Case study - opinions please!

ros

New Member
Jun 9, 2001
1,677
0
0
Saltash, Cornwall
Visit site
One of our liveries has a problem!

Her horse is about 12/13; big, square-set chap, mind of his own, gelded late; supposedly evented before she bought him at 6, and she says she competed him for the first couple of years. I wouldn't know.

He doesn't have the best natural paces - short, choppy stride - and he's the sort that likes to hurry along; he hates being held behind other horses, which she makes no attempt to do. I have a suspicion she may be a tiny bit wary of him - she says she isn't, but people do say that, don't they?

She's been diagnosed with tendonitis in both arms - first one, now the other, and she says she has trouble holding him. He's in a normal metal mullen mouth Pelham with metal curb, and she says he still gets strong in it. Personally I think the pair of them wind each other up - it's a vicious circle; part of her likes to have a horse that's a tad goey, but the other half gets exasperated when she can't stop him jogging and being silly.

She asked me the other day if there was any sort of gadget that she could use to give her a bit more control without doing any damage. Someone had suggested a particular noseband - she wasn't sure what it was but I think it may have been a Kineton.
(Don't think you could use one with a Pelham anyway - someone tell me otherwise!)

The way I see it, she's been avoiding this issue ever since she bought the horse and I'm not sure whether she's got the mental wherewithall to sort it - bit of a personality clash, really. Horse needs someone who can ride him through his little tantrums without getting wound up, and I suspect he would always be a bit of a lad even so. But of course, she loves him to death.

Anyone got any magic soutions? (Heather, you know them - it's rider M and horse T :) )
 
Is she a (for lack of a better term) "good rider"?I mean, I'm a novice and it amazes me to watch the horse I usually ride being ridden by someone with more experience. They are able to communicate so much more with their seat, hands, and confidence. So, I guess my question is really whether the problem is just mechanical (ie: the bit isn't the right choice) or more the relationship between horse and rider. If the owner is part of the problem, she could probably benefit from training sessions with her horse. If her horse acts up with everyone, maybe his tack needs looking into and maybe she could find a trainer to ride him regularly to help shape him a little. Either way, best of luck!
 
It does sound like it's more the riders problem than the horse as such. If his nature is to have a bit of go in him and he likes to bounce around a bit, no gadget is going to change that.

Does she have lessons? If she doesn't it sounds like she needs them.

My horse sounds very similar, she's a big 15.3hh, very muscular (so strong) and definitely has a mind of her own. She likes to be in charge, up in the front of a ride and running is her favourite thing in the world. She can be a bit scary sometimes as she doesn't have much of a sense of self preservation. Lessons have helped me no end. Before when she got a bit full of herself I would back off and she'd take charge, which resulted in a couple of scary situations. Now I'm confident enough to sit up, keep my leg on and use half halts, etc to get her to pay attention. Her basic nature hasn't changed and she can still bounce about with the best of them, but I'm much more able to cope with it now and it doesn't worry me half as much.

I don't think you can use a Kineton noseband with a pelham, I know that a flash isn't considered acceptable with them (although you do see it, unfortunately).
 
HI Ros,

Guessed who it was before I got to the bottom of the post! Yes he has a mind of his own, mainly because the owner has never actually ridden him properly- tending to bomb him about, and now she is paying the price of it. The rider is also very overweight and he may be in some discomfort, as I would say he is only just about up to her size.

I also think that there is a personality clash- horse also probably has a tad more brain than the rider, and that is not good! This is why I think it won't improve- she won't have the interest or the sense to try to work it out, maybe do some Parelli or something with him to get him more focused, so sorry, knowing the hrose and rider, I think that it will never get any better, unless she sends him off to Mike Peace and comes here for some lessons with him afterweards- oh, and is prepared to listen in the first place!



Heather
 
Ros

does this person take lessons at all ? How open are they to suggestions ? I was just thinking that some coaching might help - in terms of "sports pyschology" rather than "put your left leg here" type coaching.

I can't remember where you are - but there is a lady in Surrey who does something she calls "Holistic Riding" which might work - but onloy if the rider was receptive. Or there's things like Fizz Coaching.
 
Thanks all.

I think everyone is right when they guess at this chiefly being a rider problem.

Jenny - she's not a novice, and she did actually go to college down here for a spell (horsey college, that is) but didn't complete the course. Her horse went with her & she said she didn't like the way he was being treated. But I think she's at a sort of "uneducated" stage - hard to explain, she doesn't look too bad on a horse (except she is rather overweight in a solid sort of way) but she doesn't really have any idea what she's doing. She can talk some of the phrases, but I don't think she knows what they mean. However, she does care about her horse, I'm sure. (Which is more than can be said for her mother!)

