Manners!!

ooh i have just read this lot again, amylou i have seen your post under what i said before. i was not refering to you and saying that you had punched your horse! i was responding to what flony pony had said her her punching her horse on the nose. while she didn it once and for her it worked, there are people out there who do this all the time and it doesn't work.

as for what puzzle has said, i could be wrong but i don't think she is dirrecting it at you as such. i think we all understand that problems arn't always caused by the person who has the horse (or handling them) at the time. but i do agree with puzzle in that all the problems we get with horses are caused by people which is what i think she is trying to say.
 
thanks, yes that was what i meant. :-)

so the 'good wallop' could be a slap and I'm glad you don't hit the face.
i once was taught by someone who worked with Heather someone ad her hubby who run the Natural Animal Centre (used to often be featured in Your Horse and Horse and Rider magazine about horse psychology) that horses never become 'muggy' if they only gets treats - rewards - when they have earned it. it's hard to explain! i mean, many of us reward with treats but it doesn't have the same effect as when the horse KNOWS they have earned it and actually work for it. i didn't really know how to achieve that at first but it's a bit clearer now.

i have seen too many horses - clearly - wrongly hit and punished even without physical abuse, to accept it (and i don't think i ever will) and i have never seen it done in a fair, just, rational and appropriate manner. who would want to treat their horse like that is beyond me. i'm not in any way labeliing you as abusing your horse because of the way i have experienced others' treatment of theirs, but i don't think smacking is respectful - you wouldn't hit your hubby or your mum, so why your horse? i can't say i have never hit a horse (and am fully ashamed of it due to the circumstances) but i have always used other methods and they have - and still do - worked for me.

i don't really use punishment but prefer correction and praise: Michael Peace does it, so why can't i?
 
Last edited:
Thanks for your reply puzzles. I understand that maybe some people see slapping etc as a loss of control. If you hit an animal out of frustration it means that you are not doing your best to communicate exactly what you want from him or her. However, as i said when it comes to either being squashed by a rather large beast or mowed down by it i would rather use force to stop this behaviour. I am not going to get injured out of concern for smacking a horse.
I totally agree we humans are responsible for how our animals turn out. I do use other methods with this horse rather than what you would consider abusive. He was a bit head shy with me before, and i had never done anything to warrent that, so i presume something in hte past has made him head shy. He now calmly lets me rub his nose.

You go for it if you feel like you can use that method of training. I think it is great. I would love to use them too, but this horse needs more. Not that he receives a physical punishment all the time because he certainly doesnt! Its only when needed. Most of the time he is fine.
 
Thanks for your reply puzzles. I understand that maybe some people see slapping etc as a loss of control. If you hit an animal out of frustration it means that you are not doing your best to communicate exactly what you want from him or her. However, as i said when it comes to either being squashed by a rather large beast or mowed down by it i would rather use force to stop this behaviour. I am not going to get injured out of concern for smacking a horse.
I totally agree we humans are responsible for how our animals turn out. I do use other methods with this horse rather than what you would consider abusive. He was a bit head shy with me before, and i had never done anything to warrent that, so i presume something in hte past has made him head shy. He now calmly lets me rub his nose.

You go for it if you feel like you can use that method of training. I think it is great. I would love to use them too, but this horse needs more. Not that he receives a physical punishment all the time because he certainly doesnt! Its only when needed. Most of the time he is fine.

Thanks hun - about the bit in bold: i didn't mean it was necessarily abusive, only almost all of the behaviour i had seen was so.:)
It's fab that he isn't so headshy any more, well done for that and good for you!!:D
 
I have added a reply to your other post on this horse...

If he mugs you, or shows signs of wanting to mug you, get rid of the one thing that he is after..... the treats in your pocket....if you have the upper hand i expect he will allow you to put his grass muzzle on without the treat...

He is only mugging you, because he knows you have them. He can smell them.

Perhaps his owner could see the two of you together and help you get to know him better??

If you've only been looking after him a week or so, you wont know him very well.

What's his personality like? is it strong? sounds like it... but if you go in, expecting fireworks, that's exactly what you'll get.... you need to go in, stand up straight, and tell him what's what...without hitting him or getting loud (as someone else suggested)

You also said that you walked out of the feild in disgust, but then went back a few mins later. Well, good on you.... gave you both time to calm down, have a breather and a think...and then get on with things.

How do you get on with the other, a mare is it? in the feild?
 
If I want to keep My Polos in MY pocket, I darned well will, and I will not be hassleed, not by nobody!


And they know it. If one is offered they are allowed to take it, until then I have my picket fence that will not be breeched.
 
I have added a reply to your other post on this horse...

