It looks like you're facing the same issue as me weight wise nl, it's pretty tough isn't it. I don't know to compare the photos as in the first she's standing at a little angle on her fore leg so you can't gauge if there was the fat pocket near her shoulder which is present on the second pic. With that and her change in coat, I wouldn't say she's got any worse, but I'm afraid I don't see an improvement either.....but that again could be down to the angle of the pic. Her ribs are well covered and she's quite booby. Yes there's an argument that highlands always will look a little overweight, (i saw a very ribby highland at the show earlier this year and the image has stayed with me) but I think she could lose 50kilos and see what difference that makes.
I hate saying this as it holds a mirror up to my situation with my fattie. I tried muzzling I tried penning I tried walking up hills with him when I couldn't ride this summer in an effort to keep the weight from piling on but as I keep learning, there seems to be a critical point in early June time, that if I don't watch, he just balloons despite best efforts, although this year it's been less and I've got plans for preventing it next year aswell - I just keep having to hone what I'm learning. Once the pounds are on during early summer, it seems nigh on impossible to shift them until later in the year. I'd say, depending on her age, I'd be wintering without any rugs and watching feed so that she can shiver off some excess fat. I can get flip down to a good weight over winter so although I'm not against him carrying a wee bit of extra beef around this time because he's sure to use it, I need it to be less extra if you know what I mean!! :bangs head:
I know folk will make me feel suitably ashamed of not doing a better job at keeping the weight off him, it sounds so simple....'stop feeding so much and exercise more'. I don't have all the answers, I am finding it tough.
I can sympathise whole heartedly though and I guess you have the added issue that it was someone else's doing that she came to you in that condition. I'll be interested to hear how you get on. Thanks for sharing mrs x