How Do You Lead?

Flipo's Mum

Heavy owner of a Heavy
Aug 17, 2009
9,549
1,491
113
Perthshire, Scotland
Where do you have your horse when you're leading him/ her?
I was taught to lead from the horse's shoulder with head ever so slightly tilted towards me. The logic was that if he spooked he would go round infront of me rather than bumping into me. Also I can constantly assess his speed and reactions as I can feel him getting faster or slower from his shoulder movement.
In the field he'd rather walk behind me which I valiantly try to discourage for fear of getting flattened if he spooks, or clips my heels and ruins my riding boots (which cost me £100 I didnt have to replace- grrrr!)
Watching Monty Roberts on Saturday night I was interested to see him suggest that the horse's nose should be level with your shoulder. This seems to be all related to leadership and not letting the horse ahead of you but my way feels safer to me. What do you think?
 
On the left side of the horse with its nose level. I also leave a bit of a smile in the rope so I get a bit of notice that the horse is moving before the rope goes tight. I have noticed a lot of horses will go out of their way to get me on the left so I guess that is the most common side to be led from.
 
Mine follow me. I expect them to walk behind me on a loose rope, either directly behind me or slightly to the side - whichever they want to. If they spook at something, then it's up to them to go round me - they know I'm there and it's rude to run over your herd leader! But their nose should be either level with me or behind me.

I don't like walking at their shoulder as they are too far in front and if they decide at that point to shoot forwards, I've got no control. The only exception I allow to that rule is when I take my shetland out. He's used to driving and enjoys being out in front, he doesn't take off and he's small enough that even in front of me I can pull him round if I need to. But he still has to walk on a loose rope and it's only allowed when we're out. So walking in the field or anything he has to toe the same line as the others do.
 
Depends. If it's a horse I don't know then I like them more or less level with me, preferably on a loose line and out of my space as it's easier to keep their attention and make any adjustments. I'm much slacker about my two though, I don't mind whether they go behind, to the side or even ahead of me so long as they pay attentionto any requests I need to make.
 
I'd never let a horse walk behind me, whether I knew it or not. However well-behaved they are, they're still prey animals and as such could easily forget their manners if they're scared.

I keep mine at arm's length with a smile in the rope (wonderful expression, btw!) and if she strays into my space I put my arm out to show her where she's supposed to be. I tend to keep her nose level with me, but I wouldn't back her up if she plodded slightly ahead as long as she was no further ahead than shoulder to shoulder with me.

The odd times she's excitable on the lead I hold the rope fairly close under her chin and hold the end in my opposite hand, and if she gets a bit quick, an elbow in the chest soon teaches her to mind her Ps and Qs.
 
I walk level to their shoulder most of the time.

I sometimes lead the pony and my boy by walking in front, but only if on the yard etc. Would never walk them to the paddock whilst walking in front of them.

If leading two together I walk by their shoulder and hold the lead rope right up near the headcollar.

I was taught that you had the most control walking level with their shoulder.
 
I lead with horse level at shoulder with lead rope loose. If the horse has his shoulder near me there's a chance that he could bolt and easily get away in this position as I'm too close to his body (also in kick range at shoulder). He also can't push me with the shoulder. If the horse spooks then he just runs by me as he isn't behind me he's to the side.
 
I don't like walking at their shoulder as they are too far in front and if they decide at that point to shoot forwards, I've got no control.

I was always taught that you had least control at the shoulder too. You can easily get barge or the horse can bolt and you're at the wrong angle to get the head back towards you, plus if they did bolt then you're in perfect kicking range.
 
I always have Tikki with a loose'ish' rope and walk at her shoulder, as she gets incredibly worked up if you try and hold her on a tight rein..and holding her head is about the worst thing for her..also I've learnt that when she does spook or explode she kind of snakes her neck from withers to poll so being at her shoulder I can see this reaction better than if i was in front. Magic on the other hand can be quite bargy so I lead her on a loose rope but her head is level with me so I can block her if she cuts across me also behind she will very much walk through you if she thinks she can get there quicker!
 
I am not happy having my bargy boy walking behind me either. Instructor says his nose should be level with my shoulder, not shoulder to shoulder, and not held tight either. Over the last month (with my new leadership head on!!) we have practiced a fair bit. If he does get in front of me I make him back up - takes an awful lot longer to get back to the yard, but am hoping the penny will drop eventually!
 
