Case study - opinions please!

Well there you go. Probably the same generation too. We're a pair then Ros. The only difference I can detect is that in my case my actual "touch" with horses and ponies has been sporadic since I was tiny until I bought Kerry - and as yoy know - I will NEVER volkuntarily let her go!!!!!!!

Happy days.

Sandra
 
I think its a really interesting challenge. Having done various "management training" (as a victim), I know that people have to be open to particular ideas to benefit from them. If you try and lead them that way before they are ready, they normally resist strongly and it reinforces their original position.

And the rider-horse partnership is so emotional. Working with that is like doing relationship counselling for people !

So as an instructor (in mind and qualification, if not in practise) how do I work with a situation like that ?

I would love for riding instructors to be taught coaching skills (something entirely different to 'technicl instruction') as part of their training. Then you could mentor/coach clients as well as helping them with the technical aspects of their riding.
 
I do agree. The term "riding instructor" should really encompass a lot more than it seems to. I'd like to see a lot more attention paid to things that are really important to the horse - for the life of me I can't understand how anyone who qualifies as a BHSAI has any excuse not to know how to fit a saddle and bridle, but that side of it never enters into it as far as I can see! When I did a stable management course we did at least touch on the subject, but I've NEVER been shown how to check fit by a single one of my instructors in my whole life, and one was a BHSI, and I had my own horses at the time!
 
Ros, for me this is the one area of equine world/instructors that I find constantly distressing. Do everything up white knuckle tight ,shorten stirupps too and you have safe saddle and horse, don't ask questions.
Its so weird that they can't just be more open minded for the sake of the horse. But what do I know to ask such questions, Im only trying to learn so it seems,I'm 'new'
I did have to smile recently when I was talking to owners of the fjord who is for sale, at 1st the owners, they didn't really want to know me at all because..I'm 'new'
The more we spoke, over two weeks, it was unbelievable how they changed, 'please do come and see him,please' .My niece who has owned horse nearly all her life,says its so refreshing that I don't follow the supposed leaders in all of this, yet I know nothing being 'new'.
Its weird., off courseI'm a long long way from knowing it all, at this rate anyway! I'm not much use in answer to your original question,oops.
:)
 
Ros, when I did my AI in 1990, we had to do bridle and saddle fitting. But I don't remember it being checked in the exam at all (tho this may be unfair).

I do remember it being quite ironic doing the practise as sometimes you were putting what was supposed to be the 'right' saddle on, and then pointing out why it was an awful fit for the horse !

They did do a little bit on delivery of a lesson, but nothing really on how people learn (and the differences), goal setting, dealing with anxiety/fear, etc etc.

And from what I could see of the II students, they did not cover this at II level either, just worked on different kinds of lesson (e.g. private jumping lesson).
 
The trouble is, you could probably solve a minimum of 50% of all horse/rider problems without doing anything other than sorting out tack, but instead people get charged for lessons in which they don't learn anything, expensive remedial training for their "problem" horses and so on... But of course, it isn't like taking car to a garage, is it - if your car won't start, the garage either fixes it or it doesn't, and you can tell if they've done it right because the car either starts again or it doesn't. So you find them out straight away. But with horses it's so easy - you just say "it's the horse's fault".
 
The teaching course you are after used to be C&G 7307. It has had a name change, A year p/time on learning theory. lesson, and curriculum planning, Aims and Objectives and demonstration of achievement, or not, of each. A superb course. Base that in a sound environment of equine theory and management and we might just have a majority of instructors who know their way around a horse and who can instruct!!!
 
It's all sounding very much better indeed but I still think we need to add to all of that - oh dear sorry.

It's just that we need to generate quite a lot of stuff like empathy and leadership too - because otherwise we'll still end up with "this is how to teach" - which is different to having developed an understanding about how individuals "behave" and how to communicate adult:adult in order to work things through - as "equal" adults. And the same re our horses!!

Sandra
 
Hi Sandra
7307 does not teach you how to teach. It teaches you how to "facilitate learning" A different ball game altogether. It is all about behaviour, body language, psychology etc. It is very against "chalk and talk" one way dissemination of information, BUT it does insist that you know your subject as well.
 
Sounds very interesting and tempting, but you'd guess I'd ask: What's the "subject"? Oh that sounds awfull and I'm not at all wishing to be awkward - it really does sound like a vast improvement but are they into "selling" something called "facilitating learning" or something like I described I felt was needed in my last post?
 
The subject is whatever your subject is! A teacher of biology to adults will do the theoretical "theory of learning " course and apply it, and be practically assessed in situ whilst helping clients to learn biology. A swimming instuctor will do the same theoretical "theory of learning " but use it in a swimming environment. The assessors might not know your "subject" but they can sure tell whether you know it and can help other folks to learn it!
 
So they are "coaching" yes? That's fine. I'd still argue 'though that there is always something else to learn - and anyway imo we don't seem to have tried it out yet on a larger scale in the equine world. You see "coaching" to me IS fine - but it's usually applied in situations where you have really able "learners". I think the difference in the equine world is ALL of the EMO
TION which also exists and I think that learning to understand this better is very important that's all.

Sandra
 
I think we may be at cross purposes. When I did the course I was helping folks of all ages 16 to?, who almost by definition at not achieved at school, to a) learn biology, and b) overcome many and various learning. emotional and confidence gremlins in the process.
Possibly this thread has gone far enough? It does seem to have strayed from it's original point.
 
newrider.com