Catching problems (again!!)

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
So my lovely Ben has always gone slightly loopy with the spring grass and has always been quirky for the yard staff to catch. However since he has gone out to the summer grazing he has been worse than ever to catch. Yesterday the staff went to get him (on their 3rd attempt) and he ran straight through the electric fence to get away from them. It's not like he doesn't know the staff, they have all worked there since we joined the yard over 3 years ago and he really cannot use the excuse that he is wary of them. They have all made a huge effort to spend time with him, feed him treats etc. and try to be his friend. None of them are heavy handed etc.

He has always been 100% for me to catch him, but today he ran away from me, circled me in canter with a glint in his eye before going over to someone else who happened to be catching their horse and standing still next to them. This made me quite sad actually as I always had a romantic vision that he would always come in for me. It made me feel like he was sticking two fingers up at me.

He is muzzled in the field (stays out for 18 hours overnight) and he comes in for 5-6 hours of stable time and a big haynet (although soaked!) so you would have thought that he would want to come in, it's not like he is ridden straight away as he normally has his hay first. He is the fittest and lightest he has ever been (now down to 530kg) and obviously feeling good about himself.

I don't want him running through electric fencing, it's dangerous and could cause injury. I just want him to stop running away from the yard staff, and not to start running away from me. I am on assisted DIY livery and one of the stipulations was that they wouldn't spend all day trying to catch him. They are getting cross with him and so am I.

Any ideas on how to get him to change his lifetime habit and let other people catch him?
 
Totally empathise, I spent a good percentage of my teenager years in the field trying to catch my 14.1hh mare, in summer she was ten times worse and would only be caught when out alone. Infact if left totally alone she would jump over the gate and come back to the yard. It was a complete nightmare, sorry I have no solution but mine was in her own tiny elec fenced paddock, so at least I wasn't walking miles in vain.x
 
I feel for you, I used to have one that was a pain to catch unless I got all of his mates in first, pigging nightmare! Jess is normally really good but even she gave me the run around for 20 mins today. Perhaps finding another (low cal) treat to give Ben when he comes might pursuade him? I'm sure you've tried it before though
 
Ah i was chasing may around last night when she got on to a rested bit of field im afraid i went after her so she couldnt eat or anything when she ran off and soon she was back in the right side looking sheepish but appreciate its not an option if he runs through the fence! Does he come in for a treat? I used a fibre nut or 1/4 carrot for the new boy which ive stopped now but i didnt want him churning up the field in the winter when he didnt want to be caught. Might help break the cycle/habit and you can stop again? Carrots are easier for him to see....
 
So when he was running away was he muzzled at the time or without the muzzle?

yes I wondered that too.

I would do similar to what Juliecwuk suggested. I have been known to keep a horse or pony moving around a field for up to two hours. Time consuming and laborious but I have cured a couple of difficult to catch ones that way. Occasionally you might need to spend 15 minutes or so reminding them who moves their feet and who says when they can graze, but I have always found this method works with the very difficult ones.

Just a thought, and I am sure you have thought of this, but you don't always jut get him in to ride do you? I have seen many horses turn into non catchers if the only thing they associate with being caught is work. If by any chance this is the case, then I would spend a good few days mixing it up...a lot of fuss and treats but no work when he comes in...and then gradually add a ride into the mix as he changes his attitude.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
Ah i was chasing may around last night when she got on to a rested bit of field im afraid i went after her so she couldnt eat or anything when she ran off and soon she was back in the right side looking sheepish but appreciate its not an option if he runs through the fence!

This is how my friend catches her horse when he's being difficult - only happens rarely but when it does she walks after him with a twirling lead rope (and some very choice swear words), just keeps moving him so he can't eat and can't get back to his friend and pretty soon he's running around her asking to come back in. He won't go through the electric fence though, just cavorts around and refuses to be caught.
 
He was wearing his muzzle when he went through the fence, and was wearing it today as well.

