inconsistent riding lessons

Mare-e

New Member
Sep 22, 2000
194
0
0
Virginia, USA
Visit site
Started riding at age 52 and have been taking lessons about 14 months. Now going twice a week, using two different teachers and a few different school horses depending on availability. Have also started yoga lessons to increase focus, flexibility, balance, and especially calmness. Last lesson had me close to tears again with horse unresponsive to aids - reluctant to move forward in walk and then to trot,and frequently stopping. I did use a crop (reluctantly)but still got poor results. Refused to use spurs when teacher produced them, feeling as a novice it would be cruel to misuse them. Also refused to attempt cantor at teachers instruction, since have only cantered a few paces before and did not want to try speed if I wasn't in control at walk/trot! Problem is, I've had many lessons with the same horses when I needed no crop and had great rides with numerous on-the-spot transitions. Know that when the lesson starts out poorly I tense up and think that is why everything deteriorates to a miserable level. Also, hate using a crop so am probably not using it effectively. Teacher yelling to whip more or harder only un-nerves me. Sorry for lengthy post, but needed to explain if have any hope of correcting. Love riding and willing to work hard to learn. What should I do to be more effective?
 
Do you use a long dressage whip or a short crop?

Try using a dressage whip, this way you will not become unbalanced and be sending mixed messaged through the reins.

Disgusted that the instructor expected you to wear spurs.

Don't be afriad to use a stick, think what you'd prefer, an hour of being thumped in the ribs or having your bum pinched once or twice!
 
Entirely agree with Wally. Any riding school that encourages spurs for beginners should be avoided like the plague. And I agree re whip versus kicking.
 
Thanks for the responses! I have used both a crop and dressage whip and agree the latter is more effective though a bit awkward to carry sometimes. I have no problem refusing my teachers instructions (spurs) if I think it out of line, but am concerned this will make me their least favorite pupil. Any suggestions on how to get back on track if I become un-nerved when a lesson goes sour? Some days I seem to be so much more in tune and assertive from the first step.
 
Find a sympathetic instructor who will help you laugh when things arn't going the way they should, the second you start to laugh you will relax and things fall into place much better. A lesson should never go sour.

If you are worrying about the way the instructors are treating you find another, they should not be allowed to get away with such intimidation.
 
Poor you Mare-e,

It is unbelievable what some of you novice riders have to go through, and have far more sense than the blasted instructors if you ask me. Where do you live?


Heather
 
Hello Mare-e,
I just want to say that I also do yoga and find it helps
out a whole lot with the calming the nerves,keeping focused , stretching and keeping those muscles in shape.
I had a instructor who wanted me to wear spurs when i was in my 6th month of riding and told her i didn't think I could wear them and not hurt the horse she looked a little ****ed and told me next week then.I finished my lesson and started looking for another instructor who is sympathetic to horse and rider.
 
Heather, and All,
Thanks for all your advise and support. I am in New York City so have limited riding options. Cannot work (to support life plus my riding ) and take time to travel to the suburbs for riding. Have worked with many teachers and horses over the past year and find each lesson a different experience. I always learn something new. But have learned almost as much from Heathers book and this board!
 
Spurs - what next! I know what you mean about inconsistency in lessons and it's inevitable really for as long as you ride in group lessons. Can you stretch to one private lesson a week rather than 2 group lessons? This way you can set the agenda. I hate it when other riders in the lesson look on pityingly as things go wrong for you. Tell your instructor what you are anxious about and work at your own pace. The trouble is that lots of school horses are so fed up with constant kicking that it is difficult to motivate them. A sharp tingle when they ignore your leg will help, though. I find some lessons will be brilliant with me and my horse on the same wavelength and everything going to book. Then, less than 24 hours later, it all goes pear-shaped! The answer is almost always with the rider - sure, horses are entitled to off days as we are but they are far nobler and less complicated than we are. They also pick up on our moods before we do! When things are going badly for me, I try to tell myself that it doesn't matter, I relax and feel myself sit deeper in the saddle. Usually, my horse feels the release and relaxes too. THEN we can discuss things sensibly.
 
Hi,

I have just read your post with interest. I am sorry to hear about your bad experience with the instructor, I would have been tempted to give her a dig with the spurs see how she liked it.

I had to leave a school a few months ago because of the instructor, and I wrote a strong letter to the owner (who was a personal friend). She got a good rollicking and my friend who has stayed in the group, and the instructor can now not do enough for her and is nearly licking her boots.
I am really pleased it has improved for her, but unfortunately left me out in the cold.