Bebe - no, she doesn't have lessons and you're right, she should. She did have a session with Heather last year, but she's always skint so lessons would be a luxury. Mind you, interestingly she's been having my chiropractor treat her horse - he just had his second treatment today, and although it's very early days there did seem to be quite a lot of tightness in his back and shoulders; her horse is very similar to Merlin, in that he's a strapping chap, very solid and almost too much muscle, which means it's sometimes difficult to feel what's going on below the surface muscles.

cvb - leading on from that, what would be the difference between the lady in Surrey's "holistic" riding and Heather's teaching? I regard EE as very much a holistic method, since it addresses all sorts of issues other than the actual riding side. And didn't someone else mention "Fizz" coaching? What is that, exactly?

Heather - I hadn't actually thought of her being too heavy for him, you know! But perhaps I may be looking at all that fat (on the horse :D ) and mistaking it for strength? I'm going to have a closer look and try and imagine what he's really like underneath.

As for owner, I think she genuinely wants the situation to improve, but don't think she realises that it would be hard work and she'd actually have to take control of herself as well as the horse. She still thinks there's a quick fix, and until she accepts there isn't I think you're right. But at least she's made the effort to have him checked over, so there's a glimmer of light. It will be very interesting to see if he chills out a bit.

She said she's going to try him in a hard rubber Pelham instead of the metal one. I suspect it won't make an awful lot of difference. I think she's also planning on avoiding taking him out with his field mates, as she says he's worse with them. Merly and I walked up the road side by side with them last weekend and he seemed quite relaxed, but I don't like riding out with her as T always has to be in front and Merly gets terribly grumpy and sulks and trails along like an old beach donkey behind so it's no fun :rolleyes:

I'd love to get Mike Peace down her - he does day visits, doesn't he. Maybe one day if he fancies a trip to Devon...?
 
Ros

I have a really bad habit of just reading the first post - and I confess this is what I've done again!!

The tendonitis may be due to something else - it may not of course, as well. What does she do for a living??

The interaction with other horses Kerry had a major problem with (well not major in the sense that she went batty but she really objects to certain equines - she's very fussy people would say - but actually imo it was all due to a megga lack of confidence.

The leaning/pulling is something for EE - I can't fathom it except that I know from my own (limited) experience that once you're in that viscious circle of terror (which I didn't pause a fraction over admitting I experienced) it is extremely difficult to get your limbs - and fingers to do what you KNOW they need to do - the human neural networks I'm sure are designed for flight or fright when it really comes down to it - just like the equine's are.

Sandra
 
The Holistic Riding (I think its Wendy Price) is about how your mind set affects the horse.

For example, I turned up for a lesson and was a little late so was a bit flustered. Went in and 'flustered' the horse around the school. Then Wendy got me talking about it and reflecting on what it was doing to the horse. Its sort of like counselling on horse back ! But very subtle. She does work on technical aspects as well, but it is quite pyschological.

Fizz coaching was me too :) I haven't seen the kit myself but I have talked to a couple of the people. Its about the sports pyschology side - things that block you, goals you want to achieve and so on. They do workshops but you can also buy a 'kit' which guides you through the process.

Fizz are at fizz web site
 
I think there would be quite a lot of value in that - it's amazing what you can do with your mind (provided you get all the other important bits right and provided you don't start taking it all too far ;) ).

Another thing that just occurred to me about this particular situation while I was skipping Merly out just now - I remember the girl telling me some time ago that when she went to try the horse he was being ridden by a big, strapping woman who appeared to ride with quite a lot of strength. I wonder if our chap learned as a youngster to fight strength with strength as a defence mechanism? Being big, of course, he can. He's not at all nasty in any way - he's a great big softy in the stable.
 
fao Ros

Hi,

I'm still guilty of not reading all of the replies but I've now read your own.

I think she sounds genuine. Is it possible that she quit horsey college for all of the right reasons???

Mike certainly does do day visits.

I'm assuming it's her horse you're talking about re not being comfy riding out with them because the horse always wants to be in front. If this is so and she has so much less experience then I'd guess this is one example of several others and she will have a need for the right kind of support. I don't think that's her fault (and I know you don''t either) btw. I think the horse has unmet needs too - I'm probably quite wrong in everyone else's opinion but the horse must have a need to be in front and to me there's a reason for that and to me that's not the same as the horse having a problem.

Sandra
 
Last edited:
Hi Sandra

I think most horses with a speck of pride in themselves like to be out in front, but they also need to learn to be put at the back or in the middle and not make a big fuss about it. My old lad was a right royal pain in the bum - he'd jog and pull constantly until I let him go up front, then he'd draw himself up and swagger along, happy as Larry.

I was out on Merlin once, with little Midnight (one of his field mates). Mids was in front, and Merly was sulking, and he just ground to a halt. I actually got off and checked all his tack and his feet because I thought there was something wrong with him. Couldn't find anything, got back on - just the same. For some reason Mids dropped behind, and Merly perked right up again - little b----r was simply sulking because he thought Mids (who's bottom of the pecking order) had no business being out in front.

Going back to our livery, I think Heather's right, in that he's been allowed to gallop about unchecked for years, and now that his rider finds that she can't hold him so easily she's unfortunately reaping the consequences of all those years with no proper schooling. I suspect that what she says she's done with him and what she's actually done with him may not be *quite* the same thing - I remember her mother once telling me she was capable of Advanced dressage!

