looking for informations

Status
Not open for further replies.

horseback

New Member
Feb 24, 2006
11
0
0
Hi,
Please don't get me wrong !!!!
I know that my request is extremly hazardous.... so please don't get me wrong ....my attention is not to start a war about diffient opinions....

So here I go...:
I 'm working on a study about Pop.Natural Horse Man Ship Trainers, like Monty Roberts, Pat Parelli and so on,....and their methods...
I do have already a lot of positve informations, what I realy need by now are the negatve sides....not the commercial ones that are already well known, I do need facts about negative impacts (abuses....?!) on the horse caused by the different Trainers or their methods.
Concerning this I do have already some stuff concerning Monty Roberts and Klaus Ferdinand Hempfling....I realy need ( if they are....?!) some informations ( negative ones ) concerning Pat Parelli and his PNH program...

So if anybody can help me out with this kind of informations I will be very thankfull !
I will keep all the Informator confidential of course !
So, if anyone can help me he may contact me directly via mail : [email protected]

Thank you very much in advance and hopre to hear from you !
With best regards
 
Are you talking about documented cases or are you looking for personal opinions?

What is the study for? I'm happy to help and put my opinions but it depends on what it's being used for. Are the negative opinions on Monty and Klaus your opinions or opinions that you have gathered from other people?

Are you talking specifically about Monty, Pat Parelli, Mark Rashid etc or about the way that the methods are interpreted by the masses? The problem if you're not being specific is that someone following, for example, Monty's way of doing things may not be doing them in the way that Monty does them if that makes any sense.

As I said, I'm happy to give my opinion but I want more info first please.
 
Bay Mare said:
Are you talking about documented cases or are you looking for personal opinions? .....Both...

What is the study for? As living in France, I do write my study about what is natural in the natural horsemanship movement and this means to show of the sunny side of it aswell the darkside...I'm happy to help and put my opinions but it depends on what it's being used for. Are the negative opinions on Monty and Klaus your opinions or opinions that you have gathered from other people? [....B]I do have already + & - negative facts and opinions about Roberts and Hempfling and I do ask my self concerning the mostknown of all...P.Parelli, if there is aslo shadow by so much light... well there is ,for this moment very few shadow that I do have collect and I ask myself if is there more...[/B]...
Are you talking specifically about Monty, Pat Parelli, Mark Rashid etc ....more this than the people, I guess that they maybe didn't have it realy understand if things goes wrong and I don't blame them for that...nobody's perfect...even not the masters...that's what I look for .......or about the way that the methods are interpreted by the masses? The problem if you're not being specific is that someone following, for example, Monty's way of doing things may not be doing them in the way that Monty does them if that makes any sense.

As I said, I'm happy to give my opinion but I want more info first please.

So I hope it brings more light on my request....
 
I think the main negative for any horse training method is misuse or misinterpretation of it.
Alot of people who criticise a particular method do so because they often dont understand it. I think the biggest critics of parelli for example are people who have either never dont it, or have been taught be someone who really wasnt qualified to teach them, or the method didnt suit them or their horses for some reason. The same could be said of Monty Roberts and many others. Most people I have talked to that have actually done Parelli and given it more than a cursory look ( for example didnt just read the book or watch the video's) have either gone on with it or they are happy with the amount of knowledge they have gained and dont want to go further for many different reasons.

There are some methods that have negatives in my opinion but thats only my opinion. It may not be an actual negative for the horse or trainer.

I would hope that if you are doing a study you will focus on experts opinions rather than armchair experts who are merely spouting their opinion rather than hard cold facts :)

Anecdotes are often very misleading unless you actually witness the event, and even then personal biases can come into play.
 
If you do a search on here there are one or two threads where people related problems they'd experienced when trying PNH.

The difficulty with finding negative experiences of any trainer's stuff is that those negative experiences can happen for so many reasons, not all of them to do with the trainer's method itself.
 
Well, I'm looking not for "armchair" or secondhand opinions... I'm looking for firsthand experiences ( like somme in the old post "Who needs Parelli") one one hand on the other hand sure I will be glad too have experts view of the work - method and statemants of the weel known trainers and it's negative impact on the horse.....Especially since Parelli has become official here in France he is full of glory and nearly everybody is blinded by the light.....one will nearly see him to be able to walk on water.....So by soooo much of light there is surley some kind of shadow aswell .....I do know already of a case of a horse died of nervous colic in switzerland 2 hours after a trailer loading demonstration by Mr Parelli himself..... so.....I'm sure that there is some stuff like this.....I don't want to discredit the known trainers , I just look for facts....nobody is perfect and free of failure....even not the Pop star like trainers or they Instructors.....
So any help will be welcome that will help me to set the things into the right light..... more and more scientists here in France are more and more against some of this stuff done and told by some of these trainers.....I do look for facts.....nothing against a certain method bout I do ask myself if it's all gold that shines so bright ?!!!!
 
