join up frustration!!

risky buisness

old newbie
Jan 28, 2009
462
0
16
kent
hey, iv been trying to do join up but the thing is we dont have a round pen only a normal rubber school which is quite big.(when running around after a horse!) i find it hard to keep her going as she stops in 1 corner will im dieing from running in the other:p im just finding it to hard to make join up happen!!

just wondered if there was a kind of parelli/monty roberts game i could do with her that could gain what join up does ...i hope you can understand this because im finding hard putting it into words... :) i have done the 7 games in 7 minutes with her ... i have done join up with her before at my old yard but i find that were miles apart at the minute and would love to join up with her again:o if anyone has any suggestions that would be great all help appreciatated :D
 
Pat does the catchig game which is more of a "draw" thing.
Well done on doing the 7 games in as many minuits,it took me quite a while to sort out the sideways game :D

she was brill at the games she had the sideways game in seconds! it was backing her up that took forever she got really frustrated but loves it now she can do it:p thanks will look that up join up in a normal school is just not happening:rolleyes:
 
is there no way you can creat a caral in the school, this is what i did in my last yard, as we had no round pen, so long as you have quite a few jumps its easy enough, doesnt have to be round either.
bambi 029.jpg
havnt got a better pic sorry but give you an idea, (i actually used this one for jumping, but if you use a corner you only need to make two sides
 
is there no way you can creat a caral in the school, this is what i did in my last yard, as we had no round pen, so long as you have quite a few jumps its easy enough, doesnt have to be round either.
View attachment 37249
havnt got a better pic sorry but give you an idea, (i actually used this one for jumping, but if you use a corner you only need to make two sides

its a good idea but amey would jump the jumps!! not to mention that i have a few moany ladys at my yard who would complain that im taking up up half the school and blocking my horse in using jumps which is dangerous :rolleyes: i might try this though when there not around:p
 
i was lucky i had three days i could keep them up as the yo didnt ride on them days but taking them down and putting them back up was a pain, the jumps need to be high, suki tried it once and knew then she could get out, so had to put them high, but she is only 12 2:D
 
i was lucky i had three days i could keep them up as the yo didnt ride on them days but taking them down and putting them back up was a pain, the jumps need to be high, suki tried it once and knew then she could get out, so had to put them high, but she is only 12 2:D

wish i had the yard for 3 days to myself !! see amey is 14.2 although thats not much bigger:p i might give it a go ask see if everyone is ok with it first! but if not any other games or not what would be a good help
 
You can get the same results as join up by doing groundwork exercises, because at the end of the day all it's about is the horse knowing that you can move it's feet about and knowing that you're consistent and reliable and good to be around. Does your horse follow you round the school without a leadrope?
 
Does your horse follow you round the school without a leadrope?

yes she does follow me without one on.:) i do quite alot of ground work but we dont seem to be getting on that well latley i dont no why :( its kind of getting me down last time i felt distance from her i did some join up and just spent time just grooming/feeding and stroking her and we were ok...but this time she just dosent seem to be interested in working with me..i no it has somthing to do with what im doing not sure what that is :confused: but i thought some join up would be good but i cant do that at my yard so i thought some parelli games would be good to:)
 
but this time she just dosent seem to be interested in working with me.

Careful you dont turn the 7 games into 7 chores!

Have you mixed them up ie not doing them in the order you learn them and used obstacles? Are you 'enjoying' playing or are you just going thro the motions? Maybe your horse needs you to be more provocative?

I cant give you much more than that unless you give me an idea of her character ie is she confident, steady, slow, fast, tense, mouthy, does she look at you with both eyes and ears or look elsewhere? etc...
 
i do make sure that i dont do the 7 seven games to often and always mix it up :) her character shes very confiedent in what she does , she always been a fast pony:p she can be tense at times depends on what im asking of her. most tense when schooling (were working on this).

she does look at me with eyes on me and ears forward ... but she hasnt latey she seems kind of distracted like shes thinking bout somthing else...in her own little world somtimes..:confused: like to what that is !
 
she was brill at the games she had the sideways game in seconds! it was backing her up that took forever she got really frustrated but loves it now she can do it:p :

Parelli really do need to take a lesson in teaching horses to back up in-hand. This has confused horses and handlers for years, and still they refuse to address it. Every week, on some forum or other, there are people and horses with the same problem............the four phases of backing up. :rolleyes:

she does look at me with eyes on me and ears forward ... but she hasnt latey she seems kind of distracted like shes thinking bout somthing else...in her own little world somtimes.. like to what that is !

PNH trained horses often display this characteristically vacant demeanour............I'm sure it's caused by boredom and, possibly, frustration. They are constantly having to do the same things over and over, without inspiration or seeming to progress, which causes them to lose all their vitality.

Imagine a parent expecting a child to only play in a small garden with the same ball every day..........sometimes throwing it, sometimes kicking it, sometimes heading it, but not being allowed other toys or another environment to explore.

