Earning respect - which way?

kyanya

Active Member
Jan 19, 2003
5,837
1
38
39
Aberystwyth
spaces.msn.com
As I've previously posted in this thread, I've had a few problems with the general behaviour of Gypsy, the pony I share. This has included dragging me over when I tried to stop her going to grass while I was leading her and planting herself on the yard and not wanting to walk on in any direction.

I've come to the conclusion that she lacks respect for me. As her owner says, she's still testing me out (I've been sharing her for about 2 months though and seeing her weekly) and she's seeing how much she can get away with and where her boundaries are with me. Therefore, she's prepared to push me to the limit, and I need to let her know where she stands.

However, I'm not the most confident on the ground. I'm not a complete wimp either, but I've not had much experience with horses other than riding school ones who are generally well-mannered and don't question your authority. So this is a new situation for me, and I want to make sure I'm giving the right impression to Gypsy and I'm being the leader, which I'm not sure I am currently.

Therefore, I'd like to follow a horse behaviour training 'method'. Admittedly, I know very little about the training of horses, and I'm not sure on what I should be doing really. I know there are many methods like Parelli, Kelly Marks, Mark Rashid etc, and I'm not sure which one to go for, if any in particular.

Does anyone have any advice on this matter? I'm ideally looking for to buy a book and use it as a guide, so I can read it and then try and put what it says into practice. I'm just not sure which book to get. Also, I'd like something I can get fairly quickly, as I have Easter holidays next week when I'll be able to put a lot of work in with Gyp. We have facilities like an empty field, an outdoor menage and all equipment to use as well, I just need to know what I'm doing first!
 
hey there ny advice would be ground work ground work and mroe ground work youw ill not develope respect from your horse at all i you do not develope it on the groung
good luck
peace
Hayley
 
When you go into her stable does Gypsy move away from you or just stands there? If not look at whatever book you get and get to move away from you. Good method is to put your hand on the front of her chest and push backwards, as you step forward and giving verbal command to 'BACK'. Do not have to shout, but firm tone. Then try standing next to her shoulder and push her head over and expect her to move away from you. Do this again nearer her flank area (may have to move nearer bum end). But always working from side of horse. When moving her from side say OVER. If she does not move with slight hand pressure, up the pressure, until you get some reaction. Please do not expect her to move over several steps straight away, it may take a couple of days to get one step, but pesevere and let her get to know and understand what it is you are trying to communicate to her. As far as she is concerned you may just as well be speaking Martian to her initially.
I would do this initially in the stable - so as you can move around her - saftly. Then try it out in menage.
When you are leading her and she goes to pull you over to eat the grass. Is this happening when you turn her out or bring her in or probably both. Try putting the lead rope over her nose. If not working then lead her in and out with her bridle on. You can buy control halters for about £30 which are effective too. This will give you more control initially. So as she starts to learn more respect for you you will be able to eventually lead her in and out with head collar and lead rope. Could also be the time of year - mine are desperate for any blade of grass they seem to be able to get!!! I am having to lead my cob in and out with a chifney - something I really do not wish to do, but also aware that I need to be and feel safe - he also respects it and does not pull me off. But I am working on respect as well - so we are all still learning. I do know that once he is established in the summer grass fields he will settle down and brining in and out with headcollar / lead rope will be ok again.
Does your horse lunge at all. If she does, but you are not sure then get someone to give you some lessons. This helps horse see you are boss as well.
Ride her out with others, ride in your menage as well. My horse did exactly the same thing, so bit by bit I got further away from yard on each occasion, even if it was just a few yards. But eventually we got further and further. My horse hates going out alone, but I felt he needed to trust me enough to do that - now does. You are also still getting used to Gypsy, seeing how far you can push her before she reacts etc as well. Do you have lessons on her at all? May pay to have one of these a week - it will increase your confidence.
Other things like muck out around her in the stable if able to. Groom her as well.
Being able to spend time with her each day during the Easter break will do you both the world of good. Just do not expect too much too soon - its like getting to know a new friend.
Look for some books on Horse Psychology and behaviour. Also remember that horses prefer quiet matter of fact people around them, not flapping or getting frustrated and waving their hands around, nor shouting at them. A firm No is better than swearing and loosing your rag at them. Go and watch the horses in the field and see how they interact with each other. When looking for books if you can get to a place where a number are sold, look for ones that say what you want in language you can understand. There are loads on the market.
Don't forget to have fun - like getting to know a best friend again will always take time.
Good luck - you will get there, just give yourself time to adjust and her time to adapt to you.
 
You're gonna have to get TOUGH - in a respectful way. :)
She was testing you - but after two months, she's seen that you are lower down of the herd order, and is taking full advantage.

Although I can't think of book off-hand that will help you specifically (although, Kelly Marks 'Perfect Manners' is a great start, but nothing will fix this over night), I can give you a couple tips from what I've read.

When she plants her feet & wont be led in any direction, move from infront of her around to her shoulder at around 1m intervals. The further you move towards 90degree to her shoulder, the more off-balance she becomes. It's up to her to decide how off balance she wants to be, & hopefully you wont have to be at her shoulder.

Teach 'Back' (as per shirley). But I take the rope in hand, and as I ask for back, I push the rope into her chest, thus mimicking the use of reins. Don't expect her to back up by meters straight away. A great start for her would be to just shift her weight backwards. You can progress to steps the more you practice (but only do it about 3 or 4 times in a row, or she'll get bored, and march off to eat grass).