I prefer to have Roxy with her nose level with me or ever so slightly in front.

She prefers to walk behind me though and if I leave her be, she will fall in line behind if she has her way. I try to bring her to my side but it takes some effort! I also keep the rope very loose. I personally have no preference for either side.
 
We walk with Arns nose by my shoulder having been taught by someone who follows Monty's school of thought.

Arns is not allowed to walk past me and gets my indignant lollipop lady impression (pantomime leaping up and down in front of him whilst facing him so he has to back off) if he should try. This usually has him licking and chewing and he remembers not to go past his mother (!).

We always keep a "smile in our lead rope" ie have a loose curve of rope.
 
This might come out quite flippant so I'll apologise in advance. But with my girl it all depends on the time of day. For example in the morning it's a case of her being really good coming out of the stable, she must wait for me to be outside before she follows me then I tend to get dragged in which ever direction she feels like to get some grass. Thens there's our early morning pony grass skiing practice towards the field and past the gate in total darkness to get to the lush rich grass she may have missed the morning before.

However coming in from the field in the afternoon its a case of her at my side never past my shoulder and behaving herself in a calm and collected manner, she never barges, never pushes, never misbehaves.
 
I have a general rule of thumb...

Young - well behind on a long rope!!! (Head-tossing injury risk)
Bit older - well behind on a shorter rope and two eyes in back of your head (toe crush risk)
Older - anywhere but relaxed between shoulder and nose (should know the ropes by now.. fnarr fnarr :biggrin:)

Well behaved - as Older.
An arse - as Young until taught the ropes (i just can't resist it can i...)
Stallion - as close to his head as poss with a massive stick (precaution only, can sniff mare from 100yds away!)
Mare - any of the above.

However, you are allowed to use discretionary measures to change between the above.

ta daaahhhhh :biggrin:
 
Never have the horse behind me , I gather that if your horse is behind you it's driving you therefore in charge. Always walk with a loop in leadrope & horse's head in front of my shoulder & with enough space between us so that horse doesn't come into my space
 
Another vote for the Monty school of having the horses head at your shoulder. Also makes it easier to turn both ways, so if you are leading from the left for example and want to turn right, it is much easier (for me anyway :biggrin:) to do this when their head is level with you rather than you being at their shoulder.

Also echo what Tubby said, whoever controls the feet is the one in charge, so if they are behind you, they are driving you forward and in control of your feet....
 
Depends what I am doing and where I am. You try leading 5 of the blighters in rough hill and have them along side you.

If I am training them to lead I want them by my shoulder. If I am showing them, again I want them level with me.

it's safer in rough hill ground to have them walk behind you, then if they need to take a step to keep their balance you don't get trodden on.

there is NO WAY any of mine are in control of my feet and they know it! If I stop they stop like a shot, it's how they are taught, My personal space is mine and heaven help them if they try to take advantage and be bargy.
 
I always thought at the shoulder too but one of the first lessons I had with my new RI was teaching Rafi how to lead with his nose near my elbow but not touching - it is, as you say, all about respect. If he tries to get in front I have to move him back (whilst keeping my feet still - easier said than done for me anyway!), likewise if he bumps into me I have to move him away. I lead with a fairly slack rope and if we're leading in from the field etc, as opposed to working, he is allowed a certain amount of freedom, ie he can look around if he wants as long as he doesn't pull on the rope or push into me. It didn't take long for him to get the idea and now when I lead one of the other horses on the yard I really notice the difference - some of them really march on and a couple will drag you into the stable given half a chance.

One thing I haven't asked RI because I keep forgetting, is how to you manage when you're showing if your horse is trained to walk slightly behind - I think when showing aren't you supposed to be positioned by the horse's shoulder?
 
Rosie is a shoulder leaner so we are also nose to my shoulder. She is not allowed to walk ahead of me and if she starts to or gets cocky she'll get a stern 'back' and I do make her back up a few steps (her feet move not mine) or sometime straight to the very subtle, non agressive rope twirl in front of me. She always choses not to walk into it! If needed I can get assertive with this but we've learnt now - I dont look up or at her, just twirl the rope and she moves - usually as soon as I lift my hand :wink: If shes dropped behind and is trying to sneak up the other side I twirl to the side. Im OK with her behind me but she cant cross sides otherwise shes on the opposite side to the rope and itll all be tears if she spooks!
 
newrider.com