Critique

KateWooten

New Member
Sep 28, 2005
5,715
0
0
58
TN
This is theNewMare ... I've had her 8 weeks or so, but we haven't rushed her. We bought her cheap as a project. She's sturdy enough for my husband (a beginner) to ride... but has no brakes or steering. She's 10, and her breeding is unknown - probably QH x TWH but thank goodness, she's strictly walk/trot/canter. I first saw her in a jumping lesson, with a very experienced rider (who I personally don't think has a very good grasp of pressure-release, particularly with the hands)... Her history is that she was born and raised at the local hunter barn, and has been hunted for several years there. They were getting rid of her, because she throws her head around uncontrollably, grabs the bit and tears off. She only has two paces - stop, and go fast.

She's all over the place whenever she's with people. Nose is always thrust to the outside of the circle, finding things to spook at. She always has her own opinion of where we should go next ...and it's always opposite to mine. So, she's basically bolshy, sel-opinionated - pulls your arms off all the time. I've spent quite a while doing groundwork - not really to work on her paces, just to get her to soften and focus on me. Mostly she's been worked in just a rope halter.

The past three days, we've been concentrating on the ideas in Heather Moffet's 'Enlightened Equitation'. There's a lot in there about seat aids. I've had to put the nasty Wintec saddle back on theNewMare for now, while the treeless Fhoenix is on order.

I've had 3 rides on her with the pelham, rather than a snaffle. I'm really enjoying the pelham. I'd got her to the point in the snaffle, that she was quite light - not pulling. I've never felt she needed a 'stronger' bit - she braces against pressure, so obviously what she needed was to learn to 'give to pressure' - not a harsher bit which would just increase the pressure more, giving her more to brace against etc etc. Heather's use of the pelham is to maintain light contact via the snaffle rein, and to vibrate just fingertips against the curb rein to ask the horse to soften its jaw - releasing every time that softness is felt.

So, here's the first attempt. Bear in mind, I know nothing about dressage, except what I've leaned in books, so try not to rip me apart, but OTOH, I won't learn if you don't tell me !

Thanks
Kate

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Waox0wipWVA
 
I dont see much wrong actually. She certainly doesnt look too much like the horse you've described in the post. But, that could be down to your good training skills ;)

She's not steady in her balance, but that could be due to the ground being uneven too.

Stick with rising trot for awhile. Your hands will be steadier which will help her with her mouth problems.

Keep your leg in line. Remember for every second your body is out of balance (out of that ear, shoulder, hip, heel line) she must come out of balance to compensate for the change in gravity.

Stick with it. Retraining is just showing the horse that the cards have changed. One day she'll realize it and these will be things of the past.
 
I should have got a video of her antics earlier on - but I'm on my own most of the time, so no pics. She's taken forever to settle in, at first she was so aloof - I could catch her and manage her, but she was so distanced. I think she took the move from her old home really badly.

One thing I remembered late, was the '5 minute ride' ... the idea that if she puts in a real good effort for me, we stop right there and reward her. For a few of the first rides, I fell into the same trap as her old owners - they're primarily a riding school, and they tend to think in 'hour' rides. So she'd start stiff, we'd work through some stuff, get good, and then I'd ruin it by carrying on til she was stiff and grouchy again. The first time I got off her in the middle of a training session because she'd tried so hard, her big brown eyes were on stalks. The third time we did that, she changed completely. She wanted to be with me, started to be keen to be ridden, and her attitude under saddle just changed completely - that's why I was so pleased that my MIL turned up right then and videod her .. because apart from throwing her head in transitions ... all I can see in the clip is her trying, trying and more trying. I have to admit, I lost my heart big-time over this mare. 2 months ago, she was 'ok, it's a horse my husband can ride, and we can always sell her in the Spring' Yeah right. (yet again) .

Ok, so now yes, the ground is uneven - and damp there right now - I've pulled my two youngsters from doing anything other than a walk there - and Rosie not even that. The season is about over for us as regards footing. It's not so much slippery in the paddock, it's just too rough and rutted to be safe much longer.