I don't think you'll need a control halter, and my horses lead worse in a bridle. My suggestion is: Rope Halter. As Parelli explains, broad webbing halters encourage a horse to lean against pressure because there's no incentive *not* to lean - the webbing spreads out the pressure, and dulls the signals coming from you. A rope halter, OTOH, is thinner (instantly giving a more direct signal to the horse) and has knots that act on pressure points. So when a horse leans on a rope halter, they think "ow - this isn't comfortable", and eventually (if dumb enough to keep leaning) "OW! This hurts!!".

Another thing to consider is the length of your rope. I always use a 12ft training rope when leading my difficult horses (infact every minute your horse can see you, you are training it in some way). The reason for this is that a) I get to be at a safe distance when I need to be, if I need to be, and still have hold of the horse, and b) I can move them on with a swing of the rope to drive the hind quarters. (and c) drive the horse away if I need to) The rope can be your 'tail', and horses use their tail in communication. By swinging it, you are say Oi!! Get out of my space!

Ok, I'm out of mind power to write, so I'll leave now for other people to rpley!! You might give Harry Hobbes a hoy - he's magic on all things of equine psychology.

Oh! one last thing. Instead of trying to decide which NH you want to follow, just grab one & if you don't like, try the next one. I started with a Kelly Marks book (GREAT Pics!!), but think parelli is in a more user friendly format (if a bit expensive).
 
Parelli is pricey but I have had far more success with that than any of the other methods. However for a good (cheap!) basis for ground work the exercises in the Kelly Marks book 'Perfect Manners' are very similar to the basic Parelli ones. However Rupert was like you describe but also very wary of people and spun round and round when being tacked up/mounted. Now he is lovely and can be led on a loose rope and tacked up/mounted without being held and that is after doing most of his level 1 Parelli.
 
I'm in the minority here in that I prefer the IH/Kelly Marks methods to Parelli. It's really a matter of what suits you and your horse though, there's nothing to stop you taking bits from different methods.

If you're not confident on the ground then get someone in to help you. I've had an RA (Recommended Associate) out to Saff and it's helped enormously. I'm seriously thinking about doing their courses (once I've got a job!). The good thing about RA's is that they don't just work with the horse, they involve you in it too. When ours comes to the yard we all hang around and join in with everyone else's session, it's great for your confidence and great for learning things that you wouldn't from just your session. I can't recommend them highly enough :D and they're NOT expensive! Ours solved Saffy's rearing in one session and even when we REALLY pushed her in my lesson on Tuesday (way past the point where she used to go up) all she did was fuss a bit (she does an on-the-spot canter) but then settled down again within seconds.

BTW contrary to popular opinion you DON'T need a round pen, our school is being extended at the moment so one end is 'open', it doesn't stop us from doing stuff in there!
 
Another vote for Perfect Manners, and if you can run to it for having a session with an RA to show you the exercises and give you some general advice. We are happy to shell out hundreds of pounds a year on people instructing us on top of a horse, so a small amount for the same on the ground isn't out of the way:)
 
We're definitely going to give 'Perfect Manners' a try. If it goes well we'll look into doing a workshop/seminar a bit later. If it doesn't go well, we'll have a re-think, but at least I've got a starting point now.

I've got hte afternoon with her on Wednesday, so I'm undecided as to what I'll do with her then. If I have the book we'll start having aplay with some of the stuff it says, otherwise I may try lunging with some supervision and see how it goes. We haven't done that yet, so it'll be interesting!

I thought about trying some long-reining, but I'm not sure if this is a good idea or not? She's been broken to harness a few years ago, but hasn't done anything like that for a couple of years now. I've never sone any long-reining, but my mum has and she'd be willing to help. Do you think I should try this as a way to get her listening to e and paying more attention, or leave it until we're a bit more established? Would you advise doing it in a manege or a field?
 
First of all, find as many books/articles on the subject and read them all back to front inside out - then pick and choose which bits will suit you and her. Don't think that you have to be too tough on her all the time - Ebby came be a right madam if she thinks she can get away with it, but sometimes it's just genuine fear that she doesn't want to do something. Like Entreat said - you are going to have to get tough, but in a nice way!

A woman at our yard has just moved her horse here, and she was having some leading issues down to the yard, and sometimes the horse wouldn't stand/move over properly when being groomed. After a couple of weeks of me, YO, her daughter and husband handling her, we've come to the conclusion that the horse doesn't respect her owner - but will for everyone else. It has got to be about the temperment of each of these people - I'm tough but in a nice way and am quick to praise, as is YO but who won't take any nonsense what-so-ever - the daughter is more in-charge of the horse and the husband is bigger than it (unlike the rest of us!). We have no problems leading said horse anywhere. The owner is very emotional, is slightly nervous and I think feels intimidated by the horse. She doesn't like to tell the horse what to do after asking it to politely (but then do any of us?) and isn't clear in her instructions. When leading from the field, horse will pull owner over to hedge, stop and reverse, won't budge etc. I come over, pull the head out of the hedge and say "NO" in a loud tone. Horse plods next to me not even thinking about eating. Same for YO and daughter. With the husband, horse comes down with her head down relaxed as anything.

I loved reading the Kelly Marks book (before sister took it back!), have the Parelli books as well as RM, MP etc etc, but to me the Mark Rashid books really explain everything in the simplest way possible. I find I take more in when reading it in the story way - and they are good books to refer back to (and read again and again!).

Next time Gypsy does stop when leading etc, broaden your shoulders, take up the rope a little mopre and ask her to walk on clearly. If nothing happens, pull a little on the rope. Keep looking up, and if nothing happens again, flick the rope at her hindquarters. Still no movement then mover her front end over and walk in a different direction, slowly circling into where you want to go.

Or, if she's really taking the mick, do what I do out on hacks - reverse her.
 
Last edited:
newrider.com