I do agree it depends on the horse, but in my honest opinion i dont think a bit of rain is a good enough excuse to get the rugs out. I go by my own rule that if i can see my own breath, the rug comes out. The problem is with this weather is that as soon as i put a rug on Aramis, the next day its boiling and i regret it. So now i just dont put one on. If there are thunderstorms, she's fine, she keeps her weight well and hardly ever shivers. She just gets wet, basically.
To me its summer, and in summer its warm. Ok it can sometimes drop a little, but the next day you find its gone back up again. When it gets to late september early October and the shivers come...i will then get the rugs out permanently.