im considering givin up

lauraandharvey

New Member
Jan 10, 2008
6,463
0
0
36
wombwell
its not a whinin thread just need to clear things up
i give quite alot of advice but never seem to get it in return
for the last few weeks my boy has worked brilliantly in the school and weve even had fun doin abit of xc
i know hes only 4 (5 in a few month) but i feel im lettin him down :/
i mean i am quite an advanced rider but sometimes he just doesnt do anythin i ask
maybe im doin something rong
i have a lesson next week with new ri
maybe i should put him out for lease, i really dont want to sell him
for a first horse maybe i should have got a been there done that and not started with a youngster :(
FEEELING POOP

rode today and he was just dead to the leg, he usually just goes of my voice command and hes so forward going
but not today
he jumpd a small jump without hesitating and then nothing :S:S:S:S

:(
 
with a young horse, if you are not experienced, then it is a bit blind leading the blind as they don't know what you want and you don't know how to tell them correctly.

there isn't much of a way round it other than lessons lessons lessons and practice in between - when I got Rosie she had never done school work (aged 14) so we did a bit of learning together to get her a bit more supple.

but regardless of that you always get days when you wonder why you bother as it doesn't go well. that's life. but not a reason to give up.

if you can find a better/more experienced rider to help school then that would help move you forward a bit more. or just hack out for a bit and give the horse a bit of fun.
 
with a young horse, if you are not experienced, then it is a bit blind leading the blind as they don't know what you want and you don't know how to tell them correctly.

there isn't much of a way round it other than lessons lessons lessons and practice in between - when I got Rosie she had never done school work (aged 14) so we did a bit of learning together to get her a bit more supple.

but regardless of that you always get days when you wonder why you bother as it doesn't go well. that's life. but not a reason to give up.

if you can find a better/more experienced rider to help school then that would help move you forward a bit more. or just hack out for a bit and give the horse a bit of fun.


i am expirienced enough, but then i think should i give him a break
should i just turn him away for a year
but then he'd get massive from no excercise
thing is no one is willing to ride him properly except for fun :(
he doesnt charge around, hes never bucked or reared in his life
he doesnt spook, he ocassionaly naps
 
rode today and he was just dead to the leg, he usually just goes of my voice command and hes so forward going
but not today
he jumpd a small jump without hesitating and then nothing :S:S:S:S

:(

It sounds like he's just having a bad day - Casper has them too, as do I! Just forget about it and look forward to your next ride.

And as for questioning whether or not you are letting him down - the fact that you are paying for lessons shows you are not.

i'm in the same boat as you hun - been riding for less that 4 years and bought myself a 5 Y/O unbalanced cob who didn't know how to canter.

We have our good days and our bad days but as long as those good days are there then we're making progress. I don't care if he never becomes a show horse, never wins anything - as long as we have fun and trust each other - after all - that's why we have these big furry beasts!:D
 
Has he been turned away at all?

I turned my girl away when we were having problems (shes 6 now) only for a couple of months, but when she came back into work everything seemed to click into place

x
 
With youngsters, there are good days and bad days. Some days its just "not happening" and yes, we get down. Then there will be those moments where it all comes together perfectly and makes it all worthwhile :) Through my youngster I have learnt a massive amount. One of the biggest things is that when he doesnt do something right, I need to re-consider how I asked him and whether I was clear enough. He is my first horse too and sometimes I wonder whether I should have got an older horse but we are coping fine and he should turn out very nicely. But, I have a huge amount of support from very experienced people. If I didnt have this support I know I'd feel alot less optimistic.

Im sorry to hear your having such a rough time, I have been there too at some points :( But, look at the good points! You say your horse is usually forward going and goes off the voice command. Thats great! And he's popped a small jump willingly too? And XC?! And working nicely in the school for the last few weeks? Those are pretty BIG things for a 4 year old! My 5 year old cant do half of that! But I am thankful for the things he can do. I was mega happy today because we had some good circuits on the lunge. :)Appreciate those little things, its very easy to get depressed if you think of all the things they cant do as opposed to what they can do.

I would suggest that you take the pressure of yourself! Hack out lots, have some lessons but just relax. As someone else suggested, turn him away for a few months if you dont feel like riding and you think he would benefit. You have years ahead of you and just imagine how nice he will be when he is 9 or so and that you will have been on this great journey together.

