Conformation colouring judgement

carthorse

Super Moderator
Jan 6, 2006
13,805
8,551
113
Do you think how a horse is put together has an effect on how people view them overall?

Luka has a big neck (gelded late plus breeding) that is set very high. Even when relaxed he stands very up, when he's wound up he positively towers since his neck is also a lot longer than it looks. His breeding and conformation mean he's also naturally quite high stepping, with a big overtrack. I fairness I will add that he's the sort that doesn't miss anything, he may not react to it but he doesn't miss it and it's clear that he's always on the lookout. It seems to me that so many people look at his build and movement and assume he must be a handful to ride and handle, I had a woman say as much to me the other day when he'd patiently waited for nearly five minutes while she'd tried to get hold of her dog - short of laying down and having a nap I don't know how he could have been less of a handful! People just seem to associate the high carriage and step with him being on the point of exploding and not look at him and see it's physically how he is. Likewise I have a friend who had a horse that was built running onto it's shoulders and had a very flat action, people tended to assume it was quiet and trustworthy yet I knew that horse couldn't be trusted because it would spin and tank off at the slightest excuse - the slightly sleepy tired look was a complete con.

By the way I'm not claiming Luka is a candidate for sainthood or a horse I'd put a less than competent sensitive rider on, but I find it interesting how many people make a snap judgement on him even when he's quietly going about his job on a long rein. And it's quiet and I thought a discussion type thread may liven things up!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrC
People do make a snap judgements when they meet a person for the first time, so it's going to happen with horses isn't it.
I suppose people might look at mine and think she's a lazy slow plod, yes I suppose she is on the whole if you don't ask you don't get and she will just amble along.
But she's got some antics I think @Jane&Ziggy called them.
Possibly they are known as quirks, she's no push over.
I know when I arrive I will be verbally greeted and she will approach, but occasionally you will get those head tosses that convey something, usually annoyance at something, usually me! 🙄

The second view is I bet she's as comfy an armchair. We've discussed the bareback aspect, that's called slip, slide and too wide. 😂

Then I get is she blind, or oh she's got different eyes. I think if I had a £1 for each comment, I would have enough to get her some contact lens 😂 or an eye patch.
However my first judgement on being told she had a blue eye wasnt a good one. I didn't know if I would like it being that she's solid a colour.
 
I don’t think there’s any question that people judge based on conformation and body language, it’s an evolutionary safety practice.

Many a person who saw me riding Jess thought she was a plod and didn’t care about anything, little did they realise she was sharp at a tac and ready to go at the slightest hint that I wasn’t there in the moment and and had the situation assessed.
She is low set, low stepping, ridden on a loose rein mostly, so people assume that is her nature. They don’t realise that she was trained for years to appear relaxed.
My now farrier, I met as he brought his wife to rides I organised, after 50 years breeding and handling horses he’s not a bad judge of character, but even he assumed Jess was angelic, until he came to top my field for me and Jess got defensive against the tractor, he saw her other side and was really surprised by it. He’s seen it many times since, when she looks fine to the uninitiated eye, but I’ve read her subtle tells and she explodes the moment I turn her loose.

Niko is the more upright, bigger action, with slightly wild eyes and prone to snorting a lot, but he’s not nearly as sharp as Jess to ride or handle. Not that he’s not sharp, he can be, but there’s not a nasty bone in him, and he is learning to control his anxiety posture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
Yes, people definitely judge based on appearance and make judgements quickly. I learned in my consulting days that we generally form a judgement about another person within the first 30 seconds of meeting them, and I expect it's not that much longer for someone to form a view on a horse.

So people see Sid - patchy, wide, hairy - and assume he is a plod and a typical Gypsy cob, unreactive and not bothered by anything. The trainer at the polework clinics says of him that his looks are deceiving, as he is actually really up for it, keen, energetic, and all sorts of other good things. He is also really looky (I think like Luka), always aware of everything.

When you're training someone to do recruitment interviews, part of the training is to get them to become aware of their initial judgement and to spend the interview trying to disprove that judgement. Human nature is to look for evidence to support your initial judgement. I suspect that experienced horse people do the same.
 
Definitely with Sapphire being 17'1 and very very tall at the front, as i said to the vet when she was out looking at the wound on Friday, if she had been 15hh I would probably have had the confidence to deal myself with the napping issues but because of her size I called in help after the first major strop as didn't want it to escalate. She is extremely good looking and knows it but is also the most filthy horse i have ever had, always utterly covered in mud, manure, totally clarty
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jane&Ziggy
I think it's more to do with his aura than conformation, but I was constantly surprised at the yard how many people were wary of Raf, and he's the gentlest least aggressive horse in the world. He does have a look that I think of as imperious, and he is a little bit stand offish with people he doesn't know . Some people were obviously seeing that as threatening, but nothing could be further from the truth. It wasn't until one lady told me why she was scared of him that I realised his reserved attitude was off-putting to some people. And I suppose if they were a bit scared of him he will have immediately picked up on it and been even less confident about them.
 
