my gran's case meeting

eventerbabe

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2004
15,114
550
113
well, unfortunately i was not allowed today off to attend :( but my mum and dad did, along with a letter from my uncle expressing his wishes. Mum said it was a bit of a white wash. The doctor, psychologist, physiotherapist and care manager would hear absolutely NO discussion on allowing my gran home with carers. They stated that she had dementia and they judged she didn't have the mental faculties to cope. They were wholly basing their decision on her return visit home when they said she appeared confused. Well, come on people, you've had the old woman couped up in hospital 3 months, her flat has been gutted and reorganised AND there were 5 people and my gran crammed in her small flat (it is SMALL!) on her home visit.

Several things annoy me about this. (a) she's been dottled for YEARS and they didn't care until she went into hospital (b) they wouldn't even hear the family's wishes and WE know her better than them (c) what right do they have to hold her hostage in a hospital?!

I am hoping someone on NR can point me towards some sort of legislation (we are in scotland), or offer advice on how we can get gran out!! they cannot hold her there forever and it's my understanding that they cannot force her into a care home.

My dad negociated us taking her on a home visit on sunday to see how she got on, so i'll be going along to help with that (i'm more patient than my dad!). I was thinking some nice coffee with cream and some of gran's fave biccies would help her settle in for the afternoon.

i'm utterly seething right now and i'm going to blow my top if i have to have much more to do with these so called "health professionals". The NHS is a flippin joke :banghead:
 
Not sure, but my nan under similar situations had orange pull cords installed in her own home along with a sort of communication thing where a local warden from a local care home called through (box on the wall like a telephone on speakerphone, don't know what it's called) each morning and checked if she was ok.

My nan would normally answer with "It's okay, (name of warden) I'm not dead yet but thank you for asking." :-P

Eventually my nan did have to go in a care home after multiple strokes though but I moved her to a care home near me so i could visit her almost daily. Would have much preferred to have cared for her at my own home though had there have been space.
 
my gran's home is in a sheltered housing complex. There is a warden there to help her (warden will fix her lunch for her etc.). She has pull cords in all her rooms with an intercom to a control centre. that seems to count for nothing as far as these "professionals" are concerned :rolleyes:
 
Oh EB, I dont really know what to say - I cant understand why they arent listening to what you and the rest of her family are saying - as I've said before, they wouldnt take my gran into a nursing home unless she agreed so i cant understand how they can keep someone who wants to go home???

Hope you get something sorted for her - hope all goes well on Sundays visit too.
 
i'm on the verge of going off on one tomorrow, i really am. they cannot keep her there, yet they won't let her home. She's now getting depressed and WANTING to go home. i hoped having her old favourites (she's been desperate for coffee with cream for months!) would help her settle in a bit better.

my mum's boss is an NHS manager and fought a similar battle with her mum. I've told mum she's to take her up on her offer of advice on what to do next. First step in my eyes is a reassessment for dementia. Apparently, it's policy that a family member MUST be there for the assessment. I was physically prevented from even seeing my gran the day they did the assessment with her. so i definately think a proper, official reassessment is needed.
 
thanks for those links, i'll start looking through them :) i'm tempted to call the hospital tomorrow and demand to speak to the care manager. This is unacceptable. Mum joked we might have to get the police involved for kidnap. Now i'm thinking that might be the only way to get my gran out!!
 
there was some very interesting info on that first link. Apparently we can request a "care needs assessment" though social work. I'm wondering if this is also something to get in motion?
 
now this is interesting...

The hospital should have carried out an assessment of your mother's needs, which should show how those risks have been considered. The assessment is the basis on which decisions about further care are made, so there should be a discharge plan and a care plan. The assessment should show whether continuing care after leaving hospital is the responsibility of the NHS or social services. Close relatives ought to be asked for their views as part of this assessment. The way to dispute the hospital's decision would be to ask to see the assessment and discharge plan, and challenge them if they do not properly consider the risk to your mother of being moved.

Now i know what i'll be demanding to see when i phone tomorrow!
 
Oh Anne what a horrid situation for you.
Here are a few things for you to check out. Has your gran seen 2 doctors to assess for incapacity? Has anyone got a welfare guardianship order over her? If so who. If no one has then they can not stop her leaving however if she tries to then they could get one rushed through.
Sadly no matter how well you know your gran you dont have any say in what happens to her. They should work with you and take your views into consideration but without a welfare guardianship order you have no say.
If I were you I would get a welfare guardianship order put in place ASAP (if you can get 2 doctors to do an examination and assesments for incapacity and depending on results of course)
However even then she might not get to go home. Who ever runs the sheltered housing might refuse to take her back if the out come of the home visit was not good. They might be worried about falls, fire hazards, overdose of medication, to much drain on staff and so on :-(
Could she move in with your parents?

