How tough should one be?

SJ

New Member
Feb 1, 2000
141
0
0
East Sussex, UK
Visit site
We have a brilliant Exmoor X pony with attitude, 10yrs old who we've owned for 18 months. Her only real bug bear is loading. Once in, she travels well. I'm pretty sure the problem down to leaving her mates in the yard. I was advised when we bought her that we would have to get tough with her (whatever tough means?). I'm afraid it doesn't come easily to me to get tough with animals beyond a growl and the rare thwack for serious disobedience.

I have tried every gentle approach to loading over the last 6 months, feeding in the trailer, walking through very regularly, loading a mate first, bach flowers and even homeopathic treatment recommended by Tim Couzens MRCVS in Horse Magazine to try to stop panic attacks. She is very bright and works out exactly which trips are for real and which are just practices - the practices she loads like an old pro! Several people have told me she is taking the Micky and I need to get tough and show her whose boss.

I load her in a bridle which at least helps me to hang on to her, she is very strong and whips round fast.

I got so frustrated with her at the weekend I kicked her with my outside foot as she was messing around which did actually work and she shot up the ramp but it required a rather gymnastic approach on my part. She keeps inventing new evasions, a couple of weeks ago we got her loaded, breeching bar locked in, she ducked down like a cat and ran backwards down the ramp before it could be raised. Had to be seen to be believed - I have now had the bars put really low to avoid any more limbo techniques!

Should I get tough? How tough is tough? What are tough measures? Will it gain her respect and cure her or will I always have to be tough?
Sorry this is so long.

Sara Jane
 
Your post made me laugh as it sounds like a typical stubbern Exmoor Pony.
It sounds like your getting into a bit of a battle about this and i know from experience that when it comes to the battle of wills with an Exmoor, just dont go there!!:)
You say he goes in ok just for practise perhaps he senses that you are abit on edge when it comes to putting him in for real and thats how he knows the difference.
When you put him in for practise do you actually go anywhere? If not you could try driving up the road and back so its more like the real thing. Lots of praise and maybe a treat when he comes back out. Do this lots of times, i know its a pain and alot of hassle but its worth a try. Have you tried walking him into the trailer, when he stops tap him on the rear with a whip, you might need some help from behind for this.
I think tough means firm, make sure that you are in control not the pony. Dont let him get away with anything for example if you want him in the trailer make sure you get him in there even if it takes along time. Each time he gets away with something he knows hes winning. Practise some basic manners in the school. when you say stand make sure he stands keep doing it till he stands. Lots of praise etc. Walk on when you say not when he wants to.
I did this just recently with my Exmoor and he is now listening to me and doing what i say. If he reverts back i go back to the school and do it all again.
Hard work - YES, Boring - Yes, Worth it - DEFINATLEY
Good luck
 
Thanks for your prompt reply hlstarmie! I'd forgotton there was someone else on this site with an Exmoor. I'm sure we could exchange hilarious stories for hours, they are great characters.

Generally our pony is very well behaved and ridden mainly by my 9 yr old daughter, both hacking and in local shows. She's also schooled regularly. Having been used as a lead rein pony when we first had her, she is very used to following me around obediently. I think you're probably right that she has found something she can beat me at and we both now get ourselves in a tizz - my homeopath suggested I took the same remedy as the pony a few days before loading, which I do. I have to admit that loading is the only time I've been frightened by this pony and I'm now having to conquer this as well. There's pressure on us to get her up the ramp first time otherwise I know we're in for a battle. She's pretty thick skinned as far as being bullied with a whip is concerned.

Unfortuately, as we are usually loading early in the morning it puts a bad start on a jolly day out. Funnily enough she loads easily coming home so I think she probably is taking the p***!

Any other advice really welcome, I really need to know how to become No.1 pony in this pack!

Sara Jane
 
Have you tried the lunge line approach? Ideally you need two lunge ropes, attach one to each side of the trailer, two people hold an end each behind the pony, then change sides and cross the lines just above the hocks and apply pressure on them. Usually works, we have a pony who occasionally gets stroppy about loading, now she sees me going to the car for the lunge line and loads like a lamb. Hope this helps.....
 
Lunge lines

Yup, we've tried lunge lines, she's so jolly quick and strong that she jumps off the ramp and ties herself up in the lines, having done this she stands perfectly still and gives me a look, the equine equivalent of "so there! you can't make me", I can read it in her eyes! If it wasn't so frustrating she would really make me laugh.

I think the "getting tough" suggested involves causing her some pain, hence my reluctance. Either a sharp jab in the mouth as she tries to run backwards and/or and serious whack with a lunging whip - tickling the whip behind is no help at all.

Is there ever a need to frighten/hurt an animal into submission. We really have tried all the gentle methods over a long period of time, she's a really gorgeous pony apart from these antics but we do need to be able to travel her.
 
I know what your dealing with as i have one like it, but i would not cause pain to him especially to the mouth. He might loose trust in you all together.
I know they are so stubbern you just feel like there taking the pi** all the time but you cant help but laugh as they look at you with such an innocent look.
Patience is required here and lots of it, count to 10 and all that but pleeeeeeesssssssseeeeee stay calm.
Good luck
 
I've got a mare very similar to yours in terms of trailer loading (although not a pony- she's 16 hands and 1200 lbs, so when she doesn't want to go, there is no arguing with her!) We did all the usual approaches, feeding in the traielr, etc. Much like your mare, she did wonderfully while practicing, but then came THE DAY when we were going on a wagon trip via horseback, and needed her to actually go in the trailer for real. Well of course she knew the difference, and we spent nearly an hour trying, until someone suggested a different approach that works as a quick fix. Get a long lead rope (10 feet is ideal), make sure it is not frayed or anything, and clip it onto the halter (don't use a bridle for this) next to the regular lead rope. Take the long one and wrap it 3 or 4 times around a support bar of the trailer and get someone to hold it. Then cue the horse with the regular lead rope as you normally would, and this way when she pulls back, she cannot pull you with her. Our mare pulls on the lead rope for 5-6 seconds, then wlaks into ther trailer normally. For her, she just has to test us and see whether she can pull us around. I don't know if it is the same situation with your horse, but you might try it.

Also, when you practice loading, do you have the trailer hitched to a truck, or jsut standing alone? Do you have it in a different spot than where it would be when you are actually going somewhere?

Allie
 
Thanks for your encouragement! Yes the trailer is in the same place and hitched up. She's just very smart. I even bandage her tail just for practising so she hopefully won't tell the difference.

I'm not too happy about tying the line to the breast bar for the same reasons we tie her on to twine and not the fixed rings. It might be worth a try.

We're going to a show on Sunday so I'll keep you posted!

Sara Jane
 
newrider.com