from there.

First, if you keep a horse on a tight rein he doesn't feel free to look around him, and that makes him nervous straight away. Second, if your horse is on a short rein and gathered up beforehand, he's already in the best position to sprint away - if he's on a longer rein and a little strung out he has to gather himself together first, and that gives you your split second to react. Third, if you grab the reins and tense up as soon as he shows signs of being worried about something, he thinks you agree with him that it's scary and if he's worth his salt he'll try to save you both (well, someone has to take the initiative :rolleyes: ).

If you can steel yourself a couple of times just to sit there and relax, let your mare have a look - don't let her run away, of course - and just wait quietly and confidently for her to decide that you're not afraid so it must be OK, she'll start to get the message. If you REALLY find you can't do that, then perhaps she'd be better off with a less tentative rider for a while - at least until she learns for herself that the world isn't trying to eat her.

As for naughtiness - sometimes a little joke on her part might backfire on her a bit: she pretends to be scared to see how you'll react; you do get scared; she gets worried because gosh! it isn't a joke any more and there might REALLY be a tiger behind that bush; you smack her just in case she's trying you out, which she thinks is REALLY unfair because now she really IS scared - oh dear, it's a vicious circle, isn't it! :(

And in the first place, you're dealing with someone else's problem here - an intelligent little mare who was used to being in company, now living all alone, having been ridden for some time by a lady who seemingly couldn't help her develop her own confidence... It's hardly surprising she's posing you problems, but they aren't insurmountable if you take the right approach, and you're thinking the right way, so that's a good start :)
 
Last edited:
Hi Everyone. I think the tensing and tightening of the reigns may certainly have worsened matters. This is the first time I had experienced this horse napping.My friend had warned me about it, but on previous occasions when I had ridden her this hadnt happened. The first couple of times she napped I wasnt anticipating it and was able to get her to move forward. But by the third time i was expecting it to happen, and perhaps did tense and tighten the reigns sub-conciously. Also as she got more agitated I knew I was completeley loosing control and I was beginning to get increasingly nervous. I could hear my friend shouting and trying to lead her forward. I was at this point just concentrating on staying on. I remember practically giving the horse her head at this point and holding onto her mane, thinking to myself this just isnt working and my god what is she going to do next?!
Problem is, how do you relax in such a situation?? I certainly wasnt aware I was hauling on the reigns. Although my friend did ask me afterwards if I might of been. So maybe I was. In normal circumstances I always try to give with the reigns as much as possible,because of the pelham.
 
Please don't think I'm being mean or patronising, but I strongly advise you and you friend to have lessons. I understand you have bought a horse that is insecure, and though it has problems, they can be overcome

To be brutally honest, (unless the horse has teeth problems) the french link bit did not make your horses mouth sore - it was harsh hands. The bit is not a braking system. Though the pelham used correctly with 2 riens is a very good correctional bit, used strongly can very easily teach them to tuck up behind the bit, creating a harder to correct evasion.

You can not ride a horse forward on a short rien, its the equivalent to pedalling a bike with the brake on.

With an insecure horse you must build up a trusting relationship, and be someone in thier eyes that offers leadership and can be trusted. To be that you must offer trust by being relaxed, giving consistant, clear aids and offering a relaxed rein to go forward into.

I understand that using a stronger bit gives your friend more confidence, but really its like putting a bucket under a dripping tap, the problem is not solved, just curtailed for a short time.

When riding there is a circle of aids - legs, seat, hand and always in that order. Our position,balance and response is crucial. This is where a good instructor is invaluable - you can't beat an experienced pair of eyes on the ground.

Lesley
 
Hi Dizzy
Dont worry I dont think you are being patronising at all and as I am relatively new to riding i am very open to suggestion/criticism. However I do have a lesson every week. Not on my friends horse but on different horses, all of which wear a variety of bits and I have never experienced what we were experiencing with this mare before. If you did loosen the reigns even slightly she imediately rushed towards the gate and it was impossible to get her to go around corners without her shying out of them. She had been on loan briefly previous to this and we think that this was where she could have developed a sore mouth, maybe due to rough handling. Perhaps it wasnt the bit but all we know is that she appears a lot more comfortable in the pelham. My friend is reluctant to change back, although I have suggested she try her in a mullen mouth. Not that I am very knowledgeable in such matters, but I have read that it is much kinder and that horses used to a pelham are usually excepting of this.
I am working on my seat/aids and try to stay aware of my reign contact at all times. Perhaps the only time I am not is if I lose my balance which is happening less and less or when I find myself in very tense situations, like the napping incident.
 
Mojo I would go along with Dizzy's advice and get some lessons with the horse. I had a problem with Rhi napping for the gate whilst riding in the paddock. I had a lesson from a more experienced and confident rider (I was dreading the lesson with her as she used to scare me as she would not be the kind of person to give in easily or accept any nonsense from a horse or rider :eek: - and I do not mean that nastily ). However by the time she had instilled into me that I should shorten Rhi's inside rein and keep my other leg on I was feeling much more confident and now I can cope with her. The trick with this is to be ready for her. If you know she is going to nap at a certain place each time you can prepare yourself first.
 
Hello again everyone. I am overwhelmed at the response I have had.I will be seeing my friend on Tuesday, so am taking all your replies with me. I am also going to get my instructor to come over and give me a lesson or two on her to see if she thinks it could be my riding that is increasing her tendancy to nap. To be honest though we dont usually have any problems with schooling her in the field since she has been wearing the pelham. On the very odd occasion that she tries to nap by the gate we have corrected her without much trouble. Of course I never feel as secure riding her outside and I could have more tension in my seat/reigns that she is picking up on. For the time being I am going to work at schooling her in the field so we can build up more trust in each other and let my friend take her out if she feels she needs to. I will let you all know how things progress. And once again Thanks for all the info!!
 
newrider.com