I need help! Instructors

Rakeli

New Member
Oct 30, 2002
312
0
0
Devon
Visit site
I'm very confused as to what to do, so please bear with me if this turns out to be a long post!

I used to have lessons with someone who had been a working pupil of Heathers, and was excellent. I understood everything she told me, it all made sense and I loved it. But she has had to stop teaching and can only teach me very very occasionally as she now works full time. So, I've now started with a new instructor who she recomended to me. But, whilst I like her and think she's good, and she would never hurt a horse that she was riding, sometimes I don't really agree and wonder whether to stay with her as an instructor. She's focusing on my position, which is great, but has told me to:
- ride circles right in to corners (I queried this, as I thought circles were a continuous bend, with no straight lines. I didn't really understand the explanation).
- have leg on every stride, all the time.
- if his pace becomes flat, to ride through it. Now, I can't do this with Jazz, his body starts to go faster than his legs, so I come down to trot and start again. But she didn't seem very keen, when I asked, of me doing that.
- only sponge with the inside rein. I'm not allowed to do it with both reins, which was what Jazz understood.
Although she has also told me the same or more amount of useful stuff.

I've only had two lessons with her, but am unsure whether I should continue, or find another instructor. I want to learn to ride in a way that's best for my pony. I feel really really guilty about saying this! But thing is, I can't find another instructor as good as my first one. All of the ones that I know in the area are either bossy and part of the 'kick and pull' brigade, or won't push me. I'm finding it frustrating as I really want to learn!

So, basically what should I do? And if I should change, does anyone know any good freelance instructors in Devon? (I can travel to a certain extent).

If you got through to the end of the post, thank you!

Rachel
 
If you're confident enough in your own style, then you can do this:

Take lessons from this instructor; take lessons from anyone you can get your hands on. Learn what they can teach you, keep what's effective, drop what you don't wish to use.

If this instructor is focussing on your position, and you like that, then let her teach you what she wants to teach you, even if it conflicts with what you'd rather be doing...and when you move on, keep what you liked. You can't ever find someone who agrees with you 100% ;) so gain what you can, where you can.
 
Oh dear - been there done that and got quite a few tea shirts really!!

It is difficult to summon up the confidence to explain your own view (on behalf of yourself and your horse) - as a pupil. In fact it is SO difficult sometimes one has to reflect and wonder why - because surely it shouldn't be like this at all because we're clients. And wouldn't it be SOOOOOOOO lovely if the UK was full of instructors who really "thought" (and had the capacity to do this too dare I say) about how to achieve the best for their pupil and pupil's mount?

Some analogies are required I think but with an apology first. I can't think of one from my teenage years so grandma style will just have to do, I'm sorry.

If I had deliberately or unwittingly terrified, or humiliated, my children as I was teaching them oh I don't know, maybe how to clean their teeth or tie their shoelaces, or how to be nice to and understand our cats I wonder how they would have turned out as adults?? Instead of teaching them (or should I say coaching them) with a bit of "feeling" maybe I should have taken a course which gave me some "credentials" which would have resulted in me "instructing" them using meaningless phrases they wouldn't understand whilst I felt really good about myself and they cringed throughout the rest of their lives.

btw I did NOT take that course at all.

In the end Rakeli I have resorted to saying exactly what I feel and thank goodness I have a home-based instructor who "listens". So nowadays when I say: "NO, I don't think I can do that." as opposed to: "NOOO, I can't do that." I thankfully have someone who can distinguish between the two. In the first instance he knows I need some extra help, and time, to achieve the task - in the second he knows I will not do that!!!!!!!!! I also take every opportunity to draw attention to Kerry's own reactions to what we're doing of course.

If I lived in Devon I would love it - and if Kerry lived in Devon she would adore it. You have a very rich arena from which to select the help you need so good luck.
 
p.s. whilst I'm on my "soap box". Does anyone else appreciate that thing I call "silence"...................................................... Yes for however long it takes, once some advice has been given it takes a while for some of us to grasp what has been said and put it into practice. I think being given this time to practise to get it right is what I appreciate above all else from my trainer and instructor - it stands in such contrast to the repetitive harping on of people who don't seem to have grasped anything at all to do with "teaching" and "learning".

Sandra
 
Thanks galadriel and Sandra. She isn't that bad by the way! After having a lesson today with her, I've decided to take galadriels advice and 'stay put', as I do need the regular lessons that she can give me, but take lessons from other people. I do like her, she's very fair (with the horses!), it's just a few things that bother me. I would prefer it if she was 'enlightened'!

Sue - if you read this I've tried to PM you back but your inbox is full!
 
Well done. I think a lot of us would prefer it if our instructors were "enlightened" but.............there aren't that many out there are there?

So, if you've found someone you do like, can get on with and can learn from in some of the ways you wish that's a brilliant start - a foundation on which you can build. It's just that - as in most things in life really (but somehow it seems very hard to do in the equine world) you may now need to set the scene of "compromise" - the end result of which is just as Galadriel suggested. Take what you want and discard what you don't want. It's sometimes quite hard to do but you can take it in stages - and feel GOOD about it because you are doing it for Jazz as well as yourself.
 
HI Rachel,

Are you having lessons on one of the school horses? Della, who is another of my working students also gives lessons here, but usually only for riders with their own horses or on the simulator. My warmblood mare Millie, damaged a tendon sheath back in October, and is not going to be back in work for another couple of months, and then won't be fit for another couple.
But when she is, Della will be giving a few lessons on her each month, and Debbie my yrad manager also is happy for us to use Fly her own horse who is medium level dressage.. Even if you could only get over for the occasional lesson - and you would also be welcome to stay and watch me work the Iberians- I think this would help to keep things clear in your mind.

Heather
 
It's no good <sigh> ... I'm going to have to move to Devon so I can have regular really good lessons with Della, Debbie and Heather ... and watch those beautiful horses of yours Heather. <Heather running in opposite direction ... lol ... making enquiries as to nice equestrian properties in the Outer Hebrides!!!> :D
 
The lessons I'm talking about are on Jazz (my own pony), though I do have (free) lessons at the school.

It would be fantastic if I could do that! I could probably get Jazz over, not really sure, but as Jazz is the most 'advanced' horse that I've ridden (and he's not that advanced. My first half-pass came from teaching it to him!) it'd be really interesting to ride a horse that knew more! And watching you with the Iberians would be great, I've never watched anyone school before.

Ooh, exciting!
 
newrider.com