How are we doing?

Clava

New Member
Apr 24, 2008
5,526
0
0
On the South Downs, Hampshire
Ok, so Renegades have arrived and I will sort out the straps, I was just wondering how Belle's hooves were looking as I'm no expert and have so much too learn. So far we have done a little road work, she has improved remarkably on stony ground (path to the stable) and seems very happy in her hooves. I think they are looking rather worn so I'm glad the boots have arrived. The shoes were removed 12 and half weeks ago and they haven't been trimmed (nothing to trim..)

front off side
hoofside-1.jpg

hooffront-1.jpg

chip atthe front I'm not too worried about.


rear offside
rearhoof-1.jpg



Front underside, we had some thrush in the frog but this is now gone, no smell and regrowing.
P1030230.jpg



Ok....so how are they looking...? The bars have worn last time out...
 
Last edited:
They look pretty good.

I think they could do with a bit of a trim even though there isn't any spare length, the edges could do with being rolled and there's a bit of flare that could be trimmed. But I'm fussy :)
 
They look pretty good.

I think they could do with a bit of a trim even though there isn't any spare length, the edges could do with being rolled and there's a bit of flare that could be trimmed. But I'm fussy :)


My farrier doesn't do a "roll", I think that's something I'm going to have to work on. I can see the bit of flare, again something a trimmer would work on, but my farrier probably isn't going to worry about.....if it's a problem I may have to research trimmers, or learn to tidy them up myself.
 
Last edited:
What Melanie said :D They don't look bad, and if the horse is comfy that's what counts. Putting a roll on and tidying flare yourself isn't that hard - would your farrier let you have an old rasp, and perhaps also show you how? Can but ask!! :D
 
Many thanks for everyones comments, I feel we are going in the right direction. She shall be a barefoot TB :D!
My only slight concern is slow growth as in over 12 weeks the wear is equal to growth and I've been on the roads say 6 times (not long distances). Hopefully the boots will be the answer, but will wear encourage the hooves to grow faster to compensate?...or will the new growth be tougher? As it's only been 3 months the new hoof growth (without shoes and with supplements) will not have reached the ground yet.
 
Hi,

I agree her feet look pretty good. I agree too that they need to be 'rolled' tho. This will reduce the likelihood of chipping & cracking too. As the flaring on her fronts is minimal, it might be all that's needed to correct that too.

The sole shot shows that the quarters could do with being 'scooped' a little shorter & while this angle doesn't make it clear, I suspect the heels are a little long - I would gradually reduce them, trimming little & often. Her heels are a little more contracted than I like to see, but bringing the heels down should help, and without knowing her history, it could be that that problem is already improving with each trim & ride you take.

Re growth, of course good nutrition plays a part in this, as do the overall health of the feet - perhaps they were shod & unhealthy until recently? If so, they should improve in strength a little anyway now, but as a rule, exercise is one of the biggest factors in hoof growth & strength. The more she gets, the more her feet will grow. The hoof will put out as much or as little as it needs. That's why you can have, for eg. healthy, sound, barefoot carriage horses working full time on city streets.

Depending on her hoof health at the moment, how much/where you ride, what she lives on, etc it could take a while for her feet to become healthy & well conditioned enough to cope fully tho. It's a holistic thing and depending on any of those factors, the horse may never become conditioned enough to cope with everything you may ask of her. That's where hoof boots come in. I advise a horse is ridden as much as possible bare, but so long as they're comfortable & sound(they still often pick their way a bit), using hoofboots when necessary. This usually means that they need the boots regularly and sometimes constantly for the first few weeks or months, then only on rough, hard ground, or nearing the end of long rides where growth is not up to wear, then occasionally on the roughest and longest rides.
 
It's a holistic thing and depending on any of those factors, the horse may never become conditioned enough to cope with everything you may ask of her.

I think it's wise to sound a note of caution as there are many potential limiting factors, including the dreaded Tb genetics, though some do successfully go the whole hog. But if you have great boots then it's not a problem :)
 
Wundahoss - Thank you for your comments. Just to give you a little background, she is 8yrs old and this is the first time without shoes (she's an ex-racer), she lives out 24/7 with only token hard food with hoof supplement (HoofMender), I ride her 2 or 3 times a week, but rarely on the roads (hopefully I'll start doing more now the summer holidays are nearly over and kids go back to school). She looks fit and healthy (pic on my profile page).
My question is....is it exercise (working in the field) or wear (walking on roads) that encourages new growth? I understand that hooves grow to keep up with wear, but does exercise encourage growth when the surface is soft?
At the moment I intend to use my new hoof boots for longer road rides and for when I go down our stony lanes (if possible, long story invloving ruts). I think her heels have recently started to reduce slightly...with more wear could they self correct?
Yann - I'm bearing this in mind, genetics are not on our side, but I'm very happy to use hoof boots too! Especially funky orange ones.:D
 
My question is....is it exercise (working in the field) or wear (walking on roads) that encourages new growth? I understand that hooves grow to keep up with wear, but does exercise encourage growth when the surface is soft?
At the moment I intend to use my new hoof boots for longer road rides and for when I go down our stony lanes (if possible, long story invloving ruts). I think her heels have recently started to reduce slightly...with more wear could they self correct?
Yann - I'm bearing this in mind, genetics are not on our side, but I'm very happy to use hoof boots too! Especially funky orange ones.:D

Yes, exercise on just about anything will help, but firm ground is much better. Seems to be exercise and wear play a part in governing how much the foot puts out. I would ride her on paved and stony roads bare as much as she is able, and use the boots when necessary to ensure her comfort and if her feet get worn down too much.