I only know a little bit about the various forms of Natural Horsemanship (which is a bit of an engendered term, but hey!) but I do know more about equine psychology and behaviour.

Equine psychology and behaviour is a scientific discipline, acceptable in modern academia with measurable and quantifiable results.

Therefore, to critically appraise Natural Horsemanship methods and the way in which they manipulate the horse's natural behaviours to reach the desired outcome; I would say go away and read as much as you can on animal behaviourism and a a bit on equine evolution too.

Then you have a good basic knowledge and understanding based on scientific rationale to use as a baseline meaure to deconstruct the theories of Parelli, Roberts et al.

This book is a good introductory reader:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/0632048786/qid=1140970174/sr=1-2/ref=sr_1_0_2/203-2929048-4652752

and this is very easy to read:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/0753801124/qid=1140970281/sr=1-7/ref=sr_1_3_7/203-2929048-4652752
 
Thank you very much.....I do indeed read a lot about animal and horse behaviour.....as a future scientist in animalbehaviour I know that they are "some things" mentionend by the so called "natural horseman's" are far away from real live.....what I look for....are testmonials concerning the negative impact on the horse.....like the one that I have mentioned in my previous post concerning the horse in switzerland that have died by colic after a trailerloading session done by Pat Parelli himself.....I've seen a video recording of this session and it was far away from a stressless and resistance free loading demonstration.....there was a huge gap between what Parelli was saying and what he was actually doing......a lot of people present at this demo was finding the endresult (the horse was nearly jumping into the trailer) a kind of "oh great!" moment.....but unfortunaly they was not putting in question that the horse was soaked in sweat and clearly afraid about the man and his actions toward him......on the other hand I have seen by my own, a session (here in France) by Klaus Ferdinand Hempfling done with a 2 year old filly that was turning into a real nightmare.....an the only commentary from Hempfling was: "well, this can happend".... Sure, it can...but I'm not sure if it doe's do by a so called professionel....
So, hope you have know some ideas for what I'm looking for....?!
 
Ah -I can see exactly where you are directing your research.

Have you thought about approaching the trainers directly? If they are as open minded and non-judgemental as they suggest then they should be co-operative and freely share their information and failures along with their successes. Most of the trainers have websites and there are very many other acolytes and assistants who follow the methods of the high profile NH people like Monty Roberts, Pat Parelli et al.

I think you will need the co-operation of the trainers otherwise you run the risk of relying on anecdotal evidence. Have you thought about advertising in the equestrian press for information, although to do this tactfully and not imply any criticism will be difficult.
 
I've seen a video recording of this session and it was far away from a stressless and resistance free loading demonstration.....there was a huge gap between what Parelli was saying and what he was actually doing......a lot of people present at this demo was finding the endresult (the horse was nearly jumping into the trailer) a kind of "oh great!" moment.....but unfortunaly they was not putting in question that the horse was soaked in sweat and clearly afraid about the man and his actions toward him......

How appalling, and exactly the reason I have reservations about aspects of his 'system'. I would feel the same about this happening with any trainer, whoever they were.
 
ambatt said:
Ah -I can see exactly where you are directing your research.

Have you thought about approaching the trainers directly?
Oh yes.....already 6 month ago and guess what ?....No answer at all.....!
If they are as open minded and non-judgemental as they suggest then they should be co-operative and freely share their information and failures along with their successes. Most of the trainers have websites and there are very many other acolytes and assistants who follow the methods of the high profile NH people like Monty Roberts, Pat Parelli et al.

I think you will need the co-operation of the trainers otherwise you run the risk of relying on anecdotal evidence.
Well since the trainers prefer not to answer.....to busy with their bussiness, I guess or everything is fine....? I think that I have to take this risk....of relying of the "anectotes of the victimes"....
Have you thought about advertising in the equestrian press for information, by this way I do have found the swiss incedent....but informations are rare, 'cause everything is nice or the peolpe are to afraid...(at least about what...?)...?
although to do this tactfully and not imply any criticism will be difficult.
So, I can hardly beleave that it is all gold what shines....
 
