Its all gone wrong - don't know what to do

hoofhearted

New Member
Jan 25, 2004
217
0
0
North Wales
Visit site
Went out on Rosie as planned this morning with OH and son walking with us. She planted at the bottom of the steep hill and wouldn't go any further. Eventually got her going and started off down the lane. She was really on her toes, gawping around and then she kept stopping dead, head up in the air, neck stiff as a board. After a few minutes of this I got of (no surprise there:rolleyes:) and led her a little way.

By this time OH had walked on ahead (I had told him to when we were stuck at bottom of hill) and a friend pulled up alongside and I explained how Rosie had been. She encouraged me to get back on and led us along for a short way, then I turned round and headed back towards the yard.

Well, Rosie was jig-jogging, I was trying to relax and sit deep, kept stroking her neck and talking to her. Next thing I know she starts bucking :eek:. Managed to stay on and (amazingly) didn't bail out but kept going, turned the corner and a few yards later, (just as a cars coming down) she repeats the bucking and takes off. She did stop quite quickly, but by this time my nerve had completely failed and I did get off. She was really strong in hand and OH had to lead her as I was struggling, she was quite determined she was going back to the yard asap.

When we got back and turned her out she galloped like a mad thing back to the others in the field.

Please don't slate me, I know I've not had her very long everythings new to her etc, but my confidence was low anyway and tbh I really don't think I'll be able to get back on as I just feel I don't trust her. My nerve has completely gone. She was sold as a bombproof hack and I totally believe the person who sold her, I've also spoken to her previous owner who confirmed this. The only thing that is different is that they always hacked her in company - could this make such a difference to her behaviour.

I'm sorry this is long winded but I'm sitting here in tears, I had such high hopes and I don't know what to do.
 
Of course it makes a difference ! It's a huge difference. The horse needs to be trained to this, just as she would be trained to do anything else. She just doesn't know you're the trustworthy herd leader yet, who can be relied upon to fend off the lions. She feels alone and scared.

Get yourself some help with this horse. Hacking out is as much a skil as 'jumping' or 'dressage'. You need some lessons on 'hacking' with this horse. pay for some help - you don't need to be going through this on your own.
 
I know it doesn't feel like it but this is completely normal. Horses have to be taught to go out on their own. Our youngster started doing it on long reins and in hand. If your horse has never done this its not a bit surprising that you are having these kind of problems.

What you probably need is an experienced and confident rider to teach her to go out alone.

I agree you need expert help, this problem is no different to schooling or jumping issues. It would be worth paying someone to ride out for you.

Until her issues are sorted can you find someone with a quiet horse to go out with you, I'm sure you would be fine in company.
 
Oh dear, poor you. That's the most horrible experience a horse can give you; but you can be really proud of sticking on through two bouts of bucking and gallop – you must be a better rider than you think. Now stop crying, and start planning ...

Kate and rtk are right of course: this horse is very new, she doesn't know you yet, she doesn't know where she is, and she doesn't feel safe unless she's right in the middle of the herd.

What can you do? You can do ground work with her – lunging, leading, all the obedience and manners stuff that Kelly Marks and the rest talk about. Then, when she listens to you in the field, you can lead her out (in a bridle or rope headcollar, not an ordinary webbing headcollar), starting with very short walks, then gradually making them longer.

If you can find someone to ride out with you, or to ride her out for you, or to give you lessons in the field on her, it would help speed it all up.

You will get there - but it will take a bit of time.

PS I'm sorry – I've just looked back, and I see you were having trouble leading her right from the beginning; is she better about leading now? Because that is definitely the place to start.
 
Last edited:
A little bit more has come to light - I've managed to trace a few owners back to a riding school that she originally came from. Have spoken to a lovely girl who has told me that Rosie did used to buck and eventually they stopped using her in the school. Also told me that her nickname was 'pink pig' - bless:D

She is going to get a couple of people who used to ride her the most to call me and give me some more info.

Thank you all for your replies, please keep them coming, need all the help and advice I can get.
 
Please go back and read what I posted to your original question.
I probably should not have written that I hadnt trained a horse not be be scared of something? I meant I hadnt trained a horse of my own. I am a riding school rider.
I hack a lot with just one escort, very often one who is training a horse that has newly arrived at the yard or riding a spooky pony. I have been able to try out the Michael Peace approach, both on horses I ride and by suggesting it to my companion. So far it has worked.
I have seen Michael Peace work with Police Horses twice at demos, when it seems like a miracle. But it works for me too, so there is no magic about it.

However, if you were sold a horse as a safe hack that had not been taught to hack on its own, you may have been mis-sold the animal.
 
Hi. Very sorry to hear of your problems. I also have a horse that napps out on her own. I'm gradually working on this problem riding out with other horses and occassionally building up a safe distance between us to build up both of our confidence.

What I have found that is more helpful for me is spending time riding her in the safety of the farm on her own. Is there somewhere you are able to do this? When she does start playing up I feel more confident in dealing with the situation as there are people around and no cars etc to worry about.

Good Luck

Ps Forgot to add have you got any pets as my horse will accept someone walking my dog with me riding. I know it sounds bizarre but it works!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Skib, I have just re-read your post and agree with what you say. I have got one of the books - the Michael Peace one - Bombproof your horse.