I always catch him with a small handful of feed. It's the only feed he ever gets and I give it to him as soon as we get out of the gate. The yard staff normally bring a half full feed scoop out, but he is an expert at taking a mouthful of feed and then spinning away the split second before the leadrope is attached to his headcollar. If the staff try to hold onto his headcollar with their hand he will pull back and run away.

When I catch him in it is normally to ride him first but I don't normally have a problem catching him (I am hoping today was a one off!). When the yard catch him for me he goes straight into his stable with a full haynet in it, so it's not like he is associating being caught with being worked. He also isn't always tricky - sometimes he will decide that he wants the staff to catch him and will walk straight up to them. The spring grass is definitely tempting him to stay out but he will refuse to be caught at random times of the year as well, there doesn't seem to be much logic to it.

He was like this in his previous home as well. The yard manager where he was kept warned me that his one and only vice was being caught by multiple people. He is very much a one person horse and ever since he was 3 years old he has proved tricky for yard staff to catch (he is now 11).

Moving him around and not letting him eat isn't really an option because when he gets into this mood he just wants to run anyway. The field is 20 acres so it would take a very fit handler to keep chasing after him. He literally canters in big circles round the staff and treats it all like a game. It's frustrating!!!
 
I have also successfully caught horses by making them work very hard when they won't be caught. Basically I approach politely but the moment they move off I get assertive and keep them walking or trotting with a twirling rope. Every few minutes I will offer them the option of being caught again and if not back to work they go. Obviously not for a wary horse but for a horse who is choosing to ignore me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
The staff have told me that he sometimes will do his merry cantering away and they leave him, and then 10 minutes later he will come over to the gate and ask to come in. There is no logic to it though, sometimes he just has to stay out until I get there because they simply can't catch him. I would love to know what is going through his head. He is the quietest horse to ride and my instructor said that sometimes very sensible horses under saddle can show their wild side in a different way. She thinks that he is just expressing his opinion and I should be pleased that he chooses to do this when I am not sat on him. I know that I shouldn't take it personally, but I was really upset when he ran away from me today. I always liked to think that he wanted to be with me.
 
There is a long description of catching a horse Monty Robert style in the book Whispering Back. You need all day tho. Mark Rashid did it far more quickly at a demo two years ago but in quite a small enclosure. The theory behind both was the same, not to allow the horse to rest or stand. Allowing the horse to rest was the reward for not moving away from the catcher. Even tho Mark might not at that point be up close to the horse. And would turn aside to take off the pressure.
This is not something I have done as both my share and Maisie are easy to catch. Today Maisie simply continued grazing till I put my arm over her neck - quite weird. But one thing I picked up from Richard Maxwell was to approach obliquely. That has become my habit. Rashid did not do that at all. However all trainers are uniform in making not being caught harder work for the horse and absolutely preventing any grazing. And in all cases the people doing the catching were not the owners.
So more detached and just doing their job.
Do you have any idea why Ben went and stood by another owner? Had she been treating him?
 
I know from previous posts MP how you feel proud that Ben has always let you catch him. It must be a real blow that he was naughty with you today, I am sorry to hear it.

I agree with Skib that not letting him rest and enjoy being away from you is appropriate - he shouldn't ever get a mouthful of grass while he is refusing to be caught. Other than that, I think your instructor has a good point, and if being naughty to catch is his only foible then it's quite a little one. He is obviously a right monkey for the yard staff though - he must really like you!
 
The other owner was offering him a big juicy carrot but she didn't actually give it to him. He stood next to her and then let me catch him. I was gutted he choose her over me, especially as he knows I always have feed in my hand.

The difficult thing is that I can't expect the yard staff to devote all day to trying to sort out his catching issues. They have tried lots of different things over the last 3 years, and because he was previously on part livery they sometimes had to go out multiple times to get him in. Now we have moved to assisted DIY and I have had a significant reduction in my livery bill, they are no longer willing to invest such a huge amount of time in catching him. The deal is that on the days that I can't get to the yard in the morning, they will try and catch him when they are going out to the field anyway. If he gives them the run around then he just has to stay out. I'm not actually paying them to catch him, they are doing it out of goodwill to help me out.

