Giving up horses!

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
When do you know it is time to pack it all in? I’m lying awake at 2.30am with bad bruising and I’m in pain. I have spent so much money on buying Eoin, all the vetting, the saddle, livery etc. I haven’t really enjoyed it at all. I have spent the last 2 years grieving for Ben and trying my hardest to move on, but nothing I do works out. I really can’t imagine getting on any horse again. Eoin is going for schooling and will then be sold. And then what? I have run out of energy and enthusiasm for something I used to love so much.

Sorry for the self indulgent post. I guess I’m feeling sorry for myself!
 
Can you go back to riding your share? You were enjoying that weren’t you?

Perhaps book a couple of lessons specifically designed to help confidence, horseback combat has a program I believe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
Can you go back to riding your share? You were enjoying that weren’t you?

Perhaps book a couple of lessons specifically designed to help confidence, horseback combat has a program I believe.
This is what I was going to say, you used to really enjoy your pony time.
Don’t throw the towel in just yet, get yourself recovered from your bruises, get Eoin off to sales livery and take some time off, see how you feel in a couple of months time once the dust has settled.
Take the pressure off yourself, if you decide you never want to be around horses again that’s just fine but right now you need to be less sore and less critical of yourself.
 
What about trying something that does not involve riding or crises of confidence? You seem to enjoy the care side more (I can relate to that), so perhaps help out someone else by grooming and/or assisting at competitions, or getting a pony to show at local level, or volunteer for RDA (or do you already do that, I forget). There are loads of non riding things to do around horses/ponies. It would be a pity to waste your skills and experience.
 
I never have felt it time to pack it in, I'm lost without a horse.

When I lost Jim I was heartbroken, I think the only thing that stopped me going to bed and not getting up again was the fact that I had Little Un and he needed to be cared for. I'd bought him years earlier for Jim and I owed it to both of them to keep looking after him, particularly when he seemed as lost as I was. I got over myself and he blossomed being number one.

When I lost Little Un I wasn't as devastated - sorry Little Un - but it still hit me hard. However I knew I wanted another, it just had to be the right one and that, for me, is about personality. I took some time to go and ride a variety of others, both friends and at schools and hacking centres, it had been a long time since I'd needed to get on horses and quickly make an assessment of them and I felt that would help when I was buying. I also didn't want to rule out a type simply because it wasn't what I thought I was looking for, but I quickly found out I still didn't like riding lighter weight types! Some rides on a friend's wonderful and very safe cob also reminded me that while his type are worth their weight in gold they aren't for me because I find the standing like a rock to handle and never putting a foot wrong under saddle actually quite boring - the chances are you'd have loved him though @Mary Poppins and I know his owner will never sell him.

I'd say give yourself some time, no point in doing anything while you're hurting as you'll feel unsafe, I'm a painkillers and get on with it type but I appreciate that isn't for everyone. Then find something to handle and ride but make sure it's safe. Go to a few schools or hacking centres to ride different types, the horses there will be safe and reliable which will help with your confidence and if you explain in advance and book private sessions you can keep it to a pace you're happy with.

If you want to carry on with horses you do need to move on from Ben. Not forget him or stop loving him, but accept he's gone, nothing will bring him back, and stop holding him up as the perfect horse that nothing will ever match. Take other horses you deal with as themselves, not as a second class Ben. And if you do decide to buy or loan again then look for something older and well established in whatever it is you want to do, a safe schoolmaster like my friend's cob.

Take time to heal up first though.
 
I know exactly what you mean.

Take a step back. Take some time for yourself. You are young and you will find horses if you want to again. And if you don't, I doubt your life will be the emptier.

I have had numerous breaks from horses all my life. I needed to get over my beloved "fat farm pony" dying without me and it took many, many years to fall in love with another horse again.

Don't beat yourself up. Time will help - it will give you perspective. Pack all your horsey stuff away somewhere safe or sell it if you must. Everything is replaceable. Move onwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Silvia
I think you need to look back at your posts with how excited you were and the fact you didn't want to get off him when you tried him.
Then before this you were happily sharing, so it's not a case of whatever you do doesn't go right. It's just how things are just now.
Things were going really well, you were happy riding and being an owner again. But when something popped up with his behavior, you couldn't deal with it.

I wouldn't be giving up horses, I would be looking for something that is described as a first horse, confidence giver. Nothing that wants educating or confidence from the handler.
I did actually quit riding, my confidence hit rock bottom and I felt I would never be confident on anything. That changed when I found the right pony to ride and from that day forward I have started riding similarly described mounts. The cob was my step up, she's laid back if her opinions don't get there first 😂 I nearly sent her back.

I would book some stable management lessons at a nearby stables. Go and handle horses you don't know that are quiet and calm. Brush up on your skills that builds confidence.
You are having lessons to help you ride, I think you need help on the ground of you struggle to pick out feet of the horse says no.
 
Let the dust settle first before you make any big decisions about your future.

If you've had enough for now, then take a break. Either permenantly or temporarily. You don't need to commit to anything right now.

I think a lot of horsey folk are prone to believing that life is only good and validated if horses are in it, which isn't true. The world still turns if people don't pat ponies and ride, I promise you. There's a a world out there of equally fulfilling activities that & hobbies that needn't involve going near a horse if you don't want to.

Equally, if you want to try again with another horse, a share or lessons then do that in your own time too when you feel ready.

Other than finding Eoin the best new home you can, there's nothing about your future you need to decide now. And when you do make a decision it doesn't need to be permenant, you can always change your mind or try again if you want to.

The best of luck.
 
