Clinton Anderson

G'day all,
Any long term members of this forum will know we have a problem with the clinton anderson juggernaut.

I’ve been here since 2002 and I’m afraid couldn’t find anything in the search function, nor have I seen any threads about him before

Clinton was challenged in 2003 about statements that the extra knots on his halters were positioned on pressure points. We asked a simple question, as pressure points are all known and named, can he tell us what points are stimulated by these extra knots, the meridians they stimulate and what organs are effected. All these questions can be answered by any person that stimulates pressure points. In reply clinton admitted he knows nothing about pressure points but knows the extra knots get results and he will sue us if we dont stop publically questioning his techniques !!!
Of course the extra noseband knots get a response from the horse, these halter noseband knots compress delicate nasal tissue between knot and bone. Most people call this pain, and all reputable trainers will tell you that pain is a poor motivator.

Another clinton technique that appears barbaric to modern horse trainers is the 'choke out' that clintom took from the Jeffery Method. Even the parellis ommitted this technique from their training system that took so much from the aussie horseman.

No doubt clinton has many followers, we are just not among them and are embarrassed that he is considered a representative of horsemanship downunder, our horsemanship is miles from clintons....and we object strongly to any comparison. We do not terrify, flood or hurt our horses during training.

cheers all
Rob

Anywhere I can read up on this ?
When you say ‘we’ what is it that you practice?


It is impressive for a young horse to tolerate chainsaws, stock whips, hand guns and snow blowers after just an hours work, but does it produce a horse that can be handled the next day?
have a look at the 2nd & 3rd whisper challenges, Clinton Anderson floods the horses, chokes one with the Jeffery 'magic rope' and ends up with a horse that could only be ridden by someone with CA's riding/rodeo ability, then look at the calm horse Josh Lyons finished with...
As for the showman stunts performed by CA while other trainers were trying to work with their horses...this was inconsiderate and/or bad sportsmanship, especially when CA talked about kangaroo shooting from horseback, despite what may be commonly thought, all kangaroos in Australia are fully protected by the relevant Wildlife Acts in each state and has penalities of up to $100,000 and 10 years in jail for the illegal killing of kangaroos.

Still raving on...sorry about that.
We are no experts, far from it, but we work to teach our horses to give desired responses to specific cues, calmly and thoughtfully as we do not want reactive horses.
The best way to end up with a non reactive horse is not to teach it to react by flooding, force or pain.


Chokes? Something I haven’t yet witnessed.

To be honest a lot of what you write I haven’t yet experienced first hand or heard of before. As I said I have started watching him on rural TV and have not witnessed anything that’s been mentioned so far – but only watched 4 episodes.
 
I havent seen any of that either Nookster - but I've only seen the odd youtube video. I would be interested in hearing more after that.

I have to say that Shane Ransley talks about phase 4 being your equivalent of "teeth". The theory being if your horse has ignored 1,2 and 3, phase 4 would be likened to the nip that another horse would give - short and sharp but quite decisive.

My problem was that I wasnt clear enough about 1 to 3 and was going straight to a 4 which was confusing Arnie. Once Shane showed me it became so much more obvious. Personally, it taught me that I couldnt learn purely from a book or video - I needed to see it in action to understand. I think this is a major problem with nh. People just dont really know what they are aiming for. Its not totally fluffy bunny but it should be crystal clear to the horse if its done correctly.
 
Hi Nookster
It is almost 2 am here in OZ, I have been making rope gear since 8am, I am a litle bleary eyed so i hope my reply makes sense :)

1. I dont have a list of all my previous posts on CA but I do have one from 2007 when Chilli and i posted (read as argued to a standstill) about clinton & aspects of the jeffery method.... this thread also contains some links to info on the jeffery method or google it as there is a lot of info online.
http://www.newrider.com/forum/showthread.php?t=123127
2. Sorry, the use of 'we' is a habit as most of my time online is answering email an the 'we' represents Sharon & I and our business LodgeRopes.
We began with parelli in the early 90's but drifted off after becomming interested in round yard techniques and general approach of other clinicians such as John Lyons & mark Rashid.
Today we support anyone who is offering a better deal for horses & riders, just more for some than others. We do not condone any method or technique that puts the horse or rider in danger or uses pain, intimidation or force as a motivator.

3. the 'choke out' is a compontent of the jeffery method...
I must point out that this technique was intended to be used on wild horses not domesticated stock (as I understand from written material) It was a part of a system that was, in the early years of the last century, a better deal for horses compared to the methods commonly used at the time.
This is fairly well covered in the NR thread link I posted above.

4.The jeffery method has some great techniques. Kel jeffery laid out the principles of 'approach & retreat' for desensitising a horse, a technique that is now commonplace in many styles of training/starting horses.

Finally, i readily acknowledge what a great rider CA is, and many of his training techniques will help a lot of people....BUT there are aspects we do not use as other trainers offer an alternative that works for us, others we wouldnt use as they contradict what Sharon & i want with our horses and there are some techniques we actively oppose and will continue to oppose them and anyone who uses them. I offer a different opinion, thats all.

Hope that covers everything, have a read up on the jeffery method, it is good reading, but watch how clinicians apply pressure.. do they get a reaction or a response? have a good look at the horse they are working on, is it relaxed/calm/responsive or terrified/nervous/reactive during & at the end of the training session?.

cheers
Rob
 
Last edited:
newrider.com