Rising trot is something I really need to work at. I have a feeling that I'm so bad at it, that I slow the horse down until I can manage the trot, rather than improving me .. I might have slowed the little grey horse down too much already, so I'm a bit wary of it. I'll go practice. The day before, we were doing lots and lots of walk-trot transitions, staying in trot only a stride or two ... and after a few of them, theNewMare felt just amazing - totally soft, her back was like soft and springy, and since I've never felt this before, that was what I wanted pictures of, to see if what I was feeling was the magic 'rounded'ness and pushing from behind that we're aiming at. I don't think we quite caught that, because I was being tense for the camera - but I did like the look of her over-all.

I think I'm really struggling against the saddle to stay in balance - Tootsie, did you ever see the joseph video, where he's in the Fhoenix ? It certainly felt like I was able to sit much better in that saddle - my lower leg still flapped about a lot .. but the rest of me looked better ...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=123FA2Gos9M
 
Well, if your more comfy at sitting trot, then definately stay there. Whatever you can do to keep your hands super still will help her. I only advised rising because its usually easier for people.

She actually looks like a lovely ride! Credits to you!

I wont do it unsolicited, but if you want some help with the canter on Joe, I have a few things to add... ;) :D
 
Yes - please go ahead and think about joe and canter for me !

The story on that vid is this : about a year ago, joe was newly backed. He's a lovely willing boy, and I pushed him too hard. He happily cantered two 20 m circles for me, when I should have known better. The next day he (quite rightly) refused to go anywhere near the 'school' and asking him for canter resulted in pinned ears, bucking, bracing ... he gave me very clear signals poor boy. A year of chiro, saddle fitting, new saddle, backwork, only ever walking and trotting under saddle. Then 3 months of walk with stretching, combined with lunge-work and establishing a good canter cue from the ground. Eventually, we got to the point of being able to ask for canter again. That was 4 weeks ago, and just a week before he'd been entered to do a dressage test with 2 canter 20 m circles (shouldn't have been entered, I know, but there are only 2 shows a year, so it's better to enter and scratch, than to not enter). So, we learnt to canter oe week, and did our test the next .. and then the day after, this Fhoenix saddle arrived .. and I took him down there just to trot (which,if you've tried the Fhoenix, you'll know - it's so very different that you do have to spend a little time figuring out the trot!)

So .. there's the background ... I'm down there on this lovely - but very different - saddle, asking the 'I won't canter no way' pony to trot .. and ! LOL My trotting is so bad that he's straight into canter !

I'm kind of half-heartedly wanting him to slow down there, but laughing because he's so cute. I can see my lower leg flapping about like a windy flag, but .. one good thing, I thinky my butt stays in the saddle better than I thought.

So, yes, fire away - my main issues with it are my lower leg, and the fact that my hands are never even with each other -not working as a pair ... of, and my toes at right angles to the horse as always ...
 

Regarding the first video, top effort. That is just what anyone would wish to see from the type of horse you have described. She has a good rhythm, she is relaxed and definitely showing every development of a comfortable contact. Not a great contact, but I don't think anyone could expect more of her at this stage considering her background.

My one feeling on how things could continue to improve is to remember to ride the contact from the hindquarters rather than the bit. If you look at the action of her hindquarters around that last bend as her head starts to come up you can see that she looses her forward around the start of the bend well before she comes above the bit. When a horse is loosing forward momentum it is best in my opinion to give the bit if anything, improve the rhythm and impulsion first and only when those are right take up the contact again.

I know it's only a short clip which makes any critique seem picky, as this may have been a one off thing, but perhaps it will be useful to you anyway.

Cheers,
Shiny.
 
No No not at all picky ! Thanks :) That's exactly the sort of thing I'm hoping to pick up from you guys... it's really hard at the start not to ride just on the hands .. fortunately for me, I have 6 months of just western horsemanship style loose-rein training, so although I can't quite get my head to stop thinking about the front end all the time, at least my hands don't yet have dreadful heavy-handed hunter-jumper muscle memory

So, I need to think about the rhythm .. .well, more 'get into' the rhythm with her, and be very quick with the leg to push her on when she first starts to falter....

I'm going to catch her now to go play .. there'll be no video but there will be a report back later ...
 
Glad your having success with a pelham! I had a similar problem with the snaffle and recently put Gitcha in a pelham and he is collecting very well!
 
newrider.com