Chin up hun! :) x
 
Hi:)

You sound a bit like me some days. Horses can be a real 'pain in the butt' - and they don't even know it. They just don't realise how much they make us feel down and 'rotten' when things don't go to 'our' plan!

I agree with BabyBear, you are experienced and obviously care enough to pay for lessons to help you and your horse progress!

As for turning your horse away for a break, if you want to give it a try, I would think it wouldn't hurt to give him a break for a couple of months to see what happens. I've had different experiences with a couple of horses - one was backed, started and then turned away for 6 months, then he was brought back into work, and everything had 'sunk in' - he transformed into a willing and able horse who is now really wonderful. The other (nightmare) horse was the exact opposite. I did the same with him - backed him, started him, then turned him away. When I brought him back into work, he was horrendous! He was downright dangerous to be honest, and required completely and very carefully re-starting. The joys of horses!

Don't make any drastic decisions just yet - you and your horse may have been having an 'off' session! I seem to have them with one horse or another quite frequently! Maybe have a bit of a break from your usual riding routine and try something different which will make him 'think'. I hope you get on with your new RI OK, and that they can make some positive suggestions to help you both along.

Please don't ever feel you are letting your horse down - if you love him, look after him and do your best for his care, how can you be letting him down? I know what you mean, you think he should be doing this or that, or competing or whatever, but there's no set progress rate for a horse and owner - Just try and stay positive and put your 'negative' cr*ppy day behind you. Even the 'professionals' have their off-days with their horses! And trust me, many a time I've gone storming into my office/tackroom, slung down my tack and declared that I'm giving up horses and becoming a professional flower-arranger or taking up cross-stitch instead of riding! But 29 years (and many cr*ppy days!) later, I'm still working with horses.

Have a good scream (not in front of the horse!) and try again another day. I don't want to sound patronising or like I'm belittling you, I'm not! I just know exactly where you are coming from and how bl*ody frustrating horses can be!! :rolleyes:

All the very best - good luck to you both! :)
 
Hi:)

You sound a bit like me some days. Horses can be a real 'pain in the butt' - and they don't even know it. They just don't realise how much they make us feel down and 'rotten' when things don't go to 'our' plan!

I agree with BabyBear, you are experienced and obviously care enough to pay for lessons to help you and your horse progress!

As for turning your horse away for a break, if you want to give it a try, I would think it wouldn't hurt to give him a break for a couple of months to see what happens. I've had different experiences with a couple of horses - one was backed, started and then turned away for 6 months, then he was brought back into work, and everything had 'sunk in' - he transformed into a willing and able horse who is now really wonderful. The other (nightmare) horse was the exact opposite. I did the same with him - backed him, started him, then turned him away. When I brought him back into work, he was horrendous! He was downright dangerous to be honest, and required completely and very carefully re-starting. The joys of horses!

Don't make any drastic decisions just yet - you and your horse may have been having an 'off' session! I seem to have them with one horse or another quite frequently! Maybe have a bit of a break from your usual riding routine and try something different which will make him 'think'. I hope you get on with your new RI OK, and that they can make some positive suggestions to help you both along.

Please don't ever feel you are letting your horse down - if you love him, look after him and do your best for his care, how can you be letting him down? I know what you mean, you think he should be doing this or that, or competing or whatever, but there's no set progress rate for a horse and owner - Just try and stay positive and put your 'negative' cr*ppy day behind you. Even the 'professionals' have their off-days with their horses! And trust me, many a time I've gone storming into my office/tackroom, slung down my tack and declared that I'm giving up horses and becoming a professional flower-arranger or taking up cross-stitch instead of riding! But 29 years (and many cr*ppy days!) later, I'm still working with horses.

Have a good scream (not in front of the horse!) and try again another day. I don't want to sound patronising or like I'm belittling you, I'm not! I just know exactly where you are coming from and how bl*ody frustrating horses can be!! :rolleyes:

All the very best - good luck to you both! :)


thanks
i just feel that he should go to a more expirienced person
he was backed and turned away for about 9 months i was told
he was uttter crrr***p when i got him
he spooked at EVERYTHING and now he doesnt, unless hes having an off day
he was a stallion so he wanted hump anything
since ive had him gelded hes calmed down alot but hes also banged on sh*t loads of weight
broke 6 of my toes, and was just a git,
dont know what i saw in him
i guess most of the reason is that im on a competiition yard where its all dressage and discipline
im sat blubbing now
goin to go and have a long cry into his lovely mane :(:(:(



thanks babybear
where do you live?


thankyou Kis Vihar :)
 
Oh hun don't be sad. We all have days like this, I have them all the time. I got my mare when she was 5 she had been passed from home to home but I fell for her straight away. I couldn't even hack her out when I first got her, but for some reason I loved her to pieces, she ripped every rug i bought her, was bargey had no space awareness, was horrible to every horse in sight!

