keeping the horse moving

Emarmite

New Member
May 19, 2000
268
0
0
66
Manchester, England
Visit site
I have had problems this week with getting the horse to move.
I had a private trial lesson at a new school and it did
not matter how much I kicked he would not go any faster and
when I gave him a tap with my crop he just stopped. I ride
twice a week and do not usually have this problem, but on Monday I did not seem to be able to kick my horse without my feet moving in my stirrups, maybe it made me more
paranoid. When I asked the instructor what she thought I was doing wrong on the trial lesson she said "well you will have to come for lessons and find out", I did not think
this was very constructive, any advise I would appreciate it


Beverley
 
Hi Beverley - could it be that you were riding one of those school horses who are just dead to the leg? Sounds to me that if you don't normally have this problem, it was the horse rather than you (or rather, all the badly taught riders that horse has had to endure in the past, so that now he just ignores the leg). And as for the instructor saying, come back and find out...! That makes me froth at the mouth. You were already paying to be taught. Is there another school in your area, or other teachers at this school, and some more forward-going horses?
 
I second Fran's comments. It is scandalous that a) these poor horses have been kicked into oblivion by pupils who are not to blame either- it is the instructors/system that are to blame and b) that you have to pay money to be taught on deadened, bored animal that nobody bothers to school, even less to then keep up to scratch. People can't believe how responsive my horses are. I couldn't teach people to ride properly if they weren't, and yet I am something of an outcast in the mainstream teaching world, because I don't 'conform'- and what is more, I never will. My job is to teach, and to do that effectively, you need the correct 'tools'. If that means being different to he rest, then so be it!

Dont do yourself down. I am sure that it isn't your fault!


Heather
 
I think it may well be the horse.
Was this your first lesson at this school?
If so, look at it from the instructors point of view. She had no idea of your standard of riding, so maybe, she put you on the school stodge, safe in the knowledge that this particular horse would not react no matter how bad a rider you may have turned out to be.

I cannot stand people belting my horses in the ribs. Yanking mouths and harsh kicking are guaranteed to make me short tempered with folk.
I wish one could demonstrate to the rider just how it feels to be kicked in the ribs. Unfortunately it probably results in assult charges!!
Thankfully most of our horses will react if "kicked", this teaches folk to be a bit more thoughtful in the boot department.
 
What kind of an idiot are you!? You have absolutly no right whatsoever to be kicking your lesson horse!, And you have even LESS right to be using a crop on that horse! Did it ever enter your mind to learn the horses name and to try and coax him or her into lugging you around on his/her back. Horses are very intelligent and they will understand and obey if you get there respect.

p.s. You can't earn a horses respect by kicking and whipping them.







suprjocky
 
Gerrad I appreciate you may feel strongly about this but calling someone an 'idiot' is not very constructive. Beverley is there to learn that is the whole point of forking out for lessons - its diffucult to be expected to learn how to ride or to improve on a horse which will not respond to aids - it will just turn into one big viscious circle. I blame the system too - the fact that Heather is made to feel an 'outcast' says it all really.
 
Next time, dismount and say, (very politely) "Sorry I don't seem to be able to ride this horse. Could you show me how well he really CAN go?" Then judge the quality of your instruction by the response.
 
Name calling

Gerrad. R

Beverly was obviously having a pretty difficult lesson. For those who can already ride and/or have the access to well-schooled horses, it is much eaasier to work to the ideal. I am positive Beverly was not trying to gain the horse's respect, but merely to proceed with a trial lesson and was probably responding to an instructor's suggestions.

People who can ride/own horses do owe it to those less fortunate, those who are simply trying to learn to do something they love, to offer support and constructive advice, rather than criticism and insults. I am sure you did not mean to put Beverly down in such a harsh manner, but words can pack a powerful punch when thoughtlessly used.
 
Just to say thank you for everyone's imput to my question
about moving the horse on. I appreciate the help this site gives and it great to hear other peoples point of view.

I will refrain from making any further comments about Garrad's remarks except to say I was extremely upset when I read his comments.


