Feeling flat after todays lesson - help!

New Rider Nic

Active Member
Jan 6, 2015
138
100
43
53
Motherwell, Scotland
I had a different RI today & was on a horse I’ve only been on once before. Last time I was on him was my first ever attempt at canter and I spent the whole lesson trying, but failing to get him to canter so I knew it would be a challenge.

I’ve since had 3 canter lessons on two other horses which have went well & I felt like I was improving.
BUT… today was a nightmare from start to finish!

It took my RI & two teenagers shoving & pushing at him to even get him near the mounting block. I couldn’t even keep him in a trot (never been a problem before) he stopped dead when I tried to do 20 metre circles and it was like a battle every time I changed the rein. The RI told me to use the crop but every time I did, he bucked.:confused:

I did get him to canter every time I tried though, and at the end of my lesson I actually managed to keep my canter going round the whole school (1st time ever) But the lesson just felt like I was fighting with him the entire time and it’s really knocked my confidence. it just felt like everything i've learned fell apart.

It didn’t help that the RI ended the lesson by saying I needed to improve my leg position because that’s why I was “failing so much”

Today is the first time I’ve felt like I’ve “failed” in lessons! I came home and nearly burst into tears when I was telling my OH. Even my first few lessons were better than this! :(

Have I been kidding myself that I’m improving? Should I be just as good no matter what horse I’m on? I’m now doubting myself and thinking I’ve only been feeling like I’m progressing because I’ve been on “easy” horses.

Aarghhhh!! :mad:
 
Last edited:
Don't be so hard on yourself! You are still improving from what you said, first time keeping the canter round the school on a horse that you don't find easy is a huge achievement! Some horses will make you work a lot harder than others and some you just won't get along with as well either. Today's horse sounded like a challenge, but you did your best, got some good results and improved throughout your lesson (from not being able to sustain a trot to keeping canter)

Also sounds like this instructor isn't quite as supportive as your other one, but that isn't always a bad thing, they may push you to try harder and you will want to prove them wrong and in doing so you will improve so much more.
 
Like Ale said - don't beat yourself up about it. If riding was nothing but up all the way, there wouldn't be any point in it; with horses there are always ups and downs, and often the downs come just when you don't expect them. You got onto this horse feeling negative, and horses pick up on our feelings and respond to them: probably the fact that you were worried made you tense, and that would have made the horse tense too. In any case, there aren't many people among us who can get on to any horse and get the best out of it straight away - and they're probably the professionals. It's like learning a new language. First you can just communicate about the simplest things, and at that stage you're a lot further on than when you started. Then you gradually learn to handle more complicated stuff, and finally, if you're really good, you can deal with whatever happens, even if they're using words you've never heard before. But whichever stage you're at, that's what you have to work with - you don't expect fluency after your first lessons.
 
Thanks Ale, I am really hard on myself and probably need to focus more on the positives - which you've just reminded me of. Thank you:oops:

Some horses will make you work a lot harder than others and some you just won't get along with as well either

Definitely the case today :rolleyes: I actually felt bad that I was having to use my legs & crop so much with him, I think I've got used to riding horses who I "get on" with. My recent lessons have felt like I'm working with the horse, today felt like we were in a battle of wills against each other.

they may push you to try harder and you will want to prove them wrong and in doing so you will improve so much more.

I felt exactly like that!! I felt like she taught me a lot, but then I also wanted to show her what I WAS capable of - which is when I got my first full canter. I think my mindset changed at that point, I found myself talking to Dalton (the horse :)) saying "C'mon buddy, we can do this" I also promised him polo mints if he behaved, maybe he understood ....

there aren't many people among us who can get on to any horse and get the best out of it straight away - and they're probably the professionals

Thanks Linda, I had the idea in my head that "proper" horsewomen could get on any horse and be perfect, so that really helps put it in perspective.
And your language example is spot on! I've been learning Spanish for 6 months and I would never expect to be fluent quickly, I need to have realistic goals don't I?
 
I rode a forward going responsive horse in my lessons for a couple of years and while he was wonderful and taught me lots, when they
put me on a horse less well schooled/ lazier and I would get frustrated and red in the face,
my instructor would ask me why and I would say I can't get him to do x or y. She would say it doesn't matter, you are here to learn how to and I can see you are trying and he is trying, so keep doing what you are doing and you will get there. And you do! And it feels great.
 
