Catching problems (again!!)

Moving him around and not letting him eat isn't really an option because when he gets into this mood he just wants to run anyway. The field is 20 acres so it would take a very fit handler to keep chasing after him. He literally canters in big circles round the staff and treats it all like a game. It's frustrating!!!

Mmm, I can see your difficulty! If he gallops away to the other end of a 20 acre field he's going to get quite a lot of grazing in (or whatever he wants to do) before the human has caught him up enough to move him on! I wonder if it really is a game to him?

On reflection I think I like Jessie's idea of the whistle best! Maybe try it in the school first?
 
You could clicker train him to come to a whistle anyway. I find a gesture helps too for high winds. I pat my thigh when I want Ziggy to come and he has learned to come trotting for a treat.
 
I have an old gundog whistle and by chance I used the same recall whistle pattern on it (3 short blasts) to teach both boys to come to call, within days they got it.

Mine has 95% of the time come trotting for a treat, I don't always have one as he can start to mug you.

If you get a spare hour or two and he's out I'd leave him out and walk out to him 'Hello Ben - nice day', give him a polo / peice of carrot, smooth stroke and walk away. Walk around the field, suddenly find trees or the view interesting whilst ignoring him.

I'd do it a few times, as ours lived out they are used to us visiting them in the field and it not meaning they are coming in, but they always walked over to greet us on the off chance we might have had a high value sweetie for them.

If using bribery as well, I'd eventually move to leadrope snapped on THEN treat is given. Giving food before hand teaches them to get quicker and sharper before buggering off, he gets a mouthful and takes off, he's had his reward then and gets to flick a V sign your way as he runs off thinking 'I've had my treat thanks!'

I can totally relate to not being able to keep chasing them, my husbands horse went through a phase of 'Ha ! Catch me if you can !' and he was on 35 acres so no chance is getting him caught / keep him moving, my husband equalled work to him but I was the person who sometimes had mints and gave him a groom never any work. So for a week or two only I could catch him ! Good luck with it.
 
I went through this same situation with my "perfect horse" when we moved liveries. He used to whinny every day to me unit we moved and he realised the new place was such paradise that he no longer needed me:(. I was delighted that the was happy but crest fallen when he decided he didn't want to be caught. My RI gave me some tips too always mix things up when catching him, like sometimes just pet him and go away, spend time with him without taking him out of the field, put head collar on then just take it off again without asking anything from him, bring him in without always riding, put feed just outside of his field and take him out to it then let him go back in etc. etc. I found this really difficult as I travel 35km to the livery and not being able to ride when I got there wasn't my ideal but it did work.
This prob won't help your livery staff to catch him but to be honest if they can't put in the same efforts as you there they're pretty much leaving themselves stuck by choice.
Sometimes the best we can do is retrain them and pass on the method to the staff, if they can't follow that then at least you've done your best & more importantly repaired your own relationship with Ben.
 
So today I got to the yard to take Ben showjumping. I did allow an extra 15 minutes to catch him. I walked very quietly up to him and within 10 metres he said 'no thanks' and cantered some circles around me. I remained calm, just stood there and then approached him again and he did the same thing. After about 5 minutes to quietly walking I am not proud to say that I completely lost my temper with him. I swung the leadrope round and really made him move around. This resulted in not only him, but all the horses going for a nice long gallop round the field. I kept this up for 15 more minutes and wouldn't let him rest, he kept moving away from me, making no attempt to graze and was very happy to keep running around. I called him some very bad names and I really did get cross with him, and very upset.

I started to feel a little vulnerable with hooves so close to my head so went back to get my hat. I was very angry with him and my riding instructor made me sit down and calm down. She then walked straight up to him and caught him!!! It took her 2 years to be able to touch him in the field, and I don't understand why she is now in favour and I am out.

We went out in the lorry to a jumping show and he was 100% perfect. He was so perfectly behaved and as it was a busy show and he has been bouncy to ride recently, it felt like he was making it up to me.

