Is this a completely nuts idea????

MP do you trust your vet? Or do you have doubts yourself? If the first then I'd be telling the yard staff that under no circumstances will you allow another vet to examine Ben, even if they have offered it for free, if the second it might be worth getting another vets opinion, but before you do be very sure that you will go the route suggested by the new vet, because if you do allow the second vet to examine him and their opinion is different to your own vets, you will face an even bigger dilemma. The yard staff will never shut up until you comply with whatever the second vet suggests and to be honest I think in this situation your yard sound like a bunch of bullies NOT your friends, but you obviously know them and I don't. They sound like typical 'my way is the only way' kind of horse people.
 
Of course I trust my vet. What she suggested is really nothing more than common sense. I know Ben is still overweight, I can see his crest and feel his fatpads. To me there is no question that I am doing the right thing. But it just isn't worth causing a big fall out over it. I don't have to argue, I just need to let it go, let them have their say and do what I am going to do anyway. Life is too short and I am otherwise happy on the yard.

It is interesting searching the web on horse weight issues. Some organistions estimate 80% of horses in the UK are overweight.
 
im sorry you are having such a stress and hats off to you for feeling able to take this on the chin...

however Id not stand for such a thing, it’s not legally or ethically correct for your YO to arrange for your horse to see a different vet. Unless of course I am missing something and your YO has a right of legal ownership/care over your horse? Furthermore, your vet may well have something to say about this!! Does the vet they are using realise also he is being asked to step on another vet’s toes and act without the consent of the owner?! Sounds like a can of worms to me and sounds like you are being completely bullied :(
 
Of course I trust my vet. What she suggested is really nothing more than common sense. I know Ben is still overweight, I can see his crest and feel his fatpads. To me there is no question that I am doing the right thing. But it just isn't worth causing a big fall out over it. I don't have to argue, I just need to let it go, let them have their say and do what I am going to do anyway. Life is too short and I am otherwise happy on the yard.

It is interesting searching the web on horse weight issues. Some organistions estimate 80% of horses in the UK are overweight.

Well you are a far more laid back person than me then MP, if someone on my yard suggested getting a second opinion from a different vet (their own) which they were prepared to pay for I'd be telling them to think again! I still see it as bullying and while it's good that you can let then do whatever they want without losing your temper I can't help but feel that once you do you are opening a can of worms for the future. I know you love your yard but really, your happy for them to ride rough shod over your vets and your own wishes? No way I could do that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and Gimp
But when it comes to the care of my horse, it is all under my control. I am the one who looks after him everyday and I really don't care it anyone thinks my methods are wrong. At the end of the day, nothing has actually changed significantly about his care. The yard advised I ride him through the cough and the vet said to ride gently, so I am riding gently. The vet said get rid of his straw bed but the yard said keep it. I have got rid of it. The vet said don't turn out on 20 acres of lush grass, the yard say that is fine. I am bringing him off the grass during the day and he is out overnight with no rug unless it rains. The vet said he has a crest, fat pads and too much body fat. The yard say he doesn't and is the perfect weight. I agree with the vet and when he is well I will ride him more to try and burn this off.

It just isn't worth potentially leaving the yard over and having a huge row. What would be the point? I have not given permission for another vet to look at him and they will respect this. They do have his interests at heart, this is just a difference of opinion.Since when did horsey people agree on horse care? I am glad I can come on here to vent though, it does help so thank you all for listening.x
 
Sorry MP didn't realise you'd told them you don't want a second opinion, my misunderstanding.
No reason or point at all in rowing over Bens care, he's your horse so you call the shots, I hope they respect and understand that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I think they have a duty of care if the horse is on their yard and they disagree with your care. I'd probably let them do it but I'd want to be there and I'd want to be able to talk to the second vet aswell as ultimately it's the horse's best interests which are being questioned and everyone has their own agenda and opinions and will sometimes skew things to fit with their agenda and opinions. It's good that they care.
 
I have not been on many yards having mine at home but I really have not heard of a yard not liking your vets
diagnosis.

Right now Sonny and Andi are across the street and are the ONLY 2 not blanketed.
No one has mentioned or questioned me on that at all.
They will be there til we are set up here and they are happy over there -- I am very lucky its
a nice low drama place. (and right across the street);)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
OMG poor you MP. So to sum up he had a cough so you changed his bed (that he is only on during the day anyway) to a small bed to stop him eating it and to reduce the dust? You are riding him gently through the cough and you ride to keep his weight down.

I think you have done the right thing reference his bed. They don't need a massive bed anyway and he is on matts so whats the issue.

I currently have a cough and had 1 week of running then a gentle week now back to slightly more move work. Sorry don't see that working a horse hard when they have a cough will do other that irritate their lungs more and course the issue to be more prolonged. I wouldn't push myself hard at the moment but it's OK to push your horse. Sorry you are right here in my eyes as well.

I do not have good doers I have the opposite. So while you don't feed and don't rug know one seems to question the boys rugs feed I just poor doers and they shut up but it seems that everyone has an opinion on your horse.

Send them to some local shows and put out horses that actually need their concern.

Thank them for their concern but whether they agree or disagree you are not causing your horse any harm and he is loved and cared for. Of he was bone thin or unwell than they have caused for comment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: joosie and Trewsers
My first reaction on reading this was tell them to go hang and no way allow anyone else to dictate to you which vet sees your horse. But on the other hand - is it the yard owner or yard manager that wanted to do this or just other bitchy liverys sniping at you?

If the former , it could be that they are protecting their own reputation if they do feel that a horse on their yard is not enjoying the welfare they would like for their premises and all horses that are there. They really do have a duty of care, even if they don't own the horse, but it could be they are being a little too robust in their actions and haven't handled their concerns the best way they could.

If it is just other liverys poking their nose in just ignore them and tell them to mind their own *@*%@* business!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp and Trewsers
newrider.com