Horses fighting while being led

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
Within the herd, Cally is fairly dominant, Zak is easy going and seems to get on with everyone without ever making waves and Xav is totally at the bottom of the pile.

I can lead Cally & Zak or Xav & Zak without problems but when leading Cally and Xav she makes threatening gestures and causes him to pull back. As far as I am concerned, herd dynamics can play out without my interference when they are loose but once the head collars on they should be polite - with each other as well as me! But I've never been clear on how to correct this apart from just making sure she is walking with her head on my shoulder and pushing her out of my space if her gestures get into it - which they do when she lunges towards him for example.

Well today as we were walking down she suddenly swung her quarters and double barrelled him hard in the belly. He buggered off back up the hill, lead rope trailing. She may be in season as she has been very prancy with tail stuck in the air recently. How would you a) correct her immediately as I don't consider that acceptable behaviour and b) deal with it long term? Or should I just not lead those 2 in? But my view is that I should be able to lead any horse with any other horse as once they are under my control they should comply. Is that unrealistic?
 
When I arrive all bets are off, all arguments finish and any fighting among themselves stops.

It's not unrealistic to expect them to defer to you and behave.

It must come from her having total respect for you. Do you do any work in hand with her?
 
Thanks @Wally That's the attitude I want too! I did a lot of in-hand work when backing but not so often now. But she will back up, yield, side pass, trot, change direction all on a loose lead rope. I never allow her into my personal space. But I get confused between what is 'respect' and what is just training. As far as i can tell, she does the in-hand things because I've shown her what I want but that does not seem to mean her overall attitude is respectful. How do you command respect?
 
She would have gotten a severe telling off and I mean a severe one. I'm the same as Wally when I'm there the politics stop, end of and if a harsh reminder of manners is required on a few occasions then that's what will happen.
 
What does a severe telling off look like? How would she connect the telling off with the behaviour? (Not disagreeing with you, just trying to understand.)

I whacked her with the end of the lead rope to drive her back and backed her back up the hill about 10 feet. In my head I was 'telling' her that I out ranked her and that her behaviour was unacceptable. I also then made her keep several feet away from me - Ie I widened my personal space zone to reinforce the 'I outrank you' message. If she came near I backed her back up the hill again pretty assertively causing a couple of mini rears. So she was in no doubt I was unimpressed. My worry is that I have no idea if any of my assertive/aggressive behaviour meant anything to her or whether from her point of view all I did was 'attack' her for no apparent reason! Especially as my timing wasn't great as I was trying to hang on to Xav before he got away from me so the telling off was after he ran away, quite a few seconds after the kick.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keren@serendipity
I personally wouldn't lead them together at this time. Both of them are new to you and it takes time to develop trust and respect between both of them and between you. For the time being I work work on their manners separately and not put yourself at risk.

I too am intriged to what a 'good and severe telling off' is exactly? At my old yard many years ago one of the staff was leading 2 horses when one kicked the other. The handlers response was to kick the offending horse hard in the stomach. Is that what you clasify a 'severe telling off'?
 
I probably wouldn't lead those two until you are a bit surer about their behaviour in that you must be respected at all times, despite seasons etc.
My Storm loves pulling faces and will try and double barrel if she feels Chloe is too close - but that's when they are in the field together - not when I'm around. Storm knows that even though she is top dog I don't want behaviour like that - she knows to save it for the field. But I feel it's something that has developed over the years. I don't remember actually setting aside time to develop this kind of manners / behaviour, it's just something that through handling her and I guess correcting over time has become the norm?
To keep things safe I'd probably lead separately until I was sure they knew to put all thoughts of such misdemeanours out of their heads. Time and consistency I guess? Correcting "in the moment" whenever possible? For me a stern word is normally enough.
 
My initial reaction would be to give her a good wallop back although I'll probably be shot down in flames for saying that. Nothing too much just a good hard slap with the rope and shout No! More to focus on me again rather than anyone else and not as a punishment

For now I wouldn't be leading with two. I'd get them both listening to you and when that happens then you ccan try leading Xav and Zac.
 
Mine would have had a hard wallop as well, I would never ever tolerate attitude to each other when lead. I'm the same as Wally in that when I arrive and the headcollar goes on and herd politics are later NOT when I am around.

Our two sometimes would pull faces at each other but only occasionally never would there be teeth / heels as they knew better !
 
To get the respect all the time you have to insist on it all the time, every intetaction with a baby is training time at no point should they be allowed to cross the line or else it becomes fuzzy to them when you expect respect. If you cant manage to discipline her whilst you have xav in tow then dont have xav on tow or you may be closing the gate after the horse has bolted.
If my horse kicks another and the only thing I have free is a leg then she will get the side of my foot in her belly fast though not with great force, its not about hurting them its about the shock of the action. I would much rather square them up by some agressive backing but when you are leading 2 and trying to nurture confidence in the other backing isnt nec the easy option. I would never let jess escalate to kicking out though, I would be telling her long before that it isnt her decision and to back down, she is super dominant and battered me several times as a youngster so its something we had to work through, though she still cant be lead with another dominant mare with out risk of needing to be squared up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and KP nut
If she is the aggressor and he is submissive then I would have a schooling whip in the hand that leads her and as soon as the faces are pulled or any aggression is shown she gets a flick with it. You don't have to let go and it also means she will move away from you rather than into you as the next time you could be in the floor between them and that's. It a great place to be.

