Catching problem

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
Someone on the yard has asked me to help her catch her pony who is turned out wth mine. She has a history of neglect, and is a very scared little pony. Lat summer she was uncatchable and I spent some time slowly building her trust and she soon allowed herself to be caught. By me and by owner. There haven't been any catching issues for a while, but now she's been turned out in a bigger field she's off again!

I have tried approach/retreat whichwas helpful in the summer but she won't get nearer than 5 feet. She's not bothered if we catch all the other ponies and leave her alone. And she won't even approach for food. I go in with hay, and put it out in piles and wander casually round scratching petting the others while they munch but she'll wait till I go before she comes for any.

Any ideas?
 
When you say she's not interested in food, what is it that she's being offered? Is there anything you could use to tempt her to risk a bit more contact with you?

I get the impression most experts would want to approach this sort of problem with the horse in a smaller enclosed area, although that's not always possible.
 
i had a similar problem with my mare because she had been on box rest and then turned out and totally didnt trust me.

when she wouldnt be caught i took all the horses out and just sat in the field and waited for her to approach me. if she didnt then fine it was her loss, but i didnt rush her at all. when she did i gave her lots of treats and praise and walked away slowly, she used to follow me eventually then i would stop and repeat. It did take months for her to trust me enough to come to me for haltering. And its taken almost 2yrs for her to come straight to me and put her nose in the halter. I have kept to a routine now though and always give her a treat when putting her head collar on.

good luck
 
I get the impression most experts would want to approach this sort of problem with the horse in a smaller enclosed area, although that's not always possible.

Yes, but we can't catch her!!!:D
I'll try with more tempting food offerings and see how I get on.
Thanks for replying.
 
when she wouldnt be caught i took all the horses out and just sat in the field and waited for her to approach me. if she didnt then fine it was her loss, but i didnt rush her at all. when she did i gave her lots of treats and praise and walked away slowly, she used to follow me eventually then i would stop and repeat.

That's what I did in the summer and it only took a couple of days to be able to stroke her & take hold of her head collar. I think the problem is that I am being asked to help for something very specific (catching) whereas actually, this pony needs someone to address all her anxieites at the same time. So last summer, once she was catchable, she was then ridden, probably before she's really got comfortable even about being caught. I think I'll just stay out of it, as really the catching issue is just part of a wider trust problem but I don't think owner believes that.Thinks it's just 'naughtiness'.
 
That's what I did in the summer and it only took a couple of days to be able to stroke her & take hold of her head collar. I think the problem is that I am being asked to help for something very specific (catching) whereas actually, this pony needs someone to address all her anxieites at the same time. So last summer, once she was catchable, she was then ridden, probably before she's really got comfortable even about being caught. I think I'll just stay out of it, as really the catching issue is just part of a wider trust problem but I don't think owner believes that.Thinks it's just 'naughtiness'.

I think thats a really good point you have made, its probably part of a wider issue and if the owner cant realise it then its not gonna get solved. Your very good for helping them, but your right that they need to address it themselves ideally
 
Yes, but we can't catch her!!!

Exactly :D In an emergency you might be able to herd her into an enclosure but that's likely to be traumatic and possibly even dangerous.

Something that might be worth trying that helped me when I was trying to catch a very tricky pony for my YO was to crouch down low, eyes down, and offer the treat at arms length, which seemed to make it easier for him to approach and take it. But he was very food orientated, so it may not work.
 
I know how frustrating this is! Last summer my mare would NOT let me near her!! even in an empty field she didnt care i know she was just being cheeky as its never been an issue before she just wanted that lush grass! I resorted to a field safe headcollar and a feed bucket of goodies! But with this Little pony sounds like shes got some issues that need worked on xx she might also just be chancing her luck in a bigger field too ;)
 
When I had a problem catching a horse some years ago, I used to put an empty crisp packet in my pocket and gently crumple it. I then just stood in the field making no eye contact with the horse or showing any interest in him. He was so intrigued by the sound of the crisp bag that he came over to me. It took a while to start with but it worked and other people have since found that method helpful.
 
I think you'll have to carry on with the approach and retreat but keep on going with it even if it takes all day.

It does work but the first few times might take you literally all day. Hopefully the time then becomes shorter. When you say she stops 5 feet away well you then need to keep going with it.....but the important thing is once you can get close enough to make contact you must then go straight away and leave her alone. That will be her reward.

Also make sure you are following approach and retreat to a t. ie. when she looks at you or flicks a ear in your direction, stand still and then 'retreat' a step or two. The minute she looks away 'advance' again.

It can be hard in a big field but it has worked for me in a 3 acre field.
 
newrider.com