  • Like
Reactions: New Rider Nic
Are you sure the RI didn't say "flailing so much" as in flapping your leg. Would make much more sense for her to say that as most novices are quite flappy!! It will improve as you get used to using your leg muscles and you develop lower leg stability. And leg position is also very important in getting a better response from a horse without having to flap your legs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Ohhhhh, maybe KP nut. I hadn't thought of that. She did say I needed to work on lower leg strength.

With slower horses I'm very conscious that my legs do sometimes feel like they're flapping when I use them.

I keep reading about leg aids being a squeeze. But mine are more of a kick. Squeezing is completely ignored! And my RI tells me to kick, kick, kick. Is that because it's RS horses?
 
Partly. And probably partly because your legs are unstable and therefore inefficient and inconsistent. Most horses will go better for better riders without the better riders appearing to have to do much.. People say it's because they take the mick out of more inexperienced riders but I personally believe it's more likely to be because some horses need clear instructions and novices make a lot of 'noise'. Ie unclear movements or confusing cues like being kicked then being pulled when they move off the leg as the rider is behind the movement. So they learn to tune out anything subtle and need kicking on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Next time will be better:)
I had a few bum lessons, one in particular springs to mind where I slithered less than gracefully off down the side of the lovely RS cob's neck and landed in a sort of heap. We were meant to be asking for canter. God only knows that happened!! I swear the horse was laughing:D
 
  • Like
Reactions: New Rider Nic
I personally believe it's more likely to be because some horses need clear instructions and novices make a lot of 'noise'. Ie unclear movements or confusing cues like being kicked then being pulled when they move off the leg as the rider is behind the movement.

That makes so much sense. When I have a good lesson, I actually feel so pleased for the horse not having to put up with my wobbly mixed signals. Its frustrating that I know what I'm doing wrong...then do it without meaning to! I often find myself apologising to them when I lose balance & pull on the reins. I'm all "oops, sorry pal, please bear with me" then i compensate with big pats & polo mints :)

I swear the horse was laughing
Thank you Trewsers, I guess I was overdue a bum lesson. I swear today, my horse was counting down the minutes till I could get off...And laughing at my feeble attempts to control him :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Oh gosh I remember that feeling when you have been riding an easy RS horse and then they put you on one that is not easy! It is as if you have never learnt anything.

Don't worry, you will get stronger, things will get better. Hang in there.
 
I too got bitterly upset and wept after every lesson. It turned out I was being horribly bullied and a mother spectating reported the RI. None the less we adults are very vulnerable when learning to ride and tend to go on peaks and troughs.
My OH being an elderly gent has always said that it is saddle time that counts and if one spends enough time on a horse eventually one learns to ride. I think there is a moral there for us more emotional people. He made no demands on himself. He just went on riding once a week and proved it to be true. Tho he still claims he doesnt know how to ride and just does what the teacher says. Persistence is all that matters and the money to go on paying even when you feel you are getting nothing but your time on a horse.
O yes, and that means enjoying it.
 
That makes so much sense. When I have a good lesson, I actually feel so pleased for the horse not having to put up with my wobbly mixed signals. Its frustrating that I know what I'm doing wrong...then do it without meaning to! I often find myself apologising to them when I lose balance & pull on the reins. I'm all "oops, sorry pal, please bear with me" then i compensate with big pats & polo mints :)

We all do it wrong! It's just that as you get more experienced you confuse the horse in different ways! I remember trying to teach my horse turn on the hind quarters and I was using the wrong bl00dy leg so no wonder she had no clue what I was on about :rolleyes:

I think the most important lesson I ever learned in working with horses is that I give the horse the benefit of the doubt 99% of the time and assume that if they aren't doing what I want, it is down to me and my riding/handling instead of blaming the horse for being stubborn, naughtly, idle, stupid or whatever. I honestly think they know if you are willing to take some responsibility for how they are going and they appreciate it!!
 
I think the most important lesson I ever learned in working with horses is that I give the horse the benefit of the doubt 99% of the time and assume that if they aren't doing what I want, it is down to me and my riding/handling instead of blaming the horse for being stubborn, naughtly, idle, stupid or whatever. I honestly think they know if you are willing to take some responsibility for how they are going and they appreciate it!!


