I should be shot!!

shandy84

New Member
Oct 10, 2003
8,688
0
0
42
Essex
community.webshots.com
Well to those of us who think they are perfect riders never and i mean never watch yourself on video!!!! :eek:

I look so so bad on horseback my poor ponies having to lug my heavy load around. So I have decided after being humiliated that enough is enough and I must must sort my position out.

Things that are bad, shoulders curved and slumped, gaze too low, sloppy back very bent, legs were just about passable feet point out but that has a medical basis rather than just being :eek: I just look so so bad any suggestions on getting a good posture would be really really helpful!
 
I know how you feel - sometimes I watch a bit of video of myself and just cringe :rolleyes:

I think that a good position comes from the core of the posture - the seat and stomach. If you are secure in the core, then your legs should be able to drape from the hips naturally, and your back should be held upright but relaxed, balanced above the hips, and the strength of the stomach will prevent you being pulled forwards.

There are many books written on the subject - Heather Moffet, Sylvia Loch, Sally Swift have all written reams of brilliant material, and also worth picking up are the Joni Bentley books which incorporate the alexander technique. If you can't fork out lots of money for books, Joni Bentley has written a very concise but informative threshold picture books guide, which costs about £5.
 
I just watched a video of my lesson from this weekend. I am ready to quit right now. I even imagine the hair thing. I am posting on my toes (still after 2 years) and have a straight line from the bit to my SHOULDER.
My teacher tells me all during the lesson to get off my toes but has never mentioned the other problem.

I am very disgusted and feel very depressed!!!!!

I was sitting fairly straight and my leg was pretty good, but the rest was just awful. The whole thing looks awkward and pointless.
 
Hehe, my favorite exercise, backward stirrups!!! it's EXCELLENT for leg position, all you do is put the heel of your foot into the stirrup instead of your toe. It's hard to balance at first and keep the heel in, but it works WONDERS with the position. I had trouble with keeping a steady position with my legs and after 1 grueling lesson of this at walk, trot, canter, and small jumps, we went back to the regular position and I could really feel the difference and my leg was a lot steadier. So go ahead and try it! you don't have to do it as long as I did, 20-30 minutes will be fine. And don't worry about putting your heel down when you do this, because your toe will naturally point up. :D
 
Argh, I've had the same experience. The good news is, the video really helped illustrate the problem, so I had the information I needed to fix it.

In my case, my posture, in and of itself, wasn't so bad. However, whenever I looked down (which was all too often), I brought all of my weight with me - slumping my shoulder and rounding my back. My instructor had told me that I was doing this, but it didn't fully hit home until I saw the video. By focusing on my "eyes" (keeping a focal point ahead of me at all times), many other issues resolved themselves.
 
i used to be obsessive about my position (actually still am a little). i got a shoulder back device for christmas and i wore it for weeks (not just on horseback either) i would wear it during the day, i couldn't believe how much i wanted to slouch! it certainly helped me to sit up once i got rid of the thing though!

moral of the story really- when you arn't on the horse think about your posture, thinking about sitting up straight, finally take that advice of your grandmother and mother!
i also was told the 'pretend someone is pulling your ponytail back' and that did help also.
are you taking lessons? its allways good to have someone on the ground telling you whats wrong. the best way to fix your small problems are to not worry about them SO MUCH if you get stressed out about them you'll just be a more tense rider. if you are taking lessons i would hope that your instructer is working on getting rid of those problems one by one and not throwing 1000instructions your way at once.
chin up- noone is the perfect rider!
 
i have only ever seen myself in still pictures, but im sure if i were to take a video i would look hidious!!!

I think its great that you got the chance to tape yourself as most times visual images stick with us much longer than words ;). Also you get a better idea of just how much you need to change something to improve your riding.


the only thing i can say is if you can find your seat bones off the horse (sit straight up on something hard and take your hand and pull your inner leg out from under you --or just turn your leg in--and you should feel 2 bony things that you want to point straight down all the time) then you can practice sitting with good posture --it just happens when your seat bones are down. Im guessing your rounding them under you which in turn rounds the back..

...i have this problem so bad its not even funny :rolleyes: but ive been working on it and i do notice a difference on the horse (in feel anyway..not sure how i look :p )

as for the sholders being forward... i havent figured that out either :( let me know if you do!!
 
Get your instructor to be really picky with your posture.

Make sure that you think of your posture even when you're not on the horse, maybe get some Pilates lessons or something like Alexander Technique.