I dont know of any legaly requirement for family to be present at assesments. I have been on home visits (only to observe) to assess things and there were no family there. I have also known care managers get guardianship orders against family wishes but this is very very rare.

I really really hope that this works out for the best and that your gran gets home.
ps what I have put is what I believe but Im not saying it is def 100% right. Im pretty sure it is though

http://www.publicguardian-scotland.gov.uk/whatwedo/guardianship_order.asp
 
Last edited:
Try and work out exactly what she should be entitled to and then request that it happens, quoting relevant papers that you have read etc.

Also request that all meetings are minuted and keep copies, keep a note of any conversations etc and keep all emails.

I know it's hard but try and stay as calm as you can as getting angry wont help your nan. Give the scottish alzheimer people a call as well and get their advice.
 
I've never heard of the welfare guardianship. I shall look into that. tbh, i think the hospital would not let 2 doctors assess her. She's been seen by 1 (very poor) doctor since she went in.

We were informed by the dementia assessment unit (through mum's boss) that legally we were entitled to be at the assessment and we can demand reassessment if we are unhappy with the initial assessment. I don't actually think she's been properly assessed.

I do not believe that some pen pusher has more say in my gran's future than us as a family do. I'm on the verge of discharging her myself! warden is very happy to have her back, she's already proven she can easily manage the stairs (up and down) herself. Her mobility isn't in question, it's her mental capabilities. Warden and anyone who knows my gran knows she's been dottled for years and the NHS didn't give a flying fig. They only care now they are trying to force her into some substandard care home (we are well aware of the bad rep of the home they are trying to put her in).

i shall contact scottish alzheimers and i was also wondering about age concern? i shall see if mum has the minutes of todays meeting. If she doesn't, i'll phone the no-good pen pushers and demand a copy!
 
They also tried to push my gran into a care home that we deemed unsuitable - you really have to find out what you are entitled to and fight for it.

Stick to your guns and get as much info as possible, my mum is a CPN so was able to get help from Social Workers that she works with - you have to know how to play them at their own game - once you start quoting various laws at them, they will prob back down. Fingers crossed for you.
 
i think this is where my mum's boss will be invaluable. being in the NHS, she knows just how to play their games!

I've been reading the alzheimers scotland website and i really don't think my gran has dementia. she likes to play the martyr to get attention, she can remember well enough when she's not playing her little game.

From what my dad has just said, everything is hinging on this home visit on sunday. I thought by having some of her favourite nibbles and drinks out she'd feel more at home.
 
I would have thought the best thing for your Gran is to be amongst the people who love her, NOT strangers, who really don't give a t***, they just want to be paid:banghead:
No wonder she's unhappy, a place like that will only send her downhill, and that's something you don't want:frown: Treated like an invalid, when she obviously seems to be capable of making decisions by herself..
That maybe why they refused to allow you to be at the assessment, so they can hide the truth from you, and bleed your mum, dry, financially:stomp:
Is there not anyway, you can make external arrangements for her care, and take her by force? They really can't stop you from taking her, they just wouldn't be able to help you once she's at home..
Or there is one other suggestion.. Demand a second opinion from an outside source.. they would have to have used the mental health act to keep her in, otherwise they haven't a leg to stand on..
 
Last edited:
Im pretty sure a POA over money/assests would of been made while your gran still had capacity and would not have any bearings on what is happening now. Im pretty sure you can also get a Financial guardianship order over people with no capacity but it would not give you any say on there welfare side.
I am almost 100% sure that if the care manager had a welfare guardianship order over your gran then you would know about it.
I really think that you need to talk to the care manager. Keep your cool and phone up and make an appointment to you and your parents to talk about things. I am pretty sure they will have big concerns and class your granny as high risk if she goes home or maybe as vunrable??
Hospitals dont want bed blockers and if they can send then home then they nearly always do. Think of what is easier for them. Sending someone home or having to do visits, reviews, find other accom, keep her there until a place is found.. They must be worried about sending her home. Even if the warden says your granny is managing ok sadly it wont be up to her. It is quite common for sheltered housing to refuse to take people back once they go into hospital.
I think the only way you are going to get the answers you need is to meet with the care manager and discuss things. Have your parents been to any meetings/reviews about your granny.

you say your granny has been dottled for years. What do you mean by dottled? Do you see her often? Have you noticed her getting worse? What home are they talking about sending her to?
 
Last edited:
newrider.com