Joy is girthy again

I know pink doesnt like wintecs but surely they are not bad for all horses i have a TBx whom i ride in a wintec 500 and never had any probs.


I would never say a saddle is bad for all horses, it just didn't suit mine despite being told by a professional that it did. In fact I think I'm right in saying that Pink's friend is getting one as it does suit that horse and even Pink agreed!

If I thought for one moment that my saddle was going to be bad for all horses then I wouldn't be cleaning it (:o ) ready to sell on eBay. I would rather take a loss than put a bad saddle up for sale to muck up another horses back.

I just dispair. I did everything I should have and still got it wrong :mad:
 
Another Update

I went out to a tack shop that carried a vast number of saddles including Saddle Company and spent the morning trying them out for comfort.

Funilly enough, I didn't find the Saddle Company one very comfy at all :eek:

The one I immediately liked was the Thorowgood L6. It had a nice deep seat and wasn't rock hard. Has anyone had any experience of these?

I have another saddle fitter coming out to me a week tomorrow bringing a selection of saddles with her including the L6's and Saddle Company. I am looking forward to getting Joy more comfortable :)

If she suits the L6 and I get some good feedback on NR about it then that would be my preference. The most important thing to me is getting something that fits her and then I will consider my comfort.
 
i am going through this with jay right now, im looking at the T4 high wither.

hope you find one that suits you both :)
 
I have someone coming over from Boorley Green. Joy is just outside Droxford :)

I sat on a few different makes whilst I was there and was disappointed that I didn't like the Saddle Company one they had there. I was leaning towards that one :rolleyes:

Anyway, this is all by the by as there will be a large selection to choose from and it's just a case of finding the right one for Joy and making sure I can cope with it too.

I ideally need something with a deeper seat that won't chuck me into a chair seat position :o

The L6 was really comfy for me and I like the fact that the back panels can be changed too rather than just the front gullet. Given that it is the back of the saddle that has been causing the stiffness in Joy's back due I am keen that her new saddle will fit right in that area.

I need to have faith that this fitter knows her onions :(
 
well good luck i hope you get it sorted soon saddle fitters are as difficult as farriers by the sounds of things.Its so annoying they are suposed to be the profesionals whom we rely on to get things right, it kinda makes you wonder who to trust doesnt it.:confused:
 
I have the saddle fitter coming out today. Fingers crossed this one knows her job :(

I Googled her and she has been recommended on other forums but then my last saddle fitter was recommended to me AND my RI uses him so what can you do :confused:
 
Final Update!

Well the saddle fitter came today. She rang to say she would be late so it was all very rushed in the end as I literally had to dash off to pick up my daughter from school.

The important thing was that she was with us for 2 hours and the fitting part wasn't rushed, she just didn't have time to explain in full what I would be getting!

The upshot is that I am getting the new Thorowgood Cob T6. There was a lot of options to run through. Different trees, then different panels.

I'll pop up to see her tomorrow to find out exactly what options of each she has gone for and why.

Joy has a very forward girth groove which doesn't help and also can't take more than a 17 inch saddle although my bum is more deserving of an 18 inch so I need to diet.

Add to that Joy is still slightly croup high so has more growing and filling out to do.

We have a well fitting (I hope) saddle sorted out so all I need to do is get hubby to phone up and pay for it (and a non-slip numnah) once he has been paid on 15th :p

Athough the saddle is great for Joy, and she moved nicely in it, I don't find it as comfy as my Wintec VSD. The important thing is that Joy is happy. I'm sure I'll get used to the new one in time and will forget about the old one which I am now going to list on eBay.
 
Thats good news. Thorowgoods are nice saddles. My only gripe is the very narrow panels they have at the back.:rolleyes: I have a thorowgood cob with Flair but eventulally got a saddle company saddle as the panels are wider.

If you find it uncomfy try a seat saver - can work wonders!
 
Thats good news. Thorowgoods are nice saddles. My only gripe is the very narrow panels they have at the back.:rolleyes: I have a thorowgood cob with Flair but eventulally got a saddle company saddle as the panels are wider.

If you find it uncomfy try a seat saver - can work wonders!

Thanks pink :)

The lady spent time trying various panels and we thought we had a fit until I got on to ride and she made me get straight back off again :D

Looking at the Thorowgood website, the only mention of the 3D fit is with the L6 but this new T6 has the same features.

