Failed vetting, thought please

Star the Fell

Well-Known Member
Jun 14, 2015
1,118
785
113
So Ziggy came out of the stable and was ever so slightly lame in trot on right fore. Trotted up several times with no change. Flexion tests were done and he then trotted up perfectly sound on gravel and on concrete
He is unsho and was trimmed 2 days ago. Vet says his gut feeling is that they took toe back slightly too far or he stood on a stone. He recommends a re test in a week. Also has Mallenders. Gypsy cob with loads of feather do not unusual.
What would you do? Currently up for sale for £2200 including absolutely everything he owns. Was thinking of offering £2k and hoping he passed re test. Waiting for his owner to call me back.
 
Bugger! Sorry to read this. Gracie had Mallenders. Two jabs of Dectomax saw it off. I wouldn't talk money at the moment. Wait and see what he is like in a week. Deffo sound like a bit of post-trim pain if flexions were all OK. What was the owner's reaction?
 
  • Like
Reactions: OwnedbyChanter
I personally think vettings are highly risk averse and throw up 'problems' far too often. (Incidentally my vet agrees with me.) You may want to be risk averse as a buyer but good ponies are hard to find so to lose out on one for no good reason is not good for buyers either.

Someone missed out on my lovely Lisa because of 'failed' flexion tests. The next buyer also vetted and a different vet passed her on flexion tests but failed her on slight foot soreness which the first vet did not mention! 2nd buyer bought her anyway and she has been perfectly sound ever since and they adore her. First buyer walked away and said it was the 4th pony in a row she had arranged a vetting for who had failed. She missed out on an absolutely cracking pony.
 
Very difficult situation as I need a sound pony because of one that is lame. Not my usual vet as out of area, but he seemed really nice and told me his gut feeling was that nothing was wrong. Can't get to speak to owner at the minute - we keep missing each other. I feel like I should ask her to do second vet check next week, and I should still go and ride him this weekend. I didn't check for Mallenders tbh, just queried mites. Will be able to see myself how bad it is. I believe it's treatable if not too bad?
 
Tough one, the fact the vet has said his gut feeling is nothing wrong then maybe re test next week. But bare in mind when you come to insure you have to declare any vetting's you've had so the insurers may quibble about insuring that foot/leg in future even if he passes on the second one.

Vetting's are funny things as @KP nut said, but there are also a lot of horses out there that will pass a vetting no problem so sometimes it's worth waiting. Price wise if you decide to go ahead without the retest or he's not right on it I'd want more than £200 off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Personally I wouldn't be buying a horse that popped lame when trotted up.

Too many are presenting as 'oh he was just shod' or 'just trimmed' yes that does occasionally happen but always seems to be the cause when a horse is being sold.

Yes a vetting is a picture on the day, but I take Kia as a prime example when I think of a vetting. He was pulled out of a field having been in no work for years, passed a full 5stage with bloods and flexion and was chipped and passported same day as soon as he passed, in my mums name.

We pay for the vettings so why disregard them?

I wouldn't part with 2k for something needing veterinary treatment for something and failing a flexion test.

Your money however :)
 
The Mallenders wouldn't bother me one bit - very easily dealt with and almost part of the territory with hairys. Coming out of a stable lame and then improving with work would. Personally I wouldn't buy full stop. Always seems odd to me that people pay good money for a vetting and then try to argue themselves into still buying when the horse fails? What is the point in having a vetting if you are going to ignore lameness in particular? Of course you could pay again for vetting (or at least the lameness section) next week and the horse might be just grand on that day, but I just don't swallow the 'oh they have never done that before, must be trimmed short, recent shoeing nail bind etc. etc. ) I would only buy a £2,000 horse that passed the vetting on the day without any sign of lameness or other issues at all (not something as minor as the mallenders of course.) Now if it had shown initial couple of strides lame after the flexion test I might still have considered it at a lesser price, but that is another different debate altogether. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ruskii and MrC
Always seems odd to me that people pay good money for a vetting and then try to argue themselves into still buying when the horse fails? What is the point in having a vetting if you are going to ignore lameness in particular? . :)

I agree with this.... which is why I don't vet! Plus if you vet and get advice/caution on a non-issue you run the risk of being faced with exclusions that would not apply if you just didn't vet in the first place.

Vetting is a great idea in principle but I just wish vetting in general was more pragmatic. If a vet says he thinks it was a minor and temporary issue I would re-assess in a week and take it from there. I really would not pass up on a good pony if your vet's gut feeling was that nothing was wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lemme
Standing on a stone or having been trimmed a couple of days earlier shouldn't make a horse lame unless there's an underlying problem or the trimmer is doing a bad job. I would be reluctant to go forward unless there's something about that individual that meant I badly wanted him.
 
Mallanders can cause lameness I believe, if it's bad enough.