Automatism...........Involuntary action, unthinking routine; action performed unconciously or subconciously, mental state accompanying such actions.

Although these horses are doing different 'games', the pressure is unrelenting, and they are subjected, all the time they are working, to the attentions of the carrot stick, and a handler who may be just as confused as they are.

Perhaps that would be different if a professional horse handler/trainer were working with them, but when it's amateurs, using remote teaching to learn, it's no wonder horses become like this.

Why would you want to do Join-up with this mare?

What she needs is walks in-hand, a bit of loose schooling and simple jumping, long reining..........let her see a bit of the world.......anything to stimulate her mind and give her decent breaks from the pressure of these mind-screwing games.
 
Why would you want to do Join-up with this mare?

That's what I was going to ask as well. It doesn't sound, to me, that there's a *need* to do Join Up with this mare. There are plenty of other things that you can do to build your relationship with her.


What she needs is walks in-hand, a bit of loose schooling and simple jumping, long reining..........let her see a bit of the world.......anything to stimulate her mind and give her decent breaks from the pressure of these mind-screwing games.

I agree. You don't need to be doing groundwork constantly to get results. You can still teach manners doing other activities too which will keep your horse interested in their work. It's also more interesting for you :D

I do think that the 7 games are unnecessarily overcomplicated and drawn out. It took about 5 minutes to teach Saff to back up. No waggling ropes or carrot sticks required. She will now back up from a verbal command or a hand signal and, if anything, is more interested in life and work since we've cut back on the negative reinforcement and introduced predominantly positive. The backing up also translated well to rein back under saddle as she already understood the voice command.


she does look at me with eyes on me and ears forward

I don't hold a lot of store by 'ears forward'. When I'm working with her I want her attention on me which means that one ear can be on me. If she has her ears forward then she's concentrating on something in front of her and not on me.


The best 'non traditional' method that I've found so far for builidng a relationship with your horse, getting them onside and getting them interested is clicker/positive reinforcement. Yes, we still use some negative reinforcement but it's predominantly +ve.
 
Parelli really do need to take a lesson in teaching horses to back up in-hand. This has confused horses and handlers for years, and still they refuse to address it. Every week, on some forum or other, there are people and horses with the same problem............the four phases of backing up. :rolleyes:


Although these horses are doing different 'games', the pressure is unrelenting, and they are subjected, all the time they are working, to the attentions of the carrot stick, and a handler who may be just as confused as they are.

Perhaps that would be different if a professional horse handler/trainer were working with them, but when it's amateurs, using remote teaching to learn, it's no wonder horses become like this.

What she needs is walks in-hand, a bit of loose schooling and simple jumping, long reining..........let her see a bit of the world.......anything to stimulate her mind and give her decent breaks from the pressure of these mind-screwing games.

amey knows how to back up now by command so were ok on this.

we dont do parelli constanly she isnt parelli trained! i just like to maybe once a month do some parelli games as she enjoys doing them when she hasnt done them in a while:)

i do loose schooling every two weeks i lunge/longrein twice a week and take her out hacking or do a bit of schooling and jumping the rest of the time and we always walk up the road to cool off (in-hand). as i sed above we dont do parelli constanly just every now then i do a game for something different as she does enjoy it :)
 
Last edited:
do make sure that i dont do the 7 seven games to often and always mix it up her character shes very confiedent in what she does , she always been a fast pony she can be tense at times depends on what im asking of her. most tense when schooling (were working on this).

Ok, so she appears confident and at times will be so. But when she is tense and fast, she is not thinking, she is worrying and therefore she wont learn (at least not something positive or new). At tense times you need to retreat and WAIT. If you put pressure on when she is tense, you wont achieve anything! Wait for her to get her brain thinking again - I wouldnt be surpised if this is where your join up prob lies as she wont come to you if she is only thinking about surviving!

she does look at me with eyes on me and ears forward ... but she hasnt latey she seems kind of distracted like shes thinking bout somthing else...in her own little world somtimes.. like to what that is !

Thats a typical dominant behaviour! (would figure why you had probs with the back up too) When she goes into distracted mode like that she is playing you at mind games. When she does look at you its cos you are interesting and therefore when looking away, you're not or not being a good leader at that point! Cure? do completely the opposite of what you would do! She wont be expecting you to be unpredictable so you need to be!

PNH trained horses often display this characteristically vacant demeanour............I'm sure it's caused by boredom and, possibly, frustration. They are constantly having to do the same things over and over, without inspiration or seeming to progress, which causes them to lose all their vitality.
Any horse doing relentless, non progressive work will turn out a bored, unmotivated horse, which is precisely why Parelli tells you to be PROGRESSIVE and PROVOCATIVE.

I don't hold a lot of store by 'ears forward'. When I'm working with her I want her attention on me which means that one ear can be on me. If she has her ears forward then she's concentrating on something in front of her and not on me.
BM, sorry you've missed the point. When a horse is on the move, granted what you say is true, however, when stood at eg at the end of an exercise then you wait until the horse gives you 2 ears and eyes before moving onto the next one. If as RB's horse is doing, it is looking elsewhere then, it is down to 'whos being the leader here'.
 