@Bodshi, that sounds like Luka, and imperious is an excellent word for it. Combined with an up on his toes carriage and upright conformation I can see how it gives a false impression but it still amazes me how many people judge by look rather than what he does. Interestingly it's often horsey people who comment on him looking a handful etc while non-horsey ones see a kind eye and, on the ground a mummy's boy. Maybe being none horsey they look at actions more, and fall for the big white blaze.

@Jane&Ziggy the horse I was referring to was a coloured cob too. He was usually ok as long as everything went his way and required minimal effort, if it didn't he was hellish.
 
Definitely, I remember one of the liveries at a previous yard being amazed that Belle ‘could turn on a sixpence’ and that she was ‘flippin quick!’ Yes she looks fat and lazy, but she’s more than capable of a quick whizz and yes sharp turns are her thing. She’d be great at pony club games. 🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
@Bodshi there was an Arab gelding on the yard when I was sharing, he was much like your beautiful Raf, he’d have that Imperious look about him and quite a few people didn’t like him, but he was honestly just a sweetheart once you made the effort to say hello. I used to ride out on my share with him and his owner sometimes and he was a very ‘places to go, people to see’ kind of jiggy joggy boy, like his feet just couldn’t stop moving, even if we stood waiting for traffic so we could cross a road he jogged on the spot, lots of folk wouldn’t ride out with him because they thought he must have been nervous and spooky but he was as solid as they come, he just used to appear ‘busy’ and distracted.
 
I find horses with the action and looky fantastic for photo opportunities. It's what the judges call the wow factor, look at me move and express myself.
The times mine has had people stop and look at us, it's not the same feeling!!
If they get their camera out, I usually want to slip away slowly 😂

She used to pursue anyone coming into the field when she was younger. The nervous people were fair game. She made friends with the horse I was told to watch out for. Great! So trying to get her in and correct her, I had a broodmare checking me out, protecting her!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: carthorse
I've had people video him trotting up the high street, and ask if he's a film horse in Downton Abbey (filmed not far from us) - it's all because of the showy action. Time was the trot took a lot of containing because he was stressed and wanted to get everything over and done with, now he'll strut his stuff, stop to chat, and trot away again basking in the admiration :D
 
  • Love
Reactions: Jane&Ziggy
They do tend to use horses with more carriage and action for those types of films.
Mine would be at home doing scenes for Follyfoot 😁

Eta.
I do get some ask me if I am backing her / is she young if they see me lunging or long reining.
No idea what they think of if I am on board 😂
 
Last edited:
There is an instructor I used to use. She then taught the girl who rode Robin. As Robin is a warmblood. She immediately classed him as a “dumb blood” and therefore useless. He would never amount to anything (even tho he had already proved he was very useful). They had a xc training session. She turned to me “will it jump the ditch?” “Yes, if rider wants to”. She was very peeved when he popped over no problem.

A couple of years later she was at my yard. I asked how she was etc. she then asked if I still had that bay thing.

He never put a foot wrong the entire time she was teaching him yet he was classed as a dumb blood and useless.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Jane&Ziggy
Flipping heck @Doodle92 , warmbloods have pretty much taken over the higher end of dressage, showjumping, and eventing - what planet is that instructor on?
 
I did have someone tell me to get a proper horse when I got the cob.
I think sometimes people are negative towards you or your horse if they are jealous?
That's what I got told anyway in this case, they were jealous of what we were doing because they were struggling with theirs.

When someone says warmblood to me, I think wide awake, walk away I won't be able to manage. I wouldn't be compatible with anything over 15hh, the horse will block the views I am trying to take the photos of 😂
 
My thinking now is she is so used to pc and teaching ponies she just didn’t know what to teach as he was doing everything asked without a fault. That xc schooling session she also criticised his over reach boots!
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
She used to be very good. She was invaluable when I had soli. She is great with kids and ponies now just not so great when that kid moves on to a horse 😂
 
@Doodle92 she doesn't sound like she should be teaching.

@newforest Luka' barely 15hh but I bet his neck would block your views.
😂
Possibly if he's looking at things.

And I would walk away from that instructor, no excuse to critique without offering a positive suggestion.
My ex instructor used to comment on other horses that she wasn't even teaching and she became an embarrassement.
She was also incapable of listening to yard rules of dogs on leads! My yard isn't for you to exercise your dogs unsupervised.
 
newrider.com