I do not regret complaining because you are being taught to ride, and the instructor should listen to you and not yell, it just makes you more nervous. I have just joined a new group lesson which is great and the instructor never shouts
but will explain.


Anyway good luck with the riding, keep us informed


Beverley
 
Jo,
Thanks for sharing your experience. Sometimes I think my problems just stem from my old age(though I feel 16), late start to riding,and inexperience. Also, I am almost embarassed to tell you I DO taken private lessons at the exhorbitant rate of $100 per hour! That is also why I cannot tolerate unproductive lessons. Did have a very smooth lesson today and put a lot of the advise I got here into play. Found that proper timing of the aids makes a big difference in response. Also starting out with quick transitions gets this horse listening and ready to work and by-passes some of the confrontational "who's the boss today" stuff. Agree that relaxation and humor go a long way to building team work with the horse and teacher.
 
Hi Mare-e

$100 works out about £75 per hour. If I was paying £75 an hour for a riding lesson I would really want to be riding a horse which was well trained and would make things easier for the rider. Having said that, I have paid quite a lot of money out in the past to ride so-called well-schooled horses which were anything but! I always seemed to find that when you went to a riding stable, you were given the plods which really didn't help your riding in any way whatsoever.

One saving grace has been the NEW RIDER SEMINAR with Heather Moffet. I was on the second seminar and every horse I rode was well schooled and a pleasure to ride. I own my own horse so you do get used to riding one horse and also my horse happens to be very rhythmic and regular in her paces and also her diagonals are very even. I have been on previous riding holidays because I think you need to ride different horses and I really end up appreciating my Shady Lady because she is so comfortable and forward going.

I would have a quiet word with the Instructor to make sure that when you have your next lesson, you are given a horse which will HELP your riding and not hinder it!
Good luck!

Judy
 
I must say I agree with everybody else here and especially Judy. People will probably shoot me down in flames for saying this, but it almost impossible to find a riding school to teach you anything but the basics well. As I see it the problem with most riding school horses is that they are ridden by so many 'learners' they just don't react in the way that they are supposed to. The end result is that the pupils have to work harder and harder and the horses get more and more fed up. I have been trying for years to find a place where I could ride nice, well schooled responsive horses and have never yet found one. I'm sure that is why most people end up buying their own horse. I'm not trying to slag off riding schools in general, I appreciate that they have a living to earn but I do think it is when you get beyond the basics that you start to have problems. I've no idea what prices are like in the US but for the amount of money you are paying for these lessons, I would expect a red carpet to be rolled out whenever I turned up at the yard! I believe you have a right to insist on being given a suitable horse to ride and an instuctor to whom you can relate.
 
Glad to see others share in my experiences. Not that I wish anyone else the same frustrations, but it does help to evaluate my learning curve (or sometimes FLAT!)realistically and sort out what is my fault and responsibiltiy, and what are circumstances beyond my control. Would love to go to a Heather Moffet seminar if she ever comes to New York.
My goal is to become a strong enough rider to go on week long riding vacations each year, and some day lease a horse where ever I retire. I always thought I would retire and continue living in Manhattan. But with my new found love of riding, my future fantasies all revolve around horses. Am now thinking of places to move where the cost of living is low enough to afford supporting myself and a horse during retirement. If only Bush or Gore were campaigning with a proposal to make horses dependants, and therefor tax deductable!
 
It is a sad fact that a great deal of riding school horses have been treated like machines. I have to CONSTANTLY remind folk ( usually tourists out for one ride) that they are not on a bicycle, the horse has feelings too. So many schools I have been to (approved too!!) have treated their hores like inanimate objects. It is up to the instructors to monitor the behaviour of the riders and teach them not to make the horses sour and dead. I will not tollerate Kicking, hauling or general mistreatment of our horses. They are our asset and if the riders ruin them we have no business. Sadly this in not the case in a lot of schools. However if the rider is educated from day one that half a tonne to 3/4 of a tonne of horse can be moved with a feather there is no reason for a horse to become dead and sour. The condition and obedience of the horses is a direct reflection of the quality of instruction one can expect!

There now I've put myself up for ridicule!!
 
Wally,
I loved your thought about moving the horse with a feather. Think of the impact that visual would have on a beginner. To stand in front of the horse and tap him in the chest with a feather and have him step back on command. I bet it would save alot of mouths and ribs to give that show right off. I always tell the young kids that come out with us that they should picture someone hauling them around the school yard with a wire on their braces. That usually gets them to stop pulling on the reins. Keep up the great stream of thoughts.
Happy trails.
 
