Different 'twist' in different width saddles?

Santi

New Member
Dec 11, 2005
207
0
0
Suffolk
Does the twist follow the width of the tree, i.e. narrow twist on a narrow tree - or can you have a narrow tree with a wide twist?

I have two 2nd hand saddles, one old passier dressage i bought from my teacher and an Albion K2 GP i bought a month ago from the local fitter/saddle dealer. The passier is lovely i can sit in it all day even though its hard and old but the K2 is killing me. I went out for a hack in it today and my bum is really sore!
I am sure its the twist because my partner is a cycling nut and drags me out on long rides and i cured my bum ache on the bike with a wider 'female' bike saddle. I'm pretty slim but i think my hips are quite wide.

There's a gap between the inside of my thighs and the saddle too -is that an indication of a poor fit for me? My knees ache from it a bit. I could just keep the saddle only for jumping and never hack in it but it seems a bit of a pity after spending all that money! it was still £800 2nd hand...

Should i ask my fitter to take it back and ask her to try and find me another one - my horse takes a narrow-med fit saddle so is that possible to get one of those with a wider twist??
 
Last edited:
twists on treed saddles seem to be a pretty standard width. If your bum is sore its usually because the saddle seat is hard.
try a seat saver, it should make it a bit more comfy for you:)
 
Doesn't surprise me with an Albion ;) ;)

How old is it?? If it's 20 years old or so bin it!
 
uncomfortable - twist on saddles?

The K2 is about 5 years old apparently - its in good condition. I didn't know Albion had a reputation for being uncomfortable!.....
 
Albion have a reputaion.......

I used to work there and was not happy with the way they were made.
 
uncomfortable brands...

Thanks - i think i will try and get them to take it back.

My horse doesn't fit a barnsby tree (very high narrow withers), the other saddle they push alot are the Harry Dabs - any opinion on that brand?

I was also looking at Excelle saddles but i haven't tried them on my horse, they sell those at the saddlery shop nearby.
I sat on a Passier Marcus Ehning (?) the one with the sythetic tree which was lovely - maybe i need to make the overdraft a bit bigger and buy a new saddle...:eek: don't tell OH...

any recommendations?
 
newrider.com