Nearly four years later I love her even more, she is a madam a lot of the time and some time does not listen to me what so ever, like u i contemplate selling her but i could never go through with it. I am looking for a sharer, just to ride her, so that could be an idea for you, ask for a confident knowledgeable rider with time and patience there are lots of people out there that can't afford there own horse but would love to ride - they may even muck out too.

I agree with the others it may just have been a bad day. Chin up xxxx
 
ive had him 2 years and hes come on alot
*will try find a pic*
dont have any action pics im afraid
will get one this weekend *promise:D*
but this is the first xmas i had him
Image077.jpg

and this is him a few weeks ago
he has matured quite alot
S4300074.jpg



i really do love him to bits but i feel im leting him down
before he used to come to me when i shouted and now he doesnt even look up!
the bond has just gone and i dont know why
:(
 
Oh bless him - he's gorgeous. I wouldnt give up just yet!! As long as he is happy and healthy then how on earth are you letting him down? He might just be going through a grumpy phase, as everyone has said - there is good days and bad days. He really does look lovely :)
 
thankyou
ive been told he has good markings
ive never owned or loaned a coloured :/
alwyas had chesnut or bay so i ive not shown i hand or anything
but my yo has been there done it got the tshirt and she sed his colours are phenominal and could win loads
:)
xx
 
Ah bless him, he's only a bubba ~ give him a month off on the grass, let him get his head round stuff, then bring him back into work.

BB was very stale by end Nov last year, and I realised I'd asked so much out of her for the past 18months, so she had Dec-Feb off, now she's coming back into work ~ and loving it, fresh and forward.

Don't doubt yourself, you wouldn't have posted if you didn't care. You'll both be fine.... XXXX
 
Please, don't give up on him.
I broke my stallion in 2 years ago, and I still get weeks, sometimes months of feeling we're are getting nowhere, where I try and try to get him going right, whether it may be to get him into an outline, or listen to my legs. It sometimes feels like we're going backwards and not forward. He is really hard work. I get frustrated at him and also at myself and I feel like giving up as I have other easier horses to work on. This is the point where I step back and assess how far we have come and how close to my goals we are getting. I think about where the main areas of concern are, and think hard about what I can do to improve these issues. I read about it in books, I ask advice on places like here.
We then get a really good day where he goes perfect and it really feels as if we have achieved something worthwhile.
 
You've had quite a few replies and some advice though :confused:

Find a good RI if you're struggling for help from your yard. Shame that they're not more supportive. Could you not speak to the YO and say you're having some problems/would she mind helping or can she offer some advice? Just be really direct!
 
noo i didnt mean on here
nr is the best thing since sliced bread
im off to see the yo tomorow who is my new ri :D
shes ranked number 1 in south yorkshire
i watched her ride yesterday
perfoming pirroutes (sp)
WOW
im not a fan of dressage but by god that woman is marvelous

x
 
He has such a kind eye

I couldn't give him up, maybe get an experienced sharer who can school him on a little with you ?
 
He has such a kind eye

I couldn't give him up, maybe get an experienced sharer who can school him on a little with you ?

i had a word with my yo a few weeks ago about shcooling livery
as im on livery i would only have to pay on of the girls to ride him for me
so i think i might do that once a week
 
Hi again!

You posted some pics of your boy after I posted my reply - I just wanted to say he's GORGEOUS! :D

And don't worry if he goes through phases of ignoring you in the field when you call him, etc, he's just being a (frustrating) horse, and mine all do the same! My big cob mare who I've had for 5 years now can go through phases of coming running to the gate whenever she sees me, to being a right 'cow' to catch at the most awkward times! :rolleyes: They can be frustrating creatures! But we love them! :)

Good luck with your new RI, and never feel pressured to compete at whatever everyone else is doing on your yard, do what you want whenever you and your boy are ready for it! He looks a real sweetie and I bet you'll have loads of fun together!

All the best, K
 
newrider.com