What would the best thing have been to do in the situation? I felt I couldn't give in to her napping so pushed her on and it was then she seemed to be really on edge, although it was actually on the way back she started the bucking?

Sorry I know that doesn't seem very clear:o
 
I look at it like this - at the start, we don't know who the horse is .. we don't know what is easy for them, what isn't. So I go out 'and see'. Numerous times with my youngsters, I've made a mistake. I've taken them out of their comfort zone too far too fast. In those situations, contrary to the old school way of 'show them who's boss' and 'ride them through it' and 'never let them win' ... I just get off. Usually apologise and do smething we both can do. Then in the background, I'll be formulating a plan to deal with how to get them to the point where it isn't an issue any more.

If you get to a point where a horse is unhappy, and you persist ... what have you just told the horse ?

John Lyons says "ride where you can, not where you can't". And if you get into a sticky situation, or come off... until you've dealt with that situation, there would be absolutely no point in getting back on, and being right back in the situation again !

So, a plan. It is perfectly feasible to work on hacking comfortably alone, if this is what you want to do.

Here's a brief outline :

1) establish respect and control on the ground. You can go about this in many ways. You can pick up bits and bobs here and there, do a bit of Kelly Mark's nice, anecdotal half-explained stuff, read everything you can, try to distil out of it a method that works for you .... or just follow the clinton Anderson book since he's done all the footwork for you, and you can just get straight out and start dealing with it

2) use your new found ability to work horse from the ground, and take it out of hte arena, finding new obstacles and scary things to deal with ... in a quiet and confident and matter of fact way.

3) start riding, right by home. Go no further away from your safe place than she is comfortable. Away, and back ...over and over. Work her from the saddle whenever you are close to home. Learn the skills you need to really put her feet to work from the saddle (they're all in the book). Work her by her home ... and take her away, to the edge of her comfort zone to rest. Do this religiously, and her comfort zone will expand in a safe, progressive way, without ever getting into the fight.

If this sounds like something you'd like to do, but might be a bit too advanced for you right now, then get an RA (or similar) in to help you out.
 
don't worry, you're not alone :)

mine went through a napping phase when i first got her 3 years ago. despite the fact her previous owner had mostly hacked her out on her own. we had many occasions where i turned round and went home, because she kept on spinning and/or jogging backwards and sideways :o we also had a rather unpleasant episode in a field where she bolted back to the gate and i had very little in the way of control.

but! once she got the idea that i was to be boss and if i deemed it was a good idea to plod ahead, she was fine. im sure you and rosie will get the hang of it :)

Julia
x
 
Napping I could cope with but the bucking? - I'm not sure. At the moment I just feel that I don't want to get back on her. Sorry if it makes me sound feeble but those of you who have read some of my other posts will know that I totally lack confidence when riding and it was just so unexpected when she bucked - I had been told she could throw in a little hop when she was excited but this was more than that:confused:.
 
Sorry just realised my last post might have come across wrong - I know napping can be a pain to deal with and have suffered anxiety over it, but I feel more able to cope with it (as long as they don't do anything like rearing or spinning!) than with the bucking.
 
I went through a loss of confidence with JOy earlier this year and really thought I would have to sell her. I even wrote the advert :eek:

Now looking back I can't beleive I did this and that my yard mates didn't say anything about it except going along with it. I was mad to even think that way without getting in help :eek: :eek: :eek:

Now I couldn't be happier. I just needed to find someone to help me to help Joy. :)
 
i'm not sure she was sold to you are described i.e. you thought you were buying a bombproof hack, but now it is she's never gone out alone, always in company, and her history is not as Rosy as you thought.

Hindsight is wonderful but you should have tried riding her out alone as part of the pre-purchase trial - this may well have told you not to buy her.

I have another strong minded Rosie cob here, and there is no way I would describe her as suitable for a novice, she is bombproof and fearless but you need to be in charge of her and I had to have NH lessons with her to get her attention and respect - she broke my wrist on day one so I understand how hard it is when you lose confidence/don't trust the horse and feel unable to cope with them

I do trust her now, but it has taken a lot of ground work which then carried onto her hacking out, but i bet you if a strange rider got on her she would plant and not go. She was a bit arsy last week when the vet had to inject her, so I have dug out her pressure halter just to remind her that we don't revert to being a nasty sow. She recognised it immediately....

I think you have two very serious choices to make

a) don't keep her and get a more suitable horse - if she is a bucker, and knows that is a wonderful evasion and way of winning, getting her own way, getting you to back down, then she isn't necessarily going to stop it, in fact she may do it more as she knows it works.
b) keep her but you are going to have to invest heavily in time (and money) to get help to build up your confidence and give you techniques to outwit her or get her to think it was her idea and a good one at that. you may need to get another stronger/more confident rider to get her over the hump of not going out - but unless you can get her working well with you on the ground, and respecting and obeying you, then even this isn't going to work, as she will associate obedience and good behaviour with this other person and may be a total saint with them and nasty with you.

I am really sorry that you are in this situation as it is horrible and very depressing.
 