Thank you again


Beverley
 
Don't be Discouraged

Beverly,

I agree with most of the persons that it was probably the horse in combination with how past riders (especially beginners)have treated it in combination with the teacher's neglect to explain proper procedures. Obviously the horse has become numb to rider's attempts. This isn't right. Where I ride there are also lazy horses, but with the right constant leg pressure and just carrying a crop (not using) gets them going. It also has to do with your mood during the lesson. I have been riding for 2 years and taking lessons for this whole time. Sometimes my sensitive thoroughbred even lags and will continue to do so if I become frustrated rather than focused. Like people, horses have their lazy and spunky days. Do try one more lesson here, perhaps with another horse, if the teacher still responds in this manner find another stable!!!!

Good Luck
 
As far as I was aware . You squeeze with your legs, if the horse doesn't respond, you squeeze harder, if still no joy you give a little kick, after that you give a little tap on with your stick. That is the way I am being taught at he moment and I have different instructors. Do not listen to the opinion of others unless it is constructive, and well founded. Try a different instructor or a different horse but do not lose heart.
~Dave~
 
Never be afraid of backing up leg aids with a tap with the stick.
What would you prefer, one or two taps with a stick or a constant battering in the ribs? You are not being cruel.
 
Sadly I fear the "dead horse syndrome" is far more common than any of us realise.
Some time ago I booked myself in for a week's jumping course at a school. Second day, they put me on a 16hh chestnut for some gridwork. We walked into the school with no problem, walked around on a loose rein for a while, then trotted. Again, no problem. Then we lined up behind the other pupils as they took it in turns to canter around the outside of the school before popping over a very small warm-up crosspole. As soon as it was our turn, my horse simply refused to budge. He did not want to jump and no amount of squeezing/coercing was gonna change his mind.
I gave him what I considered to be adequate flicks with the whip when he ignored my legs. I was stunned when the instructor told me to hold my whip up high "as if it was an umbrella" . . . then bring it down with all my strength.
Now I'm just under 6ft and 12.5 stone, so bringing a whip down from that height with all my strength leads to a pretty powerful blow. I did not do this, but did give a stronger flick than previously. When the instructor insisted I hit him much harder I said I really did not want to beat a horse to death just to get him to hop over a pole.
Eventually, he agreed to move after the instructor ran up behind us flicking a schooling whip at his hocks while I waved the whip, jockey-style. It was appalling and both the horse and I hated every second of it.
After the so-called lesson, the instructor told me that my horse was "the bane of her life" and simply did not want to work anymore. I later discovered that this unfortunate animal often jumped six days a week, sometimes twice a day. No wonder he didn't want to do anything.
I quit the course the next morning. I only wish I could have taken the poor animal with me.

Neil
 
This is a very sad story Neil.

I really do feel for these bored, stale horses. We never allow our horses to take on such monotonous work. Variety in everything. This horse is trying to tell you something, sadly the only people who are willing to listen are those without the power to do anything practical.

I certainly would not like to get the full force of a whip weilded by someone over 6 ft tall.
I also feel it is a litle unprofessional to chase a horse and rider with a stick. As an instructor it is an admission of failure to both horse and rider!
 
Neil,

I was nearly in tears by your story, what an awful situation to be in, I think I would have burst into tears, that poor horse. These so called instructors should be put in the arena and whipped and see how they feel. Since coming onto this site I have my eyes opened, and I am so much more reluctant to have to make the horse work through constant kicking and cropping. In my lesson last night one of the younger girls, about 11 or 12, was gently walking around the arena with the rest of us and she was kicking like mad at her horse and wacking it on the backside with her crop This poor horse did not deserve this because he was not doing anything wrong. It took all my willpower not to go over to her and give her a good telling off. But at the end of the day she is only doing what they are teaching her. Maybe I should buy her Heather's book for xmas!

If you read my message from last night, it tells you my new experience with a horse by keep talking to her and gently squeezing to move her on, and at one point just asking for trot and she responded, I cannot begin to describe the feeling I had it was lovely. I got some very funny looks from the younger riders as I kept talking to my horse, but who cares, my horse I thought got an 'enlightened rider' who is trying really hard and she responded beautifully.

I hope my story inspires you and wish you the best of look in your next school.

Keep us informed

Beverley
 
newrider.com