I'll pop in to her today if she is going to be about and have a more indepth conversation about what panels were available and what she decided on and why. Having been let down once I want as much info as I can to get things straight in my mind.

I don't know if it was just wishful thinking or Joy showing off for her field mates and neighbours again (as she was doing on the lunge) but she did move beautifully when I trialed the saddle.

Hubby gets paid soon so I get Joy's new saddle soon.

On the plus side, Joy seems to have lost a lot of her stiffness down the right side. She still has some that I can feel down the left side.

The plan is to get the physio back out again at the end of the month to reassess the situation. Once I am happy that the physio is happy then I will start building up the hacking and will get my RI back in to ride Joy and see if she notices any chance in Joy. :)

In the meantime the massages and groundwork continues :D
 
Had a chat and Joy has the cob tree, medium wide gullet and drop panels.

She showed me the difference between the ones she was looking at and the drop panels we ended up with. There is a lot more support through the shoulder as when I got on Joy with the first ones in place the saddle dropped down at the front hense I was ordered off again straight away :rolleyes: Also if you look at the back (which is the problem area of the old saddle) it has wider weight bearing surfaces there too. It was good to be able to look at the differences between the 2 options that she narrowed it down to :)

Aparently, from what I could gather, for my needs I had the option between 2 different trees - the cob and the GP, 4 different panels and 5? different gullets.

The panels on the Thorowgood feel a lot softer than the Wintec ones although the seat on the Wintec feels deeper to me - it may just be because that's what I am used to though. I'll need to bring Joy back into proer work gradually and see if the seatsaver will be needed or whether it is just the shape and depth that I find different. I'll know after building up to my mega hacks :D

Looking forward to seeing what the physio has to say once Joy is back working under saddle again as Joy is less stiff through her back but then she would be because I'm not riding!

The saddle fitter certainly talked the talk. She comes from a behavioural background so looks to the horse for signs. Also she keeps her horses barefoot which is something I would love to be able to do. I like people who don't have to stick with convention for the sake of it.

Thanks everyone for your input. :D
 
Last edited:
Jusr read all of this and really pleased to hear its OK now for Joy, even if you do have to ride with a fluffy seat saver.:p

On that note there are some lovely pure sheepskin seat savers out there. I ordered one and also ordered the sheepskin girth cover as well. Joy might really like that as an optional extra. Unfortunately in my case they didn't have the black seat saver in stock, but I love the grith sleeve. It's like a girth sleeve shaped teddy.;)
 
I think I said in a previous post that I was considing a girth sleeve.

I think as Joy's coat continues to thicken up I will get one. A nice black sheepskin one so that her coat doesn't get pinched and to soak up some of the sweat. Her sweatiest bit is her girth area :)
 
Wow, sounds like thorowgoods have come on leaps and bounds since I bought mine (only last year!).

Once you've got your saddle you must send me pictures please - I'd like to see this new panels thingy. I've heard of this new fangled panel change thing which sounds like a good idea, but not see it yet. Thats great they've changed to panel width - my saddles panels looked like this:mad:

saddlenew003.jpg


This looks worse than it was - it has flair fitted so the panels were very very swuishy and moulded to her the second weight was put into the saddle. But still FAR too narrow!
saddlepanelsnarrowness.jpg
 
Just read this and my interest perked up when you mentioned Physio and Winchester ... was it Amanda Sutton ?

I recently had her out and we've been using her for the last 10 years. Fab lady :D
 
Just read this and my interest perked up when you mentioned Physio and Winchester ... was it Amanda Sutton ?

I recently had her out and we've been using her for the last 10 years. Fab lady :D


She was was Sutton's but it wasn't Amanda herself, T'was someone from the practice whose name I have forgotton :o but she is from New Zealand :)
 
I know how you feel about professionals letting you down. I had a dentist come out and give Curly the all clear, got another one and he had a feel in her mouth and picked up 'The Big Rasp' - he let me have a feel and her teeth were sharp and mouth was all ulcerated and cut. I felt so guilty and awful for her but dont beat yourself up about her saddle, you didnt know :)


I had a sit on one of the new Throwgood saddles - i liked it. Looks lovely aswell. Im after the T6 jumping saddle.
 
newrider.com