I agree that some horses, particularly within certain breeds, have genetically weak or problem feet, but that's not to say all horses of certain breeds. Just because she's TB doesn't equal bad feet. I would venture to say that the vast majority of 'bad feet' come from management & nutrition(environment) and that there are probably very few horses in the world with genetically bad feet.
 
Ok, you can probably tell I'm giving Belle's feet and being barefoot a bit of thought at the moment and thankyou all for your replies on the poll thread. As an update I took some pics of Belle's feet today, she's been barefoot for 6 months now and quite sound but very slow growth / or wears easily. I try and ride out once a week, but not always and usually with the Renegades on the front but occasionally without.

Front off........................................................and 3 months ago
P1030810.jpg
hoofside-1.jpg

now..............................................................and 3 months ago
P1030809.jpg
hooffront-1.jpg


P1030820.jpg
P1030230.jpg


Hind off now...................................................and 3 months ago.(not quite the same angle photo)
P1030824.jpg
rearhoof-1.jpg

P1030827.jpg

P1030823.jpg


The nearside are much the same, will up load photos later.

So how are we doing now?
 
Last edited:
They look ok and look like they've improved. There's still room for improvement (if they're just trimmed then I'd not be too pleased with the trim, but if due a trim then might be fine) but they're not bad feet :)

They don't look too short so as long as she's comfortable its probably all good. Some horses do just grow what they need and never seem to have much excess length. I've got one like that, if she does way more work than normal she pops up a sole callous and then the wall catches up pretty quickly, she has no problems growing enough foot but she also never grows excess length. Actually most of the working barefoot horses I've trimmed never have much excess length but also very rarely manage to wear their feet too short or get sore.
 
They look ok and look like they've improved. There's still room for improvement (if they're just trimmed then I'd not be too pleased with the trim, but if due a trim then might be fine) but they're not bad feet :)

They don't look too short so as long as she's comfortable its probably all good. Some horses do just grow what they need and never seem to have much excess length. I've got one like that, if she does way more work than normal she pops up a sole callous and then the wall catches up pretty quickly, she has no problems growing enough foot but she also never grows excess length. Actually most of the working barefoot horses I've trimmed never have much excess length but also very rarely manage to wear their feet too short or get sore.

They have not just been trimmed and I have to admit that they've not been trimmed at all since having the shoes removed as there is nothing to trim (not for my farrier to trim anyway), but quite possibly a trimmer would have some work to do, which is really why I'm wondering about the trimmer route....:confused: but she's very happy in her hooves and getting better on stony ground too.
 
The main things I can see that a trimmer might address differently are the height of the heels and probably a bit more thoroughness with removing any flares and leaving the hoof wall bang straight. Ironically this might possibly leave your horse less comfortable though, in the short term at least.
 
MelanieD and Yann - thankyou are replying, If neither of you are too concerned then I wont rush out to find a trimmer just yet. I think the new growth of hoof is better and I can see the line (near the bottom now) when I bought her and her shoes were removed and she started living out 24/7. The new hoof growth has less ridges in it. I'm not sure the length of heels is much higher than before (the angle doesn't help), but I will keep an eye on this and ask my farrier too (he's positive about being barefoot, but I get the impression he's not into fine adjustments:o). I'll post again in another 3 months, if you're up for giving me your views, but generally I hope we are going in the right direction.
 
It is very difficult to make any comments on photos as without seeing them in the flesh you can't rely on the camera/angles not to distort things. I am no expert, so take anything I say with a pinch of salt, but it appears to me that the heels have become a little more under run - I think this is probably just due to the fact that they are probably a bit high and if brought down a little it would look much better. My concern would be that if the balance isn't addressed that the heels will continue to migrate forward. If you look at the latest pic of the OF you can see that there is a little 'bulge' at the quarters which I would say is probably due to the heel position and flaring. The heels are certainly less contracted (particularly if you look at how much the frog has opened up which is great), although I think it is perhaps a little deceiving as to how much due to the position of the heels, but as I say it is hard to be accurate with photos.

It would be interesting to see a straight on shot of the hind soles if you have one?

They really don't look bad, but it is difficult for me to comment - particularly as most of my experience is 'before' and 'after' shots taken by my partner and when you see them it is very easy to comment on how they looked before ;-)! I am also a bit of a perfectionist with feet, purely because of what Tim does as I get to see pics of really nice feet!

I would think though that another difference a trimmer would make is the conditioning aspect, which does play a major part of the transition. For example, I am pretty sure work over tarmac would really help to get the heels back more, and varied with some work either in pads, or on a soft distorting surface would help with the frogs, etc.

I don't usually post on these types of thread as there are just so many variables with everything and giving trimming advice from photos is just so hard (and I don't feel i am qualified to!). Also, it is very easy to look at pictures of feet and think what needs to be done is quite straight forward, but unless you understand every aspect of how hooves actually function I think it can be oversimplified. If Tim were to look at these feet for example, he may well agree with me that the toe plane may be too high, but it may not simply be a case of taking the toe plane down to rectify the problem straight away, as it may cause a problem elsewhere, etc, etc! Hooves are so much more complicated than we realise, but at least we are beginning to understand their function now!

Hope some of that makes some kind of sense?! :)
 
newrider.com