I also have a youngster, he's 5 but very very green, however, this has worked in my favour as I can train him to the way I wish to ride, which by the way is using the lightest of touches and with out putting any undue stress in his path.
I first began teaching him to halt from the ground (infact I taught him everything from the ground first, as being a novice rider I did not want to confuse him with too many aids at one time)to stop whilst being lead, from the field, from the stable in-hand walking etc. So that he understood that when I stopped and said stand, he was to stand next to me and not move (he used to shake his head in protest and spin around to look at something else) Once this was established, I then went onto prefecting the ridden halt transistion. I found that from the ground as I asked him to stand, I also breathed out and relaxed my back and leg muscles, a natural movement when walking then stopping. So I did this in the saddle along with my voice command.
So long as my legs are kept in gentle supporting contact with him, to keep him straight, all I now have to do is think stop, my own body naturally relaxes to a still position and he halts without moving or shuffling wherever I ask. It has taken me and my horse 2 months to get to this stage so patience is a virtue and you must remember to tell him how good he is for even the tiniest improvement he makes. I am sure in time he will understand and give you what you want without you having to make him do it.
If I were you, I would try the groud work first and concentrate on your own body's natural movement into a halt and then try to emulate this in the saddle, which in turn will make you more relaxed and hopefully not have to fiddle and pull a little on the reins.
P.S. I am lucky enough to have never had to fiddle with the reins in a halt, but I do believe that each horse will learn at its own pace in its own time, and therefore patience is an essential quality when riding and there are no set standard that can be applied to each horse. All you can do is the best you can and all he can give you is the best he can.