Mare-e, it isn't your age! I'm about there too and have good days and bad days. Luckily we have good instructors and one of the things they insist on is a "warm-up", with just walk/halt/trot transitions. This usually tells you if the horse is feeling lazy today or if you yourself are not quite bright. The transitions help the horse listen to you as well.
I love Wally's feather analogy. Taking a break from lessons,we were on a trail with nice safe comfy horses who walked past a big road caterpillar, ignored a wallaby popping up in front of them, disapproved of a motor bike using the horse trail with a snort, shook their heads slightly at a currawong on the trail (Black, crowlike bird), stepped over a tiger snake with disdain and then Tom (whom I was riding) bolted when a leaf blew off a tree and touched his eye! Of course his idea of bolting is a more excitable horse's slow canter, so I was quite safe, but the things they choose to find objectionable is beyond my comprehension.
Good luck with the lessons,remember you are meant to enjoy them! Vera
 
I love this site - it keeps me sane!

Vclay, I loved your story - horses just don't percieve danger in the way we do - and we don't see it their way either! I love the idea of a horse moving at the bidding of a feather - and why not? They feel flies landing on them so we should remember their sensitivity before we set about them with hob nailed boots.

Well, I am amazed at the cost of private lessons in some areas. I have to pay £15 for an hour's private lesson, whether it be on the lunge or not - and they are good lessons, too.

I watched a programme on Lorenzo today and one thing he said sticks with me: it doesn't matter what age you start riding, if you want to succeed you will. Just listen to your horse! Quite inspiring really. I asked my mare whether she wanted to hack out tonight or whether she would prefer 30 minutes in the school. She said she'd sooner be fed and let out to paly with her mates. I obliged!
 
I agree with the idea of listening to the horse. That would make the good instructor more of an interpreter between horse and rider.

I also love the image of moving a horse with a feather. It is very much on target. My best rides have required almost no force and have felt like a graceful dance with a skilled partner. My worst rides have made me sense the full weight of 1200 pounds of unwilling horse flesh.

Saturday's lesson was on a new horse, a bit more forward moving but with a huge bouncy trot that threw me into posting whether I wanted to or not. Of course that would periodically unbalance me, make me tense up, and guess what. Yes, we have a stop-and-go horse again. My fault, I know. As soon as I got home I could visualize myself balanced, relaxed, without my seat clenching, and riding correctly. I often wish I could get off my horse, take a walk, and come back and start fresh again. That is not an option at the school I go to. I envy you who have your own horses, to ride when you want and to build relationships with those magnificent creatures.

Again, thanks for all your support.
 
Hi, Mare-e

Boy, you and I have similar experiences! I started riding late - I was 47 - and have been riding now about 18 months and wishing in some way that I had started as a child so that I didn't feel that nervousness and fear of falling. Like you I feel very committed to it all to the extent that, like you,I think about moving to the country towards 'retirement' and really enjoying it as a big part of my life. But, most important, like you, I sometimes feel that I am getting nowhere on horses that just take the **** the whole time!! On Tuesday I rode a horse who just lumbered along unless I kicked him into kingdom come and then just stopped and stood! I am tackling more difficult things now, like collection, so I'm feeling like a real novice all over again...

Relaxing is really important - literally trying to get detachment so that you don't try too hard. And just realising that it is hard learning to ride, that we didn't have the advantage of that natural learning process that kids have, but that there is no reason that, with patience, we can't become confident, competent riders. I have no ambitions to go in for events, but I would like to be able to ride confidently on my own on a hack, do a bit of jumping and just feel that I am more in control as a rider. That the horse respects me!

Mind you, the more I do the more ambitious I become but that's no bad thing. Part of our problem is that the horses are a bit dead to the leg. I rode Lusitanos in Portugal this summer and they we just fabulously schooled, totally responsive, and I couldn't believe what they did for me with the minimum of asking. (Incidentally, there was a very nice woman there called Toni who rides at a school in Manhattan. Might you know her?) Of course, when I got back to London, the horses I ride there looked at me as if I was mad when I tried to reproduce my Lusitano experience!

Anyway, I have't said much except that we have to enjoy it and try to get that childlike quality into it all somewhere, relax, be a bit detached and not try too hard,(I'm convinced horsed prefer it when we just care less!) and believe we can do it!! At least we are committed and prepared to work at it and we're not going to give up for exams and college and boys!

Good luck!
 
newrider.com