Critique! I need help!

BeachRiding

New Member
Aug 26, 2004
7,680
0
0
USA
I rode again today, I am finding my position appalling and it is really affecting my riding. Critique my faults and please tell me how to fix them. Be as harsh as you want.
Gitcha011004_0001.jpg


Gitcha011001_0001.jpg


Gitcha012001_0001.jpg


NICE.jpg


Gitcha012004_0001.jpg



It's killing me! How can I get my leg in the correct position?
 
Last edited:
you need to bring your whole leg back and down more -i've seen your other threads and you've recognised you have a chair seat.
some no stirrups work would really help. i would take my leg out of the stirrups (you can do this whilst in halt) and pull each leg back individually, turn your toes forward and pull your leg forward again to the "ideal" place. do this with your other leg. that should deepen your seat and improve your leg position.
your foot looks to be very through the stirrup, the above should help.
your hands vary in position - it looks like that is partly to do with whether your horse is spooking or not though. i would like to see more bend in your elbows in general but a bit like pic 1.
all things are connected and once you get one bit going better the rest will fal into place.
hope that helps :)
 
Faults i can see:

Need to put ball of foot on stirrup
Your shoulder's are slipping just slightly forwards in some pics - simple shoulder's back :p
Don't know whether this is a problem but you could do with your lower leg a bit further back

Overall, your both doing very well

Answer to your question work with out stirrups something i need to do a lot. It should be possible to draw a straight line from the shoulder to the hip to the foot of the rider. Although i my case i over do that line a lot :o How about a lunge lesson, so you can concentrate a little more on your lower leg? Make sure of your stirrup length. You can not achieve a balanced seat if your stirrups are too long or too short.
 
Work without stirrups to help strengthen your leg.

Also a lot of work in your two point it will help your overall balance. Another thing to do is stand straight up in your stirrups, bend slightly in your knee and you can bend slightly in your hips but the only way to stay standing is to get your leg under you it will help you get your center of balance and get your leg under you and solid. Riding around like that will really help.

while you ride try taking your shoulders and rolling them one at a time as you seem to be a bit stiff through your arms/shoulders. try to loosen up and move a bit up there. You would actually be surprised at how much more relaxed your horse gets as you let go with your body and loosen up.
 
Last edited:
That saddle needs to move about 3 inches further back - it's putting you in front of the movement which is what is making your leg come forward. Oyu can see that his nech appears to be coming out from between your legs, esp. Pic 1! If you put the stirrups on the balls of your feet that will help.
Once that's done, then work without stirrups will strengthen your position :)

There's nothing hideously wrong, don't worry! Your upper body looks good :)
 
Thanks everyone!

StormyJ- That's extremely helpful. Will see if it sorts out some of my leg position problems. I never used to ride in a chair seat until I started riding english. Hmph..


Anyone think I should lengthen or shorten my stirrups?
 
I agree with the others, stirrupless work, relax your shoulders a bit your shoulders being a bit forward is a confidence issue relaxing your shoulders will help your arms relax so you will have more bend in your elbow:) Your foot looks to be far to foward in the stirrup (I have a thing about that:o due to being dragged after a fall - I was still a beginner at the time but it was a lesson I learnt about having my foot too far forward in the stirrup). Otherwise I think you are doing Ok, you have come a long way in your riding from just a few short months ago when your confidence was at an all time low, keep up the good work and it will all fall into place:)

I would also put your stirrups down one hole and see how that works.

Just a thought WL what size saddle do you have? My daughter was riding in my Isabell Werth saddle, which the PC coach said did not fit her anyway the IW is definetly not the saddle for her as it was affecting her position. In her case pitching her forward which of course did not help with her confidence issues either. We changed saddle and her position has improved:)
 
Last edited:
I agree with the others, stirrupless work, relax your shoulders a bit your shoulders being a bit forward is a confidence issue relaxing your shoulders will help your arms relax so you will have more bend in your elbow:) Your foot looks to be far to foward in the stirrup (I have a thing about that:o due to being dragged after a fall - I was still a beginner at the time but it was a lesson I learnt about having my foot too far forward in the stirrup). Otherwise I think you are doing Ok, you have come a long way in your riding from just a few short months ago when your confidence was at an all time low, keep up the good work and it will all fall into place:)

I would also put your stirrups down one hole and see how that works.

