IMO, open fronted tendon boots are a must for jumping. Any horse, even the most careful, can land short and a hind foot will quite literally sever the tendons into pieces if they hit it. Any horse can catch a fence and tip up - I have had it happen to me on a horse I consider to be very careful. The fence itself was only small too - we just caught it wrong and ended up kicking the pole along with us. Horse was lame for a week or so and the vet said it could have been much worse had it not been booted up. I also think over-reach boots are important, especially if the horse is shod. Again, any horse can land wrong and split it's heels/pasterns open.
I wouldn't even consider going XC without event boots all round. Horses can break legs on solid fences very easily and I want to help prevent that as best as I can.
There will always be the arguement that it stops them feeling a pole etc, which is why I use open fronted tendon boots for SJ. They feel if they're careless and rattle a pole, but their tendons are still protected. However you wouldn't take a careless horse round XC in the first place, so going in open-fronted boots for that reason would be madness.
Personally, it's boots all the way for me when jumping. If you'd posted that pic on here I wouldn't have said "oh you're cruel" etc etc as it's your horse and your choice, but I may have suggested boots - some people will jump without boots and never have a problem but others will not be so lucky. I've seen some nasty accidents in the past, and it's always awful to see a horse injured, but when it happens and it could've been prevented then it's ten times worse.
I have three horses - one is now retired through injury but when he was in work I always schooled him in front brushing boots because he moved quite closely in front (if doing lateral work I put back boots on too), and jumped in brushing boots all round and over-reach boots. He was careful anyway so I didn't worry about open fronted boots - I knew that if he hit a pole it was a genuine mistake and not down to carelessness. One is ridden in over-reach boots (wears them all the time) as he wears egg bar shoes. He jumps in open fronted tendon boots and nothing behind. Before he needed the egg bars he jumped in his open front tendon boots, and went XC in boots all round and over-reach boots. My third horse also moves quite closely and I school in front boots. He doesn't really jump but I plan to get him going over summer, and he'll jump in boots all round and over-reach boots - I don't know yet whether he'll wear open fronted tendon boots or brushing boots; depends if he's careful. Again if he ever went XC, boots all round and over-reach boots.