Sounds as though you did give her a telling off and she knew it. You cannot just give in and say well I won't lead her with such and such as then the behaviour goes unresolved and suddenly she does it again with something else.
 
She knew it! But I'm not sure she knew why as the timing was rubbish so the correction was probably not linked in her mind to the kick. The schooling whip is a good idea, plus I'll be alert to it now so a warning flick in response to a threatening gesture should make thing clear to her about what is and is not ok. I'm not against using pressure with horses - they use huge amounts of pressure on each other - I just want it to be meaningful to the horse otherwise nothing gets learnt as far as I can see and trust may get eroded as I don't think horses like inconsistent, unpredictable behaviour - which is how Cally would see it if she does not understand it. I agree too about not letting it go. If anything I'm tempted to do the opposite and lead them regularly to provide more learning opportunities. She needs to show the behaviour for me to be able to correct it, for her to learn not to do it anymore. My worst ever horsey accident was while leading two so I have no intention of tolerating any argy bargy, I just wasn;t sure how to go about it, and I don;t think I was effective today :(

But I've got some ideas now. So thanks for replies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Leading my two together I find the trick is to never take my eye off Jim & make sure he knows it. I also allow Little Un to go slightly behind where he's out of reach of Jim's teeth - Jim doesn't kick but he can be very quick with his teeth if other horses irritate him. If he does dare lunge at LU he gets my fist in his teeth, a threat will get a growl & raised hand as a warning - the fist sounds harsh written down, but that's what it takes to get through to him that his behaviour will not be tolerated & I'm not arguing about it! If, by some miracle, LU is the instigator then a quick turn towards him & stamped foot has him nearly shitting himself -a strong telling off really does depend on the horse in question!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and Jessey
Our fell mare cannot be led in with another pony. She is a very dominant little mare and when she's in season she's worse. Its a good job we love her. xx
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Sounds as though you did give her a telling off and she knew it. You cannot just give in and say well I won't lead her with such and such as then the behaviour goes unresolved and suddenly she does it again with something else.

I don't agree with this at all. From what I remember Cally is 3 years old and Xav is a pony who has hardly had any human contact for the last 5 years until a couple of weeks ago. You cannot expect them to automatically do everything nicely and most importantly safely from day one. Manners and trust take time to establish and having a heavy hand and such a dominant attitude from the handler is neither helpful or understanding to either horse. Is it really so wrong to lead them separately for a couple of months until they are both more settled and used to each other? To me that is the safest and most sensible option for the time being. Why create an unnecessary battle?
 
I do see where you are coming from which is why I asked the question. I did wonder if I was expecting too much, but my instincts were that they should never squabble once caught so I am reassured others also share that view. For me it's not a question of being heavy handed but of being clear about the boundaries. If you introduce a new horse to a herd the herd does not think 'oh let's tolerate rudeness for a bit while we get used to each other'. They impose their limits from day 1. I see horses as repeatedly asking questions. Is this ok? Is this? What about this? And I want to give clear and consistent answers to those questions from the very first day. Manners do not take time to develop in a herd - within minutes each horse knows exactly what is ok and what isn't and they are happy with that clarity. @MrC sugesstion of carrying a schooling whip to give a warning flick at the first rude gesture is not heavy handed, it is communication.
 
Manners do not take time to develop in a herd - within minutes each horse knows exactly what is ok and what isn't and they are happy with that clarity. @MrC sugesstion of carrying a schooling whip to give a warning flick at the first rude gesture is not heavy handed, it is communication.

But you are not part of the herd. If you were part of the herd you would have to fight for your place and you would have to expect to take a kicking or two before you found it - and anyway what makes it right for you to automatically expect yourself to be the herd leader? I don't agree with the humans taking the place of the herd leader, the human and horse relationship is so very different. You are not a horse, you are a person.

It wasn't really the schooling whip comment I was referring to when I said heavy handed, it was more of this:
She would have gotten a severe telling off and I mean a severe one.

It's just my opinion, but if you do continue to lead 2 young and green (well one young and one with hardly any handling) horses together armed with a schooling whip with the aim of giving them a severe telling off when they don't behave perfectly, you are asking for trouble and could well end up injured.

Why not teach them to lead separately well first, and when that is established teach each to lead nicely with an older sensible horse. When that is working then try and lead them together again? I think that your expectations are set too high at this stage.
 
I have no intention of giving her a severe telling off. I intend to communicate clearly with as little pressure as possible that fighting Xav while attached to me is not ok. And I'm not trying to be the herd leader. I'm just saying horses learn limits fast so you don't need to build up trust over time before you impose limits and boundaries.
 
If you are happy with your training methods and your results then feel free to completely disregard my opinion. I would just ask yourself if you are being fair with your expectations at this stage in their training and make sure that you wear a hat while leading both together. I personally think that you are expecting too much too soon, but what do I know? They are your horses and you know them best.
 
I'm not disregarding yours or anyone's opinion. I think carefully about all replies. In fact I became aware after my last reply that my thinking about 'rank' is muddled because I don't believe in 'being the alpha' but at the same time I was trying to show her I 'outrank' her when I squared up to her and backed her. (There will be another thread on that soon I expect...)

But in the end I need to consider all views then go with what feels most right.

I do appreciate the replies though so thank you. ☺
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
newrider.com