Makes uneasy reading.

Yes I agree, very uneasy.

I am only a novice, and I am not qualified to judge. But if something doesnt feel right there is a reason you feel like that. If you are a new owner its easy for you to be taken in by experts, but to go ahead with something that she was warned might kill her horse? What kind of horse was she expecting to get back? one that trusts her? or one that is really and truly 'broken'

Trying to put myself in the shoes of the owner, and if Cracker hadnt turned out to be more or less perfect, if the only way I could ride him is by subjecting him to painful 'training' regimes that might kill him, he'd be retired or I'd have him humanely destoyed. No way would I pay to let someone else inflict pain on him to the extent his life is at risk.

Also he says his methods treat stable vices like stall kicking?? WTF? risk a life for showing impatience? My boy kicks his stable door, no biggy IMO, I've screwed a rubber mat up so its not so loud and he doesnt hurt himself. But he still doesnt get his dinner any quicker, or get turned out first just because he thinks this is the correct order.
 
I was reading about this elsewhere, all very disturbing. But the most reveling thing in my mind was his written response to the critics, said a lot about the man's character and motives IMO.:devil:
 
What a wanker. I haven't read his response, but I don't agree with the hobbling - and by the sounds of it I probably wouldn't agree with any of his methods. Why do people send their horses to folk like him??? Surely common sense would kick in........? And yes, I'm a novice so talk out of my arse from time to time about how horses should be kept and trained and yes, I'm probably a total fluffy bunny most of the time, but I know something wrong when I see or read about it. Poor horse. Poor horses any of them that have been to his facility.
 
His response as s**t happens is repulsive.

Turning a horse out in hobbles is crazy for starters, thats before looking into his other 'methods'

lokos to me like him offering one of his horses and refunding her money etc was in the hope of keeping her quiet. How bizarre you are not allowed to call or have anyone else come with you when you collect??
 
YIKES!

no thank you. i'd rather have a partnership WITH my horse than have her 'resigned' to anything. why do these people think they need to break a horse's spirit first before they can 'do anything' with them? like that other NH guy (might have been Parelli?) who mentioned in a book that it could be a good idea to withhold water (!) until the horse was so desperate to drink that it would HAVE TO come crawling to its 'master' for water :devil:

PS: just read the guy's 'response' - repeatedly using bad language (sh*t happens etc) and repeatedly referring to the poor horse as 'it' - what a knob.
 
Last edited:
He's always been at the baddest end of the Parelli type spectrum, so it's not exactly surprising that this has happened. Sadly you don't have to be an NH trainer to abuse horses and it takes many forms, but when you use a lot of weasel words to describe what you do it makes it worse.
 
I've watched CA on Horse & Country TV and I have never liked his approach.

I hadn't heard about this sad death but his response to the incident defies belief really. In my opinion it reflects badly on him both as a horseman and as a businessman (which he undoubtedly is).

His assertion that it wasn't his fault that the horse died, and also that 'no one knows how he died' are potentially conflicting. And his repeated use of swearing and the general tone smacks of huge arrogance.

The Epona article is very interesting and thought-provoking on a more general level though. Thank you for sharing, Wally.
 
I read this on another site.
I know little about the trainer and nothing about the person complaining and their horse.
But I recognised the name of the trainer as one who in the past was greatly esteemed by some members of NR. Just that he didnt come to the UK and I never bought his books, being already out of money having bought John Lyons and using him instead.
I say this because in all honesty the internet and the amount of info lacking made it impossible to judge. The thing which did strike me applies too to the thread on NR about employing an adviser from IH. The famous trainer was not around when the horse was at his yard. When the big names delegate, that never seems the same to me. I was reprimanded on NR for not regarding one of Rashid's former assistants as an unquestionable authority on his work.
I have had bad trouble with one of the best local lawyers here, again because expansion of the business involves delegation to lesser mortals. Whom I wrongly trusted.
This shocking complaint by owners - doesnt altogether convince me that the intelligent riders on NR who recommended this trainer in the past and gained from his teaching were all wrong.
 
What a wanker. I haven't read his response, but I don't agree with the hobbling - and by the sounds of it I probably wouldn't agree with any of his methods. Why do people send their horses to folk like him??? Surely common sense would kick in........? And yes, I'm a novice so talk out of my arse from time to time about how horses should be kept and trained and yes, I'm probably a total fluffy bunny most of the time, but I know something wrong when I see or read about it. Poor horse. Poor horses any of them that have been to his facility.

Completely agree with Trewsers and couldn't have put it better myself.
 
To tell someone horses die in my care, why are the welfare not involved and what person still sends their horse!
Its no good wanting people to know if you were warned and ignored it, your problem.
Why hobble a horse in the pasture, how :ninja: cruel is that to a flight animal. Bucking and bolting isn't related to its turn out though it could make bit worse with lack of turnout.
It can't roll, can't lay down-sleep deprivation.
I would like to tie his legs together!
 
if the horse was fed, watered etc. and not mistreated (no idea what the law is over there though ...) I suspect there wouldn't be a 'welfare' issue :(

It was actually parelli that said withhold water and the horse will want to be with you, I disagree in making the horse want to be with you. The cob may call for her bucket but she won't die without it.
The only time you withhold food and water is for health reasons as in colic, sedation, not to catch it. I strongly disagreed with that footage.
 
Sorry, I was referring to CA with my 'welfare' comment.

Withholding water from a horse (unless for health reasons and I can't think of many!) is very wrong indeed :( if people (Parelli or whoever) need to rely on emotional blackmail for their horses to 'want' to be with them, that's very sad indeed! heck I can get mine to trot up to me in the field without a bucket or treats in sight!
 
Clinton Anderson is a d*ckhead. No other way of dressing it up.

Ciuld be a cultural thing, but I HAVE hobbled in the past and I would do again in the same circumstances. My horse at the time was a former stock horse and used to them. We were camping in the outback and it's a method of restraint. I would never do or allow a stockmans hobble on my horse.
 
When I was having issues with Flipo, I watched a fair bit of Clinton Anderson on horse and county. Until I saw a hobbling episode. I respect that this method may have its uses but it didn't sit well with me and overshadowed the rest of his suggestions so that I stopped watching.
I've read his response. I guess he's trying to bulldoze through the rumour mill with a 'frank' explanation but that statement does come across as arrogant where he should have been gracious and apologetic. I would imagine I'd be especially suspicious if my horse died while in someone else's care, no matter if the reality of it was natural cases and bad luck.
 
He is described in the intro as an "Australian entertainer".

Horse breaking and training is not for entertainment. It should be to introduce cooperation, partnership and understanding, and establish working relationships for a confident future. Demos should be informative and educational. For thinking individuals this will prove entertaining as well, something aided by the personality of the trainer.

I worry occasionally about what goes on behind the scenes and at the business places of these people who go round doing demos and expounding their ways of working with horses. Some I feel at ease with, others less so.

We don't really know what went on in this case, but the bare known facts are repugnant. Firmness has a purpose, cruelty does not.
 
newrider.com