See if you can afford one of Heather Moffatt's 'Equisimulator' courses. I've not been but the feedback has always been positive.

Get a Flexion SBS with set back stirrup bars ;) Even though my posture wasn't bad everyone has said that it's improved since I've been riding in my SBS! The wide tread stirrups that have the 'hole' for the leathers at 90 degrees to the stirrup iron are good too as they don't let you poke your toes out as much!
 
i'm not keen on imagining being pulled up - that will lift your behind out of the saddle. would rather echo rachelevent that it all comes from your core muscles - stomach and back. i've been doing pilates lately, which is essentiually an hour-long stomach crunch, and that has helped a lot. think of extending the spine between your pelvis and ribcage, dropping shoulders back and down and looking where you're going.

my instructor is ever so picky aboiut my position, and boy do i need it...
 
i second the pilates idea! i've been doing it for nearly three years now (due to back injury) and it has really helped my position no-end. are there any classes in your area?? i don't reccomend videos til you have got the basics right, or else its pointless. good luck!

EDIT: i mean pilates videos, NOT videoing riding! pilates is something you need to be taught 1 to 1 to get things right, but once the basics are down pat videos can be useful in expanding your knowledge and difficulty level of exercises.
 
Last edited:
I have found that no instructor is ever as critical as I am about myself, so as often as you can get someone to video you, you will be amazed at how much of a difference just being aware of what you are doing can help.

I did a clinic last year with about 8 people I have been riding with for years, I got OH to video it for me (for just this reason), When one of the other guys watched it back with me he actualy hung his head in shame. When anyone had told him he was 'pulling' his horse round the turns he would argue about it no end, saying that he wasn't and it was just her (his mare). When he watched the video he was so ashamed, he'd been riding like that for about 30 years. The second day of the clinic he completely changed his riding style and his mare was a completely different animal. His wife now videos every clinic / competition so that he can watch it back! and in the last year their relationship has a new dimension, the horse will work for him more readily and has settled down and stoped half her silly antics that used to really wind him up.

J
 
Don't beat yourself up :)

Last year I managed to haul OH up to the yard and asked if he would video me and like you when I watched it I cringed.

About every 3 months I demand that OH comes up to the yard and tapes me. Mind you, I still cringe, but I've found if I look back at the others especially the first I am alot better. I have even found myself saying my position looks quite good now.

I think it's a good thing to do because as Jessy says, theres no one as critical as yourself.

You will get loads better, I promise :)
 
I've only ever been caught on camera once, and thought my horse looked great. I on the other hand looked... :eek: There's no more critical eye on your riding than your own, as there's always a huge difference between what you feel in your head and see on screen.

If you can afford it get some lessons, especially ridden AT, because that focusses very much on your posture and position. If you're schooling babies I would imagine staying straight and balanced at all times is important for them as well as you:)
 
Keep videoing yourself - as painful as it may be to watch yourself ride round with elbows stuck out and back hunched over (speaking from personal experience here :D ) next time you get on you'll be 100% more aware of what areas need improving. Then next time you film yourself you can look back and see how much youve improved - instant boost!
 
Horrible feeling isn't it!

I can remember seeing videos from when I worked at Turville and we used to do the classical dressage displays - I looked cool, calm, elegant and in perfect balance - something to do with riding four different horses every day under the watchful eye of a couple of the best classical riders / trainers in the UK ;)

Seeing myself now is just torturous - I hate it, round shoulders, no core body control, stiff, tipping forwards, always clutching at the right rein, gripping up...... :eek: I really don't wonder why Safi can be so stubborn and tight - it's all in the pudding bouncing around on her back.

Luckily I have now got an instructor who points out every fault the instant I produce one - and Safi picks up when I'm right and goes soft again.....we will get there ...we WILL!!!!!!
 
My reins were so long and the horse's nose was sticking way out with the curve of the neck all wrong. I have been taking lessons here for a year and don't think I am any better than I was the year before. I'm now looking for a new place- it will be hard to find one. sigh

If i wasn't such a low-tech idiot, I would be able to post some before and after pics of last year and this past weekend- same pose of rising trot.
altho I would probably be too embarrassed to put them up. :P
 
For position- you should be able to draw a straight line from your ear to your heel. Remeber chin up- always looking ahead, and if you need to look down (ex. checking leads) then always do it with your eyes. Shoulders should be back, your back straight, and heels down. :) Hope I helped.
 
newrider.com