I'm kind of in the same situation, my new boy (of 5 fab weeks :D :D :D ) is fine in company, but is dodgy with me on my own.

I hacked him out on his own when I tried him and he was fine, but I had people on foot with me, I rode him past them and went out on our own and he was fine, after a few more tries (on different days) I had this lovely idea in my head I could hack out on my own straight away. ..... Wrong !! Lee had other ideas. :rolleyes:

First ride I had OH with me and he rode out with me on his horse, Lee was fine, second ride, we tried seperating them (ie I go one way, OH goes the other and we meet up in about 10 mins) well Lee didnt buck but he wasnt happy, he threatened to rear with me and got quite excitable but he was ok, unnerved me though! Next time I rode out I had OH on foot with no horse, he was ok to start off with again, but we passed another rider, Lee wanted to follow her, I didnt and made him go the other way and we had an arguement, I somehow stayed on, but it did frighten me a bit, next time we rode out, I went with OH and his horse again and he was fine. It was my mistake and I dont blame Lee at all. He's just nervous of being on his own in a new environment.

For the moment, I'm taking him out on his own, but I'm longreining him, as for me I feel I've got more control on the ground, yesterday we passed two horses (I longreined the same circuit I ride him) about 25 yards away and he got excited, but all he did was trot on a bit, snort and fart about, I promptly turned him away from the horses and made him do a circle around some gorse bushes to get his attention back on me, he soon calmed down and actually did some really nice work for me :D

Dont feel to depressed, if I were you I'd be getting out an AI to help you with your confidence, and maybe for the time being stick to riding in a school ? Or you could get the Clinton Anderson book like KW suggested, I'm another big fan of his stuff :) :)

Best of luck :) :) You'll get there ! :D
 
Thanks again for all your replies. Am feeling really low at the moment. As Big Ears said, its a horrible place to be. I thinks she has been hacked out alone in the past - I am hoping that someone else from the riding school will call me with a bit more info as she was out today and the girl I spoke to said she would give her my number.

LindaAd - you're right, I am still having difficulties leading her - not all the time but some days she is very reluctant to leave the others and really drags back on the leadrope and refuses to budge.
 
I was really sorry to read your post. It must have been scarey for you.

I have suffered badly with my nerves in the past and have really learnt how horses do pick up on your nerves. I used to turn the most bombproof horse into a nutter, just because I tensed up every time I felt scared - which was most of the time. I used to feel totally useless because if a horse was being difficult, someone else would get on and they would behave perfectly. My answer was to find a totally safe horse who just ignored me and didn't get wound up. I had so much fun on her and she taught me to relax.

So, the question is where do you go from here? Others will probably disagree with me, but I wouldn't be able to trust a horse who had bucked and taken off with me. If she has done it once, she could do it again. You could get some help and try and sort it out, but personally I wouldn't be able to do this. I would try and return her and get something else. There ARE safe, bombproof horses out there and with the right horse you will rebuild your confidence.
 
Thanks MP. It was in the field when Rosie galloped off, sorry if I didn't make that clear :D, when I was turning her out (so not on her luckily). She did sort of race forward for a few strides while bucking but she did stop. But two episodes of bucking has really scared me and while I know that they probably weren't the most humungus bucks and more confident riders might be able to deal with it I don't know if I can.

But I feel really bad. This pony has had 3 homes within the last year and goodness knows how many before that. But ....I know she bucks when she is frightened and I don't think I can cope with that either.

Taking her back is not an option as she was a private sale. I did speak to her previous owner today and she was shocked at what had happened.
 
Oh I didn't realise that you were not on her when she galloped off - that makes it slightly different as I think that ground manners are easier to change. I am terrifed of being bolted with so couldn't ride another horse who did that with me. I am also not a huge fan of bucking, but think that this can be overcome in certain circumstances. I assume that the usual checks on saddle, teeth etc. have been done? If there is a physical reason for the behaviour then it can be changed. If the bucks are part of her personality as her history seems to suggest, you need to ask yourself if you can deal with this part of her.

Ask yourself some honest questions. Are you a good enough rider to ride out the bucks? Can you sit to them or do you risk coming off? Are you tensing up and holding onto her too tightly so that she is getting frustrated? Perhaps some lessons will help with this.

The biggest question of all is do you want to deal with this? Confident riders will probably wonder why you are nervous and lots would even enjoy the challenge. I think that unless you have suffered from nerves yourself and been scared out of your wits from something relatively trivial, you have no idea how utterly demoralising a bad ride can be. I have been riding for 26 years - spent thousand of pounds on lessons and still am terrified if a horse spooks on a hack! As I said before, the only thing that made me enjoy hacking out was to find my perfect horsey partner.

You say that Rosie has had many owners in the past and been shipped from piller to post and of course you are going to feel responsible for her. However, if you don't trust her, and even worse - if you are scared of her, neither of you is going to enjoy this partnership. It takes real guts to admit that you are not suited and although this is very sad, sometimes it is the best thing to do.

I don't mean to sound unduely negative and I do hope that you sort these issues out. I just wanted to let you know that I do understand how you feel.
 
newrider.com