If he was difficult for me to catch then I could work on it, but because he is generally fine for me but naughty for the staff I feel very limited in what I can do. It's not the end of the world if he has to stay out until I get there, but I don't like the idea of him being muzzled for so long. He only comes in so he can have some muzzle free time and a haynet.
 
Is he running away or just playing games with the yard staff? I made the mistake when Bo was young of playing 'tag' amongst other games with him, as he got older i stopped, but he didn't understand that and catching time was a perfect opportunity for him to instigate play, tag being let me touch him then he'd run off, do a few laps and then tag me (could have ended very badly I later realised) but in order to stop the behaviour I no longer wanted I had to teach him a replacement behaviour. I used a whistle and food, like high volume clicker training :D it didn't take him long and I could whistle and he would come full pelt up a long 15 acre field for the treat :D
 
I top have used the moving them on method. When I first got Oscar he was difficult to catch so I tried not allowing him to graze and moving him on. It took about ten minutes before he was asking to come to me and he never ever did it again thank fully.
Do you ever just hang out in the field with him MP? I think sometimes they can be difficult if they only see us when we want to catch them. Don't be upset that he went to someone else, horses don't think like us so I wouldn't take it personally. I'm sure he still loves you just the same as always. .
 
Is he running away or just playing games with the yard staff? I made the mistake when Bo was young of playing 'tag' amongst other games with him, as he got older i stopped, but he didn't understand that and catching time was a perfect opportunity for him to instigate play, tag being let me touch him then he'd run off, do a few laps and then tag me (could have ended very badly I later realised) but in order to stop the behaviour I no longer wanted I had to teach him a replacement behaviour. I used a whistle and food, like high volume clicker training :D it didn't take him long and I could whistle and he would come full pelt up a long 15 acre field for the treat :D

Now that is a pretty good idea. If I could train him to come to call with a whistle or something similar, then perhaps he would come for the yard staff as well? At least if I looked into this I would feel like I was doing something to try and address the problem, and I would love him to come to the gate for me, especially when it's raining!

I'm not sure if he is running away or playing games as I only hear the stories of what he does and don't actually see it myself. The running through the electric fence yesterday really worried me as that has obvious risks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I top have used the moving them on method. When I first got Oscar he was difficult to catch so I tried not allowing him to graze and moving him on. It took about ten minutes before he was asking to come to me and he never ever did it again thank fully.
Do you ever just hang out in the field with him MP? I think sometimes they can be difficult if they only see us when we want to catch them. Don't be upset that he went to someone else, horses don't think like us so I wouldn't take it personally. I'm sure he still loves you just the same as always. .

He has always let me catch him previously, it's just been today that he ran away. I think that running through the fence yesterday upset him a little, but also he is just being a testing horse. I am much more concerned about him running away from the yard staff as he gives them the most problems. He knows them all really well and they have gone to great lengths to gain his trust, and it's not like he is always difficult to catch. Sometimes he stands by the gate waiting for them.
 
Even though you don't really have any problems with him, I would still be looking at the moving him away game. He is being cheeky and expressing himself - which is fine if it is fine with you. But if it's not, it needs addressing. Him dragging his heels when he comes in sounds like part of his little game too!

The aim is not to chase him off at high speed, just a slow walk or a few steps of trot - just enough so he isn't still or eating... After a 2-3 mins give him a break and see if he offers to come over to you... If not keep him going again.

Madam does all this nonsense. The move on game worked very well for us. She knows being caught means grooming, riding, farrier, vet, dentist - and she would of course LwYs rather eat grass over these!!

You can see her grinning when she plays up. She rarely does it now, but save her most spectacular performances for an audience! I nearly had to apologise d send farrier Away a few weeks ago as half an hour on and I couldn't get near her still! Instead I caught rascal, took him in and she was Nnoyed I left her out so bought herself in!!!!

As others have said though, it is a small price to pay for horse who is otherwise perfect for you :)
 
newrider.com