I need to get over being upset that I feel he is rejecting me and will deal with the job in hand of catching him tomorrow. My RI said that chasing him round is not the right thing for him, and the best way is just to be quiet and patient. Plus apparently making a fuss of other horses normally has him coming over to investigate. She says I just need to accept this part of his personality and that on the yard we all work as a team and to ask for help if he won't come in for me. She says that all horses will test from time to time and that is all he is doing and it will most probably be short lived.

I do feel very upset and rejected though. I feel like after being perfect to catch for 3.5 years, he has suddenly decided that he doesn't want to be with me anymore. Bloody horse!
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
After about 5 minutes to quietly walking I am not proud to say that I completely lost my temper with him.
Bloody horse!

MP I really do feel for you but this did make me LOL! Only because I've been right there myself doing exactly the same thing, swearing and all!!
You will find a solution I'm sure. Sometimes it just takes a while for the "bl***y horse" to tell us what it is though;)
 
Reading the replies what comes over is the staff are accidentally teaching him not to be caught. If he runs off and they don't have time to follow it up, what they have started then is in effect saying that's what we want. Do they need to catch him at all?

I have helped people who can't catch their horses and my only need is that they bring me refreshments. If it takes three hours so be it, it takes less time the day after that.

Have you tried catching and letting go, walk off return and repeat it.

Mine sometimes comes to call and a whistle. The whistle I use for other things so she knows what that sound means. If you have a large field you may want to buy one and be prepared for other horses to twig onto the whistle as well.
I don't use any form of treat to bring in, she knows she gets a teeny piece of carrot to stick her supplement to, but not for coming in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gimp and Kite_Rider
He probably allowed himself to be caught because you made him run! Cantering round in big circles for fun is one thing, being assertively driven away by someone is quite another, I think you did the right thing personally but obviously your YO knows him better so I can see why you feel stuck. Did she explain why keeping him moving is not right for him? It strikes me as perfectly appropriate for a mickey taking horse!
 
Reading the replies what comes over is the staff are accidentally teaching him not to be caught. If he runs off and they don't have time to follow it up, what they have started then is in effect saying that's what we want.

Totally agree. Evasiveness is very effective for him so is being strongly reinforced. The option of sticking 2 hooves up at people and being allowed to go back to grazing and playing with his friends should never be available or of course he will start trying to actively choose that.
 
Moet is a tricky horse to catch if in a big field. Even in a small field she is apprehensive. I always have to trick her a little bit (fake treat give, occasionally actually treat give) one of the things I do if she does walk away is turn and fuss Rosie instead then she comes to find out why!

I've tried the chasing her away and if I'm honest it never worked well for her, it made her more nervous of me (she ultimately is a timid horse, whereas I know Ben isn't by the sounds of it)

When they got out of the paddock twice Over the winter no-one else could catch Moet at all, eventually I had to drive up and catch her (she came to me so it was easy). On one hand that makes me confident she won't get stolen, but it worries me if they ever escape and are in danger
 
My RI thinks that he is actually quite a nervous horse, although he doesn't display this when he is ridden. She thinks that if I chase him around then he will just become impossible for me to get anywhere near as they have tried this with him and it made him worse. I don't think that there are any quick fixes because he has been like this since he arrived on his previous yard aged 3 (he is now 11). I do need the yard staff to catch him because I can't always get down in the morning due to children and work. He is muzzled in the summer and needs a break from this to have some hay, and in the winter we don't put hay out in the field so he has to come in for his hay then as well. I can't dictate to the yard staff how they deal with him and do their job and I don't know what to tell them anyway. They are a great bunch of people and have tried lots of different things, at the end of the day they have accepted that this is a quirk which they have to work round.

Every April he does something to test me. In previous years this has included planting himself and not moving, last year he suddenly started spooking at everything. This year he has been energetic to ride, but has not been naughty. I do think that it's down to the spring grass and I am hoping that if I am calm and consistent he will get over it and let me catch him again. I am surprised how upset I feel about it and just how angry I got with him. I was always so very proud that he was never naughty for me to catch and now I can't say that anymore. I need to stop getting so emotional and feeling rejected and just get on with it. Tomorrow is another day and all that.
 
