Well... if her farm's any bit like the ones where I live... I would believe it. Especially if it's a hunter barn. What I wouldn't believe is whether or not she can jump that high well. I mean, techinically... there are plenty of old schoolies who you can throw anyone on, point 'em at a fence, give the horse a smack on the rump and off they go, no matter how unbalanced or unskilled the rider is. But that's not really being a good rider. All the RIs around here like to brag about how fast they can get students jumping- but it's really not a good idea- they're gambling their student's safety for a confidence boost, an adrenaline rush, and something to brag about. Unless you're taking private sessions three or four times a week with a trainer, it's going to take a long time to build up the various abilities required for good, safe jumping.
You need independent balance (not dependent on your hands or your feet- a good rider needs to be able to stay balanced over a fence even if they lose a stirrur, and can't be holding themselves in the saddle with the horse's face over a fence!), excellent riding form (yes, chin up, weight on the rider's block, shoulders level, soft hands, a good ear/shoulder/hip/heel line... the whole package), did I mention soft hands and good balance?, and most importantly- INSTINCTS. You need to spend a lot of time around horses to learn how, when, and why they react to safely jump horses, and you need to be completely comfortable and understanding of a horse's way of going. You can't be caught off guard.
I wouldn't compare yourself to the other rider. Either she is an extremely talanted and natural rider, or her RI is pushing her faster than she can learn, and she's not really that good of a rider.