Moral dilemma.... WWYD?

domane

Retired cob mum
Jul 31, 2005
15,978
6,023
113
Gracie needs a new saddle as she has changed shape. Had fitter out this morning. 7 saddles put on her back, I picked 3 to ride in. They were with me for about an hour. Made my final decision and they want £750 for it second hand. They have left it with me and couldn't take a card payment because of no signal at the yard. So no money has changed hands yet. Also it is black so I will have to buy a new bridle because my current one is brown.

However, said saddle is only £880 new (they didn't have a new one on them, just the jump version which i don't want) and now that I am home I have just found a brown one on ebay for £500, which looks just as lovely as the one I have been left. Now the 'blurb" reads well - you can feel the love and it has obviously been well looked after.

We can't really afford £750 what with all the costs for the dog recently.

Moral dilemma. Should I take the black one back, or pay the extra?
 
I have to say that personally I would keep the one the saddler has left for me, unless I decided I wanted them to order a new one for me. They've spent time fitting it, and in all fairness if you do take it back I think you need to pay them for that. Also you can see this saddle & it's fit has been checked, there's no guarantee that the one on ebay is in the same condition or that the fit will be the same so at the very least the flocking may need adjusting - who will you get to check it & do that?

Realistically do your saddle and bridle absolutely have to match? It won't alter the fit or effectiveness :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frances144
Even if money is a bit short - I think I'd also be keeping the one the saddler left. Like carthorse says, the one off ebay might not be a good fit. My saddle and bridle don't match - I guess it is personal choice tho.:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: chunky monkey
If its not the colour or model you want I wouldnt keep it, pay them for their time and maybe ask them to keep an eye out for what you want or even explain you found the one you really want and could they check/fit it for you, in all likelihood doing it that way probably won't work out far short of the other one but at least you get what you want :)
I've brought lots of saddles off sales sites, I always consider if it doesn't fit is it one I'm likely to be able to sell on easily to make my money back. Is the eBay one close enough for you to pick up so you can check it before you buy it?
 
If you ever want them to come back to you.........

Personally, you agreed verbally to the one you tried and kept.

Life, or karma, has a very nasty way of coming back to bite you in the bum. If you get the one off Fleabay, how do you know it doesn't have a broken tree, something drastically wrong? I am a "Suspicious Aloysius" about most things off Fleabay.

If you really want the one off Fleabay, I would pay them for their time, leave on good terms and hope they will still want you as a client.

A good saddle fitter (up here) is like hen's teeth.
 
I took the saddle back to the shop, paid £40 for their time and messaged the fitter who had already said she wouldn't be back there today. She was lovely. She actually apologised for getting caught up in my enthusiasm to find something comfortable for G and me! Said she will happily come out and check anything I purchase in the future. I do feel relieved. We've had a lot of costs for Ruby.

So now G and I will be doing groundwork for a while.....
 
newrider.com