Thing is I know he was trimmed on Monday as she mentioned farrier was due when I viewed on Sunday.
I am really wavering on this one. I haven't seen anything local enough that I like as much, within my budget.
I'm head says don't buy as he's not 'perfect vet' my heart says buy as he is everything I want in a pony!

I don't have to decide for a couple of weeks as owner is going away until beginning of September so I doubt there will be chance for any viewings before then.
Will keep looking in the meantime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
yes it can Nf but it would need to be very bad though and long ignored to do that. I don't think I have ever had it do that in any of my hairys but I always use to slap a lot off gloopy stuff around the susceptible area even if they hadn't got it, and on the other legs for Sallanders - so to me anyway, it isn't a deal breaker. :)
 
The thing is if he passes the next vetting will it be because that one was lucky, or is this one unlucky? You haven't been looking that long, and as autumn approaches the chances are more will come on the market as people start thinking about winter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
A trim really shouldn't fail a horse.

If he gets left out this time and passed it could disguise the stiffness from having been in?

With an already lame horse I think I would be walking away. Has vet said your current one is retired? I might be inclined to get a short term loan until they come sound?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I would not buy at this stage. I would have it rechecked in a few weeks if the owners are happy to wait. Walk away if still lame then. If you can trial or loan. I would do that. If it's barefoot it could be footy on stones of course. During a trial ride it as much as possible. You need to put it through its passes to decide if it's just footy or if somethings going on.
I had a horse vetted and it failed and I said to my vet if I ask less money. My vet immediately said to me it's not about the money. You are asking for my professional opinion and I feel he's minor lame on his fore. If he goes lame once you buy him it could mean a huge bill to investigate. Thank God I didnt buy. I found out that the people loaned him out after the failed vetting. The loaners brought him into work and horse went lame. X-rays showed nothing. He was box rested. Then restarted, went lame again. Further x-rays from a different angle showed additional bone in the foot sticking out. Horse was PTS. Because it showed up on vetting the leg would have probably have been excluded on the insurance. It could have been very costly for me. I guess it depends if you have a bottomless purse.
 
Being off at first and then sound on gravel and concrete doesn't scream over trimmed to me, if he had been trimmed to the point of being sore it wouldn't go away after 5 mins :( unless he stood on a stone just then as he came out of the stable (wishful thinking I think). If the owner is mortified and going to pay for a recheck regardless of a sale then I might stay in touch to see how it pans out and have a rethink then, but I wouldn't put my own money/heart into a recheck.
 
@MrC I agree about the feet thing, I advertised Charlie on Thursday evening he was sold by Saturday afternoon I didn't expect him to sell that quickly and his feet were due the next Friday, farrier couldn't get there before so he was 5 stage vetted with feet a little longer than I would of liked and old shoes. He flew through the vetting no problem though and vet commented on what a sound, tough little horse he was.

I would also be wondering if it was something to do with stiffness, they have to stay in the night before a vetting to show any stiffness up. I'd also be more concerned about coming out lame than failing a flexion for 1 too many off strides. This is really cynical of me but do you trust the vendor not to leave the horse out or bute if you decide to have a retest, unless you're having bloods too? I don't think I would, not the amount of dodgy horses I've seen recently.

If it was me I'd walk away, I'd always be worried about that foot/leg and waiting for it to go wrong. Why buy a lame one when you can buy a sound one? Although I appreciate it must be really disappointing when you think you've found "the one" you never know though it could be a lucky escape.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I would walk away. If this horse is lame because he was trimmed on Monday, do you really want to have a lame horse every 8 weeks or so after every trim? It doesn't sound right to me. If you are particulary looking for a horse with no lameness issues it makes no sense to buy one which walked out of the stable lame.
 
Most people are saying walk away apart from the vet who actually did the vetting who says his gut instinct is there is nothing wrong. I'd speak to the vet again. It's all very well people saying that 'doesn't sound right to me' but he is a highly trained professional who you paid to vet the horse, he knows what he saw, what he thinks about what he saw and he is the only one who can really advise you objectively imo.
 
Vets aren't paid for gut instinct and if STF buys this horse based on the vets 'gut instinct' and it's wrong who is left with the lame horse and vet bills and possible lack of insurance?? I can assure you the vet won't cop to saying that as the practice would be liable. I could have sued my practice after I was told that Eowyn would return to full work infront of three witnesses however the vet who told me it didn't put that recommendation on the scan report and I box rested and rehabbed a horse for months and months ( god it was a nightmare NEVER again) that I was assured would be fine. Final scan the practice owner did it as the other vet had 'left' and I was asked what I was expecting to do with her, I said full work Low level BE etc and was told Happy hacker or broodmare as 2/3 of the tendon was permanently damaged. I'd have PTS had I been told that from the beginning.

I don't know any vet nowadays with the sue culture going on who won't just pass or fail a horse based on what you need the horse for.
 
newrider.com