Heels, hips and straight lines!

happy_bunny

Member
Apr 12, 2008
465
3
18
St Mellons, Cardiff
I have just been reading the 'Kinder Way To Ride' articles by Heather Moffet and in the picture of the girl sat correctly, her feet are flat to the ground so that 'if the horse were whisked away she would land on her feet'. And her example of an unbalanced 'chair' seat showed the heels down but the head-hip-heel line has gone wonky.

So my question is: if this is correct then why is my RI always saying 'heels down!'?? I am only just trying to learn to ride properly after many years of just banging about anyhow but the advice seems to be a bit contradictory - is it because when you put your heels down you also have to pull the lower leg/stirrup back to keep the line straight?
 
When my instructor shouts "heels down" it's because the weight is in my toes, and my heel is up in the air (as though wearing high heels or standing on tip-toes). I've always been taught that the "correct" position for your foot is parallel to the floor.
 
"Heels down" is really a bit of a misnomer - if your leg is in the right position then your heels will be down, but you need to work on your leg position first, not your heels. What frequently happens is that if you push your heels down your leg will move forwards into the dreaded chair seat.

Unfortunately, over time the emphasis has gone from getting your leg position right, which results in your heels falling, to pushing your heels down, which results often in a poor leg position.

Ignore your heels. Work on your leg position.
 
try to think 'knee and heel down and back' instead. you don;t want to force the heel right down, because that does shoot the lower leg forwards and then you do get left behind. you don't have to be exact about landing on your feet if the horse disappears, just as you don't have to be exact about heel down as far as you can go. as said, parallel to the floor or heel slightly down is what you are aiming for.
 
There's a difference between the level of heel down depending on what you are doing too! Dressage/flat work tends to be foot level as you ride with longer stirrups, without stirrups the heel tends to be very slightly higher unless you have very good leg position and jumping would be more heels down.

Think of stretching your leg down rather than just your heel and do work standing in the stirrups to encourage the ankle to soften and the heel to drop. In fact heel down could be better described as soften the ankle as when you have a relaxed ankle then the heel will drop much easier.
 
I used to get told heels down
New RI has told me to relax the back of your lower leg which then means your foot is parallel to the ground as your leg is in the correct position
I think
 
My daughters have started lessons recently and the RI is now working on their position. He tells them 'toes up'. When I learnt to ride (80's!!) I was taught heels down.

Presumably this is because trying to lift your toes is more subtle than heels down?? :)
 
Heels down was the cry of my childhood instructor and what a load of rubbish too. Now its a case of having flexible open hips, lenghtened deep thighs and feet that just sit flat in the stirrup with no tension. I do drop more weight into my heels if I am galloping across country on uneven ground in a forward seat though as it is a different position from my flat schooling seat. As I have broken both my ankles in the past and torn the tendons on the right one in December heels down could be a nightmare. (not I may add in riding accidents!) I avoid tension in the leg and do lots of excersises to tone and lenghten my leg using my swiss ball and physio roll.

JW
 
heels down, or toes up, same thing, is to help with balance and your leg position. More important for jumping. Having said that, it does take time, :cool:, and will come. Patient :D
 
Thanks, Im feeling less confused now :)
Maybe it is the incorrect leg position that makes me bounce so much when I try to do sitting trot (?), I don't seem to be able to relax my knee or lower back :confused:
Oh well, I have another lesson on Sunday, maybe I can work on it then :p
 
Have you tried the sitting trot without stirrups, you let your legs hang lose, feet relaxed, kind of sit on your jeans pockets ok, best to try it on the lunge first, breath, breath, sing a song, or think of anything in general to get YOU to relax, you will soon find your lower back will not be tense, this is what makes you bounce. Then try it again with your stirrups back, do the same, breath, sing, count, and you should able to relax your lower back. Do a few sitting trots, do a few posting trots, a few sitting trots and so on, fingers crossed for you :)
 
Thanks for the advice, I seem to be getting on a bit better. Tried having longer stirrups than normal and it made a huge difference :) - think I had them too short before so the tension on my knees was pushing me up and out :rolleyes:

I also found out that the horse I have been riding for the last few weeks is notoriously difficult to sit to - rode a different one this week and everything was easier :)
 
i was always taught (wrongly) that heels should go far down, this has now resulted in me having a rubbish leg position as my heels are down therefore my legs go forward and hey presto...chair seat :rolleyes:
 
Heels down is an easy way to explain to kids (tendancy to have a high leg position) and its very difficult to get them to understand how to sit correctly. When teaching adults there should be a lot more description going into how to sit correctly.

It is very difficult to explain on hear...I would really advise anyone to go out and get The Classical Seat written by Sylvia Loch...Very easy to understand and a full description on how and why you should sit...

I think it is more important to learn why you have to sit correctly 1st before trying to learn how...

Remember not to be scared off by the word "Classical", it is only the method that has been devaloped over thousands of years to make things as easy, comfortable and manageable for the HORSE as possible.

Best of luck with this...Really would recommend that book, its only a tenna.

Best of luck XX
 
This was a helpful thread to me to. My RI was saying "heels down, toes to the sky" several times tonight. My mom took pics and I look like I'm sitting wrong. I don't think my long legs help either *sigh* Hopefully it will all come with time.
 
Yes that 'heels down' thing is a misnomer. Instructors however do often say that to get people to stop lifting their heel up and when they lift their heel they are of course drawing their leg up so not an ideal way to stay balanced. Sometimes it works better to say toes up. Maybe you push down on your toes, if so, when your instructor says heels down you should think of toes up. Not curling your toes up you understand, but lifting the front of your foot up - which should have the effect of dropping the weight back and off your toes.

What is understood by one person is often totally misunderstood by another. One person told to squeeze with their leg might do it with their knee. Another might do it with their thigh and a third with their calf. Some instructors just need to take time to explain things better.
 
If I am on a fast hack then I have my heels lower but then I'm in 2 point and need to to keep that position. The faster the work, the lower the heels for me :)
 
newrider.com