If he mugs you, or shows signs of wanting to mug you, get rid of the one thing that he is after..... the treats in your pocket....if you have the upper hand i expect he will allow you to put his grass muzzle on without the treat...

He is only mugging you, because he knows you have them. He can smell them.

Perhaps his owner could see the two of you together and help you get to know him better??

If you've only been looking after him a week or so, you wont know him very well.

What's his personality like? is it strong? sounds like it... but if you go in, expecting fireworks, that's exactly what you'll get.... you need to go in, stand up straight, and tell him what's what...without hitting him or getting loud (as someone else suggested)

You also said that you walked out of the feild in disgust, but then went back a few mins later. Well, good on you.... gave you both time to calm down, have a breather and a think...and then get on with things.

How do you get on with the other, a mare is it? in the feild?

Thanks for both replys. Il say what i have already said. This post is a little old. I have known him about a month. I dont usually carry treats but as wally said if i did i wouldnt want him to mug me even if i did have them. He really did need something to get him to wear that silly grass muzzle. But he got the message and for about a week now he hasnt needed treats. I thought we had gone past that but obviously we havnt. He is a strong horse and a cheeky one, but most of the time he is great. Iv no need for lead ropes to take him to other field as he follows me (gate leads off same field). He is very food orientated.If he has food in front of his face h e will let you do anything to him!
 
I take it you do not agree with the grass muzzle?

The grass muzzle is there for a purpose. To restrict the grazing of grass when Laminitis is present or to get the weight off a fat horse/pony. there is nothing "silly" about them. They are a god send to many owners and horse's not that the horse thanks you for it.

Wally - fair goes, you keep your polo's in your pocket, if you so wish, but if it were MY horse, and your were my sharer, I would warn you not to have treats in your pocket, and tell you what the horse is capable of, and if you ignored the advice, and you got bitten, in the process of being mugged, then be it on your head.

Not all horses are food orientated. Most are because we make them that way. Some horses that are clicker trained are not and simply crave the "good boy/girl" nice vocal tone in which they know they have done well.

Amylou you cannot liken the training of a dog, to the training of a horse. It is very different.
 
Excuse me but you have no idea of the situation of this horse. For all you know his owners may be over protective. I say 'silly' because it has been a struggle with him. I am still continuing to put it on him at hte owners request, even if it is a struggle so if i thought it wasnt necessary i would be saying something ot the owner. If there is no reason to stress out a horse then it shouldnt be done. I am well aware of why a grass muzzle is needed, i am not stupid.
I am very aware that the training of a horse and dog is different. I never said they are the same. You have a way of posting your replies in a manner that seems rude and im not sure i like it. I respect your opinion but this being my thread id appreciate a little open mindedness and proper reading of previous posts.
 
Well if you do then thats all all good. But it would have been good manners on your part if you had told me you were on here. As i say, no biggy. If you have any other questions about how i take care of Seamus feel free to call me or text me instead of posting it on a forum. Welcome to NR. :)
 
If you would like me to come up and spend some time with you and Seamus and see if I cant get you two to get along better, then please say so.... or pm me...i don't have your number (nor transport at the moment) but I could show you some ways that work with him, and less frustratiing for you... As you've found, he's not the easiest horse to get on with... hope he hasnt trod on your toes yet with his new shoes...

:D:D
 
We get on really quite well. Its only when mares are around that we have issues. I want to work on them myself, if thats ok. I see it as a challenge and if it isnt effecting the horse then its ok. I can handle him, no need to worry :) I just like to vent my frustrations on here. It helps. Feel free to pm me some options to deal with him and if i feel like i need to il refer to them. I have dealt with horses before in hte past. Many jobs (crappy pay of course :)) etc so il get through to this cheeky dude :D
 
I also think it is really rude not to tell amylou that you know the horse in question, and feel your posts are written in a really patronising tone, julz :mad:
 
I also think it is really rude not to tell amylou that you know the horse in question, and feel your posts are written in a really patronising tone, julz :mad:


I have explained my reasons in a PM to Amylou. I apologise if you feel it came across as patronising. :cool:
 
I wouldn't get bitten, the horse recognises alpha female when he sees one, and if he don't well, he'll soon learn not to mug me! :D :D
 
He doesn't mug (anymore - used too) but will try it on with someone he hardly knows. She just needs to be firm with him, not take treats and tell him in a firm voice NO!!!! also two fingers in the soft part of his nose on the side along with the NO, and he'll soon catch on..... and before you all jump on me for suggesting that, someone (forget name) suggested it to us, and it worked! He's not stupid, quite the opposite infact.... he'll soon remember..
 
Here is the horse in Question.....

As he was when we first got him
FatSeamus-1.jpg


As he is now, two weeks ago
Photo-0004.jpg


Apologies if pics are huge!
 
newrider.com