I really can feel like rejection can't it, but given he isn't just tanking to the other end of the field, more just toying with you by cantering round you, try to think of it that in his eyes he's just having a game with you, not that he is rejecting you :) I'm sure he will settle back down soon
 
I take things terribly to heart too when things go wrong with my horses. But I also recognise that horses are just being horses. And I do try to take a step back and get take the emotion out of the situation. Much easier said than done though. Cally planted today on her way in which is a behaviour that I find particularly frustrating and I lost my temper with her too and became very assertive, basically pulling her off balance to get her feet moving, then backing her and moving her in circles rapidly. All fine in terms of getting her moving again, but just done in an unnecessarily adversarial mood with 'I am bloody annoyed with you' body language which probably wasn't helpful and certainly wasn't necessary. Oops. But we are only human and I'm sure once the excitement of FRESH GREEN GRASS as subsided they'll all be a little more biddable. I am so glad my horses are in a huge field with good friends (as is Ben) but it does mean that the charms of our company can't really compete with the life of leisured ease they have the rest of the time! At least stabled horses are pleased to see their owners!! (Not that I would ever trade their well-being for MY need to be liked).
 
Last edited:
I swear at Maisie - My language is appalling. Plus like KP, I am Rashid educated.
A horse is a horse and knows how to be a horse. They are hard wired genetically to maximise food input and conserve energy output. But need to take their work seriously to earn their keep. I also cant help thinking that your being cross with Ben, Mary P, and swinging your rope (yes I have done both) probably contributed to Ben's good behaviour with you out jumping just after.
We are animals - just as much as horses are and the fact that we get cross at one thng one day doesnt mean we have to react like that every time. When Maisie was kicking out on Saturday, I wasnt sure that leading her up and down the yard NH style would prevent her - I stood there absolutely still -tryng to think things out and after quite some time she shifted her weight and lifted her foot . Rashid always says that just waiting for horses to think things out is very important, but in my case, I always wait a ridiculous length of time without any certainty that the horse is going to behave.
The horse behaving is not a signal that they like me - Just a signal that any human is cleverer than the average horse. When people say a horse loves you, as they say Maisie really loves me, what they mean is that the horse is used to one - so settles well with one's behaviour. Ben knows you best and it wont hurt for him to know you are an animal that sometimes gets cross or swings a rope.
 
Thank you for all the kind words. I went to get him in today and he turned to run when he saw me. I ignored him, gave his friend a scratch and a polo, and then walked to his other friend and made a big fuss of him. I then opened the packet of polos, took one out and ate it myself. He then walked over begging for one. I didn't actually catch him to start with, I ignored him and looked at my phone for a few minutes, and when I couldn't take his longing eyes anymore I gave in and he had the polo and I clipped the leadrope on. We then had a very long grooming session and a very quiet hack over the fields. I have forgiven him for being naughty and hopefully this might be the end of it now. This was exactly what my RI advised me to do, and it did work far better than the chasing.

Looking back it must have been a very funny sight yesterday. I was swinging the rope around my head shouting "If you want to *****ing run, then you can ****ing run all ****ing day and never ****ing stop" etc. etc. The yard were watching me from a distance and thought that I had lost my mind! I haven't been so angry for a long time and don't want to be again.

On the positive side, he was again a complete angel to ride today. We hacked over the xc fields that have recently been opened up to grow hay and he was perfect. Maybe it was as a reaction to me getting so angry with him, maybe not. I really wish he could talk sometimes.
 
If it were me and this was becoming a constant then he'd be going into a smaller paddock. Kia goes through phases of not wanting caught and Ive seen myself wandering back and forth across 10acres just chasing him until he gives up. I never give up and leave until he is leaving with me.
 
I am very pleased too -Why werent you banned from the yard for bad language? I was once.

However in case other people are reading this -
You have to take care when swinging a rope or bridle when close to a horse (e.g. if a horse is snapping at you when tacking up) as you dont want to accidentally injure the eye of the horse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
While I am not normally a user of bad language, the others are and I doubt anyone was offended. They found it really funny. Since having my children I 'gosh' at everything but yesterday I just couldn't hold it in. I am seeing the funny side now.

When swinging a rope you also have to be careful of horses kicking out. Ben was bucking and broncing right next to me and I didn't initially have my hat on. I did start to feel vulnerable and that's when I went back to the yard.
 
newrider.com