Bebe did something similar recently. I have a stash of small baled hay that I'm saving to feed over the summer months when the yard hay is likely to have run out. In the meantime I'm feeding the yards big bale hay. Both lots of hay are really nice quality but the small bale is greener and softer (might be an earlier cut I think).
I usually make up a weeks worth of hay nets at a time and one week my large bale ran out before I'd finished, so I just opened up a small bale and finished the nets off with that. Bebe thought the new stuff was marvellous the first night she got it, and then she point blank refused to touch it. She ate her straw bed instead and when that got boring she just got angry and slung the unwanted hay around the stable, made a right mess! I persevered for a few nights but decided I really didn't want her going without any food in her stomach overnight and ordered a big bale of hay from YO early, which she scoffed with delight. I gave the nets of small bale hay to a couple of others on the yard, one pony turned it down but the rest ate it without any problems so I don'tthink there's an issue with the hay itself.
It's very frustrating! All I can say is either persevere, they will eat it when they get desperate, or maybe mix half and half haylage for a bit so you at least know they're getting something down them.