Last edited:
As someone who gave up last year, my advice would be to have at least a year off of everything. I think you are putting waaaay to much pressure on yourself at the mo. You've obviously not had a brilliant time with Eoin so ask yourself why you are even asking us the question? To me the answer is to give up. But it doesn't have to be forever 🤷‍♀️ You may change your mind, you may not.... none of us are judging you. You've had some time without a horse recently so that part shouldn't scare you (the thought of being horseless scared the bejeesus out of me and I was totally lost in loads of empty time when Gracie went, but I still didn't regret it).

Another option, if you don't want to ride, is to buy a pony and immerse yourself in in-hand showing. There are ways of having horses that don't have to involve riding.
 
Last edited:
That's what am missing the most. As she's not paddock sound, I can't do any of our exploring or lunging.

I have booked a ride at the nearby school to get some horsey time. Instead of being an owner, you could carry on riding here and there when you felt like it?

Though I love the suggestion of getting a non ridden pony and doing inhand shows. 😁
 
Can you go back to riding your share? You were enjoying that weren’t you?

Perhaps book a couple of lessons specifically designed to help confidence, horseback combat has a program I believe.
I kind of enjoyed sharing, but I never had any real enthusiasm for it. I have barely given my share horse a second thought since I stopped riding him.

I have long battled with confidence issues riding horses, I’m not so much into riding, it’s the caring side and companionship that I miss the most. I miss the relationship I had with Ben and I miss looking after him. Eoin acts like he hates me and it’s hard to not take that personally.
 
What about trying something that does not involve riding or crises of confidence? You seem to enjoy the care side more (I can relate to that), so perhaps help out someone else by grooming and/or assisting at competitions, or getting a pony to show at local level, or volunteer for RDA (or do you already do that, I forget). There are loads of non riding things to do around horses/ponies. It would be a pity to waste your skills and experience.
It’s just not the same as having your own. I tried all that when I lost Ben, I just felt like an intruder and didn’t really belong around other horses. I miss the relationship I had with Ben, I was supposed to be building a new one with Eoin but it’s all gone sour. I know time is supposed to heal, but it has been almost 2 years and I’m no further forward than I lead.
 
I know exactly what you mean.

Take a step back. Take some time for yourself. You are young and you will find horses if you want to again. And if you don't, I doubt your life will be the emptier.

I have had numerous breaks from horses all my life. I needed to get over my beloved "fat farm pony" dying without me and it took many, many years to fall in love with another horse again.

Don't beat yourself up. Time will help - it will give you perspective. Pack all your horsey stuff away somewhere safe or sell it if you must. Everything is replaceable. Move onwards.
How don’t you ever get over such a loss? I’m not sure I ever will.
 
To move on you have to move though, it won't miraculously happen. Likewise to heal you have to want to heal and put in the work it takes. If (and apologies to anyone who has but it's the easiest way I can describe it) you lost a husband or partner you wouldn't find someone else sitting at home staring at photos, and you'd probably not do any better if you went on dates but spent the whole time talking about the person you lost and comparing your date to them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
I think you need to look back at your posts with how excited you were and the fact you didn't want to get off him when you tried him.
Then before this you were happily sharing, so it's not a case of whatever you do doesn't go right. It's just how things are just now.
Things were going really well, you were happy riding and being an owner again. But when something popped up with his behavior, you couldn't deal with it.

I wouldn't be giving up horses, I would be looking for something that is described as a first horse, confidence giver. Nothing that wants educating or confidence from the handler.
I did actually quit riding, my confidence hit rock bottom and I felt I would never be confident on anything. That changed when I found the right pony to ride and from that day forward I have started riding similarly described mounts. The cob was my step up, she's laid back if her opinions don't get there first 😂 I nearly sent her back.

I would book some stable management lessons at a nearby stables. Go and handle horses you don't know that are quiet and calm. Brush up on your skills that builds confidence.
You are having lessons to help you ride, I think you need help on the ground of you struggle to pick out feet of the horse says no.
Eoin doesn’t just say no, he blindly bolts around his stable and goes into a panic when his right hind is touched. I am well aware how to pick out feet correctly. I can easily brush a horse who doesn’t try and flatten me when I move into his space. It’s not just me that he is like this with, he has always been tricky on the ground but I thought I could win his trust. It turns out I couldn’t and other people have problems with him to. If he easy to handle I wouldn’t need to ask for help.

Eoin was sold to me as a horse suitable for a novice rider. Apparently he was owned by a nervous rider before he came to me and she apparently didn’t have any trouble with him at all. I contacted his old owner when I fell off him and now she won’t respond to me. I feel I have been lied to about his previous behaviour and am left thinking I can’t trust anyone.
 
Maybe she's upset that he's going to be moved on again? Maybe she feels you're implying she lied about him and is hurt by that?
 
You've done the right thing by Eoin, you did the right thing by Ben. You're torn up with guilt about Eoin, and grief over Ben. Give yourself a break girl - once Eoin is off for his schooling, and from there to a home that suits him, take a breath. Who knows what comes next? You might feel you're done with horses. You might want to take on a non ridden rescue that needs what you enjoy giving - sometimes when you're not thinking about it or looking for it, it just falls into place. You've done nothing to reproach yourself for, so try to stop beating yourself up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
Personally I don't think you are ready to own another horse, just yet. You are saying you miss the relationship you had with Ben, which is understandable but feel like Eoin hates you. You've said this before, which suggests you are not clicking as a unit.

He's barely moved to a new yard, with new staff, new horses, new routine. He likely is okay for a novice but because he is the unsure nervous type on the ground, that's possibly set his confidence back. It set yours back after two days when you had moved him. Maybe he's feeling similar.
 
This horse journey is so up and down. I feel like I almost like him again after watching him being ridden today. I think he needs a confident rider who can give him an education. That is exactly what he has now so we will see how he goes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
newrider.com