Just a thought WL what size saddle do you have? My daughter was riding in my Isabell Werth saddle, which the PC coach said did not fit her anyway the IW is definetly not the saddle for her as it was affecting her position. In her case pitching her forward which of course did not help with her confidence issues either. We changed saddle and her position has improved:)

ECHO THAT!. Your upper body looks good as does your hands. I think your saddle is slightly far forward. Gitcha looks short coupled so you wouldn't want it much further back than it is really about an inch or two. try putting your stirrups down a few holes. Your knee looks to be past the saddle flaps which would make me say your stirrups are too short. Also check that your have enough legroom with the saddle. Other than that keep up the good work. The transition from western to english couldn't be easy and i admire you for trying i'd like to have the guts to try Lady western.:D :D
 
You have a wicked chair seat, likely brought on with the help of a western saddle with a very forward stirrup bar. You have as the others have said a lovely upper body.

Again I would say lengthen and ride without your stirrups to help you find a better position. How fit is Willie? He may be the better candidate for working on your position while not stressed about what may/may not happen - even if just to experiment with your leg.

Someone else has mentioned it.. but my dear your saddle is too small for you, and is not doing you any favours - by sitting so far up on your cantle like that, it's tipping you forward forcing you to brace with your feet, and causing you to "stand" more on your stirrups as in putting all your weight on them - pushing them forward.
 
Last edited:
Shadowlark- Willie is retired...can't even trot anymore with a rider as of last week.
Your very right about the western saddle bringing it on. My endurance western saddle that I used to ride in all the time has a too far forward stirrup bar.
As of saddle size, that's the biggest I can get (18"). Just have to loose weight. :o which I am working on.
 
Last edited:
well, they do come larger than 18, just not everyone makes them I have a friend who rides a 20.

Not sure what to suggest.. tricky spot your in you may actually be better off practicing english equitation in a western saddle until you either lose the weight of find a saddle that fits better. Sitting up that high on the cantle is going to be messing with the weight distribution of the saddle also and could potentially be related to the bucking issue.

I am sorry to hear about willie's retirement - he is a grand fellow.
 
Last edited:
Well I certainly know my parents won't buy me another saddle. I have no one to borrow off of either. Plus both my western saddles don't fit Gitcha.
 
yeah I figured as much.. it's never easy is it?

What about a high qualtiy bareback pad like the little joe one. It won't have all the qualties of a treed saddle oviously, however it may help with some of your problems. The endurance list is really high on it and a lot of people are now competeing in it as well as training in it. It may buy you some time, help to fix your position and eleminate preassure points caused by uneven distribution in the saddle.

Otherwise, ride stirrupless and make sure you are in the DEEPEST spot you can be in in that saddle at all times. It's no perfect solution - but as I well know sometimes you just have to do the best you can with what you have.


Went link digging

Little Joe pad
http://www.better-horsetack.com/lj/index.cfm?page=bbsdl
Independant review
http://nchorsenews.com/pdf/april-2007.pdf

I am planning on purchasing one as soon as we finish our move to ensure it gest shipped to the right place :) I wish I had it now so I could tell you exactly how I feel about it.. but everyone I do know who has one rave's over them and are leaving their other saddles collect dust.
 
Last edited:
WL am I right in thinking that you have just bought your saddle and that it is a Wintec?

The bareback pad sounds like a great alternative:D Thanks SL for the link, I have been trying to find a bareback pad with an option for stirrups without much success and I really like that one:)

It is the wintec saddle (IW is wintec) that my daughter has ridden in, I have two an gp one that is 17" and a IW which is 17.5" both of which are toooo small for my daughter however M rides in her 17" status (terrible brand of saddle but came with Mu)saddle that she uses for riding at home mainly and it fits her much much better and consequently her position has improved:) I have just bought her an 18" gp saddle off e-bay and that cost me AU$150, which I thought quite good, quality looks good so hopefully will be a good saddle for her:)
 
I always find that a good way to check my leg position is to remember the old "head, shoulder, hip, heel" thing I was taught when I learned to ride - i.e. you should be able to draw an imaginary vertical line down your body and all four of those should be in line.
 
newrider.com