But yes, I'm sure she's genuine in that she does care for the horse. He's actually quite cosseted in some ways. As Heather said, if you could get him properly focused I think he'd be fine.
 
Yikes, M, advanced dressage!!!!! Advanced galloping about maybe!! You are right Ros, T is far from irretrievable, but M is going to have to learn a bit of self disicpline befoer that is likely!

Heather
 
Fao Ros

I'm, sorry. Just gave my opinion..........which is what you asked for!!!!!!!!!!!! Just hope it turns out OK for the horse and rider in question!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Sandra - what are you apologising for? We're just having a natter and *all* opinions are thought-provoking. I think you're right in saying that his "need" to be in front isn't a particular problem in the horse's eyes - it's his owner who finds this aspect of his behaviour a problem :D

I don't think he's especially dominant in the field, but that's hard to tell as it's a group of two geldings and two mares who've been together for some time, so the pecking order is well-established. As he was gelded late he may very possibly see himself as Top Pony. The trouble is, the only other person I've actually seen ride the horse is Heather in her school. I haven't seen anyone else hack him out so I don't know how he behaves outdoors with another rider. It would be interesting.
 
I "think" I know Ros. It's just that those of us who don't work with horses as a living do have our own set of "needs" and I felt your original thread was about the owner!!

We must seem at times to be a "strange breed" to you (imo) you see. And on the basis of what you said I felt a lot of empathy for the owner - and as you realise for the horse too!!

Therefore, I cannot do anything else than stick to my opinions................ What does she do for a living now??? Does she have other challenges which might result in the tendonitis she is experiencing? (From a person who has experienced this btw the pain is truly excruciating - no joke. So if she is still seeking answers to help for her horse instead of herself, then I would truly vouch for her!!!!!!!!!!!.)

All of the very very best,

Sandra
 
Hey, whoa! I don't actually work with horses for a living either - I just live on a farm where we happen to take DIY liveries :) I have to drive into Plymouth every day to earn the pennies that feed *my* horse (more's the pity).

I think I always had in mind that the problem was a rider problem and not a horse problem. But I don't actually empathise with the owner as much as you might, perhaps, because I know her. She's a nice lass, very funny, cares about her horse; but at the same time she hasn't quite grown out of trying to impress by making out that she knows more than she does, and also she hasn't learned to listen yet :rolleyes: I think maybe it's the sin of youth ;) . I suppose that's why she thinks there's some magic gadget that will suddenly cure all her problems.

I don't think there are any other stresses in her environment that might have caused the tendonitis - as for her occupation, suffice it to say that she's surrounded by professionals who can help her as far as it's possible to help someone with that condition ;) But I'm quite sure it's painful and I'm certainly not without sympathy for her, which is why I thought this might be an interesting post in the first place.

I think if we could somehow get her a) a session with Wendy Price, b) a session with Mike Peace and c) some lessons with Heather we'd be getting somewhere. Whether or not there's much chance of that is another matter!
 
So you knew ther answer all along then Ros. Whereas the rest of us only knew what you told us in the first place..

In my own defence I have to say I gave an opinion - which is what you asked for - on the basis of the history you provided!!

Sandra
 
No, I didn't actually know the answer. I suspected, but that's not the same as actually knowing, and there's always a possibility that someone will come up with some similar, interesting experience. That's why it's good to discuss these things with lots of people.

I was interested in Heather's opinion, as she's actually ridden the horse and met the owner, and I suppose I could have emailed her direct; but there are a lot of people out there who might recognise the situation, and I was genuinely interested to hear what everyone else might think. I certainly don't count myself an expert so I wanted some feedback, and it just developed from there.

So I hope you don't think it was some kind of trick, Sandra - it wasn't! And I do read all your posts with much interest because I know you've had great benefit from your sessions with Sue, for whom I have the greatest respect. Any input you can give is very welcome and might shed a little more light on the subject in hand :)
 
Ros

In light of what I would call my very very short REAL experience with the equine world I would sometimes say "anything goes" !!

If you add to that the problems of communicating "electronically
" then the problems are multiplied x-fold (e.g. I hit the delete button about five minutes ago and it has taken me this long to find the insert button on my laptop!!!)

Anyway, all I can say is thank "g" that this board exists - where on earth would Kerry and I be without it after all?????????????

Sandra
 
You talk about your "very short REAL experience" - I feel the same too. I've been riding since I was 8, and I've just turned 50. That's 42 years in the saddle. And the sad thing is that it's only really since I met Heather and Sue that I've started chucking out the c--p and thinking about this stuff properly!

When I think about what I've done to my horses in the past it honestly makes me cringe - not in any brutal sense, but in ignorance. The older I get, the easier it is to see what gentle, generous creatures they are, and how they do their damndest to please, and if they don't always, it isn't because they haven't tried. Makes you want to weep, really it does.
 
newrider.com