If you could choose...

Neither. I would buy a nice enough horse to school and enjoy without the hassle of always worrying about money or whether the horse will make it back to health or not, and since I don't have massive aspriations in competing I won't be needing world famoush instructors, though I guess a lesson every now and again wouldn't go amiss.

Nina x
 
A. Or, just to be controversial, use my unlimited funds to provide a humane end for as many of the B horses as possible. I think running some kind of ethical abbatoir with ethical transportation included would probably do more good than rescuing just one.

*prepares to be shot down in flames* :D

Although I see where your coming from completly, why not just rescue the horses and then if it is there time to go have them PTS in the nicest possible way?
 
Although I see where your coming from completly, why not just rescue the horses and then if it is there time to go have them PTS in the nicest possible way?

Three reasons:
There will always be some for whom a humane ending is the best course - even with unlimited funds to put them right - and that isn't something on offer at all at the moment for most "rescues". Those in the worst state are those most in need of help.

It is easier to find homes for those who have an outside chance of rehabilitation, so those who can still have a useful life even as companions can go elsewhere - I'll worry about the ones that don't really have a chance!

There are too many horses in need of rescue. With the best will in the world, it can't be done. Far better to give good care to some, and a swift and humane ending to others, than leaving lots of them struggling on. Quality not quantity - but applied to the horse population as a whole; not individual animals. Brutal, but better in the long run for the majority.

To be honest, there are problems with both rescue AND the ethical abbatoir, because both may perpetuate the problem of oversupply. So if unlimited funds means I don't have to work, maybe I could found some kind of campaign to educate breeders better!
 
I think that the question is very idealogical (if that is indeed a word!). Most people are saying B, but they truely believed that then why don't we all own rescue horses now? If we have to choose between A and B then the unlimited funds bit becomes irrelevent as in an ideal world we would do both. It's a nice idea that we would want to help unwanted animals but in reality how many people actually do this ahead of their desire to want to ride and compete?
 
:(I wouldn't be able to choose because A)I would love an eventer who is fantastic 100% but then B)I have a rescue and it was such a good feeling nursing him back to health. And as so many others have said, since I have unlimited funds I would have both!!:)
 
I'm not competitive, but with unlimited funds, I'd import a speed racker from the US and go everywhere very fast and smooth :cool: I'd help rescues too, maybe just financially unless I needed a companion horse. Are there enough unwanted horses in this country to warrant a special recue abbatoir? I know things like that are needed in the US.
 
. Most people are saying B, but they truely believed that then why don't we all own rescue horses now?

I'd do it if I had the brass, at the moment I've only enough (just) for our two - but if you start rescueing them then I should imagine you need to be able to commit totally to that, and that includes spending the money on vet checks, transportation, etc - even just thinking about things like more rugs, shoes, etc.
 
A. Or, just to be controversial, use my unlimited funds to provide a humane end for as many of the B horses as possible. I think running some kind of ethical abbatoir with ethical transportation included would probably do more good than rescuing just one.

*prepares to be shot down in flames* :D

I'd definitely go in with you on that.. great idea. And with the money made from the end product I would be able to keep the horse of my dreams (Stan) in the manner he has been accustomed to and be able to clone TheG.. :D
 
There are too many horses in need of rescue. With the best will in the world, it can't be done
*walks away, very fast before exploding in anger!*

*Thinks - Is it worth people even bothering to rescue when there are other equine people out there that think in that manner*.


Explode in anger all you like, I'm afraid it's true. A quick google suggests 100,000 horses are transported to slaughter in Europe every year. 5,000 are slaughtered in Britain alone. I assume you'd want to save all of these?

And that's just the ones that go for slaughter - I can't even begin to imagine the number of cases of abuse and neglect in this country that would also give grounds for "rescue".

I don't wish to sound like I'm having a go at anyone who rescues, because I'm not - and I have the very greatest respect for what they're doing:). But every time you rescue a horse, you are expanding the market. It's great that you care so passionately, but a question for you: Is it worth even bothering to rescue when every horse "rescued" from sales, meat men, or whoever, is simply creating a market for more horses to be bred to meet the same fate?

Don't get angry with me for being realistic.
 
A) definitely me and mum have rescued 3 and as good as it feels when they come right it takes a lot of bl**dy hard work to get them there (and in my mum's case a few broken bones too:o) saying that Kane is a sort of rescue he was in a bad way when we got him through no fault of his owner and we did take a risk buying him but he has huge potential and will hopefully take me where i want to go competetively or at least a lot further than our little mare can.
 
B, not that I would as I don't have the knowledge, but I'd get a rescue horse with potential so that when we get to compete at high levels it can be a proper 'rags to riches' story and we'll get a two page spread in 'Your Horse' like all those people who do such things who I'm immensly jealous of!:p:D
 
If I HAD to choose I think B.
I'm a sucker for a sob story and most of mine were bought as projects or in need of some tlc anyway, so if I bought A I'd probably spend the first 6 months not knowing what to do with it :p.
 
B everytime, Ive never competed at a very high level but I wouldn't have thought having one winning SJ round beats seeing a horse so weak that it can't stand turning into a happy, healthy and content horse?

...But with the time and TLC (and with unlimited finds, none of us are going to work are we?!) who says you can't turn your B resuce horse into your A competition horse :D
 
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB - i have no interest in competing anyway :o:p - i'd rather know that i'd helped a pony/horse to a happier way of life (hopefully :o!) and just have fun, ridden or non-ridden; i'd rather take a scraggy pony to give a whole bundle of TLC and nursing to than a schoolmaster if you offered both to me :o.
 
newrider.com