Ok, so she appears confident and at times will be so. But when she is tense and fast, she is not thinking, she is worrying and therefore she wont learn (at least not something positive or new). At tense times you need to retreat and WAIT. If you put pressure on when she is tense, you wont achieve anything! Wait for her to get her brain thinking again - I wouldnt be surpised if this is where your join up prob lies as she wont come to you if she is only thinking about surviving!.

i do understand why she gets tense under saddle. she had an ill fitted saddle when i bought her was told it was fitted... and when i had some one out to look at her back a few days after buying her because of the way she acted when ridden she found her very tense and in pain from it.. i got rid of the saddle and got a new 1 and she still can get tense when i repeat somthing that used to hurt with the other saddle! she offen tenses on the ground when she doesnt understand or doesnt want to do what is asked! which results in her putting her ears back when she does this i tend to work on somthing she likes then when shes calmed down try again:)(this is when im doing parelli or not!)



Thats a typical dominant behaviour! (would figure why you had probs with the back up too) When she goes into distracted mode like that she is playing you at mind games. When she does look at you its cos you are interesting and therefore when looking away, you're not or not being a good leader at that point! Cure? do completely the opposite of what you would do! She wont be expecting you to be unpredictable so you need to be!.

she does get distracted alot doesnt matter what work we are doing. she tends to get bored very quickly and im always trying to make it more interesting :rolleyes: she doesnt seem to want to concentrate on what we are doing for long either she seems to find that boring to its like she no's what shes doing and isnt interested!! offen trying to find other stuff to look at etc. horses coming in from the feild, the muck pile and the jump shed...


Any horse doing relentless, non progressive work will turn out a bored, unmotivated horse, which is precisely why Parelli tells you to be PROGRESSIVE and PROVOCATIVE..

i hope i havent given the impression that i do the same thing everyday with her because i dont i do as many different things as i can with her .. its important for me to do different things with her to keep her thinking :)
 
I agree with Yann.Personally (and I may be in the minority)I am not a fan of Join Up.I think it achieves a quick response but not necessarily one that lasts.Consistent and firm but gentle handling over time produces a much better result than join up.I don't think join up is a good experience for the horse.
 
i do understand why she gets tense under saddle. she had an ill fitted saddle when i bought her was told it was fitted... and when i had some one out to look at her back a few days after buying her because of the way she acted when ridden she found her very tense and in pain from it.. i got rid of the saddle and got a new 1 and she still can get tense when i repeat somthing that used to hurt with the other saddle!
Thats perfectly understandable and, as you are doing, working on it in an understanding way -brill.... you have alot of empathy.

she offen tenses on the ground when she doesnt understand or doesnt want to do what is asked! which results in her putting her ears back when she does this i tend to work on somthing she likes then when shes calmed down try again

Tension usually comes from unconfidence, not dominance, although the ears back can be from either - would really need to see her. You have a 50/50 chance of getting it right! If you put pressure on and she is unconfident, she will 'leave' if its dominance chances are she'll just give you a snotty look!
If its dominance then dont give to her whim by doing something she likes, get assertive! If its unconfidence then WAIT, give her time to think and then try again. Stop and reward the slightest try and go do something else.

she does get distracted alot doesnt matter what work we are doing. she tends to get bored very quickly and im always trying to make it more interesting she doesnt seem to want to concentrate on what we are doing for long either she seems to find that boring to its like she no's what shes doing and isnt interested!! offen trying to find other stuff to look at etc. horses coming in from the feild, the muck pile and the jump shed...

Try a change of tact. Think of 3/4 things she does well - preferably with obstacles.... Go and just do those few things. Give masses of praise and quit.
That'll get her thinking. A) because its a bit like the 7 games in 7 mins so its quick and intense, B) because you dont put her in a position that she finds boring or uncomfortable. C) she wont be expecting 'it' to be all done and dusted so quickly!
 
Is she food orientated at all? Using a clicker alongside whatever you are doing can be a great way to engage their attention and enthusiasm, might be worth a try?

qhranger, I don't have any great problem with join up, I think it can be a useful tool and can be a good way of setting off on the right footing with some horses. What it isn't is some kind of magic wand, people do seem to think they're going to miss out on something if they don't do it or can't acheive it, but that isn't really the case.
 
Is she food orientated at all? Using a clicker alongside whatever you are doing can be a great way to engage their attention and enthusiasm, might be worth a try?QUOTE]

yes she loves food:p thats a good idea iv seen a few threads on here about it. will give some thought in to that im open to any suggestions that could help us.! i understand that join-up doesnt cure problems and it doesnt do good on all horses.. but as you sed it can help us start of on the right foot as it did last time we havent been together long and were still learning about eachother :) its fun learning about her but its hard ! thanks for your replys:)
 
newrider.com