Tricky, very tricky!

Do you think the trainers will not co-operate in providing negative experiences in case they are sued? Given today's litigation culture then this would seem likely?

Mark Rashid admits when it goes wrong, but that is in his books, as someone else pointed out he is not technically an NH person.

Have you tried Kelly Marks and Richard Maxwell? I did know of someone who sent a horse away to be schooled at a known NH yard and it came back a wreck. It was a friend of a friend and a few years ago, will see if they would talk abut their experience, but it might take a while.
 
ambatt said:
Tricky, very tricky!

Do you think the trainers will not co-operate in providing negative experiences in case they are sued? Given today's litigation culture then this would seem likely?

I don't think this is just about the trainers concern about litigation. If someone says something slanderous or libellous about a trainer, they WILL end up in court. So anyone who talks about their experiences would need to be very sure of their facts - and anyone who quotes such experiences would also need to be extremely rigorous to ensure the facts of the case.

I have seen someone doing something I thought was not entirely effective - but that is not a fact, that is my opinion and interpretation of what I saw. And what I saw was not a welfare situation by any means - just not as pleasant or successful as I thought it might have been.

Is that a dark side or is that just reality ?
 
ambatt said:
Tricky, very tricky!

Do you think the trainers will not co-operate in providing negative experiences in case they are sued? Given today's litigation culture then this would seem likely?

Mark Rashid admits when it goes wrong, but that is in his books, as someone else pointed out he is not technically an NH person.

Have you tried Kelly Marks and Richard Maxwell? I did know of someone who sent a horse away to be schooled at a known NH yard and it came back a wreck. It was a friend of a friend and a few years ago, will see if they would talk abut their experience, but it might take a while.

Well, I have seen Kelly Marks here in France and was asking myself if she wanted to show the people during her demo : what NOT TO DO...." ?!
 
cvb said:
I don't think this is just about the trainers concern about litigation. If someone says something slanderous or libellous about a trainer, they WILL end up in court.

I was thinking more along the lines of *if* a trainer admitted they had made a mistake with a horse, and that horse then had an injury, or died or whatever, then the trainer has admitted liability and is therefore more open to litigation. Hence any trainer's not unreasonable desire to be reticent with potentially sensitive information.

And you are absolutely right to point out that a lot of situations are dependent on context and perception and as such open to many different interpretations.

But it will be very interesting research, and for true objectivity the flip side of NH should be examined (and I am not necessarily saying there is a negative side) I just like to see both sides of the coin.
 
ambatt - didn't mean to say your issue wasn't relevent - more than its double so because of the slander/libel element :)

Horseback

It occurs to me to ask what your benchmark is going to be ? Are you only comparing within "natural horsemanship" or are you going to benchmark to "non-NH" trainers ?

In the UK there is a process of accident reporting that all approved centres have to use. SO in theory you could use accident reports as a way in - compare the rate of accidents in NH to non-NH and explore specific accidents ?

I don't think we would have enough data on the NH centre side to be statistically significant (yet) here in the Uk but as PNH has been adopted by the French federation, you may have more...
 
I think the only way to really do the research is to go for work placements on several NH yards! I guess this is utterly impractical, but it would give you first hand insight.

I think cvb is right in saying that establishing a baseline will be difficult because there is no comparable research.

Most of your research and case histories will be anecdotal unless you actively canvass for participants.

Also if you look at the other trainers who follow the teachings of say for argument's sake, Monty Roberts, there is no guarantee that they do follow his principles and treat horses in the same way.

I do know an anecdotal story about that too and I would be happy to tell you about that by PM (will check with people concerned) and then get back to you .
 
ambatt said:
I think the only way to really do the research is to go for work placements on several NH yards! I guess this is utterly impractical, but it would give you first hand insight.

I think cvb is right in saying that establishing a baseline will be difficult because there is no comparable research.

Most of your research and case histories will be anecdotal unless you actively canvass for participants.

Also if you look at the other trainers who follow the teachings of say for argument's sake, Monty Roberts, there is no guarantee that they do follow his principles and treat horses in the same way.

I do know an anecdotal story about that too and I would be happy to tell you about that by PM (will check with people concerned) and then get back to you .

Hope to hear from you....you may contact me also via mail : [email protected]
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com