Honest opinions please

poppie

New Member
Feb 4, 2008
172
0
0
Having a tendon injury i have found that using a western saddle works better for me and a more comfortable ride with no pain.
However i'm up against a size problem, i ride in a 14'' saddle and have a small pony.
Please take a look at this saddle and what do you think of it on the pony??
100_3306.jpg

<a href="http://s1097.photobucket.com/albums/g353/stue111/?action=view&amp;current=100_3305.jpg" target="_blank"><img s
100_3305.jpg
 
Honestly, it's far too big. The skirt at the back is over the pony's rump.

This article (about back pain in a quarter horse) shows fitting of a Western saddle and explains the common fitting problems:

http://www.equisearch.com/tack_apparel/western-tack_apparel/shoulder_soreness_031408

It shows where the saddle should 'finish' on the back - you can see yours is way too long.

Western Saddler on here should be able to advise you better than I can, as I am not a Western specialist, but that saddle does not look right for your pony at all. Sorry. :(
 
Honestly, it's far too big. The skirt at the back is over the pony's rump.

This article (about back pain in a quarter horse) shows fitting of a Western saddle and explains the common fitting problems:

http://www.equisearch.com/tack_apparel/western-tack_apparel/shoulder_soreness_031408

It shows where the saddle should 'finish' on the back - you can see yours is way too long.

Western Saddler on here should be able to advise you better than I can, as I am not a Western specialist, but that saddle does not look right for your pony at all. Sorry. :(

Thank you for your opinion, i thought of taking it to my saddler to see if she could take some of the skirt of the back???
It's real shame as it's so comfortable but at the end of the day i have to think of the pony's welfare.
I did have another western saddle that fitted perfectly unfortunatly i lent it to a friend and it got stolen :stomp:
 
I agree, it does look pretty huge.

What is it that you like about riding in a western saddle?

I have a Torsion Close Contact my 12hh welsh section a, and it has short flaps like a western saddle. It's actually a toddlers saddle but my 5ft adult sharer rides my pony in it with no issues, and even I can get my bum in it. I stuffed the pommel and it keeps it's shape well (and gives a little more room in the seat) and the cantle is already stuffed.

I think Barefoot do small western saddles (kids and small adult saddles I think) as they aren't rigid it might allow you to ride in the seat size you need without being too long for your pony.
 
Honestly, it's far too big. The skirt at the back is over the pony's rump.

This article (about back pain in a quarter horse) shows fitting of a Western saddle and explains the common fitting problems:

http://www.equisearch.com/tack_apparel/western-tack_apparel/shoulder_soreness_031408

It shows where the saddle should 'finish' on the back - you can see yours is way too long.

Western Saddler on here should be able to advise you better than I can, as I am not a Western specialist, but that saddle does not look right for your pony at all. Sorry. :(


Agree entirely...
 
Gorgeous saddle, but looks way too big for your little 'un. It a bit difficult to tell from the pic, but the side of the skirt doesn't look like its really touching horse at all, looks a bit 'cape like' if you know what I mean. From the overall picture, it just looks too big all round.

What size is the saddle? It is rather lovely. I think it would be a shame to try and cut some of the skirt off. I'd be more tempted to sell it on and buy another that fits.

What a complete bummer about your other saddle, thats really annoying.

How big is your pony?
 
As others have said, the saddle is too long. Sadly, shortening the skirts will not be enough, you would also need to shorten the tree. If the tree is fitting the pony well the skirts should not be weightbearing anyway. :) As No Angel said - if you have a small rear, Barefoot do a little treeless saddle, and Freemax do a 15" seat saddle too (although I suspect that will be too long too). :)
 
I agree, it does look pretty huge.

What is it that you like about riding in a western saddle?


I have a Torsion Close Contact my 12hh welsh section a, and it has short flaps like a western saddle. It's actually a toddlers saddle but my 5ft adult sharer rides my pony in it with no issues, and even I can get my bum in it. I stuffed the pommel and it keeps it's shape well (and gives a little more room in the seat) and the cantle is already stuffed.

I think Barefoot do small western saddles (kids and small adult saddles I think) as they aren't rigid it might allow you to ride in the seat size you need without being too long for your pony.

Because i have a injury to my tendon in the groin area:redface: i have to ride with something that keeps my hips more open therefore riding in a western saddle is more comfortable for me plus my physio has recommended using one, i'm trawling through ebay for something more suitable.
 
Gorgeous saddle, but looks way too big for your little 'un. It a bit difficult to tell from the pic, but the side of the skirt doesn't look like its really touching horse at all, looks a bit 'cape like' if you know what I mean. From the overall picture, it just looks too big all round.

What size is the saddle? It is rather lovely. I think it would be a shame to try and cut some of the skirt off. I'd be more tempted to sell it on and buy another that fits.

What a complete bummer about your other saddle, thats really annoying.

How big is your pony?

Well the saddle is a 15in, i'm thinking of putting it on ebay problem is my hubby has only just bought it for me as a gift i feel really bad now.
Poppy is 11.2 her characture makes up for her size lol.
 
if you need to keep your hips open a treeless will be better for this won't it, as they can stretch your hips?
i really know nothing about treeless saddles, the only problem is poppy has no withers and is rather round what are they like for girthing up??
 
If you use a 14" english saddle you will only need a 12" western, what is the measurement from horn to cantle on your saddle. I know Popularfurball had one for sale that may be suitable.I'm not sure if she still has it maybe worth giving her a PM.
 
If you use a 14" english saddle you will only need a 12" western, what is the measurement from horn to cantle on your saddle. I know Popularfurball had one for sale that may be suitable.I'm not sure if she still has it maybe worth giving her a PM.

Thanks for that will give her a pm
 
Yes a 14" 599 big horn... been trying to get rid for ages!! Doesnt fit fattie!

IMG_0491.jpg


Finally sold for peanuts at weekend typical! Madam is 11"3/12hh and in a 15" english for comparison.

Poppie we use a15" libra trec with haf pad with sympanova underside and best thing I did for us - like a slipper :D so confy!
 
newrider.com