Had a chat and Joy has the cob tree, medium wide gullet and drop panels.
She showed me the difference between the ones she was looking at and the drop panels we ended up with. There is a lot more support through the shoulder as when I got on Joy with the first ones in place the saddle dropped down at the front hense I was ordered off again straight away

Also if you look at the back (which is the problem area of the old saddle) it has wider weight bearing surfaces there too. It was good to be able to look at the differences between the 2 options that she narrowed it down to
Aparently, from what I could gather, for my needs I had the option between 2 different trees - the cob and the GP, 4 different panels and 5? different gullets.
The panels on the Thorowgood feel a lot softer than the Wintec ones although the seat on the Wintec feels deeper to me - it may just be because that's what I am used to though. I'll need to bring Joy back into proer work gradually and see if the seatsaver will be needed or whether it is just the shape and depth that I find different. I'll know after building up to my mega hacks
Looking forward to seeing what the physio has to say once Joy is back working under saddle again as Joy is less stiff through her back but then she would be because I'm not riding!
The saddle fitter certainly talked the talk. She comes from a behavioural background so looks to the horse for signs. Also she keeps her horses barefoot which is something I would love to be able to do. I like people who don't have to stick with convention for the sake of it.
Thanks everyone for your input.