I wish I could have this written large on the riding school wall! Sometimes you will just not gel with a horse, sometimes your RI will challenge you with a horse but watch that horse ridden by a more experienced rider and take away the knowledge that you will get there with the right attitude and experience . Our most novice horses/ponies can all do 90cms plus jumping courses and Novice/Elementary dressage with an experienced riders but equally refuse to trot or canter if they do not feel you are balanced and safe. Do not knock them .... the best school horses are mortified if they allow you to fall!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey and blazer
I wondered the same as KP nut about your RI Saying flailing rather than failing, it makes so much more sense.
Learning to ride is a lifetime endeavour, if you think about doing this for the next 20, 30, 40 years, there really is no rush to progress too quickly, but it sounds like you have done a Stirling job in what is really a very small period of your riding career.
 
It sounds like you did the best you could on that horse. Don't beat your self up. Like others said Its a lifetime quest.
Schoolmasters can be tough- the ones I have ridden in lessons won't unless you do it perfect with Ques etc and .
He does not sound like a schoolmaster though if he was so hard to get to the mounting block and bucked when you were told to use
the crop.
True schoolmasters can be wonderful to ride- they just say"nope you did not get it try again!"" I don't hear you that's not the right que!"
I don't think you had really easy horses before - I suspect hes just a really Hard horse and maybe a bit if not a lot sour.

I hope you don;t get a steady diet of him in your lessons.

I suspect possibly others in lessons don't want to ride him.
 
think the most important lesson I ever learned in working with horses is that I give the horse the benefit of the doubt 99% of the time and assume that if they aren't doing what I want, it is down to me and my riding/handling instead of blaming the horse for being stubborn, naughtly, idle, stupid or whatever. I honestly think they know if you are willing to take some responsibility for how they are going and they appreciate it!!
Totally agree! On my first few lessons after learning my rising trot, I rode a horse called Hector. he was soooo slow, plodding along and it took massive effort to keep him going. But a few weeks later I was with him again and it felt like a different horse - but the difference was me, because I'd improved, I'd relaxed and he knew it. Now, I love riding him, in fact he was the first horse I cantered on and he was a dream. And as for his trotting? Fastest trot I've had yet on any of the horses. Now i'm always hoping I get to ride him!!

Do not knock them .... the best school horses are mortified if they allow you to fall!!

I've experienced this recently, the horse I've been learning to canter on up until now stops as soon as he feels me wobble even slightly. My RI says it's his way of looking after me.

I hope you don;t get a steady diet of him in your lessons.

Me too, but if I get him again, I just need to suck it up and keep at it I guess.

Thanks everyone, you've all made me feel so much better
 
  • Like
Reactions: horseandgoatmom
Ah don't worry - I have my own pony and he will not canter if I'm too wobbly...which is often! And I have to push him on in a riding lesson all the time. My RI tried him out, and there he was on the bit, stepping out and looking like a little hairy dressage horse! You will get there - and much kudos for sticking at it :)
 
All RIs are different too. I was always told to squeeze rather than kick, but my RI favours one sharp kick over squeezing and says I nag with my legs and it's better to ask positively for a reaction and get it. And even with my own horse, we have days where everything goes well, days where everything goes really badly and days where it's somewhere in between. She is occasionally prone to the odd buck too! Like you, I tend to be really hard on myself and focus on the negatives rather than the positives, but with riding lessons, you have a few lessons where you learn a lot and really get something like how to ask for canter/get a contact/whatever and you're like 'wow this is great, I'm getting somewhere' and then you hit a plateau where nothing improves for a few sessions or you even feel like you are going backwards, but you ARE actually improving, just not so drastically!
 
At one riding school I used to have lesson at (as an adult, so only about 3 years ago), they used to put novices on a horse called Duke who was probably cold-backed or had some back issue, and would bronc when the rider got on! I once saw him chuck off 3 people in one lesson. I could not understand why they used him for novices, unless perhaps they were trying to put clients off! I always refused to ride him. I also tried an RI pony when I was looking who was so dead to the leg and so bored with being in the school that I was flapping around like a total novice trying to get him to even walk. The RI couldn't do much better - she did jump him, but he literally did a few steps of a canter that was slower than my normal walking pace, and stepped over the jump! They were selling him to a private home as he'd clearly had enough of being in a riding school. Some RS horses are just totally fed up with it and don't want to do it any more. They're hard work!
 
newrider.com