Found some enlightenment today...

KarinUS

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2001
13,162
176
63
54
Texas
Do you all remember that silly saying about
it takes 7 times falling off before you can call yourself a rider
I never believed it- especially since I really don't like falling off. It hurts!

Today though I felt like a rider for the first time. Think back to when you first started riding. It's so difficult because in a lot of situations what would be natural human instinct is exactly the wrong thing to do.

We had a little mishap today and without thinking much about it I got the situation under control. I think riding might just be like driving a car.
At first you have to learn how to do it. Then you still have to think about what to do for a long time. But when you do the right thing automatically without having to think about it, I believe then you can call yourself a rider (and save yourself some pain falling).

What do you think?
 
I don't make a habit of falling of either, though it is fair to say that Rio would take some falling off. My most recent mishap (a while ago) resulted from leaning over to check the girth and rolling slowly off sideways (round horse / treeless saddle!).

I know what you mean though, when a horse spooks 6ft sideways and instead of disappearing off its back you just sit there and say silly thing. You don't realise it at the time, but it is progress:)
 
I couldn't agree more. I think that's an excellent way to describe the learning progression. The intellectual learning is easy, it's turning that into an automatic physical response that is so difficult.

Somewhat differently, I actually find there are certain situations in which I naturally ride better/more instinctually. When schooling, I can often look rather awkward and unnatural, but for whatever reason, my seat sinks deeply and relaxes on a horse that bucks or shies. My instructor even comments on how she wishes I could ride like that on a horse who is going well.
 
This is what always makes me wonder.......

Every day I tell someone to open their shoulders, grow taller, expand your chest, thrust it out and lift your self up - all these acts leave a human vunerable or at least, psychologically they do. Leaving your stomach and chest open to attack is something humans don't naturally do in uncertain situations.

It is human insticnt, when things get scary, to curl up, protect your soft bits and peices! and hang on with your arms and legs all at once, this way you won't fall out of that tree or receive an injury from a blow.

On a horse it is the worst thing you can do when everything around you is turning to a rattle of dirt!:D ;)

When you are scared out of your wits and yet remain relaxed, tall and graceful instinctively that's when you can ride!:cool:
 

It's funny I'm not really a good rider as far as I am very crooked, my seat is not a steady as it could be and my aids are not as coordinated as I like. I used to keep count of my falls out of a funny little childhood habit, to my memory I have fallen off 137 times in 13 years. However the better the rider I became the less I fell off and I would say over the past 3 years I have only had around 6 falls - as you can see I fell off alot when I was younger, surprisingly I was never injured.

Anyhow in contray to what they say about falling off 7 times to be a good rider - (which I never believed because my grandad once asked me if I had fallen off 7 times, ie. was I a good rider, at that stage I must have already fallen off around 20 times) I have reached the level where I never feel as if I am going to fall off. If a horse spooks or bucks I never have that dreadful feeling anymore of separation from the saddle. I take this as a sign of the improvement in my riding. Not to say I will never fall off again.

Why do you fall off? Because you are not prepared, their physically, mentally or emotionally and probably you haven't put the work in on the horse to avoid such situations. That is why I feel I avoid falls these days. I make sure my horse is on the same wavelength as me before I get on, as well as being more intune with the horse, the way he moves and how to best handle situations, nor do I take as many stupid risks. I think that is all a part of good riding and mature riding.
 
When I used to ride motorbikes all the time, you knew you were due a fall, you could sense it coming, it's the same with horses too. I am due a fall off, havn't fallen off since last summer!

All the other bikers could sense the impending doom of a fall. Once it was over with you could relax again for a while, maybe it was a self inflicted, who knows?
 
I used to fall off with alarming regularity when I was a child. Some of the falls were harmless; one or two didn't hurt me but did scare me quite badly; one put me in hospital for four days (but that was my own stupid fault); and some were plain funny - I remember being jumped out of the saddle once, landing sideways round the horse's neck, and clinging on upside down as she galloped off up the field, from which position I did actually manage somehow to scramble back on board. I don't know to this day how I did it, but I was absolutely determined I wasn't going down because my instructor was watching!

Nowadays I don't put myself in situations in which I'm pushed into doing things that are likely to cause me to fall off. I never fell off Frank in the twelve years I had him (although I had a few close shaves, usually while jumping) and so far (touchwood) I haven't fallen off Merly. The trouble is, if I ever do - and I don't kid myself that it will never happen - it'll probably be such a shock that it'll break my nerve completely :(

As for whether falling off really improves your riding I'm not sure, but it certainly makes you more careful, if that can be classed as the same thing :D
 
Sometimes a fall is unavoidable. Sometimes a fall is avoidable.
Therefore, I think that this 'old wive's tale' is rubbish ! Its all to do with concentration and reaction to a given situation, whether you fall off or not. L
 
I think if you've never fallen off, you've never taken any risks, or gained the confidence that comes from falling off and getting on again...I know it's just a thing they say to cheer children up when they fall off, but I think there's some truth in it.

Reading posts from people who say they never fall... well, good luck to you is all I can say. I don't fall off often, but thinking back over my last ones (since I've been 59, which is a few years now), one was because I was cantering on a verge, and some idiot had dumped an armchair in the hedge, and the horse did a huge sideways spook; one was because he took off wrong at a jump, only 2'3", but he got his knees tangled in it and did a somersault; one because I was reaching up to pick blackberries and reached too far; one because my girth was loose and I slid upside down over a jump....oh yes, and one when I rode poor Barney into a bog on Exmoor and he was swimming. I'm a pretty cautious rider, I don't think I take "stupid risks", but I don't think any of those could have been avoided, except perhaps the last. Luckily none of them hurt much.
 
Half of the time I don't fall is luck. A few weeks ago Florida took off on a bucking fit across the park and after his 7th buck, I was half way over his neck when he finally listened to me yelling "Cut the s*#t!" and stopped dead. The only part of my body still attached to his was my left leg - my right arm, right leg & most of my body was hanging over his left shoulder. (the only time I've ever appreciated stirrups!) I wasn't a better/worse rider b/c of it. I did learn that after he makes his objections know 4 or 5 times - I really need to call it a day otherwise he will:D
That being said - I'm still dreaming of the day when I can fix the problem & calmly go on with my day before it degenerates into a mess;) :)
 
Karin, did this happen on your hack? I was thinking have you done it.
Theres so much to be said for sitting tall and gracefull, although im hoping im gracefull {cough}.Calm is best even when im a little worried.
Ive only ever fallen while dismounting
:o :o but would hate to tempt fate because obviously there are lots more risk hacking.
I had a horse spin 180 degrees while on holiday, we were troting and a dog apeared from behind a bush, heaven knows how I stayed calm, but 'we' did and turned the right way like nothing had ever happened.
I will never be a rider if theory is true.:)
 
newrider.com